An explanation for the sincere
Friends, I have a piece about Israel in the current issue of National Review. I thought I’d “blow it out” here in Impromptus. By that I mean, do an expanded version, in bulleted sections. See what you think. During last month’s presidential debate, many of the candidates mentioned Israel. Jeb Bush, for example, said that we need to reestablish “our commitment to Israel, which has been altered by this administration.” Carly Fiorina said that the first phone call she would make, from the Oval Office, would be to “my good friend Bibi Netanyahu.” Its purpose would be “to reassure him we will stand with the State of Israel.” Ted Cruz said, “If I’m elected president, our friends and allies across the globe will know that we stand with them. The bust of Winston Churchill will be back in the Oval Office. And the American embassy in Israel will be in Jerusalem.” From time immemorial, American presidential candidates have pledged to move the embassy from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem. Then, when they become president, they find it inconvenient. Ted, however, is serious. (I’d better append my disclosure: here. He is a friend, and I back him.)
After the debate, some observers wondered, “Why so much attention to Israel? Are these people running for president of the United States or president of Israel?” I myself have received similar questions over the years. People ask, sometimes with scorn, sometimes with sincere curiosity, “Why do you write so much about Israel? Why are you hung up on Israel?” I would think the answer were obvious. But if it were, people would not ask these questions. And honest questions deserve honest answers. Israel is the only state whose very right to exist is called into question. (Ukraine, however, is beset with problems of its own. And Taiwan has well-founded anxieties.) Ever since it was born in 1948, people have tried to kill Israel. It is a tiny country amid enemies. Four wars of annihilation have been waged against Israel. There have been smaller conflicts as well, though still serious. Egypt and Jordan have signed peace treaties with Israel. The first came in 1979, the second in 1994. Israel is still waiting for the third treaty.
Every day, Israel deals with Hezbollah, Hamas, and their like. And Iran has pledged to wipe it off the face of the earth. They are driving toward nuclear weapons, in large measure to accomplish just that. I think Israel is a great and admirable state. I think Zionism is a great and admirable movement. The revival of Hebrew alone is one of the more astonishing developments of modern times. But put Zionism to one side for a moment (and remember that this movement began in the 19th century). Israel was established a mere three years after the Holocaust. Three years after the ovens of Auschwitz and the rest stopped belching. Three years after two-thirds of European Jewry were murdered. Think of that: The Jews fought for and established their state — or reestablished it, if you like (given ancient Israel) — a mere three years after being subjected to genocide. The Jews, as a people, refused to disappear altogether. In Israel, they are living in sovereignty for the first time in 2,000 years. To begrudge the Jews their state, after the Holocaust, is particularly disgusting, I think.
~LINK~
~LINK~

I agree we should continue to pledge to defend Israel , as President Obama has done. As we do many of our allies. As you know Israel was founded by a vote by the UN. But now Israel has many UN resolutions signed against its activities. Why?
This sums it up pretty well:
Bush calls for end of 'occupation' of Arab lands
There are many in Israel who understand this, and it seems most Jews in the US. Most won't go this far, though:
America’s Left-Wing Jews Are Ashamed of Israel’s Jews
"To understand their fury, one must first understand that no one is more certain of their moral superiority than the Left."
Damn straight we are!
I just read this one, probably not agreed to by many:
The Iran Treaty By Uri Avnery
"Uri Avnery is an Israeli writer and founder of the Gush Shalom peace movement. A member of the Irgun as a teenager, Avnery sat in the Knesset from 1965 to 1974 and from 1979 to 1981." (Wiki)
(how do I get that peace smiley out of there?)
Cletus,
Our new site still has a couple of kinks to work out, one being that certain words trigger a corresponding smiley!
:~)
Obama pledges to defend then does his best to avoid it. His lack of verbal support has been instrumental in the increase of violence against Israeli civilians.
Obama pledges to defend then does his best to avoid it. His lack of verbal support has been instrumental in the increase of violence against Israeli civilians.
Now Obama is the cause of violence within Israel's borders ? ROFL. Newstalkers is far too predictable as regards Israel. It's almost to the point where objective people might as well just skip these threads.
The Russell is far too predictable about all things Obama . His adoration of his lord & savior Obama makes it impossible for him to see even the suggestion that a mistake might have been made . And like a little school girl he resorts to the "ROFL" as the ultimate in wit . So extremely lame ! Let's get lost needs to follow his own screen name suggestion & go away ...
This is just a matter of form rather than content, but when I see a massive unending paragraph like that I don't even try to start reading it.
Need an indent button, or am I not seeing it?
In the future I'll put some tabs in, thanks.
I'll try to redo it Buzz.
Thanks, Larry. Now I have read it and agree with every word.