Heartland Department of Education
This little video put a smile on my face... BRILLIANT!!! Just brilliant!!!
Scientists necessarily place truth on a very high pedestal, it is the heart and sole of science. Science IS the pursuit of Truth!
What motivates the HI? Morally vacant ideology (IMO) that prioritizes self-interest above all else.
What was Peter Gleick's motive? A desire to reveal the truth... made evident, in part, by his own confession. But much more importantly, an understanding that our actions, if unchanged, will bring about much suffering.
When consequences and motives are considered, to me, this is not even a close call!
It's a damn shame that there has to be ANY discussion of Peter Gleick's ethics. All of this discussion is just more fodder for the HI to use in its efforts to confuse and distract people. Of course it would have been better to shed light on the HI in some other way, but there is no time to wait for a more ethical approach.
In my book Peter Gleick is a hero!!!

AH!!! You were right Perrie... it was only the preview where the video didn't show up...
One thing I said in the article is so true to me that I just need to say it again...
Morally vacant ideology prioritizing self-interest above all else...
THAT summarizes my views about almost every idea offered by the extreme right. I find that ideology utterlyrepugnant!!!I have no doubt the extreme right finds my ideology equally repugnant.
[Mal steps down off of his soapbox... flips the box over... puts his 8-track tape collection, hisEtch-A-Sketch (Mal doesn't want to upgrade to an iPad), his quill, ink, and parchment back in the soapbox... straps the soapbox to his travois... hitches himself to the travois... and storms of in a huff...]
I know.. I had to find that out the hard way.
BTW great video. Even if you don't believe that humans are contributing to global warming ( which btw.. the debate isn't if the earth is warming up, because it is. It's if we humans are the cause of it), at least it will get people thinking about what science is and what it isn't
Bravo Mal!
Mal,
You really carry a large load there!
I think that you have hit the nail right on the head.
This entire subject is a waste of valuable human energy IMO . Here is what really matters :
OMG...Pimping again Rich, LOL!
I really don't think one can intelligently discuss this subject w/o looking at the big picture . Sure it is satisfying to talk about morality but a time is coming when morality will likely be passed over just so you can fill your gas tank . And since nothing else has addressed that big picture besides my above link I felt it was obligation to inform those who can understand the lessons that come from economics . Those who don't think that economics has anything to teach them will suffer the consequences .
I agree that there is a bigger picture. Science has taken a big hit over a few folks who over stepped the boundries. Still, there is a movement that wants tocondemn science all together and that is just as dangerous.
"there is a movement that wants to condemn science all together "
Does this have something to do with religion ?
I misspoke. There are some who want to discredit the human factor from the discussion of what is happening to our earth, not just global warming.
and yes, some religious fanatics in regard to evolution.
Hey .. look who's back ! Where ya been you curmudgeon ?
I want you to consider what effects science has on society . Science has many social effects but it needs to be credible to have those effects . And P. Gleick has shown on numerous ocassions that he is willing to risk that all important credibility for political gains .
I am debating about Gleick. I find what he did more than questionable. But the issue here, is that other people are using Gleick as an excuse to discredit all science.
What a daring and visionary plan ! I would think you would try something more realizable like the space elevator ...
" But the issue here, is that other people are using Gleick as an excuse to discredit all science. "
Well that is exactly the problem . Lay persons have no way of knowing if a "scientist" is the real McCoy or not . When they find one playing with the "truth" they get upset enough to start to distrust all scientists .
What "political gains"???
Here is what I said about his motives...
Just so there is no confusion about what I say:
So it is ok to perform an unethical action against a morally bankrupt organization. I presume this is not a absolute stance. I'm rather more of a Kantian myself.
' What "political gains"??? '
The same political gains sought by Al Gore
Political Gains? Maybe personal gain... but political?
I thought that was you Robert, but I couldn't remember if you were a Robert G, E, or F. Now I know.
Tricky work, even for an experienced builder. Those fruit trees keep knocking you in the noggin with their fruit.
Hey, I want one of those cards!
Sorry Perrie. I seem to have gotten the last one 20 years ago.
RATS!
I MEAN IT RATS!
The fact that Gore did not hold office anymore does not change the fact that he created a radical political environmental block . And science has been suffering credibility problems ever since .
Rich,
So you think what I proposed for his motives hold no water???
Rich,
Credibility problems with people who don't WANT to believe what Al Gore and MILLIONS of other people believe... credibility problems that do not need Al Gore to be involved at all... credibility problems that need only for some one... anyone... to assert what others don't what to believe. Whether that assertion is true or not has nothing to do with the credibility problems. It has everything to do with what the assertion implies we must do and the fact than none of us want to do it. Some of us accept that it is something we should do even if we don't want to do it, and other simply choose to declare the assertion and its proponents to be lacking credibility.