U.S., Iran finesse inspections of military sites in nuclear deal
Major powers and Iran finessed how U.N. inspectors will get access to Iranian military sites in Tuesday's nuclear agreement, with a formula that gives the United Nations strong inspection powers while allowing Tehran to save face.
Deep in the deal's details is a procedure under which Iran would have to provide access to suspect sites, including at its military facilities, within 24 days. If Iran refused, it would face the possibility of U.N. sanctions being slapped back on it.
The procedure was crafted to ensure U.N. inspectors could get access to allay their suspicions about Iran's nuclear activities. But it does not explicitly force Iran to admit that its military sites could be open to foreign inspections, leaving some uncertainty over the access Iran will allow in practice.
In Tuesday's landmark deal, Iran and six major powers struck a compromise under which Tehran will limit its nuclear program in return for relief from economic sanctions.
One of the most controversial issues in the negotiations was whether the U.N.'s International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) would be able to visit military sites if they had questions about suspected nuclear activities or facilities within them.
The matter became even harder to resolve, diplomats said, after Iran's Supreme Leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, on June 23 said granting access to Iran's military sites was a "red line."
In the end, Britain, China, France, Germany, Russia and the United States agreed on language with Iran that requires more of Tehran than the existing global nonproliferation system while avoiding a direct mention of the sensitive military site issue.
"This is rather clever and reflects the interests of all sides," said George Perkovich, vice president of studies at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace think tank.
INSPECTIONS, 'WITHOUT SAYING SO'
Under the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty's "Additional Protocol," the IAEA may ask for "managed access" to any site, including military, but a country can legitimately bar access by tying the U.N. nuclear watchdog up in endless negotiations.
This deal aims to close such loopholes with a process under which Iran would give access or otherwise allay IAEA concerns within 24 days, a time frame experts say is tight enough to keep it from sanitizing unauthorized nuclear work.
Iran and the IAEA have 14 days to resolve disagreements among themselves. If they fail to, a joint commission comprised of eight members - the six major powers, Iran and the European Union - would consider the matter for a week.
A majority of the eight could then inform Iran of the steps it would then take within three more days.
Majority-rule means the United States and its European allies -- Britain, France, Germany and the EU -- could insist on access or any other steps and that Iran, Russia or China could not veto them.
"This almost inevitably means inspections but without saying so. Thats why diplomats make the big bucks," Perkovich added.
Nonproliferation experts said the regime falls short of the "anywhere, anytime" inspections demanded by critics of the deal, including many Republicans, but said that would only be possible in a country that has been defeated militarily.
"Its not a perfect procedure. It would be good to get no notice inspections, but that simply wasnt in the cards," said Bob Einhorn, a nonproliferation specialist at the Brookings Institution think tank and former U.S. negotiator with Iran.
NO ACCESS TO IRANIAN "BEDROOMS"
In hailing the agreement on Tuesday, U.S. President Barack Obama said it meant that "inspectors will have 24/7 access to Irans key nuclear facilities."
Obama, who on Wednesday said the deal represented the "most vigorous inspection and verification regime, by far, that has ever been negotiated," was referring only to Iran's declared nuclear sites.
Sites that the IAEA has suspicions about, including any that may be within Iran's many military complexes, fall under the separate procedure with its 24-day time limit.
The word "military" occurs only once in the agreement, where it says that access requests would not be aimed at interfering with Iranian military or other national security activities.
Senior Iranian officials said they would provide the "managed access" called for under the Additional Protocol and said little about the additional procedures stipulated under the new deal.
"Managed access" is a mechanism to allow the minimum needed IAEA oversight to ensure there is no diversion to clandestine nuclear or nuclear-related activities, while limiting access to protect a legitimate military or industrial secrets.
"We have nothing to hide. We have always cooperated with the IAEA and allowed them to visit our sites," a senior Iranian official told reporters in Vienna on Tuesday. "However, it does not mean that we are going to share our intelligence with others or allow them to enter to our bedrooms to investigate."
U.S. officials said they believed that Tehran had committed to providing access to any site, including military, though they acknowledged the possibility it might refuse.
If it found Iran to be in breach of the deal, the United States could, single-handedly, move to "snap back" U.N. sanctions on Iran.
Under an agreement among Britain, China, France, Russia and the United States, the U.N. Security Council's permanent members who each have veto power, a resolution to re-impose sanctions would be drafted in such a way that none could block it.
Reinstating the U.N. sanctions in full would be to a wield a heavy hammer against Iran and one that the major powers might be loathe to use.
However, a senior U.S. official raised the possibility of re-imposing some but not all sanctions through a "partial snapback," making the punishment more a scalpel than hammer.
Asked if Washington expected Tehran to honor demands for access, and hence avoid any need to reimpose U.N. sanctions, a senior U.S. official told Reuters: "I hope so."
http://www.reuters.com/article/2015/07/15/us-iran-nuclear-military-sites-analysis-idUSKCN0PP2TG20150715

Nice move to get into military sites.
Of course you won't hear any of this from those that want to make political hay of the agreement.
Well, okay, here is one hayseed making his comment.
I wonder what the success of the DEA would be if they gave 24 HOURS notice to a suspected drug dealer that they were going to inspect his premises.
Will Iran give the $140 billion back?
Buzz, I'm working on a piece about how it is impossible to hide nuclear research.
To that end. 24 hours, 24 days, 24 years, it doesn't matter. Once things are irradiated, they stay irradiated. To this day there are still buildings, pipes, and wiring that in Oak Ridge, Tn. that scientists can test, and tell exactly what type of radiation something was exposed to, for how long it was exposed, and how strong that radiation was. You can't change physics.
Secondly these facilities aren't something small. It is impossible to sanitize a nuclear research facility because of their size and complexity. I have more confidence in the ability to sniff out a nuclear research program than I do a chemical or biological one. The IAEA knows how to go about a search.
Also keep in mind that this is all really about getting Iran back in line with the NPT when you look at it squarely.
I don't trust them.
I know this is only one incident and one person, but to me it indicated a way of life:
My son met an Iranian-American Muslim girl at Seeds of Peace Camp, where they were both staff, and they started a relationship. One day when she visited in Toronto my son took her to a marketplace and they bought a dozen cookies from a vendor. The girlfriend took a bite out of one of the cookies and didn't like it, so she put it back in the bag and went back to the vendor and demanded the money back. My son was horrified. It ended the relationship.
Well this should convince all the skeptics.
By agreeing to this provision in the deal, the Iranians have proven themselves to be changed individuals and a changed nation, worthy of the trust of us all
They drew the red line for us by agreeing to negotiate if they decide to not allow access to a site
And how hard will it be to get the sanctions back in place (including China and Russia) if the negotiations on a site visit do not work out, not hard at all.
Yes this provision convinces me - a great deal all around
And the choice of the word finesse is a telling one - the urban dictionary defines finesse as
So I wonder did we finesse the Iranians or did they finesse us?
A question to be answered by future actions I guess
Now you have me scared Robert......
Me, I'm encouraged, but I'll keep the corks in the champagne bottles, and the cigars locked away till we get a full reporting after the IAEA inspection. Lets just get to work.
Trust is one of the biggest obstacles to overcome, and it's been that way since early man grabbed a stick and found he could use it as a tool.
Do I trust Iran, no not really. Do they trust the US... hell no. Are their going to be problems along the way, sure there are. But the more I read and grasp this agreement, the more I am confident that it is the best of all the bad choices we face.
One might remember the phrase "crap in one hand and hope in the other and see which becomes full first"
I am also reminded of a line from a favorite movie "Animal House - The uniformed ROTC cadet stands in the midst of utter chaos and over and over intones "All is well".
Remember "Trust but verify"? Is this deal any different than the weapons agreements we had to go through with the Soviets? Not really. In fact those may have been worse, because we had to show them B-52 bombers cut into sections. We had to show them Pershing II launch bodies burned out.
In this case, all of the action is on the Iranians.
Fly,
There must be a reason why they want 24 days, and not say a week notice.
And the fact that long range missiles are back on the table in 5-7 years, I am not good with at all.
I'm concerned about the 24 days. Even though they may not be able to "hide" anything in 24 days my question is this...
In light of the fact that they held all the cards in knowing when they would agree to sit down and negotiate anything at, and in light of the fact that they have had over a decade of listening to the rest of us complain and worry about their getting a nuclear bomb....
how much time did they need to work on a way to conceal whatever they wanted to within that 24 day time frame?
In the agreement it is 14 days notice. This is not a long period of time with respect to inspection. As I said, you can't hide things that have been irradiated. Buildings, concrete, piping....It is impossible. Put your science cap on and think about it just for a bit.
With regards to Missiles, what bothers you? You aren't suggesting that any country would be stupid enough to lob a single or even a dozen ICBMs somebody's direction these day? It means suicide for those that launched them. You need to fear Ryder Rental Trucks more. Hence the reason to focus on nuclear research and to get Iran back in line with the NPT.
You are a very smart lady Perrie.... Think it through. Work the problem.
Use the gray matter Mimi. If we do nothing, then they will be able to achieve what you fear without fail. Through engagement, the IAEA has at least a shot of stiffing that nuke you fear out. So what is your choice?
FLY
This deal may be the best that Pres Obama and Secy Kerry could do, but it is not a good deal, and it does nothing to make me think that we can trust the Iranians to abide by its provisions once the sanctions are lifted, because they will be very difficult if not impossible to get back to the levels they are now in any expeditious manner.
It may be better than no deal, but it is far from a good deal.
The wording "the UN may slap back sanctions..." should say "will slap back sanctions". It's way too ambiguous is it not? I mean sanctions are what brought them to the table to begin with...
Of course you won't hear any of this from those that want to make political hay of the agreement.
I agree and to some of those in Congress and on the campaign trail who haven't even read it but are trying to make hay out of it, as the President said, it's not like you can hide the evidence in a closet or roll it away on a cart. And it'll take a lot longer then 24 days for the radiation evidence to disappear or be eradicated. They can't cheat on the inspections. At least not at the sites that are inspected. If they have any hidden ones, then we don't know about them and this treaty wouldn't have had any affect on them anyway.
You aren't suggesting that any country would be stupid enough to lob a single or even a dozen ICBMs somebody's direction these day? It means suicide for those that launched them. You need to fear Ryder Rental Trucks more.
Maybe we should all open fire on every one of them we see. Are the U-Haul ones OK?
14 days, 24 days - what does that matter? Red lines are erased, time limits are extended. The Iranians will have no trouble fooling the west - they're good at it.
Huh ? With the border stops in the middle east WTF are you talking about?
It may be better than no deal, but it is far from a good deal.
But it is still a much, much, much better deal then no deal. The other option was military and we don't want, need nor can afford another war. We don't have the money or troops (without a draft) and GB will be the only country to join us with troops and I'm not even sure about them.
Can they build a weapon in ten years? Maybe they will, but it's better then having them build one now. It gives us breathing room. Will they cheat? They might try but the will get caught and then, if we can't get enough sanctions back into place to hurt them bad, then we can consider the most stupid and worstof options, a military one. They have lied to us before, but then againso has every other country on the face of the earth that I am aware of at one time or another, IMHO. Still, let's give them a chance and find out if they'll lie this time. If they do, they can't and won'tget away with it. If they don't, then it was a good deal.
It was never meant to solve all of our problems with Iran or make them suddenly a wonderful country, but neither ere deals we had with the Soviets. It was just about one single thing. Stopping them from building a nuclear bomb right now and I believe that it will succeed.
The ones in the U-Haul trucks are having a hard enough time already...
The weapons delivery vehicle of choice is a Ryder Truck vs. an ICBM
Easier to hide, and you have a much more difficult time knowing the origin of the weapon. Think Oklahoma Bomber.
You launch a rocket, and tracking systems will provide a launch point withing about 30 seconds if that long.
Be realistic, those demands could not have been written into any deal, and Iran would be free to continue working towards a nuke. Russia and China were not going to go for any additional sanctions either.
Please try to keep in mind.... This wasn't Obama negotiating, this was a bunch of countries working to try to get Iran back in line with the NPT.
What would you have the world do Dennis?
FLY
It is a subtle but valid point, that President Obama (through his secretary of state as proxy) did indeed negotiate with those that support terrorism
T G D
But it is still a much, much, much better deal then no deal.
So the administration and the media report, until an inspection is refused and the negotiating process drags on and on and nothing is done with the sanctions and ........
This is classic government in action of recent decades, kicking a problem down the road for others to deal with rather than taking more direct action. The administration(current and others)has supported and facilitated regime change in Egypt Libya, Afghanistan and other countries why not in Iran
And to be really honest again Robert, we supported and sponsored very ruthless dictators that in all rights were terrorists as well in Korea, Vietnam, Iraq, and Iran. Nobody's hands are clean,
FLY
Being equally honest, the fact that we did stupid shit in the past does not make doing stupid shit now any more palatable or right
And the hands of the current administration and president are as dirty as any who made the deals/changes in the countries you mentioned.
Which of those countries are you happy with the way things have turned out so far?
Using "they did it first and they did it worse" as a defense to a poor decision is tiresome at best, worrisome as well.
I realize that they can't hide the irradiation, but what if they have a way of locking down the places that they do, do the actual work? Everyone is aware that they have become much better at hiding what they do. What if we can't find what they don't want us to find? It could be that they have a lockdown protocol that takes some time, and hence why no "surprise" visits. Otherwise, why would they care? Also, they are not denying that they are developing nuclear power, but what they are denying is that they are doing this to make a bomb. They could claim that any radiation found is from this development, while hiding any development other than for power. And if this is only for power, why do they still want missiles?
In regards to the Missiles, I realize that for most western countries that MAD usually keeps everything in line. But as we have seen in the ME, they don't think like the western world. Heck, even India and Pakistan have gone to defcon 4 several times. Why the heck do they need long range missiles? Can you tell me why? Do we actually need this kind of additional threat?
To put it plainly, I think they speak with forked tounge.
It is a subtle but valid point, that President Obama (through his secretary of state as proxy) did indeed negotiate with those that support terrorism
The United Nations Security Council, plus Germany negotiated this treaty with Iran and the US in a member of that council. Neither President Obama, nor John Kerry negotiated this treaty on their own. This was an international effort by several nations, not an American one only.
Once upon a time it would have been unheard of to negotiate with nations that say they are (or were) communists, but we did and do. This is no different then when we negotiated with the old Soviet Union (who also supported terrorists, while we were talking to them) or negotiate with China even today in spite of it's horrible human rights abuses. Except this time we had the entire Security Council and Germany negotiating alongside of us. It does no good to negotiate with only your friends. It is useless in fact.
T G D
If you really think that anyone but John Kerry (being directed by Obama) led these negotiations, then you are much more nave than you seem.
Short of being nave you are being disingenuous
Negotiating with enemies or friends is not the determining factor in whether a good deal was made either
Iran doesn't invade on its own . They have gotten too clever to do that . Instead they give support to proxies who do the dirty work for them ...
I can be a blockhead too ... Yes they really do !
You do fit the profile . You are not here for discussion or learning . You are here to hear yourself talk .
Have you read anyone else's links and responded to that info ? If so I haven't seen it . I was going to put in a link about Iranian proxies but then I realized that blockheads DON'T READ LINKS !
I know a blockhead when I see one . All my future articles will contain ROEs for dealing with blockheads ... that means you . And it's because I AM sharp that I know better than to waste my time debating with a blockhead .
Just ignore him and write him off. He's never had an intelligent thing to say here, so don't bother with him. When you see his name, just pass him by as not worth anything, including the effort.