Insane Florida Judge Removed After Attacking Attorney In Courtroom
On Thursday, the Florida Supreme Court announced the removal of Brovard County Judge John C. Murphy. The decision marks only the seventh time that the state’s Supreme Court has removed a judge from the bench, over the last 15 years.
The Florida Supreme Court reached the decision after viewing video which was captured inside the Judge’s Brovard County courtroom last year.
The video shows that Murphy was outraged over the public defender’s refusal to waive his client’s right to a speedy trial.
The judge asks, “What do you want to do?”
name="zd_async_tagframe_z68a1dc50-092b-4cf4-987e-f6c68cdd0a2e" frameborder="0">
The public defender responded by saying, “I’m not waiving. If you want to set it for trial, set it for trial.”
The judge then loses it, saying, “You know, if I had a rock I’d throw it at you right now.” He then shouts, “Stop pissing me off,” before telling the attorney to “Just sit down! I don’t need your help. I’ll take care of it.”
Public defender Andrew Weinstock responds .”You know I’m the public defender. I have a right to be here and I have a right to stand and represent my client.”
A moment later the judge shouts, “If you want to fight, let’s go out back and I’ll just beat your ass.”
According to Weinstock, he followed the judge into the hallway at that point, thinking that he wanted to speak to him outside of the courtroom. He says that instead of a discussion, the judge grabbed him and began punching him.
At this point in the video, the two men are off-camera. The sound of the altercation can clearly be heard on the audio. The judge can be heard screaming from off camera, “Do you want to fuck with me?! Do ya?!”
Immediately after the incident, the judge returned to the courtroom , and continued to process criminal defendants, without a public defender present.
Shortly after, he took a month-long leave of absence,with pay and signed up for anger management classes. He was back on the bench within four weeks of threatening and assaulting an attorney, in an open courtroom, with the support of local officials .
Upon Murphy’s return to the bench, Weinstock resigned his position with the county public defender’s office, writing that he strongly disagreed with the decision to allow the judge back on the bench.
The incident was reviewed by the Florida Judicial Qualifications Commission (JCQ), an independent disciplinary body that investigates complaints of judicial misconduct. The Commission makes recommendations to the Florida Supreme Court.
After reviewing the evidence in the case, the JCQ recommended a four month suspension and $50,000 in fines.
In October, the state Supreme Court suspended Murphy without pay, giving him 20 days to show why he should not be removed from the bench.
Although Murphy claims to have PTSD from years of service in the US military, his statements were not backed up by a physician.
On December 17, the Florida Supreme Court removed Murphy from the bench for good. The court issued a 22 page report, finding him unfit to hold office.
“Because of Judge Murphy’s appalling behavior, we conclude that there is clear and convincing evidence that Judge Murphy engaged in ‘conduct unbecoming a member of the judiciary demonstrating a present unfitness to hold office.”

There's crazy people in every aspect of life, though they are a very small percentage, thank God. Sounds like they did the right thing in removing him, though criminal charges for assault and battery it seems should have been filed.
Surprisingly, in some areas, you can be elected as a magistrate even though you may not have any legal experience. Seems like there should be some minimum qualifications before one could even run for that office.
Dear Friends Spikegary and jwc2blue: I agree with each and every one of your points.
Judges are among the last in American society who are basically not answerable to anyone. Without the checks and balances built in to our system of government at every level in each of the three branches trouble is inevitable.
Power corrupts. Absolute power corrupts absolutely.
Spikegary's recommendation is very much of value and on-point here. There need to be minimum qualifications, beyond election and appointment for many roles in society. Judges, coroners, and heads of departments where the greater good is either enhanced or at risk are in play.
The legal definition of a profession is that the State (government at any level) has the right and responsibility to require satisfaction of accredited training programs for issuance of registrations, license, permits, etc. Without those no one may practice a profession. This already applies to such diverse substantial gainful workplace activities as lawyers, medical practitioners, those who do tattoos, nails, security guards, accountants, financial planners, sales people in real estate, stocks bonds, mutual funds etc. In New York State where I reside, there are over seventy careers which require accredited training, passing of exams and government certification of some sort or another.
If society can be hurt or helped, someone has to train and objectively, non-politically regulate and supervise those who perform such functions. Judges put people in prison or keep them on the streets. They in some cases make life or death decisions in capital crimes.
The political self-advocacy skill sets which get people elected and/or appointed to the bench are very different kinds of talents than what are required to fairly, objectively, appropriately, consistently and correctly adjudicate the law in civil and criminal judicial proceedings.
Good work by both of you here. Well done.
Peace, Abundant Blessings, and Justice, Justice Shall You Pursue.
Enoch.
There are bad apples just like in the private sector
Surely you jest, the private sector is perfect. s.
Florida? You don't say! Hardly anything crazy ever happens in Florida. (/s)
Where's Petey, to threaten me with posting a cache of evidence that Maryland is where the crazies are?
Red Box Rules, Hal.