╌>

Texas campus carry law is a slap in the face of survivors of past shootings

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  community  •  11 years ago  •  13 comments

Texas campus carry law is a slap in the face of survivors of past shootings

At the University of Texas at Austin some still remember the 1966 mass school shooting. Their pleas for gun control have been ignored.



W hen it comes to gun control, Americans seem doomed to make the same stupid mistakes. In 1966, America witnessed its first ever, recorded mass school shooting at the University of Texas at Austin. Next year, on the 50th anniversary of the shooting, a law in Texas goes into effect requiring the state’s public universities to allow handguns in dorms, classrooms and campus buildings. That’s a slap in the face of survivors – and a sign that we still haven’t learned our lesson.

Until the 2007 massacre at Virginia Tech, the 1966 shooting was the deadliest school shooting in American history. That day, on 1 August, Charles Whitman, a 25-year-old student and former Marine Sharpshooter, made his way to the campus observation deck on the 28 th floor of the UT Tower building and began shooting at the unsuspecting crowd below. Whitman shot and killed 16 people that day and wounded 32 others.

The level of violence was unheard of at the time and it became the impetus for the development of the ambulance and Emergency Medical System in the US as well as contributing to the creation of police tactical teams trained to respond to unusual situations.


But while some emergency response lessons were gleaned from the tragedy, suggestions for preventative measures such as gun control and better mental health services continue to be ignored by our state legislature.

The passage of a campus carry law in May has divided Texas, but at the University of Texas at Austin, where some still remember the day that Charles Whitman rained down bullets on their school, guns are not welcome. The overwhelming majority of staff, students and law enforcement officials are against it. The UT Faculty Council voted unanimously against campus carry and the student government reaffirmed its stance against it in a 21-6 vote.

A group called Gun-Free UT, which describes themselves as “a group of faculty, staff, students and parents who want the university to be an entirely gun-free zone”, has obtained over 7500 signatures so far on a petition to keep guns out of classrooms. Their goal as stated on their Facebook page is: “to protest SB11, to limit the impact of SB11 on our campus and ultimately to repeal SB11 and other laws that allow guns to be carried anywhere on campus”.


By passing the bill, state legislators also ignored the Texas Association of College and University Police Administrators and the Austin Chief of Police who both testified against campus carry.

Proponents of campus carry, and gun access in general, like to claim that more guns means more opportunity for people to protect themselves in the event of a mass shooter. But there is no evidence to suggest that this is the case.

The Charles Whitman massacre is one incident that is often trotted out by pro-gun enthusiasts who say that armed civilians pinned Whitman down with fire from their deer rifles, minimizing the amount of shooting he was able to do while police made their way to the observation deck. But these gun enthusiasts fail to see the bigger picture.


It’s because of easy gun access that Whitman was able to kill as many as he did in the first place. Whitman purchased two of the semi-automatic rifles he used from the observation deck on the morning of the attack, along with six additional ammunition magazines and 14 boxes of ammunition.

These new guns were added to those already at home: a Remington 700 6mm bolt-action hunting rifle, a .35 caliber pump rifle, a .30 caliber carbine M1, a 9mm Luger pistol, a Galesi-Brescia .25-caliber pistol and a Smith & Wesson M19 .357 Magnum revolver and over 700 rounds of ammunition. He had so many guns firing from different places along the observation deck that people, at first, thought there were multiple gunmen.

Claire Wilson James was the first person shot by Whitman from the tower. She was eight months pregnant and lost her unborn baby and her boyfriend that day. In February of this year, she testified before the Texas Senate, urging them not to pass SB 11 or any legislation that would allow more guns on campus.

While the civilians who shot back at Whitman were well meaning, she said , they kept emergency personnel from reaching her and her boyfriend. A survivor of the Virginia Tech massacre, Colin Goddard, also beseeched legislators not to use the incident to pass the bill saying : “We are not going to be able to shoot our way out of problems on college campuses”.


Allowing guns on campus will not make anyone safer. What we need is less weapons and more mental health support for students and staff alike. That was one of the conclusions reached in September of 1966 by a committee appointed to investigate the Charles Whitman massacre.

They found one of the most important things the state could do to prevent future mass shootings was to expand their medical services on campus and create a mental health program within the university system that provided counseling services for all students and staff.

Texas suffers from a dearth of mental health professionals to serve at such programs 50 years on. The situation is considered by the University of Texas’ Hogg Center for Mental Health to be at a crisis point . For the last decade the state spent less per capita on mental health services than any other state in the Union. In 2014, a UT Task Force on Student Mental Health and Safety found that wait times for a first appointment for non-crisis situations can be as much as three weeks, and time between appointments can vary between one and three weeks.

Where are the small government Republicans when the wants of the community that must live and work on Texas campuses are being dismissed? Sadly, they are no where to be found.

http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2015/oct/29/texas-campus-carry-law-slap-in-face-survivors-of-past-shootings?CMP=ema_565a



 


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

It seems that the overwhelming number of people who work at and attend and police The University of Texas at Austin, both the University Police and the Chief of the Austin City Police do not want guns on campus. The Texas Association of College and University Police Administrators do not want guns on the campus of The University of Texas at Austin (or any other campus). The only people who do want guns on the campus of The University of Texas at Austin, over just about every other person's objection associated with or concerning The University of Texas at Austin (or at any other Texas university), is the Texas legislature. What's wrong with this picture?

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov  replied to  Randy   11 years ago

Nothing. The legislature has that authority in our republic. Bravo!

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    11 years ago

On the other hand....

by Wayne Laugesen

This article was originally published in the Boulder Weekly , and is posted here by permission.

Oct. 15, 1999. More from the Independence Institute on school attacks and armed resistance .

 

Vice Principal Joel Myrick held his Colt .45 point blank to the high school boy's head. Last week, he told me what it was like. "I said 'why are you shooting my kids?' He said it was because nobody liked him and everything seemed hopeless," Myrick said. "Then I asked him his name. He said 'you know me, Mr. Myrick. Remember? I gave you a discount on your pizza delivery last week."

The shooter was Luke Woodham. On that day in 1997, Woodham slit his mother's throat then grabbed a .30-30 lever action deer rifle. He packed the pockets of his trench coat with ammo and headed off to Pearl High School, in Pearl, Miss.

The moment Myrick heard shots, he ran to his truck. He unlocked the door, removed his gun from its case, removed a round of bullets from another case, loaded the gun and went looking for the killer. "I've always kept a gun in the truck just in case something like this ever happened," said Myrick, who has since become Principal of Corinth High School, Corinth, Miss.

Woodham knew cops would arrive before too long, so he was all business, no play. No talk of Jesus, just shooting and reloading, shooting and reloading. He shot until he heard sirens, and then ran to his car. His plan, authorities subsequently learned, was to drive to nearby Pearl Junior High School and shoot more kids before police could show up.

But Myrick foiled that plan. He saw the killer fleeing the campus and positioned himself to point a gun at the windshield. Woodham, seeing the gun pointed at his head, crashed the car. Myrick approached the killer and confronted him. "Here was this monster killing kids in my school, and the minute I put a gun to his head he was a kid again," Myrick said.

True humanitarian

I've been intrigued by Myrick ever since that day. Most have never heard his name, because the mainstream press barely reported how the massacre was stopped. I've become more interested in Myrick's story with every subsequent mass murder. If only someone like Myrick had been at Columbine, I've pondered.

A few months ago, Soldier of Fortune Publisher Bob Brown asked me if I had any suggestions as to whom should receive his magazine's Humanitarian Award of 1999. In the wake of Columbine, the answer seemed clear: Joel Myrick. Brown talked it over with his staff, gave it some thought and went with my choice. Brown and I will present Myrick with his award Friday in Las Vegas, at the annual Soldier of Fortune Convention and Expo.

Myrick and his gun, no matter how one looks at it, saved lives. His actions saved the lives of waiting victims at a nearby junior high. He may have kept Woodham from shooting police, who would have arrived at the scene disoriented, without Myrick's home turf frame of reference. Arguably, Myrick and his gun even saved the life of the killer, who likely would have killed himself or been shot by SWAT cops after spilling more blood.

Although Myrick saved lives, beyond question, some treat him as a leper. After the shootings, and the relatively peaceful ending to something that could have made Columbine pale in comparison, Myrick was in exile. He'd held a gun to a student's head, and his colleagues simply couldn't accept that.

"Nobody wanted to dog me, but nobody wanted to side with me, either," Myrick says. "I felt like I was being betrayed by everybody." 

And that was Mississippi. This summer he studied at Harvard, where he'd been awarded a prestigious education fellowship. That's when uppity intolerance and mass stupidity took on new meaning for Myrick. "Once people found out my story, I got a lot of dirty looks and strange stares," Myrick said. "A few people confronted me."

Myrick shouldn't feel bad. Only goofy losers gave Myrick funny looks, and such people never learn. Myrick's gun, and his ability and willingness to use it, saved lives plain and simple. Yet somehow, in the minds of the anti-intellectual gun control crowd, he's a bad man who did an immoral deed.

By any sane, rational view, Myrick is a life-saving humanitarian. Even in my view, however, his heroic act will be marred by an asterisk in the annals of history. Despite the presence of this brave man, two students still died. Therefore, the footnote of far off history books will read something like this:

*The late 20th Century was an era of crude polemics, in which some people believed hardware items, such as handguns, caused mass murders.
Therefore, ineffective laws that reflected this view made it illegal for this legendary hero to have his gun on campus. The gun was in a truck, giving the killer valuable time as Myrick ran to retrieve it. In modern society, of course, responsible adults have better access to hardware than killers do.

Arguing with a moron

Myrick is as much of a hero as the law would allow. He was only seconds away from the shootings, yet the law had him far away from his gun. Federal law precludes anyone but a cop from having a weapon in or near a school. The modern spree of school shootings began sometime shortly after this law was enacted. In most places, state and local laws needlessly duplicate the federal law, serving only to accommodate political grandstanding.

In Pearl, federal, state and local laws helped Luke Woodham shoot nine students. The deer rifle had to be reloaded after every shot. To hit nine students, Woodham needed time. The moments it took Myrick to reach his gun are what allowed Woodham to continue shooting and almost escape. Gun laws, and nothing else, gave Woodham that time. 

But talking to gun control advocates is like talking to five year-olds. Tell a five-year-old it's time for bed, and he'll say "No." Ask why not, and he'll say "because." Likewise, I've told a few gun control advocates about Myrick-telling them how he would have saved more kids had it not been for gun laws-and they've said "guns kill." Or, "we have too many guns." Or, "Woodham killed his victims with a gun."

At which point I say, "Woodham violated several gun laws by having his gun on campus. The law did nothing to deter him, but plenty to deter the man who set out to stop the killings." To which a gun controller replied: "But guns kill."

Sucked in and trapped by this bizarre logic, I attempted to address it. I said: "But Joel Myrick's gun didn't kill. Rather, it allowed children, including the deranged killer, to live."

"Yeah, but all of these school shootings are done by guns," he told me.

So I pounded my head against a wall. Politics and sociology are complex. But if any socio-political issue should be a simple, exact science, it's gun control. All honest modern studies show that gun control, in this culture, benefits criminals while leaving law-abiding victims defenseless.

In his book More Guns Less Crime , Yale law professor John Lott ran the numbers every which way possible. He set out to write a book about guns being bad, and found that every gun law ever enacted in this country has resulted in more violent crime. I saw him on TV recently, debating a gun control advocate. Lott cited numbers and anecdotes. His opponent, in essence, said "but guns kill."

Politics of nothing

Right here in Boulder, a city of self-proclaimed enlightenment, city council members are hard at it trying to enact more gun control in the light of Columbine. Weird. Today in Boulder, it is absolutely illegal in every way, shape and form for a student to walk onto, or anywhere near a public school with a gun of any kind. Remove all state and local gun laws, and you still have a federal law that clearly forbids firearms of any kind within 100 yards of public schools.

Anyone who shoots up any school, anywhere, is violating gun laws. So what does the Boulder City Council think up to address the very real concern of school massacres? Hey, let's pass some gun laws. Duh. "If we can save one life," it would be worth it, Councilman Dan Corson told the Daily Camera.

If the city council manages to craft a gun law that isn't redundant to the Nth degree, it will serve only to make victims of future massacres more defenseless-guaranteed. Some politicians know this, but they don't care. What matters is how the public perceives the headlines their words garner. Guns kill. Duhhh. "Let's outlaw guns."

Gun control was essential to Hitler and slave owners in the Old South. Proven fact: Gun control oppresses and kills. Proven fact #2: Responsible adults, such as Joel Myrick, save lives. When unencumbered by bizarre gun laws, they can save even more lives.

So let's appeal to the Boulder City Council and the Boulder Valley School Board to explore ways of empowering law abiding adults. Perhaps it's time for the school district, with the full support of city hall, to establish a voluntary defensive weapons training course for teachers and administrators. Politicians who find a way to balance the firepower between forces of good and evil, by arming some teachers and administrators, might not get re-elected. But they might preclude a future disaster like Columbine, where SWAT teams sat helplessly in a parking lot while a teacher in the building prepared to fire at the shooters with a fire extinguisher.

Have a good laugh at this idea, on me. Then ask yourself whether it's more important to be re-elected, or to cut short a future school massacre.

We will never rid society of guns unless we eliminate the natural phenomenon of internal combustion. A gun is a crude instrument and nothing more than a controlled explosion. America is home to about 250 million of them, and they're with us to stay regardless of law. 

If you want to save lives, the answer is simple. Stop keeping guns from the hands of would-be heroes-the only people who obey gun laws. Joel Myrick had a gun, legally in his truck. Myrick and his gun saved lives, but they could have saved more. The lesson: Some guns save lives.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov  replied to  screminmimi   11 years ago

Bravo. A triumph of reason over trite emotionalism. The gun grabbers can not or will not appeal to reason.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy  replied to  screminmimi   11 years ago

And? That has what to do with Texas State University at Austin and all of the people there who want this not to happen? Don't they have the right to what they consider to be a safer campus? Do the want to have to try to learn while the are constantly looking over their shoulders to see if a couple of other students decide to settle a small problem with a shoot out? It doesn't take much to set some people off and it'd be better if the got into a fist fight, then a shoot out where others can and probably will be shot, wounded and/or killed. They deserve a save campus, because they are the ones going their everyday, not any members of the State Legislature.

In fact let's make it legal for citizens to carry guns into the actual legislature while the are in session. I think they might object to that when a constituent has his or her coat pulled back, showing their pistol and looking at their or a different Representative during a heated debate or vote very, very threatening.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    11 years ago

This article is a slap in the face to reason, the Constitution, and to writing teachers everywhere. Pure emotional tripe.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

The Guardian makes it sound like everyone will be walking around with a gun and holster like the old west.  This is to be expected though.

 General Information

On June 1, 2015, Gov. Greg Abbott signed S.B. 11, also known as the "campus carry" law. S.B. 11 provides that license holders may carry a concealed handgun throughout university campuses, starting Aug. 1, 2016. The law gives public universities some discretion to regulate campus carry.

The University of Texas at Austin and President Gregory L. Fenves take issues surrounding guns on campus very seriously and will strive to create policies that conform to the new law, protect the rights of citizens and ensure the safety and security of the entire campus.

S.B. 11 provides that after consulting with students, staff and faculty regarding "the nature of the student population, specific safety considerations and the uniqueness of the campus environment" the university may enact reasonable rules and regulations regarding:

  • carrying of concealed handguns by license holders on campus; and
  • storage of handguns in dormitories or other residential facilities

The law stipulates, however, that these rules and regulations may not either "generally prohibit" or "have the effect of generally prohibiting" license holders from carrying concealed handguns on campus.

President Fenves has established a 19-member Working Group that will recommend to him S.B. 11 implementation policies by the end of November. The Working Group will hold two public forums on campus and welcomes your comments through an online survey . All campus policies and guidelines will be communicated clearly to students, faculty and staff before they are implemented, and University leadership will strive to answer any questions about them.

Facts About Campus Carry

The law does NOT allow open carry on campus

S.B. 11 deals only with the concealed carry of handguns by people who have a concealed carry license. It is now — and will still be — illegal to display a firearm in campus buildings as well as on campus streets, sidewalks, walkways, etc.

A person must have a license to carry a concealed handgun on campus. One must be 21 to obtain a license to carry We estimate that fewer than 1 percent of UT students have licenses to carry. Only about 500 students 21 and older live in UT residential halls License holders have been allowed to carry concealed handguns on campus (but not in buildings) for 20 years S.B. 11 does not affect fraternity or sorority houses or other private residential facilities The law still makes it a crime for a license holder to carry a concealed handgun while intoxicated.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy  replied to  sixpick   11 years ago

One carried gun, license or 21 or not, is still one too many guns on campus.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick  replied to  Randy   11 years ago

One carried gun, license or 21 or not, is still one too many guns on campus.

 

They've been allowed to carry for 20 years.  How many mass shootings have they had during that time?

Seems to me not during that time.

When I was in school almost every pickup had a gun rack and at least one gun on it, but no shootings at all.

I'd love it if all these creeping liberals put a "Gun Free Zone" sign in their front yards. When they try to make like their underlying objective isn't to take American Citizen's guns we know they're full of it and lying.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov  replied to  sixpick   11 years ago

Campuses are not Constitution-free zones.

 
 

Who is online

Gsquared
JohnRussell


122 visitors