'It's Just Ridiculous': Bakery Fined $135K for Refusing to Serve Gay Wedding
The Christian owners of an Oregon bakery are facing a hefty fine after refusing to bake a cake for a lesbian wedding.A complaint against Sweet Cakes By Melissa was filed after the owners, Aaron and Melissa Klein, turned away a lesbian couple who requested a wedding cake in 2013.The state ruled that the owners were discriminating against the couple based on their sexual orientation.Fox News reported that the state has now ordered the Kleins to pay $135,000 in damages to the lesbian couple and issued a gag order, which bans them from "speaking publicly about their refusal to participate in or bake wedding cakes for same-sex unions."The couple told Sean Hannity tonight that they think the state of Oregon has violated their First Amendment rights."The state of Oregon violated our First Amendment rights, not only in the freedom of religion, but also the freedom of speech in this case," Aaron Klein said.He explained they decided not to bake the cake for the lesbian couple because of their religious beliefs.Melissa Klein added that they "are absolutely going to appeal this decision.""But, honestly its just ridiculous," she said. "$135,000 for politely telling somebody, Im sorry, I cant basically participate in your event. Its mind blowing." http://insider.foxnews.com/2015/07/07/bakery-owners-fined-135000-refusing-make-gay-wedding-cake
Tags
Who is online
72 visitors

I don't understand the gag ruling at all. The entire thing seems ridiculous as is, but the order not to talk about it screams counter lawsuit...
Sounds like a malicious prosecution by the state of Or.
My understanding of what a Gag order is , and what it is used for, simply does not fit the description of this case. So I am researching, and wondering after reading a handful of articles, if there was indeed actually a Gag Order involved....
I don't see how the state can lawfully prohibit private citizens from speaking nor do I see how people can expect to serve the public based on freedom of religion. This is an unnecessary collision between freedom of religion and non-discriminatory service that a store can expect to lose. Countersue the state for violation of freedom of speech for $150,000 and then settle this matter out of court (promising not to refuse service in the future which, I assume, is what the state is really after).
Honestly, this couple is just baking a cake, not hiring an open homosexual to teach in a catholic boys school. Rather than refuse to bake a cake, post biblical anti-same sex passages in the store. Put free bible quotations in all cake boxes. Tell them them same sex marriage is the work of the devil . . . write it on all the cake boxes . . . but bake the cake.
It does seem incredible. I have a hard time believing that any court would do that.
So it's okay for a corporation with friends in high places to refuse to offer to pay for birth control pills for its employees because of its religious convictions, but it's not okay for a small family owned one store only bakery to politely refuse to bake a cake because of religious convictions?
What a crock of bovine feces!
Go to another damn bakery? Was this the only one in town? Or was this the only one in town that everyone knew was run by religious owners, and the couple deliberately went there to create an "incident" either to force them to bake the cake for personal satisfaction or because they wanted the lawsuit?
I believe they have the right to their cake, and if it was the only bakery in town, that's one thing. If it wasn't, that's something else. If Americans don't start re-learning the art of compromise in daily living we are going to drown in each other's hatred, staring over the lines drawn in the sand.
Interesting hypothetical ...
What does that have to do with the subject of this seed ?
If the state has a law saying that a public business can't refuse to do business with customers because they object to those customer's sexual orientation, then they should have lost the case. Good decision. That's the same as refusing to do business with customers because of their race.
Let me be more specific since you are being evasive . Your above meaningless distraction has NOTHING to do with the subject . In logic what you did is called a "red herring" and it stinks .
Where is this factor : "a specialty cake that says F Jesus" ?
You seem to be missing the perception of how the baker viewed the gay wedding as not a wedding . He/she would not make a wedding cake for someone not actually getting married [in their perception ] .
According to you and maybe SCOTUS but not according to the baker and many others with that belief system .
According to you and maybe SCOTUS but not according to the baker and many others with that belief system ."
If they think it's all about their perception, then they will lose. You cannot sit back and allow homosexuality or same sex-marriage to become a civil right and then argue that you have an unfettered first amendment right to openly discriminate against them. You can resist but as I tried to explain, it's limited.
Sitting in judgment on the couple was bad enough. Making that judgment knownwas worse.
They could have avoided the falderal by stating that theyhad over-committed themselvesduring the time that the couple would need the cake. They could have said that they were planning to temporarily close the bakery for upgradesor repairs. They could have given the couple the names ofotherbakeries in the area who might be available to better serve their needs. This fine, upstanding, Christian couple had several less humiliating and non-discriminatory options thatthey could haveutilized in an effort to maintain their personal beliefs and values. How sad that they chose the least Christian of all of them.
And this:
...makes me sick. Thereis nothing polite about telling someone that they aren't worthy enough to serve.
As a business owner, you are, by law, allowed to "refuse service to anyone for any reason."
Being gay does not give you special rights, so they can cry and boo-hoo all they want.
The business owner is in control - not the customer. The bakery is not Burger King.
As you note, it's kind of hard to inoffensively state that you find someone offensive. This couple was clearly trying to make a statement that they find same sex marriage so immoral that they cannot in good conscience bake a cake for the event. If they feel compelled to tell their customers that they find gay marriage morally repugnant, then they have a first amendment right to express their opinion and they can do it without denying service. If they want to be inoffensive but deny service, then they should have done as you suggest.
Stores may place thisstatementon a sign but placing it on a sign does notimmunizethe owner from a lawsuit based on discrimination. The Federal Civil Rights Act of 1964 prohibitsprivately owned places of public accommodation from discriminating based on race, color, religion, national origin. Publicaccommodationincludes hotels, restrooms,theaters,banks, health clubs, and stores. Homosexuals are notcoveredin thefederallaw but localjurisdictionsofteninclude sexualorientationas a protected class. If homosexuals are covered, then they can demand to be served in a place of publicaccommodation.
Oops, I almost forgot...
It seems thatAaron Klein needs a lesson on how to walk it before he talks it.
Here's a verse for you, Mr. Klein:
1 Corinthians 6:10 - Nor thieves, nor covetous, nor drunkards, nor revilers, nor extortioners, shall inherit the kingdom of God.
"race, color, religion, national origin"
Don't see "Sexual orientation" in this list, and local jurisdiction does not include it for the general public but does for city government - It is the policy of the City of Portland to eliminate discrimination based on race, religion, color, sex, marital status, familial status, national origin, age, mental or physical disability, sexual orientation, gender identity or source of income.
It wasn't the wedding cake that was the problem, it was the writing on the cake and, I assume, the cake topper that they had a problem with.
If it's covered by the city, then it's covered and people can't be discriminated against based on sexual orientation. So the bakery has to provide service whether they like it or not.
You've got to love hypocrisy.
Also interesting:
The entire article is worth a read, but I couldn't resistdrawing attention tothe Josh Duggar/Family Research Council angle.
1st, I think the part your looking for is under the " Public Accommodations " section of Oregon's anti-discrimination law.
Chapter 659A Unlawful Discrimination in Employment, Public Accommodations and Real Property Transactions; Administrative and Civil Enforcement
This public bakery broke Oregon's law against aspecific type of bigotry.
As for the so called "gag order", well it seems that Oregon also has a specific law against publicly announcing, or publishing statements thatyour business is going to break the law and spit on any fellow citizenyou happen to deem "second class", or as the original complaint noted, you consider them"abominations unto the lord".
No there was no Gag Order. It was perceived as such, and so was called that erroneously.
Now that at least makes more sense.
Turnabout is fair play. Christians should locate pro gay bakers and order cakes that say "gay marriage is an abomination" or "God created created Adam and Eve, not Adam and Steve." If the bakery refuses, then file the same sort of complaint as was filed here and demand that the rule of law be equally enforced.
ather than refuse to bake a cake, post biblical anti-same sex passages in the store. Put free bible quotations in all cake boxes. Tell them them same sex marriage is the work of the devil . . . write it on all the cake boxes . . . but bake the cake.
Instead of being a hyper litigious society in which small business owners to consult first amendment lawyers in order to do business, perhaps it makes more sense to carry on as we have for hundred of years of years and simply let people have the choice to not participate in religious ceremonies that they object to.
What was the special part? Was there nudity involved? Or was it just a standard type wedding cake? If it was, they discriminated and deserve the fine.
No.
It's not.
He wanted her to do a porn cake, (ideological porn), she doesn't do porn cakes for any of her customers. If she did such cakes for others but refused to do the same for him just because of who he was, Then he might have had a case and you might of had a point.