╌>

Why do we freak out about terrorism, anyway? Here’s why we shouldn’t.

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  community  •  11 years ago  •  37 comments

Why do we freak out about terrorism, anyway? Here’s why we shouldn’t.



December 10 







There’s a new poll out today from the Public Religion Research Institute showing that nearly half of Americans say they’re either very worried or somewhat worried that they or a member of their family will be a victim of terrorism.

You might say that’s understandable, given how much terrorism has dominated the news recently. But the truth is, they’re wrong. On a national scale, terrorism isn’t a threat, it’s a nuisance. We’re having a collective freakout about it right now, and that freakout serves the interests of those who are encouraging it. But we need to take a step back and look at just how dangerous terrorism really is.

Here’s a question we all ought to ask ourselves: When it comes to terrorism, what exactly are we afraid of? I know it seems self-evident — terrorism is scary! — but what exactly is it? If you try to articulate an answer, you quickly realize how infrequently we actually ask the question.

The simplest answer, of course, is that we’re afraid that terrorists will kill people. Okay, so how many people? According to the New America Foundation, since 9/11 there have been 45 Americans killed in jihadist terrorist attacks, and 48 Americans killed in right-wing terrorist attacks. Let’s put aside for the moment the fact that even though these two numbers are comparable, we don’t treat right-wing terrorism as something that requires any kind of policy response or even sustained attention. But you can’t argue that jihadi terrorism is something to be concerned about and afraid of because of the damage it’s been doing. An average of about three people killed per year in a country of 320 million is next to nothing.

So if it’s not because terrorists have managed to kill a lot of people in the last few years, are we petrified of terrorism because terrorists could kill lots of people in the near future? That’s possible. But how many could they kill? Another dozen, like in the San Bernardino shooting? A hundred? Five hundred? Since September 11 we’ve made it much harder to pull off a large-scale, spectacular attack. Terrorists aren’t going to be able to hijack airplanes and use them as missiles. It’s possible that there could be repeats  of the San Bernardino shootings, and that’s something to be concerned about. But we have mass shootings in America all the time. Why — again exactly — should we be more concerned about a repeat of San Bernardino than a repeat of Aurora, where nearly the same number of people (12) were killed?

 

Both were terrible, and both could happen again. But only in the case of San Bernardino does the event cause large portions of the public and elected officials to contemplate sweeping policy change, even up to and including the idea of starting another full-scale Middle East war because we’re so frightened. (Anytime there’s a mass shooting, Democrats push for gun control measures; but Republicans only call for a major policy response when it’s terrorism.)

There are some people who would argue that even if terrorists haven’t killed a lot of Americans lately, and even if it’s unlikely they’d be able to kill truly large numbers of Americans in the future, we still need to freak out about terrorism because a group like the Islamic State represents an “existential threat” to America. But if you get specific in the questions you ask, it becomes obvious that this idea is utterly deranged.

Back in the Cold War, the Soviet Union presented a true existential threat to the United States. It had enough nuclear missiles pointed at us to kill every man, woman, and child in America (and on the rest of the planet to boot). The Islamic State has no such capability. Is the Islamic State going to launch an invasion of the United States, sweep through the nation from Manhattan all the way to Seattle, take control of the whole country, and force America to live under its brutal rule? Of course not. Is it going to launch a coup from inside our government and raise its flag over the White House? No.

So what exactly is it we’re afraid the Islamic State will do to America? Right now I’m not talking about what it could do to Iraq or Syria, because that’s a very different question. What could it do to America? The absolute worst it could do is launch some successful attacks that might kill a dozen or even a hundred of us. And that would be awful. But about thirty Americans are murdered every day with guns, and a hundred die every day in car accidents. Eighty-three Americans die every day in falls, but we haven’t declared a “War on Falling,” and nobody tells pollsters that their biggest fear is that someone in their family will suffer a fatal fall.

If you actually force yourself to think in specific terms about the substance of the threat the Islamic State poses to us, you have to admit that the actual threat is miniscule. So why are we having a national freakout about it now? The answer, I think, lies in the presidential campaign, particularly in the Republican primary. You have a bunch of news organizations following around a bunch of candidates who know that the way to gain the support of their base is to prey on that base’s fears and prejudices. Add in the fact that the front-runner is a demagogic bigot, and you quickly get into a cycle of hysteria: a terrorist attack happens, it’s extensively covered in the media, the candidates seize on it to propose ever more radical policy changes (Keep out refugees! Put troops on the ground in Iraq and Syria! Keep out all the Muslims!) all the while proclaiming that the threat from terrorism is horrifyingly large and growing larger. The media report on their statements, voters get more nervous, and the candidates respond by feeding the panic.


Even outside their campaign coverage, the media give enormous attention to an event like San Bernardino, spending weeks analyzing not just the occurrence itself but who the perpetrators were, what motivated them, what they had for breakfast on the day of the attack, and everything else that can be uncovered. This coverage isn’t problematic in and of itself, but its sheer volume serves to reinforce the idea that terrorism is a huge threat that we all need to be terribly afraid of.

 

But it isn’t, and we don’t. We should be concerned, and we should take reasonable steps to minimize the risk we face from terrorism, just as we do with all the other risks we face. But right now we’re acting like a bunch of cowards. It’s long past time

we got a hold of ourselves.

 







 


 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

Eighty-three Americans die every day in falls, but we haven’t declared a “War on Falling,” and nobody tells pollsters that their biggest fear is that someone in their family will suffer a fatal fall. 83 people a day die doing it.

 

I myself have fallen several times and haven't died, but I'm just a lucky one! We need to get the FBI to investigate all Americans to make sure they are not susceptible to falling and dying and throw them out of the country! We also need to stop all people who might be fallers at the border and stop them too! We need a War on Falling! Where is Homeland Security when we need them!?

I am afraid I might die the next time I fall! It's just like being scared of terrorism except much worse because there is a much, much bigger chance of it happening to me! We need a Congressional Committee to investigate this falling terrorism! Why haven't any of the Presidential candidates spoken out about this terrible killer of Americans?! Eighty three people a day die of falling and you or one of your loved ones might be next! Be afraid! Be very, very afraid!

 

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika   replied to  Randy   11 years ago

This is my anti falling suit. I'm not going to die in a fall...

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober  replied to  Randy   11 years ago

The fact that you are ignoring what is published on social media from ISIS accounts is where you are missing the obvious reasons for public upset . ISIS is a terrorist organization and they publish ghastly images and videos of their exploits in other countries . If you are not upset about this material you are unusual to say the least ...

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell    11 years ago

Like most things negative in our world, this problem can be traced back to right wing media, which poisons millions of minds daily. The mainstream media isn't so hot right now either. People on the right are downright encouraged to blame and attack President Obama and/or Hillary Clinton , Eric Holder, Loretta Lynch, Nancy Pelosi, Harry Reid and "political correctness" and accuse them of causing every bad thing that happens in the world. It has been going on for many years, and like radical islam, is a generational issue.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy  replied to  JohnRussell   11 years ago

Every time Trump says something inflammatory he does it on purpose. It's to get a bump in the polls in the primary when it looks like someone is gaining on him. He then gets several days of free political advertising without having to pay a dime. The problem is that the idiots who actually believe what he says have an element that is downright dangerous and will follow his speech into violent action. Right wing radio and TV pushes his BS (and I doubt that he believes what he is saying himself, as much as he is just manipulating the news and his followers) and soon the rest of the GOP field either backs down or get's shot down if they go after him, because Trump is better for ratings then the other GOP candidates are.

Yesterday Cruz took some serious shots at Trump and Carson when he thought his comments were not being recorded in which he basically called them clowns that he is using and that their candidacies are doomed to fail. Trump tweeted this morning a challenge to Cruz to bring it on and he'll go down like everyone else that has challenged him. This afternoon Cruz was groveling at Trumps feet like a whipped dog. Trump is an asshole bully who doesn't believe what he says, Carson is an idiot outside of the operating room and Cruz is a spineless wimp. Great choices for the GOP.

My guess is that they have all fallen at some point in their lives, but instead of dying got severe brain damage.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson  replied to  Randy   11 years ago

My guess is that they have all fallen at some point in their lives, but instead of dying got severe brain damage.

Eureka!!!

   applause

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    11 years ago

To me, being killed by terrorism from Daesh, or ISIS/ISIL, is about as likely as being eaten by a shark.  I haven't been to the ocean in many years...

However, I am worried about the everyday kooks we have running around.  It seems to me that the doomsday contingent keeps them stirred up.

crazy

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy  replied to  Dowser   11 years ago

However, I am worried about the everyday kooks we have running around.  It seems to me that the doomsday contingent keeps them stirred up.

 

From the article: We should be concerned, and we should take reasonable steps to minimize the risk we face from terrorism, just as we do with all the other risks we face. But right now we’re acting like a bunch of cowards. It’s long past time we got a hold of ourselves. 

Yep. More then 100 people a day die in car accidents, but you don't see 2 or 3 weeks of news cycles devoted to that every time someone dies in one. Of course we have to guard against terrorism, but I am not the least bit afraid of it. I am not terrorized. Most people on this site will die of heart disease or cancer or stroke or get killed in a car accident. The chance that an American will die from a terrorist attack is much less then getting hit by lightening. Yes, be aware of it, but you still have a much, much, much, much more chance of slipping in the bath tub nd killing yourself then you do from terrorists. Defeat the terrorists the obvious way. Don't be afraid of them! I'm certainly not "terrorized" or even a tiny bit afraid of them and and the San Bernardino attacks took place less then an hour away from where I live. I'm more worried my three Shih-Tzus will gang up on me and eat me if I don't give them their morning treats.
a

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell  replied to  Randy   11 years ago

Terrorism is kind of "sexy" or thrilling. Us against them. 

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy  replied to  JohnRussell   11 years ago

It is more "sexy" for a candidate to rail against something that has virtually no chance of happening to the average American, instead of talking about the 100,000's of people who die in this country of other things, many of them preventable and that, with good government funding, could add years to people's lives.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy  replied to  Dowser   11 years ago

However, I am worried about the everyday kooks we have running around.  It seems to me that the doomsday contingent keeps them stirred up.

More to your point. Some of the people currently running for President are using terrorism to gin up their base, keep them afraid and convince them that they are the only one who can save them from the evil people overseas. They also hint or outright say that the people who disagree with them are somehow the enemy or are agents of the terrorists or are terrorists themselves. This causes people with unbalanced minds to do stupid things like attack anyone they think might be or is a Muslim, even if that person is just working hard, making a living and trying to build the American dream they have a right to (and yes, American Muslims have a right to the American dream also).

The problem is that words have consequences when you are a public figure. Some of the people who support you may be fanatical in that support and become "radicalized" by your message of hate toward Muslims in particular. Of course when something happens the candidate can always try to wash the blood off from their hands by saying they certainly were not attempting to incite violence, when that is exactly what they are doing, just not in those exact words. Candidates MUST be more careful and measured in their message and how they deliver it, because not everyone of their followers is going to just listen and vote. There are bound to be some who will act out violently, just as those terrorists who become radicalized by the off shoot cult of the Muslim religion called Islamic Terrorists.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson  replied to  Randy   11 years ago

Some of the people currently running for President are using terrorism to gin up their base, keep them afraid and convince them that they are the only one who can save them from the evil people overseas.

This is their "business model". They sell book, get TV gigs, and collect zillions in "campaign donations". The fear-mongers make their living from the fear they monger.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy  replied to  Bob Nelson   11 years ago

And unfortunately sometimes people die because of all of the hate they put out. On all sides.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson  replied to  Randy   11 years ago

Yes. And when a nutcase shoots up a Planned Parenthood center, all these "fine folks" are saying "Who? Me? I never encouraged violence!" 

 

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy  replied to  Bob Nelson   11 years ago

One of my sad favorites. Many of the anti-abortion folks are so far out there with their langue and statements that they do incite violence. They scream and rant and rave that anyone, absolutely anyone, associated abortion or Planned Parenthood, even receptionists and friends who are there with women who are there, which the vast majority (97%) of them are NOT there to get an abortion, but are there for other health services, are murderers and killers and executioners of living babies, who then chop them up into parts like butchers with a meat cleaver to sell like at a meat market, what is some nut ball supposed to think? The lies (and they are lies) they say lead to the deaths and attacks and dead doctors and blown up clinics and then the very same anti-abortion folks say "Oh but we're pro-life and we don't support that!" They incite violence and then throw up their hands and deny that violence is what they intended to have happen. Just another lie.

Still, we are wandering off topic. Let's try to move it back toward the unreasonable fear of terrorism.

 
 
 
LynneA
Freshman Silent
link   LynneA  replied to  Dowser   11 years ago

Benefit of fatalistic ideology, no fear ever. 

We're all going to die, the manner, date and time is unknown (unless you're planning suicide or euthanasia)...why live in fear.  Living like it's my last day brings joy to my life and constant knowledge of who and what is important.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Good seed, Randy.

   applause

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy  replied to  Bob Nelson   11 years ago

Thanks. I'm thinking slippery shower floors are probably the main culprit in the slip and die terrorism. All people should be banned from showering. In fact getting in and out of the tub is dangerous too, so bathing should be stopped completely and you should be able to tell all patriotic Americans by how much they smell.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    11 years ago

I think there are some compelling reasons for the freak-out as it where, though this also feed right into terrorists objectives.

1. 9-11 is still fresh in the mind for many.

2. Terrorism's main objective is to accomplish political goals by freaking people out.

These are offered as reason, not excuses. What this article so succinctly points out is that we actually help to further terrorist's goals by being terrified.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    11 years ago

Actually, the way to defeat terrorism is to not do anything but go about your lives. Terrorism is meant to stop us from doing that. If you change your lifestyle, then they win. 

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy  replied to  Perrie Halpern R.A.   11 years ago

Absolutely right Perrie. Don't ignore them, especially when it comes to supporting our intelligence services and military, but don't let them change your day to day life. It's unreasonable to be afraid of them in your day to day life. There are far, far, far to many other things to be concerned about personally. The chance of becoming a victim of Islamic terrorism in America is so absurdly small when it is compared to other dangers. Be fearless and they lose.

Oh and be careful in the shower or getting out of the bath tub.nervous

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

Great, then people should shut up about guns too. Good deal.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

We should be concerned, and we should take reasonable steps to minimize the risk we face from terrorism, just as we do with all the other risks we face. But right now we’re acting like a bunch of cowards. It’s long past time we got a hold of ourselves.

Just because terrorism is a slowly growing threat in the US doesn't mean it doesn't have the potential to be far more serious . In Europe it already is .

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    11 years ago

By the exact same argument, we should not be concerned with mass murders or gun violence. I'm glad you've all seen the light.

 
 

Who is online





87 visitors