Judge Allowed to Double Laughing Defendant's Sentence, Court Rules
Judge Allowed to Double Laughing Defendant's Sentence, Court Rules
The two-year prison sentence was 'imposed out of haste and imprudence,' a dissenting judge writes.
An appeals court says judges can change sentences until hearings are ended.
A federal judge was entitled to double the prison term of a man who laughed during a sentencing hearing, a divided panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit ruled Thursday.
U.S. District Judge Lawrence O’Neill initially gave Ramon Ochoa a sentence of one year and a day in 2014 for violating the terms of his early release from prison, where Ochoa had been sent after pleading guilty to being a felon in possession of a firearm. But O'Neill doubled the penalty to two years when he observed Ochoa laughing in his California courtroom.
“You think this is funny?” O’Neill demanded to know. “No way,” Ochoa responded.
“What is the laughter about?” the judge inquired. “I’m just surprised,” Ochoa explained.
[ READ: Cops Won't Give 'Good Tickets' After Public Concern ]
Unsatisfied with the answer and convinced Ochoa was being disrespectful, O’Neill announced “you just talked yourself into more time” and gave him the maximum penalty of two years.
The two appeals judges who ruled the change was legal found sentences can be altered until a sentencing hearing has concluded.
The dissenting judge, Gloria Navarro, wrote that sentences, once orally communicated, could only be increased if there was a “finding that the sentence imposed had resulted from ‘arithmetical, technical, or other clear error.’”
Navarro wrote that her colleagues set a troubling precedent by taking a different view of rules that limit sentence adjustments.
[ ALSO: Family of Pot Patients Sentenced to Prison in Washington State ]
“Casting aside the clear limitations required by these provisions, the majority upholds a sentence that was imposed out of haste and imprudence, based on conduct that occurred within the courtroom,” Navarro wrote. “It is hard to imagine a more draconian rule than the one adopted by the majority today.”
Ochoa now is slated to be released on Christmas Eve, according to information on the Federal Bureau of Prisons' website and his attorney, Carlton Gunn, says he hasn’t decided yet if he will appeal the ruling, due in part to the fact that his client’s sentence will have expired by the time an appeal would be decided.
Gunn notes fast-tracked Supreme Court review is unlikely because there’s not yet a split among U.S. appeals courts on the matter. He nonetheless insists his client’s case is distinguishable from similar rulings in other circuits, as Ochoa denies he intentionally disrespected O’Neill.
“I think the decision is wrong, of course,” Gunn says. “Lots of people laugh because they’re nervous. Laughter can mean a whole bunch of different things, and it’s troubling to think a guy’s sentence got doubled because a judge happened to interpret it a certain way.”
Tags
Who is online
110 visitors

How can you expect people to respect the justice system when a judge is allowed to make a farce out of a sentencing proceeding ? He gave the defendant a year in prison for laughing in court. Outrageous.
A little respect is easy to give and would have cost the defendant nothing, but the disrespect (real or perceived depending on your viewpoint) cost him dearly.
Maybe you will be in traffic court one day, and you get sentenced to watch a driving video. Then you fart and the judge hears it. He sentences you to six months in jail for disrespecting the court. How do you like it now ?
Judges should be able to control their emotions and whims.
I always enjoy your exaggerated examples - they never make any sense but you obviously use all your brain power to come up with what you think is a clever quip
Robert, all my brain power has never been required to reply to you.
Funny since you never use any brain power to reply to anyone
Snark is your specialty and you never miss a chance to show your ass (verbally thank goodness)
The judge who doubled the sentence was dead wrong. The defendant answered when questioned that he did not find the sentencing hearing funny and was presumably not laughing at that point. That should have been the end of it right there. The judge abused their power either because they had a bug up their ass that day, had a headache, had a fight with a spouse or partner, was constipated, had the shits or whatever, but they were dead wrong.
“Casting aside the clear limitations required by these provisions, the majority upholds a sentence that was imposed out of haste and imprudence, based on conduct that occurred within the courtroom,” Navarro wrote. “It is hard to imagine a more draconian rule than the one adopted by the majority today.”
Absolutely correct.
You are apparently wrong since the sentencing was upheld. Thug got what he deserved. LOL.
When respect for the law and for the judicial system that enforces and administers it is shown disrespect, it is a step on the road to anarchy. For the convicted to laugh at the imposition of a sentence in the court is IMO disrespect, and just such a step. Although perhaps it isn't true in America, in English commonwealth countries decorum in the court is essential.