The Myth of American Exceptionalism
By Stephen M. Walt
The idea that the United States is uniquely virtuous may be comforting to Americans. Too bad it's not true.
Myth 1
There Is Something Exceptional About American Exceptionalism.
Whenever American leaders refer to the "unique" responsibilities of the United States, they are saying that it is different from other powers and that these differences require them to take on special burdens.
Yet there is nothing unusual about such lofty declarations; indeed, those who make them are treading a well-worn path. Most great powers have considered themselves superior to their rivals and have believed that they were advancing some greater good when they imposed their preferences on others. The British thought they were bearing the "white man's burden," while French colonialists invoked la mission civilisatrice to justify their empire . Portugal, whose imperial activities were hardly distinguished, believed it was promoting a certain misso civilizadora . Even many of the officials of the former Soviet Union genuinely believed they were leading the world toward a socialist utopia despite the many cruelties that communist rule inflicted. Of course, the United States has by far the better claim to virtue than Stalin or his successors, but Obama was right to remind us that all countries prize their own particular qualities.
So when Americans proclaim they are exceptional and indispensable, they are simply the latest nation to sing a familiar old song. Among great powers, thinking you're special is the norm, not the exception.
---
Article continues at: http://www.foreignpolicy.com/articles/2011/10/11/the_myth_of_american_exceptionalism?page=0%2C1#.Tp9y8B8zy3s.facebook
Tags
Who is online
70 visitors

Well all you have to do is look at Rome, or GreatBritain, or Greece.
What is the quote?Niro fiddled as Rome burned. I think we may be burning.
Max,
We know that you would, LOL!
Its true that there have been a succession of nation states which have included
their belief system as part of that dominance spread . And certainly the US is
one of those .
In particular the US concepts of separation of church & state is unusual from the
POV of most of these colonial empires . However it is not entirely unique .
For example , the Chinese system of beliefs does not include a diety at all .
Therefore they have no problem separating church and state . However they
do have a problem separating their dominant philosophy from all parts of life
including statecraft . Thus the rise of "the next big power" will be a test of
that philosophy .
Possibly a play on the word "exception" (as well?).
I agree with much of this article.
Where I would draw a distinction, is in the phrase itself. Instead of describing America as uniquely virtuous, I would say that it is virtuously unique. What I mean is that many things that make us unique, are virtuous, worthy of our contemplation and practice. We are a melting pot. Our moto, our mojo, our thing,has been from the very start, freedom. We are a highly dynamic blend of theAmerican Indian and European. Weare capitalism incarnate....
...we invented Rock-and-Roll!
Feronia ,
I think you have something there about the overzealousness of the Chinese
government . They are able to make highly focused action plans happen quickly
but when they make mistakes those are equally as large and focused as their
successes . That is the disadvantage of the command style economy .
They are already starting to make some big & costly mistakes .
We are exceptional in that we have started a great push towards human rights, free elections, free markets, and tolerance.
We may not always live up to those ideals as a nation, butmostly we do.
The difference between us and those you mentioned, is that we have not tried to build an empire. When we liberate a nation, we do not swallow them into our country, but rather try to get them to become peaceful and self sufficient. And we have have a bit of success at it.
One thing that seems to be different about this round of experiments, is our global connectivity. We have chances to learn from each other, and lie to each other, from any where! The results of this dynamic grows with thetechnology. Our technology leadership may give Americans an inflated sense of self; some folks actually believe that because we have had the best and the newest, that means we are better.
Better educated young people would be a big help, but would only marginally affect such bigotry IMHO and probably take at least 3 generations to really kick in. Our Education in this country is on the skids andreceivesnotnearlyenoughattention, creativity from the top down, or cutting ofbureaucracy. Entire school Districts in shambles; it's really justpitiful. Our kids need to be reading books now more than ever, as the years ahead are beyond a doubt, at least, perilous.
One certainly does see a huge number of empty apartments and homes here. Many were built as investments by the newly wealthy, but more recently the government has taken away deduction privileges on more than one owned home. Whatwas accomplished is that we rarely see homeless people. Of course there are some, but not as manyas one might expect considering the massive population.
One amusing thing here. Beijing was becoming host to just too many cars, and so to cut down on traffic they passed a rule that if your licence plate ended with an odd number, you could drive on one day, and that alternated with cars that ended with an even number. So what happened is that many people simply bought a second car and obrained a licence plate for it with the opposite ending number.
(I don't know why this ended up after Max's comment. It was posted to follow the comment which said that I might have something to say about "If they build it..."
One big mistake was not being careful enough with the safety aspects of the super-fast trains. You probably heard about the accident where the signal systems were not adequate to prevent one train from running into another, causing death and injuries.
"i hope china falls flat on its face, hard!"
Well Max, maybe if it looks as if it will happen, China will call in all its loans to the USA. Seems to me that the USAcould fall before China does.
Thanks for the example Buzz . Krishna posted some stuff on the vine about some huge expensive shopping mall which was completed but now stands completely empty . Its location was not where shoppers wanted to go ....
Good Question! I was wondering that myself.
I expect that there are a few bad apples but there are also no formal government regulations in place to restrict such activity . The Chinese haven't been globally "in business" long enough to have needed such government apparatus .
BTW , I'm finding this Ning notification system a PITA . Now , I'm going to have to keep a watch on my email just to get notification . Is there another way on Ning ?
You don't need to use the email to stay on top here. First, if you click on the replied by button, it will take youdirectlyto the latest comment. Looking for more? Then just look in the "Latest Activity" until you find the article that you are interested in following and see the other comments made.
Blog comments will show up on the right as well as in the forum. You are always only one click away from where you want to be.
Yes Perrie . It is indeed a miracle of technology that takes us directly to the last reply . And now that my network link is fixed I can take advantage of that feature ....
Yeah, the kids need to read the books fast before the "do-gooders" ban all the classics, including Darwin.
It's true that the reports indicate that the USA registers pretty low on the good education scale, surpisingly so. Why?
Well if this is any indication, I have met many students from all over the US apply to the top universities in the US, and most of them make me feel pretty stupid. There are many bright students out there. We just keep hearing what a pile of fools that we become, because we expected more.... and we have stagnated.
No denying that we have many bright students. At one time we were the best; some of that due to the flattening of our world as theaveragesriseglobally. Some of it due to our owninattentiveness. Some also due to the "do-gooders" Buzz mentioned, beyond but inclusiveof, book banning, is a philosophy that encourages data-manipulation instead of raw creativity.
The experiences that young humans use to interpret reality, shapes they way they will most likely learn the rest of their lives. Humans sprang from the earth, just like every other creature did. We learned from this planet and it's creatures for such a very long time --- and then---Wham!----the very way that we communicate reaches anotherPlataea!The advent of modern technology has revolutionized the very relationship that humans have with each other, other creatures, and the planet itself. Technology has also enhanced our responsibility in these relationships as well.
When I say read more books, I don't just mean that our education system is sub-par (though I do), I mean that the very philosophy that directs our education system is off kilter. Many of our urban areas have become cesspools with many children never getting to closely face the reality of earth and it inhabitants. The next best thing in my opinion are lots and lots of stories.
I say stories for a reason. Yeah, I said books, and that does include of course non-fiction; but, IMHO that is not the most important resource to be found in books. Facts, figures and detail can be ascribed to part of asuccessfuleducational system; yet not all. In stories one begins to understand that they themselves also have a role in life to play, and the difference is that THEY get to make choices. When one's stories are based on the manipulation of data, their role begins to look kinda bleak...boring...and inevitable.
Dominant isn't the same thing as exceptional. I think we used to be exceptional. Now I am not so sure.
This was an example of the kind of high level exchanges of ideas we used to have "back in the day" . Of course even then we had a loud mouth or 2 ...
Happened to that kind of discourse ?