Why They Don't Say "Radical Islam" , in a nutshell
"Our allies against ISIS in the region are out there every day saying, ' This is not Islam ,'" said Mr. Benjamin, now at Dartmouth. "We don't want to undermine them. Any good it would do to trumpet 'Islamic radicalism' would be overwhelmed by the damage it would do to those relationships." [ The New York Times , 2/18/15 ]

Our allies are out there everyday , in the region, saying "this (ISIS) is not islam", so quite understandably they find it counterproductive for the U.S. government to be saying "it is radical ISLAM".
How STUPID are conservatives and right wingers and islamophobes who do not understand this simple tactical concept ?
Experts Have Explained Why Using The Term "Radical Islam" To Define The Enemy Hurts America's Efforts To Combat Terrorism
Bloomberg View: The Term "Radical Islam" Is Counterproductive To "The Long War Against Radical Islamic Terrorists." Bloomberg View columnist Eli Lake noted that declining to attribute this type of terror attack to "radical Islam" conforms with "a longstanding U.S. policy, not only for Obama but also his predecessor, George W. Bush." Lake explained that the Obama administration didn't use "radical Islam" to describe the ideology of the terrorists who attacked the office of the satirical French weekly Charlie Hebdo because the United States' war against terror "requires at least the tacit support of many radical Muslims":
Former State Dept. Counterterrorism Official: Trumpeting "Islamic Radicalism" Would Damage Ally Relationships And Do More Harm Than Good. Daniel Benjamin, the State Department's top counterterrorism official from 2009-2012, said that throwing around the phrase "Islamic radicalism" would damage to efforts to combat terror by undermining relationships with allies:
Foreign Policy : Efforts To Address Terrorism By Focusing On Islam Have Backfired. Foreign Policy explained that programs that have attempted to combat terrorism by focusing exclusively on Islamic extremism have failed. Britain launched "an Islamic-centric counter-extremism effort" in 2005 called the "Prevent Program" that, according to Foreign Policy , "backfired by alienating Muslims and making cooperation with law enforcement officials even more difficult." [ Foreign Policy , 2/17/15 ]
The Week : Describing Terrorism As Islamic Alienates Allies And Dignifies Terrorists. In a February 18 post for The Week , Marc Ambinder wrote, "Calling terrorism Islamic terrorism ... doesn't serve the purposes of a president who has to work with countries that have a studiously complicated relationship with the purveyors of terror," meaning it could backfire by offending and alienating countries the president needs cooperation from in order to fight terrorism. Ambinder also noted that Obama's strategy behind not using the term "Islamic terrorism" is to avoid "dignify[ing] that movement by calling it what it calls itself." Ambinder added that "Osama bin Laden himself said that Obama's refusal to join the language fight made it more difficult to generate recruits." [ The Week , 2/18/15 ]
And Former President George W. Bush Repeatedly Made Clear Terrorism Does Not Represent The Islamic Faith
Bush: "We Do Not Fight Islam, We Fight Against Evil." In November 2001 President Bush delivered remarks to the Warsaw Conference on Combating Terrorism during which he stated that, "The head of the 22 nation Arab League rejected the claims of the terrorist leader and said he -- Osama bin Laden -- 'doesn't speak in the name of Arabs and Muslims.'" Bush went on to declare that "All of us here today understand this: We do not fight Islam, we fight against evil." [White House Archives, 11/6/01 ]
Bush: "The Face Of Terror Is Not The True Faith Of Islam." During remarks given at the Islamic Center of Washington, D.C in the days following the September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks, Bush assured Americans that attacks committed by Al Qaeda were not representative of the Islamic faith:
Bush: "The Terrorists Are Traitors To Their Own Faith, Trying, In Effect, To Hijack Islam Itself." In an address to a joint session of Congress following the terrorist attacks of September 11, 2001, Bush again made clear that the terrorists who attacked the United States "practice a fringe form of Islamic extremism that has been rejected by Muslim scholars and the vast majority of Muslim clerics -- a fringe movement that perverts the peaceful teachings of Islam." Bush spoke directly to the difference between extremist terrorists and Muslims:
Not naming the danger is not tactics, it's poltics. The left is too stupid to see it. Or admit it.
We have Muslims in the middle east trying to diminish the terrorists by telling the Muslim population "these people are not Islamic, (we are)".
You want to erode their effect by insisting the terrorists are islamic. Why? Why do you want to fuck up the efforts to diminish the authority of ISIS like that ?
Admitting the obvious, that these terrorist movements are based on Islam, erodes nothing. No one is that stupid. Newspeak will not help.
"Our allies are out there everyday , in the region, saying "this (ISIS) is not islam", so quite understandably they find it counterproductive for the U.S. government to be saying "it is radical ISLAM".
How STUPID are conservatives and right wingers and islamophobes who do not understand this simple tactical concept ? "
So true. It's exactly the same truth as the JDL is not Judaism, and Naziism is not German, and Confucionism is not Chinese, and the Crusaders were not Christian. ???
Out of curiosity, Diaspora Jews (even those who have nothing to do with Israel) are not Israelis, so why are they made to suffer for alleged wrongdoings of Israel?
"Radical" an adjective … "Islam" a proper noun.
ISIS, despite what it may call itself in terms of its "religion," is not representative of Islam (nor of any other organized religion). Consequently, the term "Radical Islam" does not apply to ISIS, no more than some delusional nutjob who thinks he's Jesus Christ and who kills in "the name of Christianity" … is a radical Christian.
Good analogy Mac.
I agree, good analogy. We are not fighting Islam, we a fighting a religious cult, who have stolen the real faith of the nearly 1,000,000,000 peaceful Muslims in the world, including those here in the US. When people like Trump say things like we need to stop all Muslims from coming into America, even those who are Americans who happen to be overseas or tourists or even or our own Muslim military soldiers who are serving overseas, he is doing the bidding of ISIS by creating a recruitment tool for them to say to the rest of Muslim world "See! America doesn't want you! Even if you were born there, they hate you just because you are a Muslim!! Join us to fight them or they will eliminate you! Even in America you need to kill not only for your faith, but now for your very lives! Even someone running to become President says he hates you!"
Of course what Trump said is never going to happen. First of all because he'll never be President and doesn't really want to be, but also because what he says he wants to do is probably un-constitutional and without a doubt just plain un-American. However his hateful words are all the Muslim world hears and are inflaming the problem and innocent people will die, Muslims and people of other or no religions, because of the thoughtless bigotry and hate against Muslims he spouts to the world audience. Considering his words, he might as well being collecting a paycheck from ISIS as one of their best recruiters. He personally will be responsible for deaths somewhere in the world because of his rhetoric. His words make him a terrorist supporter and murderer. He is the one who needs to not be allowed in the US. Yes, he has freedom of speech, but his speech is inciting death. He is screaming "Fire!" in a crowded theater.
is not representative of Islam
I think you are missing an important point . It is a consequential number of individuals who call themselves ISIS , not just a few . And all of them align themselves with the leadership who talks about Islam as the motivating force . Since the other muslim imams are hesitant to go against that leadership in public discourse it is in fact recognized as islam by its followers .
It is a consequential number of individuals who call themselves ISIS , not just a few .
What these individuals do is certainly "consequential," but if there are 100,000 ISIS terrorists … that is numerically a fraction of the 1,000,000,000 (billion) Muslims in the world.
Its a small fraction but it is a significant number . As such it is a subset of islam ... perhaps a cult .
BTW there is nothing being done by ISIS that wasn't done by their prophet Mohammed ...
Any good it would do to trumpet 'Islamic radicalism' would be overwhelmed by the damage it would do to those relationships."
For some reason the same courtesy is not applied to Christians even though they are being slaughtered in large numbers in Arab countries especially .
What the topic seems to be is that once a Muslim is no longer peaceful, and kills in the name of Islam, shouting Alliyahu Akbar when doing it, he is no longer a Muslim. Then why has it been reported that in some cases they question their victims and determine if they are Muslim or not, and if so they let them go free but kill everyone else?
If a Jew or a Christian becomes a terrorist and slaughters innocent people, I guess this means that if they do so they are no longer Jews or Christians.
It's the True Scotsman fallacy.
If a Jew or a Christian becomes a terrorist and slaughters innocent people, I guess this means that if they do so they are no longer Jews or Christians.
I disagree with this premise Buzz; if any individual murders in the name of his or her religion, unless the leaders and preponderance of adherents to that religion have given overt ("official"?) sanction and credence, the individual(s) has hijacked the name of that religion … BUT NOT THE RELIGION ITSELF!
It's a wolf in sheep's clothing situation, IMO.
A Wolf in sheep's clothing is an idiom of Biblical origin used to describe those portraying a role contrary to their real character with whom contact is dangerous. This idiom can be applied to false teachers and prophets that distort truth to the detriment of the followers. As a fable it has been falsely credited to Aesop and the theme is now numbered 451 in the Perry Index . The confusion has arisen from the similarity of the theme with fables of Aesop concerning wolves that are mistakenly trusted by shepherds; the moral drawn from these is that one's basic nature eventually betrays itself.
Does the self-ascribed "Christian" who murders women and physicians at a Planned Parenthood clinic represent "Christianity", or, is he a self-proclaimed Christian who deems himself a martyr?
Let's continue this tomorrow.