╌>

Don't Go Down This Path!!!

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  malamuteman  •  11 years ago  •  11 comments

Don't Go Down This Path!!!

Donald Trump suggests all Muslims should be forced to register in a federal database and carry special ID designating them as Muslim…

WHAT?!?!?  Are you kidding me??? I have always thought Trump as a candidate for President was a complete joke… But this??? This is beyond the pale.

Bend the Arc, a Jewish action organization responds…


Registering everyone of a certain religion to a list? We've seen that. It doesn’t end well.
- Bend the Arc


  DON'T go down this path!!!


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    11 years ago

I have to agree with you Mal. And it's for the same reasons that gun owners don't want a registry. Any government can abuse this. Besides. it's anticonstitutional. 

Fear should not dictate what we do. 

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell    11 years ago

Trump is seeing how extreme he can go without losing right wing electoral support. He is testing the water. He hasn't hit that wall yet. 

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    11 years ago

I shudder to think he has supporters.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    11 years ago

Yes, it would be a total mockery of America to do something of this nature for the Muslims who are living here. I do believe extremely rigorous background checks including dna identification should be part of the protocol for the incoming refugees, however. They are a very different proposition from  those who arrived a few years ago without the question of whether ISIS has managed to infiltrate their ranks, and even then, we have had some radicals slip through.

It is inhumane to "register" humans in such a way, isn't it? American Indians have lived, registered like livestock, since Europeans took over this continent. The government even tells them what blood quantum is acceptable to be called "Indian."

We certainly wouldn't want to do that to any other group, and have to make up a separate Constitution, with rules of how they are to be treated, and how they must behave in society.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.  replied to  screminmimi   11 years ago

Yes, it would be a total mockery of America to do something of this nature for the Muslims who are living here. 

I totally agree with you Mimi. Many of them came over when the Shah lost power and are very modern. 

Ironically, the Europeans are in a agreement that American Muslims are better integrated into our society than there's, even though they have a more open door policy. Recent polls have shown that most American Muslims feel they are happy here, while most European feel like second class citizens. 

We live in a very complicated world. 

It is inhumane to "register" humans in such a way, isn't it? American Indians have lived, registered like livestock, since Europeans took over this continent. The government even tells them what blood quantum is acceptable to be called "Indian."

Very true and very frustrating. It's like we are back 100 years ago. Simply the most forgotten minority group in the US. 

 

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     11 years ago

Have we not learned from our past history? It appears we haven't.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.  replied to  Kavika   11 years ago

Agreed Kavika. Just look at Europe now. The Fascist are moving into position over this. And if this goes down here, then we are no better. 

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    11 years ago

Donald Trump suggests all Muslims should be forced to register in a federal database and carry special ID designating them as Muslim.

I think he may have gone too far this time. Not only does such a list serve no purpose other than allowing authorities to round people up simply for being Muslim, he has stupidly undercut his legitimate anti-illegal immigration stance by giving his opponents a good reason to see him as a fascist. Plus, he has given ISIL a recruiting tool that goes something like this: "In their war against Islam, the crusaders make no distinction between the wicked and the just. To them, you are all the same -- to be rounded up (women and children alike) and disposed of as it suits them simply because you believe in Allah -- so do not hesitate to strike back and dispose of them the same way." I want to destroy ISIL, not expand it. Trump's rhetoric is both foolish and dangerous.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     11 years ago


Japanese-American Internment Camps

A historical fact that is not really "common knowledge" is the fact that, during World War II, over 100,000 Japanese-American individuals, the vast majority of which were actually American citizens, were rounded up and shipped eventually to internment camps. These consisted of poorly-constructed barracks surrounded by barbed wire, sentry posts and armed guards.

They were put in these camps, not because they had been tried and found guilty of something, but because either they or their parents or ancestors were from Japan and, as such, they were deemed a "threat" to national security. They were also easily identifiable due to their race. There was no similar large-scale roundups of German or Italian-Americans, even though we were also fighting them during World War II.

These people were forced to abandon their businesses, their homes and, in many cases, their families as some individuals were taken elsewhere and held, again without trial, for years. The Japanese-Americans suffered severe economic losses, personal humiliation and, in a some cases, death, due to this relocation.

The relocation itself was ordered by the then President of the United States, Franklin D. Roosevelt, and by an act of Congress.

The Japanese-American (Nisei) and the Japanese aliens (Issei) on the West Coast were rounded up and moved to assembly centers and then to internment camps. Few Japanese living in the East or Midwestern portions of the U.S., though, were treated the same way.

What is extremely interesting is that the Nisei and Issei living in Hawaii were not subject to a mass evacuation even though they formed a third of the population in Hawaii and were a lot closer to Japan than the Japanese-Americans on the West Coast of the U.S.

The reasons they weren't rounded up were both cultural and economic.

"There was no mass relocation and internment in Hawaii, where the population was one-third Japanese American. It would have been impossible to transport that many people to the mainland, and the Hawaiian economy would have collapsed without Japanese American workers. "

-from the book Japanese American Internment Camps by Gail Sakurai, 2002

"Ironically, the territory with the largest Japanese population saw the least discrimination. More than one third of all residents of Hawaii had some Japanese ancestry. Japanese labor was considered vital to the civilian and military economics of the Hawaiian Islands. Besides, the views of Delos Emmons, military commander of Hawaii, were the opposite of those of General DeWitt."

-from the book Japanese-American internment in American History, 1996.

As noted in some of the other reviews, there were a very small number of people arrested and detained in Hawaii and a small number that voluntarily went to the mainland camps, but primarily so they could find relatives. There was not a single act of sabotage in Hawaii by the Japanese Americans during the entire war.

In addition, since there were so many people of Japanese ancestry already living in Hawaii, about a third of the population, racism was not at all the kind of problem it was on the west coast.

Although prejudice and discrimination played major roles in the internment, economics and jealousy did also, as many Californians were jealous of the economic success that the Japanese-American farmers and store owners enjoyed. Thus arose a lot of the anti-Japanese-American feeling in the same way that some people despise Jewish people, largely due to their economic successes. The hard work, self-sacrifice, and strong efforts by the Japanese-Americans and Jewish people are overlooked and ignored when people of prejudice proclaim their judgments against Japanese-Americans and Jewish people.

The fact that the internment did happen here in the U.S. is something to never forget since what has happened once could very well happen again, especially in these days of growing anti-immigrant, anti-foreigner feelings in the U.S.

Don't head down this path again.
 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    11 years ago

Besides being idiotic, dangerous and simply un-American, Rumps proposal would serve to also push jihadists further underground rather than revealing them.

 
 
 
pat wilson
Professor Quiet
link   pat wilson    11 years ago

I have to question his motives for running in the first place. Did this start out as a prank and then he saw his popularity snowball ? And then did his irrational ego think "Hey, maybe I can be president" ? Then again perhaps now he's having second thoughts and really wants a way out. Hence the ever more extreme, sensational comments. Who TF knows ?

 
 

Who is online


Igknorantzruls


87 visitors