Students protest firing of officer who flipped student out of desk
A group of students, both black and white, walked out of their classes at Spring Valley High School of Columbia, S.C., wearing handwritten T-shirts reading "Free Fields" or "#BringBackFields.
Not all Spring Valley students were happy to see Ben Fields, the white police officer caught on video flipping a black female student out of her desk and then throwing her across the room, lose his job.
Around 10 o'clock on Friday morning, a group of students, both black and white , walked out their of classes Spring Valley High School of Columbia, S.C., wearing handwritten T-shirts reading "Free Fields" or "#BringBackFields,” posting images of their protest to social media.
These 100 or so students, out of 2,059 in total, left their respective classes to meet in the school’s atrium. Some told WLTX-TV that they had originally intended to exit the building
“We just want to show that we’re still supporting him and everything and that he’s still a good guy, and everything and we don’t want his reputation to be ruined because of something that happened on Monday,” one of the demonstrators told WTLX.
According to student recordings of the event, they were eventually addressed by principal Jeff Temoney. He said no one will be suspended for participating in the walkout and dismissed them back to class.
"We've heard your voices, okay," Mr. Temoney said. "We appreciate you taking time to do this, but again, as you know, we always focus on teaching and learning, so let's head on back to class."
In a letter sent home to parents, he reiterated that the school understands the students’ desire to express their beliefs. District officials told Live-5 News that the demonstration was “small” and “orderly.”
Deputy Ben Fields had been a school resource officer assigned to Spring Valley for seven years. He also served as an assistant football coach.
He was fired Wednesday from the Richland County Sheriff's Department for excessive use of force. The student, who was allegedly disturbing class, was asked to leave by a teacher and then by a school administrator, before they called Fields to the scene, say reports. When the girl refused to leave the room once again, Fields can be seen in multiple cell phone videos wrapping his arms around her neck and flipping her backwards before tossing her across the floor.
The Justice Department’s office of civil rights, the FBI, and the U.S. Attorney’s office in Columbia, S.C. are all investigating the case.
“He was wrong in his actions and it was not what I expect of my deputies,” Richland County Sheriff Leon Lott said. “Deputy Fields did not follow proper training or procedures when he threw the student across the room. It continues to upset me that he picked the student up and threw her.”
Senior John Cassibry, who participated in Friday’s protest and posted a video of Principal Temoney’s address on Twitter, said that though he thought Fields’s conduct was inappropriate, he should not have been fired .
"I believe it is important as a student to voice my opinion," he told the Huffington Post. "My belief on Deputy Fields is just that – I do believe he was too aggressive, but I do not believe it was any circumstance to lose his job, nor do I believe it was race-driven."
He said the majority of the demonstrators Friday were black.
http://news.yahoo.com/students-protest-firing-officer-flipped-student-desk-172258432.html
Tags
Who is online
142 visitors

The student, who was allegedly disturbing class, was asked to leave by a teacher and then by a school administrator, before they called Fields to the scene, say reports.
How do you remove an adult-sized student from a classroom when they refuse to go after being told to leave by both the teacher and a school administrator? To allow them to stay indicates the student has wrested control of not only the classroom from the teacher, but the school itself from the administrators.
Suggestions?
Two adults on either side of the desk, picks up the desk with the student sitting in it, and carries the kid to where she will wait for her parent(s) to take her home permanently. That's how. There's no excuse for what the officer did, period.
That's a possibility, although I don't think this kid would have sat quietly while she was being removed, desk and all. A student defying a teacher is not unusual; a student defying a school administrator is somewhat over the line. The officer should have called for backup.
So the staff should risk injury to protect the fragile dignity of one troublemaker?
The officer was wrong in his actions and is facing the consequences of those actions.
The student was also wring in her actions and should face significant consequences as well (suspension/expulsion) if unable to comport herself properly in the classroom.
Yes. She should probably be expelled. She has no right to deny education to her classmates.
Of course she should face serious consequences but not physical abuse.
Its sad the police are needed in high schools these days for crisis management.
The basic problem here is criminalizing defiant classroom behavior. This all started because the student wouldn't surrender cell phone. She wasn't violent, armed, or a threat to anybody. Instead of calling the principal or a counselor to threaten her with suspension/expulsion or just reason with her (which seems to me like a more appropriate first step), the teacher called a cop to have her forcibly removed. The cop made little effort to treat her like a student (rather than a criminal). He flipped her backwards out of the desk and then slung her across the floor. Given the relative size and weight difference, he could have drug the entire desk out of the classroom (as Hal suggests) but he chose to demonstrate his physical superiority by "unnecessarily" flinging her bodily across the room (which I doubt he would have even tried to do if he thought he couldn't do it). Curiously, the police department says he violated protocol but (to my knowledge) has yet to say what he should have done. There are many ways to handle simple defiance. Personally, I would have gotten a glass of water and told her that I would pour it (slowly) onto the table top which will run directly into her lap if she doesn't vacate the seat. She either gets up while dry or jumps up wet but, either way, I get behind her. I urge her to leave quietly without turning around so I don't have to hurt her. If she begins to turn, apply wrist lock if necessary and take her out of the room.
No, the teacher first called a school administrator. She refused to leave the classroom even when the school administrator asked her to. THAT is when the SCHOOL ADMINISTRATOR called the cop, not the teacher.
That's why I said to ignore her and allow her remain in the classroom would have given her control of both the classroom and the school. And to tell this girl she could stay but would get an F for the semester wouldn't have mattered to her, I don't think. The teacher lost control of the class the minute she refused his request to leave it, and the teacher has to be in control or HE may as well leave the classroom.
"Instead of calling the principal or a counselor to threaten her with suspension/expulsion or just reason with her (which seems to me like a more appropriate first step), the teacher called a cop to have her forcibly removed."
???
It's an indisputable fact that the principal/administrator was indeed summoned to the class room by the teacher. This student was given several chances to comply with school policy by both the teacher and the principal. Hells bells, even the other students in class (except one) were saying, "Just go already."
And no, this fiasco didn't start because she wouldn't relinquish her cell phone, it started when she began violating school policy by using her phone in the middle of class.
And this:
"Personally, I would have gotten a glass of water and told her that I would pour it (slowly) onto the table top which will run directly into her lap if she doesn't vacate the seat."
....could just as easily have put you in the same predicament as (former) Officer Fields. I can see it now: "He tried to drown me for no reason. I was water-boarded and nearly lost consciousness." You would be looking for a job while she was out shopping with her GoFundMe donations.
And speaking of donations, it bothers me that this kind of incident has become a career choice for so many. This student's crowd funding account has reached nearly $50,000. Most of that was donated after her lawyer, Todd Rutherford, released several totally bogus statements saying that his client was recently orphaned. Not orphaned, but living in a Level III therapeutic foster home, which in the State of South Carolina, means that her behavior was unmanageable at home, and no one else was willing to take her in. Completely unethical on Mr. Rutherford's part.
It's an indisputable fact that the principal/administrator was indeed summoned to the class room by the teacher. This student was given several chances to comply with school policy by both the teacher and the principal. Hells bells, even the other students in class (except one) were saying, "Just go already." And no, this fiasco didn't start because she wouldn't relinquish her cell phone, it started when she began violating school policy by using her phone in the middle of class.
Of course the kid should have gotten up but it didn't have to escalate to this when she remained seated. My main point is that the state/school is criminalizing trivial classroom behavior. By all accounts, the girl was not doing anything but refusing to leave because she thought the teacher was treating her unfairly for demanding that she turn over her phone for simply pulling it out (no evidence that she was "using" it). When I suggested that a principal or counselor be used, my purpose was to ensure that a professional exercise a scintilla of common sense and persuade compliance not simply demand it and turn the matter over to the police. How about saying this to her "I understand that you believe you're being treated unfairly. Maybe it's a misunderstanding but let's not interrupt the class further. Please come with me to my office so I can hear your side of the story. There's no need to be suspended or expelled over this when I'm positive you and I can work this out." I have been in many different school situations and this is one of the most incompetent efforts to control trivial misbehavior that I have ever seen. As for the other student arrested, she claims that she was simply expressing her concern over the cop's use of unnecessary force when the cop turned to her and said something like "since you've got so much to say, I'll take you too."
Given this girl's attitude and the information that she had to be removed from her home and placed in a "facility" rather than a foster home because she could not be handled in a home environment... I'd venture that reasoning with her wasn't an option.
I'd also guess the teacher would have asked her to put the phone away and had received a refusal before he told her to leave the class. What the teacher should or should not have said is irrelevant next to the fact that the girl challenged him for control of the class, and he had to take it all the way. She isn't the first student to have to give her phone to a teacher if she pulled it out during a class and won't be the last, whether she was using it or not.
Blaming the teacher for her refusal to obey him is a little overboard.
Given this girl's attitude and the information that she had to be removed from her home and placed in a "facility" rather than a foster home because she could not be handled in a home environment... I'd venture that reasoning with her wasn't an option.
All I've seen is that the girl was put in a foster home because she recently lost her mother. Even if she were put in a "facility", that does not remotely mean that she is beyond reason nor does it excuse school officials from employing reason in an educational facility.
I'd also guess the teacher would have asked her to put the phone away and had received a refusal before he told her to leave the class. What the teacher should or should not have said is irrelevant next to the fact that the girl challenged him for control of the class, and he had to take it all the way. She isn't the first student to have to give her phone to a teacher if she pulled it out during a class and won't be the last, whether she was using it or not. Blaming the teacher for her refusal to obey him is a little overboard.
What school officials said in handling this situation is completely relevant in examining the performance of their duties. If this trivial incident caused a teacher to lose control of the class then he/she had no control in the first place. To be clear, I'm not holding the school responsible for a child's behavior but rather holding them accountable for having no intelligent method of handling run of the mill misbehavior that has been handled by competent teachers/administrators for as long as we've had schools.
Kids are being expelled from first grade these days. There is a zero tolerance for not obeying teachers in class and I fail to see that this one teen would have missed that particular point. When the teacher sent for the principal that should have given the girl the clue that it was time to get serious and hand over the phone.
Teachers are forbidden to touch students so it wasn't like this teacher had an option of wrestling the phone from her himself. And her flat refusal to hand it over or put it away was indeed a challenge to his authority.
With the violence that has erupted in classrooms and schools in general over the last couple of years, I don't think many teachers are going to go one-on-one with students who become belligerent and aggressive. I think it's highly probable that teacher's unions have had their own secret meetings where they have come away with a mandate of seeing to the safety of the majority first, and that would be NOT to engage an overtly hostile student but to take it just so far then pass it on and try to remove the student from the classroom before a knife or gun emerges from a bookbag.
Kids are being expelled from first grade these days. There is a zero tolerance for not obeying teachers in class and I fail to see that this one teen would have missed that particular point. When the teacher sent for the principal that should have given the girl the clue that it was time to get serious and hand over the phone.
The kid had a cell phone, not a knife. Other than chewing gum or talking in class (which probably warrants calling in a swat team in South Carolina), pulling out a cell phone may be the most trivial offense imaginable. The sheriff had it absolutely correct when he said "nothing" the student did warranted a police response like this.
Teachers are forbidden to touch students so it wasn't like this teacher had an option of wrestling the phone from her himself. And her flat refusal to hand it over or put it away was indeed a challenge to his authority.
Wrestling the student to the shouldn't be an option for something this trivial. I have witnessed many more serious classroom problems than this and the teachers resolved it without a touching the student or calling a cop or losing control of the classroom.
With the violence that has erupted in classrooms and schools in general over the last couple of years, I don't think many teachers are going to go one-on-one with students who become belligerent and aggressive. I think it's highly probable that teacher's unions have had their own secret meetings where they have come away with a mandate of seeing to the safety of the majority first, and that would be NOT to engage an overtly hostile student but to take it just so far then pass it on and try to remove the student from the classroom before a knife or gun emerges from a bookbag.
There is no evidence that this student was belligerent, aggressive, hostile or a danger to anybody. One witness said she was normally quiet and not a troublemaker. In fact, she was still sitting at her desk when the cop flipped her backwards and then threw her across the floor. Absent evidence to the contrary, I'll assume that she is otherwise a proper student like any other rather than a potential criminal with a knife or gun in her bag. If the cop thinks otherwise, then he should have sought an assignment outside a prison rather than in a school.
I bet if a dog refused to stand when ordered and the owner responded by violently yanking the dog to his feet and then hurling it down the sidewalk, the public would say he should be prosecuted. A cop does the same thing to a black kid and the response is she got what she deserved. In her case, maybe being treated like a dog would be a step up.
The offense was not obeying the teacher. She compounded it by not obeying the principal. Tripled it by not obeying the officer.
It doesn't matter how she felt about being asked to put away her phone. It's the classroom rule, the school rule. Rules have to be followed in a classroom for the benefit of all the students.
We will have to agree to disagree on this subject.
If they had just ignored her chatting on her phone, it would have resulted in a complete collapse of discipline. The other students have a right to be educated.
Nice try Mikey - but, if it had been a dog - the dog would be dead now.
Somewhere, somehow, someone said that the cop "asked/told" her three times to get up and leave with him. She, supposedly, told him to futch off and didn't have to do what he said. He than placed his hand on her arm and she slapped him - that's when the shyte hit the fan.
Again - just what I heard/read somewhere. Will look for it.
" One of the videos taken as a school resource officer slammed a student sitting at her desk at a South Carolina high school also shows her punching the deputy during the confrontation, authorities said Tuesday.
That video, described by Sheriff Leon Lott as the "third video," will play a part in the internal affairs investigation into whether Senior Deputy Ben Fields violated policy in Monday's incident at Spring Valley High School in Columbia. "
" Lott said they're looking at the videos taken by students inside the class and conducting interviews with the witnesses to determine whether the officer should have escalated the situation with physical force.
A teacher had complained that the student, who has not been identified, was being unruly during class and refused to leave even after an administrator was called in.
"The student was wrong in what she did — she disrupted class, she was disturbing the others students from getting an education. But does her actions meet the level of what this officer did?" Lott asked. "That's what we're going to decide."
Lott added that she had been texting and using her phone instead of doing her school work on a Chromebook during the algebra class."
" In the third video viewed by police, Lott said, it shows the girl hitting the officer in the head once he puts his hands on her: "There's no question about that. "
I don't know about the water part but the rest of your post is spot on.
Discussion forums do love to busy body all over a story like this.
The cop did not have to throw the girl to the floor , period. The idea that he was frustrated beyond the breaking point is absurd. They should have just let her sit there and gone on with the class. When it was over tell her not to come back to school without her parents. And take it from there, one way or the other.
Letting her sit there when she was told to leave the classroom was out of the question, John. That leaves her in control of the class. Even you should be able to understand that.
The officer should have called for backup, but in any case, removing her from the class would have called for force of some kind given her attitude.
That would have been cool John - but, who would have stood in for her parents since she doesn't have any?
Eliminating cell phone use during class should not require Gestapo tactics. Below is a simple way to handle the problem without having to beat up and arrest the students.