Pro Israel lobby moves into high gear against six nation pack with Iran
Original Headline read:
Pro-Israel groups in U.S. waste no time attacking Iran deal
Within hours of the unveiling on Tuesday of a nuclear pact between Iran and six world powers, the loudest pro-Israel voice in Washington was warning the U.S. Congress of problems, marking the onset of what promises to be a furious lobbying campaign.
The American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC) said in a statement it was "deeply concerned" that the deal "would fail to block Irans path to a nuclear weapon and further entrench and empower the leading state sponsor of terror."
The considerable clout of pro-Israel interests on Capitol Hill will play an important role in deciding the fate of the pact, hammered out in Vienna after many months by Iran, the United States, Britain, China, France, Russia and Germany.
Congressional votes on the deal, which got a rough initial reception from Republican lawmakers, were not expected until September. Regardless of Israeli lobbying, however, odds were slim that U.S. lawmakers would be able to derail the deal.
AIPAC has 11 registered lobbyists in Washington and spends about $3 million a year on lobbying, according to the non-partisan Center for Responsive Politics, a watchdog group that monitors lobbying expenditures and campaign finance.
AIPAC is widely viewed as the most influential group in the United States advancing the Israeli government's agenda.
"Few lobbies dedicated to international issues are so active and well-financed as the Israel lobby," the center said of pro-Israel organizations generally.
Israeli Minister of Public Security Gilad Erdan, speaking to Israel's Army Radio, said his government "must focus and explain all of the holes in this agreement" and "hopefully the Congress and Senate will see the truth." [ID: nL5N0ZU1JP]
The agreement with Iran is seen as a legacy project for Democratic President Barack Obama, potentially more sweeping than his bold move to normalize U.S. relations with Cuba after decades of strife.
Not since 1981, when then-President Ronald Reagan proposed selling advanced surveillance aircraft known as "AWACS" to Saudi Arabia, has a U.S. administration been so embroiled in a fight with the Israeli government, normally a close U.S. ally.
Bruce Riedel, a former CIA official who is now a senior fellow at the Brookings Institution, told Reuters that in the fight over the Saudi AWACS, which Israel lost, it won a "green light" from the United States for its invasion of Lebanon just months later.
Leslie Gelb, a former State Department official responsible for arms sales in the 1970s, said in an interview that when the AWACS-Saudi sale began emerging during Jimmy Carter's presidency, Israel began clamoring for American cluster bombs, advanced helicopters and F16 jets as a counterbalance.
Another weapons shopping list could be in the mix again, according to experts.
Some of the lobbying will be aimed at Jewish members of Congress, who will be influential voices in the upcoming debate. Two of them are so far withholding judgment: Senator Benjamin Cardin, the senior Senate Foreign Relations Committee Democrat; and Senator Charles Schumer, the No. 3 Senate Democrat.
Besides lobbying, 2016 political campaign contributions to members of the U.S. Congress are expected to be dangled.
In 2014, pro-Israel groups contributed $11.9 million to congressional candidates, with $6.8 million going to Democrats and $5.1 million to Republicans, according to the center.
Among the top recipients were Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell, Senator John Cornyn, the No. 2 Senate Republican, and Representative Steny Hoyer, the No. 2 House Democrat.
Meanwhile, Sheldon Adelson, a U.S. billionaire businessman and outspoken critic of the Iran negotiations, could also use his vast financial resources to try to influence Congress.
In 2012, Adelson pumped $92.8 million into Republican "super PACs," the center said, making him the single highest contributor to outside groups that year.
Some pro-Israel groups will be arguing for Obama's pact. Americans for Peace Now has welcomed the agreement as one that will "verifiably roll back Irans nuclear program".
Ori Nir, a spokesman for the group that advocates an Israeli-Palestinian and Israeli-Arab peace, said his organization is calling on supporters to "start contacting members of Congress to influence them to support the deal."
http://www.reuters.com/article/2015/07/15/us-iran-nuclear-israel-idUSKCN0PO2S220150715

The efforts by the Israel lobby are to be expected, and respected. But do take into account that this deal was negotiated by six other world powers, and the other options were to take military action, or to do nothing.
And before you make any uninformed comments on this seed, please make an effort to educate yourself as to the details of what is in the draft agreement made yesterday...
http://www.buzzfeed.com/buzzfeednews/iran-nuclear-talks?utm_term=.o...
Scroll about halfway down and you will find a 159 page document. (note this Russian released document has not been verified for accuracy yet.)
Short of a treaty that declares the complete dismantling of the nation of Iran itself will satisfy the pro-Israel crowd. And even then they'd bitch that it was appeasement (That song is too old. They need to find something other then appeasement to sing)if it took too long to make them happy.
They are NEVER going to be happy! Not with ANY treaty! So letthem trot out their usual bullshit arguments and then fuck off!In this case atreaty is better then a war, no matter how much they bitch.
So ... I guess you approve of the religious leadership of Iran . But you hate religion in the US . A bit hypocritical I would say ...
What is most humorous is that we have individuals that believe that they know more, and are smarter than the entire negotiating apparatus of six countries that came together to get this agreement.
I see no mention of approval there Petey. It looks more like a live and let live approach.
The world would be a much simpler place if posturing wasn't so Chic.
Yes, I believe those individuals are in Israel, in the Israeli government, in Mossad, in Shin Bet, where the word "Intelligence" means something, and it seems to me that there are a lot of them in the USA as well.
If you have anything directly from the Mossad, or Shin Bet that you can share with us, that would be most welcomed and interesting to analyze.
WND? For entertainment value only, as I'm not real big on fictional accounts of actual world events. For future reference, any site that makes use of Michele Bachamann as a featured writer should be considered for entertainment value only.
Thanks. He tends to twist words to get himself off.
As Churchill said "Better to jaw, jaw then to war, war."
The ONLY alternative the pro-Israel crowd has to offer is war and a war with Iran is not going to happen with the US, because there is little tono publicsupport for it. America is sick of war andin favor of the Treaty. So their ideas are hollow.
I tend to agree with you. I get pretty disappointed to see how freely people from both inside and outside of the United States suggest we use our military to solve problems. To many of them, I'm going to start suggesting they visit:
This is essentially the same deal Clinton gave North Korea.
It took nine years, but if I remember correctly, there has never been a real inspection of a north Korean nuclear site and they currently have materials to make 6 bombs with three successful detonations.
Also, they are building a missile that is capable of hitting the US west coast. (not real functional yet but getting there)
Within ten years Iran will have their two nuclear weapons that will be able to destroy Israel.
The Israelis will not stand for this. The big question for us is when Israel strikes, and Iran retaliates, will we step up and defend Israel. There is also Saudi Arabia to consider, we actually have a mutual defense pact with them, and if they hit Iran...
WE have one hell of a choice coming up in the future.
So which one do you advocate NWM:
1) Engagement. 2) Statu Quo 3) Military attack 4) Other.... please fill in the blank.
Honest question my friend, looking for an honest answer as always.
Our options are limited. Have we ever stopped a country from getting the bomb if they really wanted it, (China, N.Korea, Pakistan, India). No matter how we feel about Iran getting the bomb, there really is little, other than invading, that we can do.
I don't want to see Iran with the bomb, but in reality what can we do to stop them? Sanctions, they seem to muddle along with the sanctions now imposed.
I favor engagement, not military attack. We have Iran surrounded by U.S. air bases, does that give us the upper hand? If we attack, they willretaliate, and more than likely against Israel. Talk about the ME exploding, that will do it for sure.
I've heard the comment, ''bomb them back to the stone age''....Sounds great, but it doesn't work. Think Vietnam. We would have to put in ground troops. Do you think that the U.S. public would stand for more American soldiers coming home in body bags?
We, the U.S. are between a rock and a hard place, with no good solution in sight.
I vote for further engagement.
I still think engagement, no matter how much I might have to hold my nose to do it, is still the right choice.
Why would you tend to agree with something that Israel is not interested in? Israel is and never was interested in anyone going to war with Iran, as is suggested.The most that was ever discussed was a bombing run of the reactors, which has been repeatedly, summarily dismissed. So if there's anything that the "pro-Israel" crowd supports, you know or care little about it, as long as you all get to repeat statements that show Israel in a negative light. It's not bad enough that Israel gets to watch the gladhanding and compromising with an enemy that repeatedly calls for our "death", but they also get pissed on by the leader of their greatest ally.
Open your eyes, and admit what you see for once.
That's right Fly and not send someone else children but their own, as for Israel, if they want war, let them fight it themselves...
It's not about putting Israel in a negative light. It is about being realistic about what can be done through negotiation.
Lets also be honest about something else too. It didn't matter what was on the table, or how long ago it was, supporters of Israel could care less about trying to see their way through any sort of diplomatic effort. PERIOD! So rather than standing up and trying to be part of ANY solution, supporters of Israel for the most part have earned the label as being part of the problem.
And don't forget..... Americans have received death threats from Iran too.... while being pissed on by Israel. The shoe fits on both feet JP.
So, in your eyes, the solution is to make a deal that the entire world knows will be flouted and repeatedly violated by Iran, until we actually witness the test fire in the Indian Ocean.
Obama said - and I quote - "This long term deal with Iran will PREVENT it from obtaining a nuclear weapon."
And again: "because of this deal, the international community will be able to verify that the Islamic Republic of Iran will not be able to develop a nuclear weapon".
And yet, the agreement offers Iran all sorts of wiggle room and avenues to evade detection. So don't piss on me and tell me it's raining. Thank you.
The supporters of Israel were in favor or tighter sanctions, until Iran cried uncle. That was the solution, according to those who don't make the headlines.If you believe that the citizens of Iran had any chance of fomenting some kind of change, it would only have been through tougher sanctions, which would have destabilized the nation to the point where revolution would have been possible. Now, we are stuffing the pockets of the mullahs again. And mind you, let's for a moment keep our rose colored glasses on. Let's pretend that Iran has now forsaken the goal of a nuclear weapon. Right now, they are the leading state exporter of terrorism, worldwide. They are destabilizing the region, and working to hegemonic dominance. Iraq, Syria, Tunisia, Lebanon, Gaza, and the list will only grow now. Why? Because we just allowed them to retrench their wealth.
If Israel pisses on the US, there's only one reason. That'll end on 1/20/17.
There are three options JP...
1) Engagement which may or may not prevent Iran from getting the bomb.
2) Maintain sanctions making more enemies for Israel and the US in the long run. Meanwhile Iran gets the bomb.
3) Military attack, being the worst case scenario, which will justify Iran making and USING a nuke on Israel and/or the US.
I suggest you pick one and start thinking of realistic solutions that we all know are not going to be perfect in anyone'e eyes, but at least move things towards a possible better position than we are in today. Either that or live with choice #2 then.
By the way have your read the proposed agreement end to end JP?
I told you already what the best course of action was, although we do not agree on the outcome.
Continuing to tighten sanctions would have rendered it impossible for Iran to continue to pour billions into the program. As far as more enemies for Israel and the US, who is the "more"? Everyone's all in on their anti-West sentiment. More? Don't think so. My take is that the tightened sanctions would further the instability within the country, and give the people the best chance they had to take the country back from the mullahs.
No FLY, I am still gainfully employed, so I don't have the desire/inclination to read all 160 pages. I have seen various summaries.
Fly,
I know that a certain amount of narcissism is required to do the job as president. My issue is with the president's obsession with his legacy. While you may be right that this is the best option, I don't think anyone, the entire negotiating team included and the president specifically, believe that this deal will stop Iran from obtaining a nuclear weapon. I also believe that they know that it's basically a agreement based on trust more than verify because the treaty does not have enough teeth to be able to actually verify anything.
But yet Obama, with his legacy as his main concern, will stand in front of the entire world and declare that this treaty will stop Iran from getting the bomb. That this treaty actually makes the middle east and the entire world a safer place. Anyone being completely honest with themselves would never agree. The plain and simple truth is that this deal was won by Iran in a landslide. They will continue on their march towards a weapon and reap billions of dollars in sanctions relief to continue their terroristic actions throughout the world. On top of that they now get access to a vast array of weapons through arms sales. This should be deeply concerning to anyone.
As for now the narcissist in the white house gets to puff his chest. He gets to stand in front of the world and declare how great he is. Time will be the ultimate judge and chances are that the only winner in this deal will be Iran. The rest of the middle east and world will suffer. Legacies aren't formed in the moment as Obama wishes, they're determined over time based on actual real world events. He's now tied his legacy to this treaty. I guess for him it is a chance worth taking.
I think your right to a point Fly...
1) Engagement, Every one has the old proverb, "Keep your friends close, and your enemies closer" Wise position. (although such position didn't do much for the Jews did it)
2) Status Quo, Unrealistic and impractical, much like Egypt learned, state support for terrorism is a road to destruction.
3) Military attack, There is some argument to be made that if you are going to strike now is the time to do it. and yes I also don't think Israel is capable of a complete single mission strike capable of destroying Iran's capability. But they are capable over time. There in fact is only one nation that could do it in one fell swoop without direct retaliation. And even that nation could never be sure.
4) Allowance, In the real world, there is no way to prevent anyone from obtaining a nuclear weapon, if they have and are willing to spend the massive amounts of cash needed to obtain the tech. I believe that North Korea's nuclear program is costing China untold billions. I believe that Iran's tech is coming from Russia and France through Pakistan. During the 60's France was selling nuclear tech all over the world. The most important part wasn't the reactor designs that is common knowledge now, it was nuclear fuel production capability that was the most difficult to obtain. France was giving it away to anyone that could afford it
Cash is king, even in the nuclear weapons arena.
We can't stop them, that is an absolute impossibility, all we can do is educate them. And there are two relatively recent lessons to be had depending on how you look at them.
Iraq and Afghanistan.
And Iran is reacting to both in very understandable ways.
Bush's invasion of Iraq. If Iraq actually had a nuclear weapon and a relatively secure way of delivering it, the invasion would never have taken place.
Al quaida's direct attack on the US. And the Taliban's decision to not allow us access. Limited scope, they cannot take on the "Great Satan" directly even with a nuclear weapon. Even with 5 billion screaming muslims.
Given those two facts what do they want?
An invasion/strike shield, A nuclear weapon and local delivery ability gives them that.
Ideological protection, the revolutionary council will not be treated like the Taliban in case one of the terror organizations in their country does decide to directly strike at the US.
For Iran it isn't about sanctions, it is about survival of their political/religious/ideological identity with actual control of the nation intact. Given the recent history of the region.
Personally I don't think Iran needs to worry about us, they need to be worrying about Saudi Arabia more.
Iran managed to "muddle along" because there were nations that did not recognize the sanctions imposed on it.
Chief among those nations was our good trade buddy, India. Who is now crying for some "relief" from the economic downturn they will be experiencing when the sanctions are lifted and their price gouging of Iran (charging up to 25% above market cost for goods) will come to an end as it will be able to procure goods at a fair price.
Gee, wonder who will subsidize India for the lost revenue?
Yep.... I remember an article speaking to this point with India a few days ago. China was in on ignoring the sanctions as well.
The Israel lobby will never allow the US to do that.
Thank you Me De Gaulle...
Thank you..... Nice to see someone else "Gets It"
Here is the Full Text .
You are aware that here in the US that CIPAC donates 10 times the amount of money to support Israel than AIPAC and that they are against this agreement, too?
Who's wagging the dog?
Hmmmmmm. For everyone, isn't it aboutsurvival of their political/religious/ideological identity with actual control of the nation intact?
Just an observation.
That statement is unfair and prejudicial - coming from you it's a surprise.
The "Israel lobby" doesn't have the power or the legal right to "allow" or disallow the US to do anything. The only tool they have is to attempt to persuade, which is not control.
I could say that CAIR has more "power" with Obama than any Jewish organization has with the US government.
More than half a century ago I learned in law school that a fair settlement between two disputing parties is accomplished if both are unhappy for not getting what they wanted. So why is this man laughing?
If I were to put a caption to this photo it would be: "Happiness is a warm victory."
And the Iranian public is celebrating:
Are Americans that happy. Sure as hell Israelis aren't.
Got proof of that? Of course you don't. All you have is your fear that keeps you from doing anything to solve the problem.
Sorry Buzz.... I'm not buying into your perpetual fear trip.
You would be fearful if you lived in Israel .
Standing still and maintaining the status quo has ZERO chance to reduce the risk of Iran building a nuclear weapon. Only engagement, as scary as it may be, has a chance to do that.
State your choice Petey..... Those are the realistic options.
Do you honestly think that China or Russia wouldn't have vetoed any move to increase sanctions on Iran at this point? So that line of thinking is DOA JP. Even if you did manage to maintain or increase the sanctions..... does that stop their research towards a bomb...No. It might make it harder, but they will have all the the materials and equipment to make a fission weapon given time. By not engaging Iran, all you are doing is providing them the last component of time they need to make the bomb you are so in fear of.
Secondly, since you haven't and aren't willing to read the agreement for yourself, your comments and opinions in the matter become something to be disregarded.
My "perpetual fear trip" is that I, along with an awful lot of other people, don't buy that the "deal" is worth the paper it's written on, and I don't care at all that the US and perhaps others are going to blow away all that money on it - a really expensive lesson is a good one.
Buzz, you're a lawyer..... Have you read the agreement?
Are you going to go along with the crowd, or try to put the pieces together yourself and think about it on your own?
Besides..... What do you gain by standing still with the status quo? Are you going to sit with the grand-standers, or at least TRY to work the problem to a better solution? The agreement is far from ideal, but it is a step to bring Iran in compliance with the NPT.
I admit I have only read parts of it along with commentary from others who have read it. However, much of my commentary was based on what YOU wrote and/or posted. I am a methodical reader and it will take the time I rarely have to get through 159 pages so I hope someone trustworthy will create an executive summary.
There were alternatives other than war, and a better deal would have been one of them, but unfortunately because your government seems to have lost its strong leader reputation (erasable red lines, capitulation, compromises), it opens the door for others who are more capable of doing so to take advantage.
As I said, why is that man laughing?
Evidently the conservative hawks in Iran are not happy with the deal either. So given that conservatives on both sides are unhappy leads me to believe that the deal just might be better than I originally thought.
The most that was ever discussed was a bombing run of the reactors, which has been repeatedly, summarily dismissed.
Because it can't be done. Iran is not like Iraq was lo these many years ago when Israel could hit them once and leave, with one reactor and that one not even operational. A treaty is it or war if you want to stop Iran from getting a nuclear weapon. Those are the only two realistic choices and besides, a "bombing run" (There would have to be many, many of them) would mean a direct US involvement and the only place that COULD lead to is an all out land war, with American troops (where else are they going to come from? Not Israel. or any of our European allies) and America is sick of our troops dying in the ME.
My take is that the tightened sanctions would further the instability within the country, and give the people the best chance they had to take the country back from the mullahs.
And that sounds good too, except they won't work without the help of China and Russia and they were pro-treaty or nothing. It's not like the sanctions were going to continue if we walked away from te table. Besides, the only reason or the sanctions was to bring Iran to the table to come to a treaty for them to stop there nuclear weapons program (if they ever had one), so the sanctions worked. We never would have got the Russians and Chinese to go along with extending them. They are both allies with Iran and Iran would not have missed us if they had them back.
That may be so, and so even if the Iranians can be trusted to comply with the INTENT of the agreement, if not the letter of it, then we only have to wait 10 years for the possibility of armageddon. At my age I will most likely have the luck of not seeing it, but I just feel sorry for my kids and grandchildren. Even if armageddon does not happen, even if the destruction of Israel and the return of the Jewish people to their being the despised wandering Jews not having a country of their own to protect their existence, it will always be held over their heads. However, with the direction of the world and society as I see it going I'm just as happy not to have to bear living in it. So, FLY, I admit that you may be right that nothing better will happen or be possible so there is no purpose in our further bothering to debate about it.
I have to say, Randy, that your theory is reasonable. Thank you.
The best part Buzz is that we talked about it, and we know each others thoughts.... That's always worth the effort.
I agree that our discussions have always been worth the effort. I know I have learned from them, and hope that you have too.
What I don't like, it was reported on the radio today that the President is moving the state department to put a resolution before the UN mandating the enforcement of the treaty.
No matter what the Senate does.
And that his intent as specified on the radio is to enforce it by authority of said UN resolution.
This was being reported by a democrat Senator that wasn't happy with that scenario who also said that Joe Biden has been informed of the President's intent to bypass the Senate and it's constitutional authority.
That makes the whole deal screwed in my opinion. WE have a president that thinks a UN resolution countermands our constitution?
Democrats should run away from this as fast as they can. Talk about shooting your party in the foot before an upcoming election.
What we have here is a country that calls itself a democracy but thanks to Generalissimo Obama has become a dictatorship. F*ck the democratic process, he will try to get what he wants any way he can. I really feel for you Americans. Look what you have lost. In the eyes of the rest of the world (especially the Muslim world) he has become a LAUGHING STOCK.
...
I just read up on it this morning. From the text...
Expect more drama from all quarters....