Freedom of Religion Requires Mutual Respect
This Saturday morning, my door bell rang. When I asked through the door who it was, it wasJehovahWitnesses. "We would like to talk to you about the good news", said the female voice from behind the door. "No thank-you", I responded, but I was razzed. Why should some strangers come to my door,unsolicited, and try to impose their faith on me? How utterly rude.
And then Sunday night rolled around, and I am watching the news, and I hear about anatheistgroup, American Atheists, who is going to put up billboards in two target neighborhoods,a Muslim one in Patterson NJ and the other one planted in orthodox Jewish Williamsburg, Brooklyn.
Here is a copy of the Billboards from American Atheists, that will go up tomorrow:
The word in on the left side of both signs is God.
Suddenly, I am having the same feeling that I had on Saturday morning. Why should those atheist come to Muslim and Jewish neighborhood unsolicited, and metaphorically, knock on their door?
In recent weeks we all have been discussing and debating our religious freedoms vs individual freedoms. But the one overriding thing that I have not been able to get my head wrapped around, is when faith or lack there of, oversteps it'sboundsin expressing itself and becomes an insult to another person or group? When do they abuse their "Freedom of Speech"? When are they just being arrogant, selfrighteousand self centered? To put it simply... are they just being rude?
We all seem to know when our own feelings are beingaffronted, but it seems to me, that we have lost our empathy. We forget to think how others may feel, when we confronted them on their personal beliefs, especially that of faith... or non-faith. How will this ultimately play out? Is this going to be a case of survival of the fittest, when it comes to religion oratheism? I hope not. Because what has always made us a special and unique nation, is our acceptance of ourplurality. Not by "My beliefs are better than yours". Just food for thought.

Perrie, excellent article!
What is the line between rudeness and leaglity? Has this pushing of the boundries between personal liberties been pushed too far? To what cause or purpose?! You know me, I believe that the boundries have to be pushed continuously to insure freedom.
I love the conversation and think you are on the right track; really, great job!
:~)
Excellent article Perrie. Randy has the right idea, I think.I would add to his sign "I will convert to your faith if you convert to mine. You first." However, as you know, Jews do not proselytize. The time to hide the mezuzah on the door is when the black hats come looking for donations that will allow them to continue their studies without having to work.
We don't seem to have that in NY, except around Christmas, when a Christian group puts up "Jesus is the reason for the season", which I don't find offensive, since it's just a reminder to other Christians, that the holiday isn't just about gift giving and isn't trying to convert anyone. But at the same time, this same atheist group puts up anti Christmas signs, which I do find disrespectful. Putting down someone else's beliefs is just rude.
Thanks Larry, but because we don't have a save in the forum( we do in the blogs), I tend to bang out articles, that have to be edited the next day... so I am not so sure about how excellent I would give the actual writing, LOL!
I would say that rudeness is a social norm. Something that is unpleasant to do to another person. An afrontment. But just because something is rude, doesn't mean that it isillegal.
I think the issue is when one of our freedoms steps on the toes of another one of our freedoms. I think that is why our founding fathers were smart and designed SCOTUS to decided such problems.
To be "right" of course!
I agree. I think that it is important to keep these kinds ofdialoggoing in order to be a cohesive society, especially one that is a plural society with no official religion. They are doing the same thing right now in France. They are trying to define what it means to be French. These are very difficult things to figure out, but it doesn't mean that we should ignore them.
Buzz, you crack me up! Spot on with that!
Our first house in the city was in a neighborhood that was slowly turning black hats. We had no idea when we moved in. But we quickly found out that they will hit every and any door looking for donations. We would just tell them "We're pagans... go away", LOL! Matt really got off on doing that.
For years, I used to open the door and try to be polite. Some where very polite and others were very forceful.Jehovah Witnesses believe that they must earn points to get into heaven and a great many of those points are from conversion and that is why some of them are more forceful than others.
LOL.... but no.
There are simple answers to dealing with the Jehovah's Witness problem :
1] Put up a donation box at your front door . When they knock , insist that they kick in a few bucks to pay for your valuable time .
2] Open the door and proceed to blow their minds with alternative religious approaches . Zen Buddhism is especially confusing since its goals are essentially opposite from those of any form of Christianity .
LOL.. That is why I used to tell them that I was a pagen. Blew their minds.
Paganism is a great choice too . But my favorite is Confuscious sayings . No one there will have a clue as to what they mean . However , if you bring out a copy of the Dao de Ching and read some of the passages aloud ... that Daoism is the ultimate in obscured meaning .
Christian here...like da Zen too!
Sadly, Humans have always fallen into that trap anytime there is anenforcementof mores. And we keep at it anyways LOL!
:~)
But truthfully I'm not sure I see a way a round it, this push/pull isn't just a result of theprocess;imhoit is the process.
Robert, I understand that "Freedom of Speech" is there to protect when we don't like what we are seeing. But this article isn't about the actual freedom. It's about respecting each others beliefs. It need not be as complex than that.
It must be difficult to deal with the dichotomy between those two ...
Actually Rich, it's a blessing.
Raised Fundy, was one of them promising new young preachers by the age of 15 anddisillusionmentby 18. Went on to Seminary, while still Evangelical it was more liberal than what I had been fed. Some really outstanding instructors with a keen sense of promoting wide research and opinions. While I forbade the ministry because being a hypocrite wasn't for me, over the years my Christianity has taken aprogressivetheological/philosophical approach.
One thing that has alwaysintriguedand motivated me is the idea of pushingboundaries. Whether scientific, ideological, or whatever...It is learning new things by being in contact with them, that really allows me honest self-criticism. And by prodding at theforbiddensometimes I learn something new about myself.
When it comes to Zen I am influenced by Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance . There are too many aspects of reality not yet explained by science or religion imho. While Buddhism in General I find interesting, zen has a something-something for me. I think it's the way it tackles immediate reality and accords solid philosophical alternatives. I dig that. One of the other thing I find valuable in Mr. Pirsig's book is that it was a direct statement towards both the Counter-culture of the late 60's early 70's, and at the changes that technology brings to society. Fascinating actually. You can read it here for free!
I heard somebody say this years ago and it has stuck with me, "All Truth is God's Truth" and I do believe that.
OK Robert, for you, small letters, freedom of speech, in to most folks has theinterpretationas something that isguaranteed, a promise, if you will, that within minor limitations, you can say almost anything.
That is a leap, if ever I saw one. No where in that article, did I even suggest it. Don't read between the lines. The question was about respect, and rudeness, of which none of those two words implies limitations. Read the article for it was.
Let me put it another way.. Do you feel the Westboro Baptist Church is nice or rude and nasty?
Larry,
I read Zen and the Art of MotorcycleMaintenance, years a go, in my early 20's. I found it also a very life altering book. LOL about you liking it. Of course you would. The guy was fromMinnesota! But really, living in the moment has always been a challenge for me. I am a worrier. I have tried to use zen think to stop this behavior, and to a degree it has helped. I have learned to let go of things. That is why I love to write about ethics. My last one "The Upside to Anger" ( which by the way, I just took a look at, and saw you made the last comment, and I never responded, since it must have fallen off the board before I saw it...I will now and sorry!), was an issue that I dealt with in my 20's also. I was quiteformidableback then.Anger was a fuel, and it was a tough thing for me to let go of. Reading this book, did have a huge effect on me, in that respect.
I'm a lot like you. I like to push and question. I think that when you stop doing that, then you stop growing as an individual, and fall into a dogma. I do realize that it makes it hard for many to understand me, and often I do play "Devil'sAdvocate", but my main purpose for doing so, is to push thoseboundaries.
OMG, Robert, stop reading things into nothing. I know that you really don't get me, but sometimes, I say stuff and there is no deeper meaning.
No it doesn't. It's a request for self control. An intervention in social norms.
Agreed.
No. Actually, I expected a deep discussion about what has happened to usrespectingeach other. If anything, I was expecting a discussion about why it's soimportantto be disrespectful to each other's faith. I don't have to be a member of the Satmar to know that the purpose of that billboard is to mock what they believe. And I don't even like the Satmar, but I respect their right to believe what they want to. This group doesn't. And if there is anyinfringementon any right here, it is that of freedom of religion, as one should be free to believe what they want to believe, without being accosted for it.
The rest of your post I have no response for, since I am not discussing freedom of speech.
Let me explain one thing about me, to you, so that you might understand where I come from. I write about ethics a lot. My last article like this was called "The Upside of Anger". I just pose questions to make people think. It's good to walk out of our comfort zones and challenge ourselves. That is the point of this article.
And I think that I have challenged myself in this exchange, and I hope I have challenged you.
Yes you have.. but that is good!
In the front piece to this book [in the hard copy] it says something like this :
"This book is not about Zen , motorcycles or maintenance .
LOL!
:~)
I think back on that now and have to grin. And I'd say that's true...it's much, much more than that!