Presbyterian Church moves closer to divestment from Israel-related companies
NEW YORK (JTA) -- The Presbyterian Church USA moved a step closer to divesting from three multinational companies that do business in Israel and the West Bank.
The executive committee of the 2.4 million member church voted Friday to pass a resolution endorsing a recommendation of divestment from Caterpillar, Motorola and Hewlett-Packard. The action followed a report released Sept. 9 by the church's committee on Mission Responsibility Through Investment that recommended divestment of companies it believes supports the Israeli occupation of the West Bank.

Well it looks like thePresbyterian Church has "over-identified".
Thanks assholes for not researching or even reading your own "holy" texts.
So does this mean they now support the Palestinian side ?
That is exactly what it means.Incorrigiblelazy bastards too lazy to Google and dig for the truth, they haveinsteadvestedthemselvesin anapparentpolitically correctpropagandadogma. Makes me want to puke.
Every time the useful idiots try to pull off a boycott, it turns around and bites them. I'm a great supporter of the BDS movement. Whenever they picket a store with their boycott, the local Jewish communities do a BUYcott, i.e. theyflock to buy their needsfrom those stores. Thatcauses an increase in exports from Israel. Although I'm not in the market for a bulldozer, I'll make sure my next mobile phone purchase will be a Motorola.
Many years ago, the PCUSA saw a big split as two more orthodox branches pulled away to formfirst the OPC , and then the PCA (from earlier versions of the PCUSA).The leaders of those organizations held different ideological and theological beliefs and interpretations of scripture, and such differences were irreconcilable.
Since then, the PCUSA has become even more liberal with their doctrine, making decisions that many Christiansbelieve are not in line with scripture. It's important to understand that the PCUSA does not speak for all Presbyterians, much less Christian Protestants in the US.
Jay,
Excellent post. I don't think that most people know that. It like the split between theEpiscopalchurch and the Anglican church here in the US.
Good information. Will there ever be rationality about the ME. Do you think this is fomented/fueled by anti semitism?
For those of us who serve Christ, many of us believe that Israel will be a focal-point during the end times and will always be at enmity with her neighbors, save for a short three and half year period of time. We've seen that Israel is capable of peace treaties with neighbors, but they're shaky - depending on which Arab despot is in power. We can see that in play now, within Egypt.
A 2.4 million member organization -especially an American organization - has the power to affect a conflict in a positive manner. Among the myriad choices they had, they could have chosen a constructive measure to engage one or both of the parties in asuch away so as to foster trust and cooperation. Instead, theychose a path of intimidation,based upon an apparently hateful stance anddisposition.
Not very "Christian", if you ask me...
Thanks for the info Jay...I didn't know that.
Yes.
The entire ME is really chuggin' right along right now. Iran, Iraq, Syria, Egypt....such a volatile situation.
No it's not. And you're right that there are so many ways for religious institutions to foster peace. Just shameful.
"Do you think this is fomented/fueled by anti semitism?"
yes, and...
by ignorance
Max,
I'm no Buzz; he is a lot moreknowledgeableabout this stuff than I; but would you mind if I also answered?
This entire Israeli Palestinian conflict goes back to after WWI when the Allies were parceling out the remainder of Central Powers and the Old Ottoman empire. Between French and British secret deals made with Arabian rulers, what was left was decided by International law. Since that time the choices that Arab leaders have made leave no doubt that they are profoundly upset by the merepresenceof Israel.
ThePalestiniansof present time is anextensionof that animosity. There have been numerousopportunitiesfor Palestine to also have a country of their own ( I mean for real chances) but Arabs have been using them to goad Israel into war. As long as Arabs can keep the Palestinians as the victim, they use them just as we have seen many nut-ball Islamicextremistsused suicide bombers. They are willing to sacrifice Palestine's chance at their own state and lives, to enhance their political position.
This thing we refer to as the Israeli/Palestinianconflict would be settled and all parties satisfied if Hamas, the Plo, the Muslim Brotherhood and all the rest kept their asses outta it. I believe that there are very many Palestinians that want peace and their own country but their own government has been proxies for Arab sentiment all along.
The reason why IMHO this amounts to antisemitismis twofold
1. The Arab world is continuing to advance it's cause to be rid of Israel and are using the Palestian's for that purpose.
2. There are many ways that thePresbyterian Church USA could have approached this issue. Lets say that they earnestly researched the subject and truly believed (erroneously) what they say, to go so far as to divest speaks to something that goes beyond a reasonable Christian response and completely dismisses truths that are self-evident even to many of Israel's harshest critics.
If ya want to get the real skinny, check out this guys blog . He's a true blue liberal and I haven't always agreed with him; but, his historical research has always been dead-on.
This is the first of four and the rest are there as well. Not too long reading and good stuff.
We can disagree Max, that's cool and thanks for hearing me out.
I guess that from what I see, those who would help out Palestians in such a way forget that Arabs really don't want to have peace, they want Israel gone.
See!
We can agree to disagree!
And I'd still love to take ya out for beer and supper if ya ever come through my neck of the woods - LOL!
:~)
If I remember you live in Colorado?
My Sister-in-law lived in Ft. Collins for a few years and I lovedvisitingfor the time in the Rockies and Ft. Collinsawesomeculture...great music at the local taverns and great beer from the microbreweries. The old downtown had some fantastic art, not theusualcheap tourist stuff, really,really nice jewelry, art and musicalinstruments. Very cool.
max: The Ottawa Protocol provides an excellent definition of anti-Semitism with reference to Israel. Take note that fair criticism of Israel's policies would not be considered anti-Semitism, but the last sentence I have bolded below is to me the most important with reference to the matter at hand, and that is why I consider that ignoring the horrible evils perpetrated by so many other nations and focusing solely on Israel, as the UN and its agencies does, is to me anti-Semitic. And so, in my opinion the whole BDS boycott and what this branch of Presbyterians are doing is anti-Semitic.
Quoted from The Ottawa Protocol:
"Examples of the ways in which antisemitism manifests itself with regard to the State of Israel taking into accountthe overall context could include:
* Applying double standards by requiring of it behaviour not expected or demanded of any other democratic nation.
* Using the symbols and images associated with classic anti-Semitism (e.g. claims of Jews killing Jesus or blood libel) to characterize Israel or Israelis.
* Drawing comparisons of contemporary Israeli policy to that of the Nazis.
* Holding Jews collectively responsible for actions of the State of Israel.
However, criticism of Israel similar to that levelled against any other country cannot be regarded as antisemitic.
Let it be clear. Criticism of Israel is not antisemitic, and saying so is wrong. But singling Israel out for selective condemnation and opprobrium - let alone denying its right to exist or seeking its destruction - is discriminatory and hateful, and not saying so is dishonest."