╌>

Reality Check -- by Bob Nelson

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  bob-nelson  •  11 years ago  •  54 comments

Reality Check   --   by Bob Nelson

This morning, several commentators have said pretty much the same thing: Last night's Republican debate was long on scary stories and short on policy ideas.

A couple days ago, I bought a corkscrew at the "household utensils" store at the Foothills Indoor Market -- a friendly Mom-and-Pop place that has everything you can imagine, and then some. As usual, I chatted a bit with the owner. He knows we live in France half the year, and expressed sympathy after the Paris attacks. "We don't dare go out anymore," he added. 

I answered that if we do not go out, then we have given the victory to the Bad Guys.

 

Paris is a city of ten million, in a country of 65 million. The probability of being killed in a terrorist attack is infinitesimal. There is no rational reason for changing one's behavior. No rational reason.

The total of all deaths in terrorist attacks in the USA over the last several decades is surely less than 5000. Over the same period, something like one million people have died in automobile accidents. The probability of being killed in a terrorist attack is infinitesimal. There is no rational reason for changing one's behavior. No  rational  reason.

 Americans are not stupid... so why are so many behaving so irrationally?

The answer is obvious, once you stop to think about it.

 


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    11 years ago

"All we have to fear is fear itself."

 

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy  replied to  Bob Nelson   11 years ago

You need to coordinate your message. The liberal talking point of the day is:

A Terrorist  threw a rock through a window of a building !!!!!!

TIME TO PANIC! 

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Sean Treacy   11 years ago

Hi, Sean...

I realize that for someone like you, who parrots Tea Party bullet-points regardless of reality, will have a hard time understanding that I don't ever follow anyone's mantras.

That's kinda sorta the point of my article.

     patience

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy  replied to  Bob Nelson   11 years ago

Hey bob, 

 I don't ever follow anyone's mantras.

The day you have a thought that isn't found on the dailykos, is the day I believe in miracles. 

 I don't ever follow anyone's mantras.

This seed is, of course, another regurgitation of a theme that has been repeated over and over here and everywhere else on liberal sites.  There are two liberal responses to Islamic Terrorism.

One, point how rare it is and declare its not worth talking about. Two, talk obsessively about the statistically much rarer non-Muslim terrorism.

The fact the responses are mutually contradictory doesn't really matter to liberal partisans. 

 

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Sean Treacy   11 years ago

Jeez, Sean... 

dailykos

Pleas point to one single link from one of my seeds/articles to Daily Kos. You can't, because there are none. I don't subscribe. I looked at it many years ago, and saw that it was just another red-meat distributor. I don't do that.

I'm afraid that all you've accomplished here, Sean, is demonstrate that your opinions are based on your imagination, and not on reality. But don't worry. You're hardly alone...

This seed is...

... not a seed. Another fine demonstration of Sean Tracy's "careful reading, thoughtful analysis, ..."

... a theme that has been repeated over and over here and everywhere else on liberal sites.  There are two liberal responses to Islamic Terrorism. ... ... ... 

... and 

Ummm... No, Sean. "Islamic Terrorism" is not the subject of my article. Another fine demonstration of Sean Tracy's "careful reading, thoughtful analysis, ..."

 

You know, Sean... you might think about going to work for the Onion. Your posts are hilariously off the mark.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy  replied to  Bob Nelson   11 years ago

You seem to be struggling with English.

Pleas point to one single link from one of my seeds/articles to Daily Kos?

The point, which you missed, is that your opinions, are typically indistinguishable from those found on sites like Dailykos. Whatever the source of your arguments, your posts end up as standard fare liberal red meat.  Just like this piece. 

mic Terrorism" is not the subject of my article

No shit. I never said it was. Any other straw men you want to concoct?  

My point, which was obvious, is  that your piece is typical of the generic liberal response to Islamic Terrorism and only Islamic Terrorism. Get it yet? Whether you happened to mention Islamic Terrorism specifically or not is irrelevant.  It's the fact that this generic argument is only trotted out (by you and many others on this and other sites) only in the aftermath of  Islamic Terrorism. It's the standard liberal way to denigrate the importance of Islamic Terrorism. 

 

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Sean Treacy   11 years ago

Ah, Sean...

You seem to be struggling with English.

Pleas 

Typo. Please excuse me. And do not... ever... commit an error of grammar, syntax, or spelling. I usually do not pick up on them... but since you have chosen to go on that playing field, I will oblige you.

 

Pleas point to one single link from one of my seeds/articles to Daily Kos?

The point, which you missed, is that your opinions, are typically indistinguishable from those found on sites like Dailykos.

OK, Dean. I'll have to take your word for it, since I never read their stuff. I would remark, though, on the "rigor" of your statement: "indistinguishable" is a fairly absolute word while "on sites like " is pretty relaxed. How can anything be "indistinguishable" from an indistinct reference? 

 

My point, which was obvious, is  that your piece is typical of the generic liberal response to Islamic Terrorism and only Islamic Terrorism. Get it yet?

Sean... my poor Sean... the word "Islamic" does not appear in my article. I purposely did not use it, because I did not want the conversation sidetracked. The topic is the media's unceasing fear-mongering.

Whether you happened to mention Islamic Terrorism specifically or not is irrelevant.

WTF?? I am the author, Sean! If I do not mention Islamic Terrorism, and then I say that Islamic Terrorism is off-topic... the that is the way it is. It's my damned article, after all.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur  replied to  Bob Nelson   11 years ago

"All we have to fear is fear itself."

Well, sort of …

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty  replied to  A. Macarthur   11 years ago

He's making progress he's not scared of global warming.  

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur  replied to  Dean Moriarty   11 years ago

He's making progress he's not scared of global warming.  

Right! He's only afraid of the things that might do him harm if he's not distracted by the supply-demand catastrophes and wars that will necessary break out when nations can't provide food and clean water because of droughts and floods.

Progress.

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    11 years ago

Yes, it's nuts we see the same thing with the chicken littles scared of being killed in a mass shooting. The media sensationalism works on the ignorant. 

I too have no desire to go back to France. Not because of terrorism but because of the rude French that hate Americans. The Swiss treat us much better. You feel like a welcome guest there. 

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Not because of terrorism but because of the rude French that hate Americans.

There's a part of truth, here, Dean.

I'd make a couple points, though.

First, you're probably talking about Parisians. They're rude to all tourists, regardless of nationality. I think it's a "familiarity breeds contempt" thing. Be aware that "provincials" (French who live anywhere except Paris) dislike Parisians at least as much as you do.

Second, keep in mind that American overreach blew the Middle East to smithereens, and that the consequences are falling on Europe, more than on the US. That's kinda sorta grounds for annoyance. Remember that France tried desperately to prevent Bush II's useless war, and got disdain and insults as a result (remember "Freedom Fries"??). So yes indeed... many French very much resent American arrogance.

That said, France remains the most tourist-visited country in the world... and there are a lot of very good reasons. Put a Canadian flag on the shoulder of your jacket next time. You'll see a difference.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick  replied to  Bob Nelson   11 years ago

@bob-nelson :

Second, keep in mind that American overreach blew the Middle East to smithereens, and that the consequences are falling on Europe, more than on the US. That's kinda sorta grounds for annoyance. Remember that France tried desperately to prevent Bush II's useless war , and got disdain and insults as a result (remember "Freedom Fries"??). So yes indeed... many French very much resent American arrogance.

Good morning Bob.  Do you think that had anything to do with the fact Hussein owed France $4 billion dollars for arming them right up to the time of the war?  A great many Americans and others died as a result of weapons and ammo sold to Hussein from the French, not the people, but through the government who keeps very tight reigns on the sale of these items.  They even had an escape plan for him, but of course that didn't work out.  They wanted their money, didn't they and a great many of people, especially American soldiers died as result of the greed of illegally selling these weapons and ammo to Hussein.  This is just a start for this one war.  Yes, the Industrial War Complex is alive and well, doing fine and making a killing, pardon the pun.  Don't feel I'm picking only on them.  There's plenty to go around.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  sixpick   11 years ago

Do you think that had anything to do with the fact Hussein owed France $4 billion dollars for arming them right up to the time of the war?

No, I don't think so. Arms sales are a sadly common thing all around the world, with the US being by far the largest seller, as I am sure you are aware. France's stated reason -- you can still find videos of Foreign Minister de Villepin at the UN -- was the risk that an invasion of Iraq would destabilize the entire region... and history has proven that to be exactly the case. 

No American soldiers -- none at all -- would have died if Mr Bush had not lied his way to convincing the American people and Congress that Saddam was an imminent danger, and thence to a war that even Paul Wolfowitz later admitted had nothing to do with WMD.

This is a duh! topic, Sixpick. Thousands of Americans and tens of thousands of locals have died, are still dying, and will continue to die for the foreseeable future because of Mr Bush. History will be very, very harsh with the man.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick  replied to  Bob Nelson   11 years ago

May I recommend the book "Treachery" by Bill Gertz for you Bob.  You can get it from the library.  I think you will be unpleasantly surprise in some things, but others will be enlightening as the public are pretty much ignorant of many facts.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  sixpick   11 years ago

Sixpick,

I am wary of gnostics. People who know secrets are often people who listen to voices...

From Amazon:

In shocking detail, "Treachery" exposes: 

•How Iraqi insurgents are killing U.S. soldiers with weapons that France, Germany, and Russia sold them

•How the French and German governments turn a blind eye to arms sales to rogue regimes and terrorist states like Iran, Syria, and North Korea 

The international arms trade is, sadly, one of the primary motors of the world's economy. America is the largest seller. Once a weapon is sold, it belongs to whoever is holding it. The Mujahedin have Stinger missiles...

 

•How intelligence reports show that China supplied arms to al Qaeda after the September 11, 2001, terrorist attacks on America

As yet, China is a minor player in the international arms trade. Why does this attempt shock you? China is not an ally.

 

•The real story of why Libya dismantled its nuclear program—how U.S. intelligence caught the Libyans red-handed trying to smuggle in nuclear weapons technology

They were paid to do so...

 

•How Pakistan's nuclear proliferation network is even more extensive than has been reported

I'm not sure what a "proliferation network" is. I know that there is a great danger in the close relationships that exists between some of Pakistan's intelligence agencies and the Taliban. That said... we could have gotten out of Afghanistan two months after we went in. We could have spanked the Taliban, and then said, "Don't give any more aid to al Qaeda, and you won't get another spanking. Now we are going home, but if you misbehave, we'll be back." Instead, in a country where every invader has failed, going back to Alexander the Great... we engaged in "nation-building". So we're still there, fifteen years later, and the Taliban are no longer just geopolitical enemies, but hatred-filled fanatical enemies.

Our bad... 

 

•The CIA report revealing that al Qaeda is pursuing—and may already have—nuclear, chemical, and biological weapons

Gertz's book was published in 2005. Since nothing has happened since, I assume that this was nonsense, like the "yellowcake".

 

•The classified intelligence showing that Russia and France were cooperating with Saddam Hussein even after the 2003 Iraq war broke out 

The 2003 war did not "break out". America invaded Iraq, without any cover from the UN. The US invaded Iraq. France had tried, very publicly, to prevent this from happening, and I assume that there was also a great deal going on covertly. I would not be at all surprised that France continue to try to stop the war after the US began its invasion. I only regret that those efforts failed, and that so many have died since...

 

•The full story of how Saddam exploited the United Nations "oil for food" program, not only to line his own pockets but also to rebuild Iraq's weapons and missile programs

I don't need to read a book on this. It was an open secret all across the Middle East. I was a consultant to a Tunisian company that sold steel plate to Iraq under that program.

 

"Secret history" is something of a contradiction in terms. If an investigator turns up something interesting, it will be sooner or later be integrated into everyone's narrative, once enough people have vetted it.

There was great confusion in American media between 9/11 and the invasion of Iraq. Contradictory reports in all directions. (Largely stoked by the misinformation coming from the Administration.) With a decade of perspective, there is no longer much doubt about what happened. We still don't understand "why"... 

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick  replied to  Bob Nelson   11 years ago

Bob like an expert who already knows everything he will ever know, you seem to be positioning yourself into that position here as well as I only told you it is a book you may be interested in checking out.  I don't believe everything I read or see these days either, but there are many claims in this book which can be verified.  Since I have read it and you haven't I think I would be more qualified to judge whether the book is good material to read.

Your comment about it shows your ignorance about many things in my opinion.  No offense to you personally as I am very ignorant about many things as well.  I've read the book and others to maybe help educate and enlighten myself. I was only suggesting it as a means to help you accomplish the same thing.

 
 
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   Spikegary  replied to  Bob Nelson   11 years ago

So, Kuwait should have just been given to Saddam as a prize for not de-stabilizing the ME?  That's kind of crazy too.  Besides torturing and raping his own citizens, what would have he decided to take after that?

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Spikegary   11 years ago

So, Kuwait should have just been given to Saddam as a prize for not de-stabilizing the ME?

Ummm... no...

You've got your Iraq wars mixed up. Repelling Saddam from Iraq was Bush I's war... along with just about every country in the world. That war had UN approval. France contributed the third-largest contingent. Even Syria contributed troops to the Coalition.

Bush I did not topple Saddam, though. That was not in his UN mandate. He crushed Saddam's army, removed the dictator's capacity to harm his neighbors... and then Mr Bush I brought our troops home. He did what was required, but did not engage in imperial folly. Mr Bush I has been regarded as a weakling by Rambo-wannabes ever since.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

American overreach blew the Middle East to smithereens,

Really? America is responsible for Shia/Sunni hatred and the fact that a large numbers of Muslims want to wipe Isreal off the map? 

Granted, the stability of 2009 has gone by the wayside, but the middle east has been a disaster for 50 years. 

Put a Canadian flag on the shoulder of your jacket next time. You'll see a difference.

Yes. The French are famous bigots. Thanks for the reminder. 

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Sean Treacy   11 years ago

Sean...

As I said previously, you really should read before writing...

America is responsible for Shia/Sunni hatred...

Of course not. I didn't say that. But America is directly responsible for removing Saddam, who had kept a lid on that boiling pot. 

 

Another example of your reading difficulties:

Put a Canadian flag on the shoulder of your jacket next time. You'll see a difference.

Yes. The French are famous bigots. Thanks for the reminder. 

Ummm... no. My words mean that the French probably see Canadians more favorably than Americans. That is not a commentary on the French, but on Americans. You could replace "French" here with "Germans" or "Spanish" or "Italians"... or "Brazilians" or "Argentines"... or "Japanese" or ... ... 

You get the idea, I think. Americans, having wrecked the Middle East, provoking turmoil across a quarter of the world... are not the most popular nationality...

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober  replied to  Bob Nelson   11 years ago

Americans, having wrecked the Middle East

Your fantasy life is rich & full ! Actually the real wrecking is happening now that the west has learned how to find petroleum without the old fashioned vertical drilling . The economies of many Arab countries is in tatters [as well as  Venezuela , Norway and Alaska] . But Arabs in their own colorful way have found a solution to their over-population and joblessness . It's called ISIL ...

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

Bob

Is it possible that the "wrecking" of the Middle Est has its origins in the imperialistic division of the region by the British and the French in the 3arly 20th century and the subsequent turmoil and trouble that eventually led to the rise of many of the current regimes (or worse) and independence for the countries of the region?

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Robert in Ohio   11 years ago

Is it possible that...

More than "possible". A certainty. 

The thing is, history is a flow, with no start and no end. The UK's total mismanagement of the Middle East certainly set the stage for Saddam Hussein. But the UK's mismanagement of the Middle East in no way obliged the US to bring Saddam down, removing the restraints that had held together the ethnic hodge-podge that is Iraq.

We could travel back further in the flow of history and say that the incompetence of the late Ottoman Empire set the stage for much of what followed, too.

It remains that if Mr Bush had not lied America into a useless war, the flow of history would have taken a different course, one that we will never know... but probably without such widespread, intense hatred of America, the foreign invader.

Oh, and... if the US had not overthrown Mossadegh in the 1950s and replaced him with the Shah, the flow of history in Iran would have been different.

There's a theme, here...

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

history would have taken a different course, one that we will never know...

You got to the subtle point I was making quickly

Saying the U.S. (Bush specifically) wrecked the middle east is hyperbole, speculation coupled with an inference of being able to see the future is events in the past were changed.

Point of fact is that if the U.S. had not become intensely involved in the middle east (beginning in the 1960's not during the Bush administration), things might very well have become much worse than they are today or perhaps they would have been better.

No factual assertion is possible, hyperbolic speculation is though.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick  replied to  Robert in Ohio   11 years ago

@robert-in-ohio :

history would have taken a different course, one that we will never know...

You got to the subtle point I was making quickly

Saying the U.S. (Bush specifically) wrecked the middle east is hyperbole, speculation coupled with an inference of being able to see the future is events in the past were changed.

Point of fact is that if the U.S. had not become intensely involved in the middle east (beginning in the 1960's not during the Bush administration), things might very well have become much worse than they are today or perhaps they would have been better.

No factual assertion is possible, hyperbolic speculation is though.

Bob doesn't need to be told anything.  He already knows it all, except he doesn't.  He stopped learning when the facts started contradicting his beliefs.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  sixpick   11 years ago

At least, Six...

I do not pretend to know what others think. I don't pretend to know that when you say "X", you actually mean "Y". If you say "X", then I take your word at face value unless or until it contradicts reality, or what you say elsewhere.

I do know some history. Factual stuff. Anybody can look it up. Anybody interested in reality, that is.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Robert in Ohio   11 years ago

I misplaced my response , Robert. Sorry 'bout that. confused

 

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    11 years ago

We don't agree, Robert .

Saying the U.S. (Bush specifically) wrecked the middle east is hyperbole, speculation coupled with an inference of being able to see the future is events in the past were changed.

No. It is not hyperbole. It is history . Whatever may have been his failings, Saddam ran a stable nation called Iraq. George Bush led (he was President , after all) an Administration that misrepresented (at best) or outright lied its way to an unnecessary war with Iraq. That is not speculation. It is historical fact. 

With the elimination of the (heavy) hand of Saddam, Iraq has gradually disintegrated into sectarian / ethnic blocs, with nutjob fanatics (ISIL) finding living space in the crevices between the big three, Shi'ite, Sunni, Kurd.  That is not speculation. It is historical fact. 

 

Point of fact is that if the U.S. had not become intensely involved in the middle east (beginning in the 1960's not during the Bush administration), things might very well have become much worse than they are today or perhaps they would have been better.

No. Not at all "point of fact  ". What might have happened had George Bush not instigated an invasion of Iraq... is pure speculation .

 

We know -- historical fact -- that Mr Bush's invasion of Iraq has blown the old order to smithereens, leaving chaos and fertile ground for fanatic terrorists.

We may speculate on what might have happened had Mr Bush not led America into this unending war. Your guess is as good as mine...

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick  replied to  Bob Nelson   11 years ago

@bob-nelson :

We may speculate on what might have happened had Mr Bush not led America into this unending war. Your guess is as good as mine...

In all honesty Bob, you don't know if his guess is as good as yours.  You don't know all the facts and you don't know if he does.

In getting rid of Gaddifi, was that the right thing to do?  I mean Libya is an anarchy now and had one of the highest living standards of living in the years before than any other country in the region.

Only by learning can one reduce his/her need for guesses and replace them with legitimate reasons.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  sixpick   11 years ago

I misplaced my  response , Six. Sorry 'bout that.  confused

... and that's twice in a row...  close call

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio  replied to  Bob Nelson   11 years ago

that Mr Bush's invasion of Iraq has blown the old order to smithereens, leaving chaos and fertile ground for fanatic terrorists

And fertile ground was begun long before the invasion by the cruelness of Saddam and the regime

You are still hyperbolizing and speculating

What call a point of fact is nothing but your opinion on what is happening and why - nothing more nothing less

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Robert in Ohio   11 years ago

Robert,

Saddam Hussein ruled Iraq for nearly a quarter-century (President, 16 July 1979 until 9 April 2003). There was no factional fighting. There were no havens for nutjob fanatics. (There was a nasty war with Iran... that did not spread... and in which we were Saddam's ally.) That is fact, Robert. Mr Bush blew that situation to smithereens. That is also fact.

Those statements are neither hyperbole nor speculation.

Twenty-five years of stability were blown away, and replaced by... what we have today. 

That is factual. If you refuse to recognize straightforward fact, then I have finished here.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell  replied to  Bob Nelson   11 years ago

Saddam Hussein tortured and or killed at least a couple hundred thousand of his own people. 

I knew some people from Iraq at the time of the first Gulf War. They despised Hussein and considered him a mass murderer. 

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  JohnRussell   11 years ago

I agree, John.

Saddam was a very nasty piece of work. The figures I've seen for deaths under his regime are pretty impressive: 300 000 to 500 000. Over twenty-five years.

Estimates of Iraqi dead since the American invasion range from 600 000 to a million. In fifteen years.

America beats Saddam! No contest...

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio  replied to  Bob Nelson   11 years ago

Bob

You are still presenting your opinion of the situation as "facts"

Your answers to me and then to John seem to contradict each other.

You cannot accurately state that things would have been better if Hussein was left unfettered in power, nor can I say that they would not have been because we do no and cannot know.

I respect that you have strong "opinions" on this and other issues, but you sometimes confuse your opinions (or the opinions of others with whom you agree) as facts rather than opinions.

I appreciate all the back and forth and the exchange of "opinions" on what might have been and what could have been

 

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Robert in Ohio   11 years ago

Robert,

You cannot accurately state that things would have been better if Hussein was left unfettered in power...

I did not say anything of the kind. I clearly said that we cannot know what would have happened in a different universe where Bush did not take down Saddam.

I said, and repeat, that before Bush took down Saddam, Iraq, and the Middle East more generally, was stable. After Bush took down Saddam, it all went to Hell. That is historical fact.

I suppose it is possible to imagine a scenario in which Saddam stays in power, and the Middle East looks even worse today... but I personally have a hard time seeing it.

 

I don't think my exchange with John contradicts what I have said to you. I have never said anything good about Saddam. He was a bloody dictator. But the numbers are clear: many more Iraqis have died, much faster, since America took Saddam down.

 

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio  replied to  Bob Nelson   11 years ago

Correlation does not equal causation and besides the middle east was terribly broken - on the road to destruction and spawning terrorist groups and dictatorial regimes long before Bush became president.

I was not a supporter of the invasion nor a big supporter of President Bush, but you present a simplistic application of your opinion as historical fact because others have said it, an opinion held by many is still an opinion

Again I appreciate the back and forth and respect your perspective on the miasma of the middle east

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Robert in Ohio   11 years ago

I have not spoken of causation. I have presented a time-line. Any conclusions you draw are your own...

I won't hide from the subject, though. My opinion is that it is safer to reduce pressure in a pressure cooker gradually, through the release valve, rather than ripping the lid off. My opinion is that many many thousands have died, who would not have died, because of Mr Bush's folly.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio  replied to  Bob Nelson   11 years ago

Nonsense

When you say

After Bush took down Saddam, it all went to Hell.

You are clearly implying direct causation whether you will admit it to yourself or others or not.

I believe we have reached an impasse on this point, so I will thank you for all the back and forth and look for something else to discuss.

See ya

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Robert in Ohio   11 years ago

Robert, 

"After Bush took Saddam down.. " is NOT the same as "Because Bush..." 

See ya 'round... 

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober  replied to  Bob Nelson   11 years ago

There was no factional fighting. There were no havens for nutjob fanatics.
....
Twenty-five years of stability were blown away, and replaced by... what we have today.

You're right Bob but your interpretation is done with blinders on . S. Hussein and his sons made up for all the factional fighting with a great many ruthless official murders and torture . If that's what you want to see for "stability" I prefer chaos . I'm sure the Kurds would agree with that .
As to what we have today , a lot of it is due to changes in the oil industry . OPEC countries have been devastated if they haven't had the foresight to diversify their economies . These include many Arab countries as well as Russia , Venezuela and even Norway .

Take off your blinders Bob . There are many bad actors on the world stage and S. Hussein was certainly one of them .

Estimates of Iraqi dead since the American invasion range from 600 000 to a million. In fifteen years.

These were due to Sunni vs Shia conflicts , not the US . Iraq would be better off split into at least 3 separate countries .

 

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Sixpick...

We may speculate on what might have happened had Mr Bush not led America into this unending war. Your guess is as good as mine...

In all honesty Bob, you don't know if his guess is as good as yours.  You don't know all the facts and you don't know if he does.

I am talking about "speculation". Imagining the future.

No one can predict the future with accuracy. We can imagine a trend from today wending its way forward... but some unpredictable incident may change everything. That's still the best we can do, I think.

For example... I think Iraq will be gone in the next five years. The three big blocs have little reason to stay together.

If Iraq dissolves, then we must hope that the resulting new countries are smart enough to understand that they should above all eliminate the chaos-makers: ISIL and the other loose canons. That's the only hopeful scenario I see as possible. 

Obviously, it is easy to construct other scenarios that are much grimmer. If the new countries to come waste their energy fighting each other, or other neighbors (Kurds / Turkey, for example), then the chaos will continue and ISIL will prosper.

Your guess is as good as mine...  peace

 

 
 

Who is online

Gazoo
Hal A. Lujah


83 visitors