Experts On ISIS Suggest That Islamic State Has Turned To Terrorism Because It Is Losing
"On Thursday, one day before terrorists who appear to have been linked to ISIS launched a series of devastating attacks across Paris, President Obama went on ABC and made a comment that now looks pretty bad:
What is true is that from the start, our goal has been first to contain, and we have contained them.
In the wake of Paris, it looked to many like Obama had badly overhyped his administration's efforts against ISIS. At Saturday's Democratic presidential debate , moderator John Dickerson asked Hillary Clinton if the quote meant that the Obama administration's legacy will be "that it underestimated the threat from ISIS."
Obama's comments don't look quite as bad in context. Rather, as PolitiFact points out , Obama was saying that ISIS's territorial expansion in the Middle East has been contained — that, partly as a result of US actions, its march across Syria and Iraq had been halted. That's both a much more modest claim and factually correct.
"The statement is, in the context of the interview ... almost entirely correct," Daveed Gartenstein-Ross, a senior fellow at the Foundation for the Defense of Democracies, told me.
But as the Paris attacks show, that in itself is hardly cause for triumphalism. And it's not necessarily a coincidence that this attack occurred as ISIS has been losing ground in Syria and Iraq. Perversely, the world's success in containing ISIS territorially actually makes the group more dangerous internationally, at least in the short term.
Some analysts worry that as ISIS suffers battlefield losses, it may shift more of its energy away from the battlefield and into international terror attacks like what happened in Paris.
ISIS is losing ground in Syria and Iraq
On the ground in Iraq and Syria, ISIS has in fact been stalled and in many places even turned back. According to Will McCants, the head of the Brookings Institution's Project on US Relations With the Islamic World , ISIS "lost something like 25 percent of their territory" since its peak last summer.
By the end of June 2015, ISIS had lost nearly 10 percent of the remaining territory it held at the beginning of the year. Red areas on this map show ISIS territorial losses, and green shows gains:
(IHS Jane's 360)
At the end of June , Kurdish fighters broke through in northern Syr ia , taking the strategic town of Tal Afar and advancing to within roughly 30 miles of ISIS's de facto capital, Raqqa.
These losses have continued since.
"You look back to the past two months," Gartenstein-Ross says, "and it's just two month of steady losses."
He ticks off a list of ISIS losses: Baiji district in Iraq, almost all of its presence near the Kurdish-held city Kirkuk, the outlying areas near Ramadi, and defeats in parts of Syria (like northern Aleppo). Just last week, ISIS lost the Iraqi town of Sinjar, which cuts off an important highway connecting its Iraqi and Syrian holdings.
None of these losses mean that ISIS is on the verge of collapse. Rather, they're part of a slow but steady process of chipping away at the group's holdings, taking advantage of its structural weaknesses — too many strong enemies, vulnerability to airpower, no real ability to hide — to put it on the path toward defeat.
"Right now — and I approve of this — we're moving at a very deliberate rate," Michael Knights, the Lafer fellow at the Washington Institute for Near East Policy, says. "We're pushing forward nice and slowly, snipping off little bits of the caliphate, [and] building our confidence."
The problem: As ISIS weakens, it could get more dangerous abroad
As ISIS loses territory in Syria and Iraq, it poses less of a danger to the people who are far and away its primary victims: Syrians and Iraqis. Still, whether Obama meant to imply this or not, his comments sounded to many like an argument that because ISIS was being contained territorially, it was less of a danger; that the threat it posed to the US was being contained as well.
Obama's comments were "terribly, terribly phrased — just disastrously," Gartenstein-Ross says. "When you use the term 'containment,' people naturally think of it on two sort of dual tracks, terrorism and territory."
As ISIS weakens as a state by losing territory, it may actually become more dangerous as a terrorist organization. Until Paris, ISIS didn't really focus much effort on staging attacks on foreign targets outside of the Middle East. Some analysts worry that Paris represents the beginning of ISIS devoting more resources to staging these dramatic attacks outside its territory — perhaps in part to compensate for its territorial losses.
"We don't yet know that there's a trend," Gartenstein-Ross cautions. "But I do think it's likely that that pivot does and will exist."
ISIS thrives on a narrative of victory. The reason it attracts so many foreign recruits, including Westerners, is that it sells itself as the prophesied Islamic caliphate: that its victories are inevitable and divinely inspired. If it's losing territory, then it needs to sell this narrative through other means. That means claiming "victory" over the West by hitting it with terrorist attacks.
"Much of ISIS's ideological support and recruiting strength emanates from a narrative that it is victorious," J.M. Berger, the co-author of ISIS: A State of Terror, explains via email. The Paris attack "changes the conversation from 'ISIS is contained' on November 12 to 'ISIS is rampaging uncontrollably' on November 14."
Moreover, ISIS may believe that terrorist attacks are its best way of striking back against — and maybe, it believes, deterring — foreign attacks. That conclusion would likely be wrong, but ISIS may still believe it. The French are part of the US-led coalition bombing ISIS in Syria and Iraq. ISIS suicide bombers have also recently hidden in a civilian part of Beirut where Hezbollah, an ISIS enemy, is strong. The group is also suspected of bombing a Russian civilian airliner in Egypt.
From ISIS's point of view, these kinds of attacks could be a way to warn off countries that are partly responsible for its territorial defeats. The more you fight ISIS, the more of a target you become — and ISIS won't leave you alone until you leave it alone."
MORE http://www.vox.com/world/2015/11/16/9744490/paris-attacks-isis-losing

"As ISIS loses ground in the Middle East, it might step up attacks on foreign countries in order to create the perception that it is winning, experts say.
The Friday-night attacks in Paris, in which terrorists killed 129 people and injured hundreds more as they took hostages, detonated suicide vests, and shot people across the city , could have been a move to distract from the losses ISIS (also known as the Islamic State) has taken in its core base of support .
"If an extremist group that has seized territory starts to lose it, it will be highly incentivized to turn to terrorist operations that allow for maximizing effects at a lower cost," Clint Watts, a fellow at the Foreign Policy Research Institute and former Army infantry officer, wrote for War on the Rocks .
Watts continued:
The Islamic State propelled its recruitment and resourcing over the past three years by sustaining the initiative, growing its state through battlefield successes and acquisitions. But the group has now peaked: It is losing territory, many of its fighters are dying in battle, defections from their ranks continue to increase, recruitment flows are slower and smaller, and new regional Islamic State affiliates in countries like Libya and Egypt now provide a range of options for potential recruits to join a group locally rather than travel to Syria.
To sustain its brand and supporting global fan base, the Islamic State needs to show success. If it cannot achieve battlefield victories and broadcast them on social media, then its affiliates and global network need to pick up the slack with terrorist attacks that capture the imagination of mass media.
Other experts have echoed this assessment.
The Paris attack "strikes at those who are fighting [ISIS]," Daveed Gartenstein-Ross, a counterterrorism analyst and senior fellow at the Foundation for Defense of Democracies, told Business Insider over the weekend. "It increases their prestige in the jihadist movement, thus diminishing Al Qaeda and raising ISIS’s stature. It energizes their base, it presents this perception of a [win] particularly when they’ve been losing ground in their caliphate holdings."
Will McCants, an expert on jihadist groups and author of the recent book, "The ISIS Apocalypse," told Business Insider on Friday that ISIS might try to retake territory to offset its losses, and that the US-led anti-ISIS coalition's recent efforts in the region could "damage ... its claim to be continually expanding."
Over the weekend, he pointed out that ISIS has also carried out other high-profile attacks against its foreign enemies in recent weeks. The group has also claimed responsibility for the downing of a Russian passenger plane over Egypt at the end of October and for suicide bombings against Hezbollah in Lebanon.
"All of that suggests that ISIS wants to put pressure on those governments," McCants said on Saturday.
ISIS's strategy to expand its caliphate and mount spectacular attacks on its enemies in the West plays into the group's grand plan to drag the West into a final apocalyptic showdown in Dabiq, Syria.
"In a prophecy attributed to Muhammad, the Prophet predicts the Day of Judgment will come after the Muslims defeat Rome at al-Amaq or Dabiq, two places close to the Syrian border with Turkey," McCants wrote for the Brookings Institution last year. ("Rome" could be understood to mean Western nations in general.)
In his book, McCants further explained the apocalyptic fervor of ISIS :
The US invasion of Iraq and the stupendous violence that followed dramatically increased the Sunni public’s appetite for apocalyptic explanations of a world turned upside down. A spate of bestsellers put the United States at the center of the End-Times drama, a new 'Rome' careering throughout the region in a murderous stampede to prevent violence on its own shores. The main antagonists of the End of Days, the Jews, were now merely supporting actors. Even conservative Sunni clerics who had previously tried to tamp down messianic fervor couldn’t help but conclude that 'the triple union constituted by the Antichrist, the Jews, and the new Crusaders' had joined forces 'to destroy the Muslims.'
Shadi Hamid, a senior fellow at the Brookings Institution, also mentioned ISIS's apocalyptic vision in light of the Paris attacks.
"ISIS and its ilk want to fashion a clash of civilizations," Hamid told CNN . They want this to be 'us versus them.' They want to exploit growing anti-Muslim and anti-refugee sentiment to push a narrative that French Muslims and Western Muslims more generally will never be fully accepted by their countrymen."
He continued: "ISIS is rather clear about this intent : They wish to extinguish the 'gray zone' and provoke a sort of apocalyptic world war, where Muslims are forced to choose sides."
As Russia, France, and the US become more deeply involved in Middle East, increasing airstrikes in Syria and in some cases sending in ground forces, ISIS recruits more and more people with the message that they're fighting the "infidels" in the West as a means to fulfill a centuries-old prophecy.
And Hamid cautioned against bargaining with dictators like Bashar al-Assad, the president of Syria, who has resorted to attacking and bombing civilians as he struggles to maintain power.
"Perhaps these politicians are unaware that the point of terrorism is to provoke target populations to do things they otherwise wouldn't do," Hamid said. "Let's start by not doing it for them.""
As ISIS loses ground in the Middle East, it might step up attacks on foreign countries in order to create the perception that it is winning, experts say.
That would seem to make a lot of sense. They are losing and that's the truth, so they may try more and more terrorists acts to try to hide it.
"As ISIS loses ground in the Middle East, it might step up attacks on foreign countries in order to create the perception that it is winning, experts say.
That would seem to make a lot of sense. They are losing and that's the truth, so they may try more and more terrorists acts to try to hide it."
Absolutely. Theyv'e already threatened that Washington is next on their list.
"The US invasion of Iraq and the stupendous violence that followed dramatically increased the Sunni public’s appetite for apocalyptic explanations of a world turned upside down. A spate of bestsellers put the United States at the center of the End-Times drama, a new 'Rome' careering throughout the region in a murderous stampede to prevent violence on its own shores. The main antagonists of the End of Days, the Jews, were now merely supporting actors. Even conservative Sunni clerics who had previously tried to tamp down messianic fervor couldn’t help but conclude that 'the triple union constituted by the Antichrist, the Jews, and the new Crusaders' had joined forces 'to destroy the Muslims.'"
Very interesting.
"Obama's comments don't look quite as bad in context. Rather, as PolitiFact points out , Obama was saying that ISIS's territorial expansion in the Middle East has been contained — that, partly as a result of US actions, its march across Syria and Iraq had been halted. That's both a much more modest claim and factually correct."
What a clever spin - that commentator should be given a bonus.
This article is hard to swallow. Today, the Kurds discovered two mass graves in Sanjar. They have just defeated ISIS and drove them out of Sanjar. 150 bodies, most likely killed last year when ISIS overran the town.
If that isn't terrorism I don't know what is...There whole campaign was and is terror.
Obviously the article is referring to terrorism in other countries. I really don't know what the confusion is concerning this article.
"As ISIS weakens as a state by losing territory, it may actually becomemore dangerous as a terrorist organization. Until Paris, ISIS didn't really focus much effort on staging attacks on foreign targets outside of the Middle East. Some analysts worry that Paris represents the beginning of ISIS devoting more resources to staging these dramatic attacks outside its territory — perhaps in part to compensate for its territorial losses."
Sounds fairly straightforward to me.
There will be more terrorist attacks to come, probably some in the US. All we can do in those cases is to hope our intelligence agencies are able to stop them. Still, as good as they are, there is no doubt that there will be at least a couple of heart-rendering terrorist attacks from ISIL, Al Qaeda or some American gun nut that will happen sooner or later. It's going to happen and we have to be prepared to accept that. From the first WTC bombing to 9-11 to Sandy Hook or Roseberg, terrorism in America is something we have come to live with and we should expect more.
God, the desperation reeks. The more they succeed (Paris, Egypt, Lebanon) the worse they are doing! For the
informed opinion of a Democrat who's not desperate to peddle bullshit to gullible troglodytes , here's the ranking member of the Senate Intelligence committee:
“I’ve never been more concerned,” the California Democrat and Intelligence Committee ranking member told Andrea Mitchell on MSNBC Monday. “I read the intelligence faithfully. ISIL is not contained. ISIL is expanding.”
This is them losing?
Didn't Cheney or Rumsfeld say something like this?
As it occurred right after they lost Sinjar, there may be some timing there.
Excuse me, but can you tell me when they have NOT relied on terrorism? It appears this is just another dumb ass who is actually stupid enough to agree with the head dumb ass on ISIS.
It's VOX. It's their mission statement to defend the administration.
ISIL isn't losing; it's just adjusting its tactics. Strategy is the plan for achieving a political military objective. Tactics are the means by which you use your resources to achieve the objective. ISIL's objective has been expanding, not contracting, which is reflected in its changing name. In the beginning, it was called ISIS -- Islamic State in Iraq and Syria. Then it became ISIL -- Islamic State in Iraq and the Levant (a reference to all of the land between Egypt and Turkey. Now it's IS -- Islamic State (of everywhere).
ISIL is viewed as so extreme that even al Qaeda won't support them but being snubbed by al Qaeda hasn't hurt ISIL. The organization shocked the world by moving through Syria and Iraq so quickly that they threatened to topple Baghdad and sweep Assad away in Syria. It's advance may have been halted and even rolled back a bit but the organization continues to expand in part due to looking like a mighty mite that can withstand the combined air power of the US and its coalition. Now it stands against Russia as well. Since air power alone cannot stop them and they feel confident that the West has no stomach to commit ground troops, ISIL has no real fear of being defeated. Now they have retaliated against the incessant bombing by bombing back . . . their way through terrorist attacks (blowing up a Russian passenger jet and striking Paris). They have cells not just in Iraq and Syria but have spread into more than a dozen countries. Not taking these nuts seriously has allowed them to become the richest terrorist organization in history, able to project power into the heart of the nations that attack them. We are not winning when the enemy is more dangerous than ever.
Send in US ground troops to chop the head off this snake before it gets any bigger and/or more globally entrenched. Specifically, I mean enter Iraq (at the request of the government) with 50,000 ground troops. Tell the Sunni that we are not taking sides in a sectarian war but we mean to exterminate ISIL. Join us or get the hell out of the way. Stop trying to depose Assad since dictators seem to be best able to control radical Islam and removing a dictator is what helped create this mess in the first place. Let Assad and the Russians/Iranians wipe out ISIL in Syria. In Iraq, drive ISIL toward the Syrian border and crush them between US and Syrian/Russian forces.