Why Hillary Clinton's legal woes are grave or even fatal: A tale of two smoking guns
The federal criminal investigation of former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton’s failure to secure state secrets was ratcheted up earlier this week, and at the same time, the existence of a parallel criminal investigation of another aspect of her behavior was made known. This is the second publicly revealed expansion of the FBI’s investigations in two months.
I have argued for two months that Clinton’s legal woes are either grave or worse than grave. That argument has been based on the hard, now public evidence of her failure to safeguard national security secrets and the known manner in which the Department of Justice addresses these failures.
The failure to safeguard state secrets is an area of the law in which the federal government has been aggressive to the point of being merciless. State secrets are the product of members of the intelligence community's risking their lives to obtain information.
Before she was entrusted with any state secrets -- indeed, on her first full day as secretary of state -- Clinton received instruction from FBI agents on how to safeguard them; and she signed an oath swearing to comply with the laws commanding the safekeeping of these secrets. She was warned that the failure to safeguard secrets -- known as espionage -- would most likely result in aggressive prosecution.
In the cases of others, those threats have been carried out. The Obama Department of Justice prosecuted a young sailor for espionage for sending a selfie to his girlfriend, because in the background of the photo was a view of a sonar screen on a submarine. It prosecuted a heroic Marine for espionage for warning his superiors of the presence of an Al Qaeda operative in police garb inside an American encampment in Afghanistan, because he used a Gmail account to send the warning.
It also prosecuted Gen. David Petraeus for espionage for keeping secret and top-secret documents in an unlocked drawer in his desk inside his guarded home. It alleged that he shared those secrets with a friend who also had a security clearance, but it dropped those charges.
The obligation of those to whom state secrets have been entrusted to safeguard them is a rare area in which federal criminal prosecutions can be based on the defendant’s negligence. Stated differently, to prosecute Clinton for espionage, the government need not prove that she intended to expose the secrets.
The evidence of Clinton’s negligence is overwhelming. The FBI now has more than 1,300 protected emails that she received on her insecure server and sent to others -- some to their insecure servers. These emails contained confidential, secret or top-secret information, the negligent exposure of which is a criminal act.
One of the top-secret emails she received and forwarded contained a photo taken from an American satellite of the North Korean nuclear facility that detonated a device just last week. Because Clinton failed to safeguard that email, she exposed to hackers and thus to the North Koreans the time, place and manner of American surveillance of them. This type of data is in the highest category of protected secrets.
Last weekend, the State Department released two smoking guns -- each an email from Clinton to a State Department subordinate. One instructed a subordinate who was having difficulty getting a document to Clinton that she had not seen by using a secure State Department fax machine to use an insecure fax machine. The other instructed another subordinate to remove the “confidential” or “secret” designation from a document Clinton had not seen before sending it to her. These two emails show a pattern of behavior utterly heedless of the profound responsibilities of the secretary of state, repugnant to her sworn agreement to safeguard state secrets, and criminal at their essence.
Also this past weekend, my Fox News colleagues Catherine Herridge and Pamela Browne learned from government sources that the FBI is investigating whether Clinton made any decisions as secretary of state to benefit her family foundation or her husband’s speaking engagements. If so, this would be profound public corruption.
This investigation was probably provoked by several teams of independent researchers -- some of whom are financial experts and have published their work -- who have been investigating the Clinton Foundation for a few years. They have amassed a treasure-trove of documents demonstrating fraud and irregularities in fundraising and expenditures, and they have shown a pattern of favorable State Department treatment of foreign entities coinciding with donations by those entities to the Clinton Foundation and their engaging former President Bill Clinton to give speeches.
There are now more than 100 FBI agents investigating Hillary Clinton. Her denial that she is at the core of their work is political claptrap with no connection to reality. It is inconceivable that the FBI would send such vast resources in the present dangerous era on a wild-goose chase.
It is the consensus of many of us who monitor government behavior that the FBI will recommend indictment. That recommendation will go to Attorney General Loretta Lynch, who, given Clinton’s former status in the government and current status in the Democratic Party, will no doubt consult the White House.
If a federal grand jury were to indict Clinton for espionage or corruption, that would be fatal to her political career.
If the FBI recommends indictment and the attorney general declines to do so, expect Saturday Night Massacre-like leaks of draft indictments, whistleblower revelations and litigation, and FBI resignations, led by the fiercely independent and intellectually honest FBI Director James Comey himself.
That would be fatal to Clinton’s political career, as well.
Andrew P. Napolitano, a former judge of the Superior Court of New Jersey, is the senior judicial analyst at Fox News Channel.

RBR: Stay on topic. The topic is Hillary, and the Democratic Candidates.
She's toast. And the Dems are starting to realize that. I read earlier this week that the DNC is working plans to add Biden or Warren to the mix.
I agree that this will be more than Clinton can overcome. Time is runnin' short to get into the mix, but the DNC had better start doing something or Sanders is going to be their candidate.
B but Bruce, people like toast...
They (FBI) knew when she was a Senator of NY that she was a liar, cheat, thief, etc... - yet, she got the SOS job.
I accept that all politicians have a problem with integrity. But in the case of Hillary, she is blatant in her lying. And it boggles my mind that so many still support her, and give her a pass on her lack integrity
Huff……….(exhales forcefully causing bangs to flutter). I have a hard time taking FOX News, MSNBC or CNN serious with the information they’ve received from “sources”. I just don’t believe much of anything that they report…..(sigh). These networks have agenda’s and they are used as tools to spout propaganda.
Bruce, you wanted me off the fence so watch out below – I’m jumping!
I don’t know too much regarding the incident involving the lower level military personnel so I won’t comment on that portion of the article. The section that addresses Gen. David Petraeus is lacking some critical information. To put it in a gentler way, Gen. David Petraeus took those top secret little books out of his drawer and put them in the night stand next to that big ole bed wherein laid the mistress (cough) I mean his “Biographer”.
There are many incidents that can be pointed at regarding treasonous acts from and during the previous administration that has gone without punishment but for time sake and because those horses have been beaten to death I’ll not revive them merely to beat them to death again.
I’m not going to discuss Benghazi because there have been no new findings and for me the issue is closed.
I believe there has been some wrong doing on Hilary Clinton’s part; exactly what hasn’t been determined. As the article suggests, it is an ongoing investigation so I think it’s premature to come to any final conclusions or to proclaim what charges (if any) should be leveled against Mrs. Clinton. The article strikes me as an opinion piece and nothing more.
This is apropos to nothing but I liked the little walking man that shouted “You Mad”. I vote you bring him back.
Look, let's be blunt.
Bruce, produce this "information" AND conclusion from something other than a right wing crank source.
Sorry, Andrew Napolitano is a crank , conspiracy theorist and rwnj who is totally unreliable as a source for a story like this.
You people just keep regurgitating the same couple of questionable items over and over again. This is so similar to "Benghazi", it is almost eerie. The same exact right wing "experts" were predicting Clinton's , and Obama's downfall over Benghazi, some of the nuttiest still do.
Some of them predicted a Romney landslide the day of the 2012 election.
You guys have a track record of going in the wrong direction.
Hillary Clinton will not be indicted. If she was, it would have happened already.
Bruce, produce this story from credible sources or blow it out your ear.
John - tell us how you really feel and stop beating around the bush! /s
:0)
You know, that's a pretty clever way of dismissing this John. What do you consider credible? MSNBC? CNN? Do you think any of YOUR sources are going to run with something that is critical of Hillary?
Andrew Napolitano believes the US government blew up the Twin Towers in NY. He is a 9-11 truther.
What credibility does that give him to be considered a source on other government conspiracies ? NONE.
John. This article is about Hillary. Not 9-11.
You don't have a credible source HERE. Go find one.
Credible source for what John? It's an opinion piece. Ovbiously, you don't agree with his opinion.
Bruce,
Gotta agree with PJ. I am not a big Hillary fan, but they have been pretty much relentless in investigating her, and have pretty much turned up nothing indictable yet. This kind of feels a lot like "Whitewater". Years of investigation and millions spent to show minor improprieties, that would probably show up on any career politician.
On going investigation Perrie. And I dispute your claim that they have turned up nothing. We KNOW that she discussed classified information, that she KNEW was classified, using unsecure communications media. THAT is a violation.
Additionally, she or her staff tried to hide/destroy evidence by wiping the personal e-mail server. No one wipes a server unless it's being replaced.......
Gary,
Like I said, I am not denying her lack of integrity in this whole affair, but it still doesn't mean that it is an offense. They are two different things.
No one wipes a server unless it's being replaced.......
Oh, I don't know …
The Bush White House email controversy surfaced in 2007 during the controversy involving the dismissal of eight U.S. attorneys . Congressional requests for administration documents while investigating the dismissals of the U.S. attorneys required the Bush administration to reveal that not all internal White House emails were available, because they were sent via a non-government domain hosted on an email server not controlled by the federal government.
Conducting governmental business in this manner is a possible violation of the Presidential Records Act of 1978, and the Hatch Act . [1] Over 5 million emails may have been lost. [2] [3] Greg Palast claims to have come up with 500 of the Karl Rove emails, leading to damaging allegations. [4] In 2009, it was announced that as many as 22 million emails may have been lost. [5]
I didn't raise this … I just responded.
I've pointed out before to you that all 22 million emails were recovered.
There's also no evidence they were intentionally deleted.
I've pointed out before to you that all 22 million emails were recovered.
There's also no evidence they were intentionally deleted.
Records released as a result of the lawsuits reveal that the Bush White House was aware during the president's first term in office that the e-mail system had serious archiving problems, which didn't become publicly known until 2006, when federal prosecutor Patrick Fitzgerald disclosed them during his criminal investigation of the outing of CIA operative Valerie Plame.
But beyond that, deleted e-mails, intentional or otherwise and other files are sometimes recoverable by computer forensics techniques and software. That deleted files have been recovered does not necessarily mean those files were "accidentally" trashed.
Given the time frame of the "lost" Bush e-mails, an argument could be made that the "loss" may have been intentional and politically-motivated.
Not all deleted data is recoverable … it depends on how the deletions are made.
Karl Rove was sweating out whether he would be indicted. He wasn't, some say because there as a Republican AG at the time.
There is a political aspect to any high level investigation. You have to have a slam dunk case to indict White House or cabinet level personnel. Given the strong likelihood that mishandling of classified information has been going on in government for decades, the strength of argument against Clinton just won't be there.
But there is a more important reason she won't be indicted. - Her political enemies want it too damn much. The legal system is not going to reward a witch hunt.
All emails in the system were lost. Not from one person or two people. It was a system wide failure. There is zero evidence that the archiving system was tampered with or manipulated. Nor is there any evidence that all emails were not recovered. Of course, anyone can claim "incriminating" emails were destroyed because it's impossible to prove a negative. I could claim that Hillary destroyed emails to Al-Queda in Libya telling them 9/11 would be a great day to attack Benghazi and you can't offer 100% proof that she didn't.
As you say, those special interest groups that sued the White House claimed 22 million emails were "lost" and 22 million emails were eventually found and turned over.
There is zero evidence that the archiving system was tampered with or manipulated.
Nor is there any evidence that all emails were not recovered.
That's irrelevant since deletions can appear to be gone from a hard drive actually while remaining and, being recoverable.
Of course, anyone can claim "incriminating" emails were destroyed because it's impossible to prove a negative. I could claim that Hillary destroyed emails to Al-Queda in Libya telling them 9/11 would be a great day to attack Benghazi and you can't offer 100% proof that she didn't.
Well then, you just lost your own argument.
No one wipes a server unless it's being replaced.......
Speculative your Honor.
And yet this has been going on for what... 2 years and still no indictment. Yes, she was not exactly forthcoming and yes, poor judgment... but there has to be proof of some sort of offense... which they obviously don't think they can prove yet.
The investigation into Petraus began in 2012. Recomendations for charges were not made until 2015.
The year's not over yet.
nd yet this has been going on for what... 2 years a
The FBI received the referral on the classified emails this summer and stepped up the probe this fall after concluding their initial fact finding.
They began investigating her for public corruption in April.
But your mistake shows how reality can be distorted by spin. Clinton supporters constantly emphasize the length or cost of an investigation while ignoring the substance. Meanwhile, the Clinton's do everything possible to stonewall and lengthen the investigation.
The perception is created that the investigation is "old news" before the investigation can be completed, because voters have short attention spans and don't pay attention. Manipulating voters into "scandal fatigue" is what the Clintons do best.
The perception is created that the investigation is "old news" before the investigation can be completed, because voters have short attention spans and don't pay attention. Manipulating voters into "scandal fatigue" is what the Clintons do best.
Now, all that remains for you to do, Sean, to nail down your case, is provide the details of any indictments, trials and convictions and you're home free.
Otherwise … Manipulating voters into "scandal fatigue" is what the Clintons do best … is your political demagoguery du jour … it ma be true, it may be your opinion … but possibly the "fatigue" to which you refer is a product of endless right-wing rants like the one I quoted above.
Sometimes we get caught up in our own noise.
1,300 + plus emails with classified information stored on a private server in the bathroom of a condo in Colorado at her direction is pretty much nothing in your view? What do you think would happen to someone who wasn't a Clinton who treated classified information like that?
As for Whitewater, I invite you and anyone who doesn't understand her role in the Ponzi scheme to read the whole link. HRC, no surprise, stole documents from the Rose Law Firm that demonstrated she lied to federal investigators about her involvement. Indictments for Hillary for prejury were drawn up but ultimately nor acted upon. This is great explanation of a complex matter:
As a result of the meeting, McDougal retained the Rose law firm to do the legal work associated with a venture called Castle Grande. The firm performed this work in 1985 and 1986.
In addition to Madison Guaranty, Rose represented Seth Ward, an employee of Madison and the father-in-law of Webster Hubbell. Hubbell was Hillary’s law partner and friend, and later the associate attorney general of the United States in the Clinton administration. Hubbell worked with Clinton on the Castle Grande matter.
Mr. Ponzi, call your office
The Castle Grande project was a scheme to commit fraud through real estate loans. It was basically a pyramid scheme that used a series of loans to enrich Madison insiders. Madison was, in effect, McDougal’s personal piggy-bank.
The land in question was a scrub pine forest that previously had failed as an industrial development project. The sales price of the property was $1.75 million.
State regulations prohibited McDougal from investing more than 6 percent of Madison’s S&L assets. McDougal therefore put up $600,000 of Madison’s money. Seth Ward put up the remaining $1.15 million.
Ward borrowed the money from Madison on non-recourse, no personal obligation to repay basis. If federal regulators found out about this circumvention, Madison could be shut down.
The land appraiser for the property inflated his appraisals to support loans to purchasers, including future Arkansas governor Jim Guy Tucker who bought a water and sewer system for the Castle Grande project. The appraiser later pleaded guilty to federal conspiracy charges.
David Hale, head of an outfit licensed to provide lending to minorities and the economically disadvantaged, conspired with McDougal and Tucker to use his operation as a pass-through to generate additional loans from Madison. A friend and business associate of Hale’s borrowed $825,000 from Madison to buy three properties from Hale. But he never used the money. Instead, it went to Hale, who used it to recapitalize his company with matching funds from the Small Business Administration.
Hale loaned a $150,000 down payment to Tucker who bought out a portion of Ward’s Castle Grande holdings for $1.2 million. Tucker borrowed the additional $1.05 million from Madison.
McDougal loaned former Senator William Fulbright, a long-time friend, $700,000 to buy out the bulk of Ward’s remaining holdings. The net effect was to remove Ward’s non-recourse loan from the Madison books and generate substantial sales profits and commissions for Madison.
Through various “cross-loans,” McDougal hoped to prevent regulators from discovering Ward’s true role, and thus Madison’s full investment, in Castle Grande. But federal regulators weren’t deceived. In 1986, they removed McDougal from Madison Guaranty.
Eventually, the FBI was called. Federal prosecutors ultimately convicted 14 individuals, including McDougal and Tucker (by then the sitting governor of Arkansas). But this occurred years later, after Bill Clinton had been elected president.
Will the Bloom Come Off the Rose?
By 1991, Bill Clinton was running for president. Like his other Democratic rivals, he campaigned against the “decade of greed” that had brought us the S&L scandals.
Fortunately for his campaign, Hillary’s involvement in the Madison scandal had remained obscure. In fact, when the Resolution Trust Corporation, a temporary federal agency created to resolve the S&L crisis, wanted to sue the accounting firm that had handled Castle Grande, it hired Rose (in the person of Hubbell) to bring the lawsuit. Hubbell never disclosed the obvious conflict that stemmed from his firm’s work on Castle Grande; nor did he reveal the fact that Rose performed work on this matter in 1985 and 1986.
Castle Grande seemed to be behind Hillary and Hubbell when a New York Times reporter named Jeff Gerth arrived in Little Rock and started asking questions. Some of his questions pertained to Hillary’s involvement with McDougal.
The Lady’s Records Vanish
By this time, the Clinton campaign already believed it had two strikes against it: Gennifer Flowers/”bimbo eruptions” and Bill’s draft dodging/disrespect for the military. Clinton involvement in the S&L scandal felt like strike three.
Hillary contacted Vince Foster. Foster had not been involved in the Castle Grande representation, but he was Hillary’ mentor and trusted adviser — so trusted that he would eventually come with the Clintons to Washington, where he served as second in command in the Office of White Counsel the unit that, among other things, tries to put out fires involving the president.
Foster and Hubbell sprung into action. They printed out all billing records pertaining to Castle Grande and removed them from the Rose law firm, whose property they were. Foster and Hubbell also collected all files pertaining to the representation — sweeping from office to office to demand the files — and removed them from the premises. And Hillary Clinton’s time sheets disappeared.
As for the electronic version of the billing records, they were erased. The FBI’s forensic team was unable to reconstruct them.
Hillary told Gerth that an Rose associate, Rick Massey, had done all of the work on the McDougal project. With the billing records and time sheets gone, she could feel comfortable telling this lie, which she would repeat to others in the media.
It sufficed. Castle Grande/Whitewater was a non-issue in the 1992 presidential campaign.
Guess What I Found
Federal prosecutors remained on the trail, however. Eventually, over Hillary’s objections, the administration agreed to the appointment of a special counsel to investigate “Whitewater.”
In 1994, the Castle Grande billing records were subpoenaed. They were not produced at that time.
A year and a half later, Carolyn Huber, a White House employee, found the billing records in the private quarters of the first family, right outside Mrs. Clinton’s private office. Huber said that, not knowing what they were, she packed them up and took them to her own office. Only later, in early 1996, did she realize that these were the famous billing records that prosecutors were after.
The billing records were then produced, two years late. Hillary’s fingerprints were on them.
T he records show that Clinton billed time for work on Castle Grande, and was the billing partner for this representation. More than that, they show that she and/or Hubbell performed legal services — described, for example, as “conference with Seth Ward” or just “Seth Ward” — on every day in which federal prosecutors had found that McDougal and/or his cronies had committed an act in furtherance of their unlawful conspiracy e.g., backdating documents and making phony loans.
In effect, the billing records place Clinton and Hubbell at the scene of the crime.
Crime and Punishment, of some
The special counsel indicted Hubbell for fraud against federal regulators. You can read the indictment here . The fraud consisted, in essence, of concealing from federal agents and investigators the true role of Hubbell, the Rose law firm, and Hillary Clinton in Castle Grande.
Out of respect for the White House, the indictment refers to Hillary only as “Rose’s 1985-86 billing partner.” As such, Hillary appears throughout the indictment. She is referred to approximately three dozen times.
Hillary Clinton was slated to be called as a witness at Hubbell’s trial. Her attorney met with lawyers from the special counsel’s office to try to persuade them that the charges had nothing to do with Hillary. This absurd claim was rejected. The very next morning, Hubbell’s lawyer informed the special counsel that he would plead guilty.
Basic Instinct
Throughout the Whitewater/Castle Grande scandal, Hillary Clinton’s instinct was to stonewall and deceive. She lied about her role, removed and destroyed documents, and opposed the appointment of a special counsel.
From Hillary’s perspectives, her instincts were spot on. Absent the special counsel, much unpleasantness, including the Monica Lewinsky matter and the impeachment, might well have been avoided. And had Clinton been forthcoming about her role in Castle Grande, her husband’s 1992 campaign might have been derailed.
The current email scandal isn’t just a replay of the Castle Grande document theft and destruction. It is a logical outgrowth of it. Her basic instinct having been reinforced in the 1990s, it’s natural that they carry the day now.
That's hilarious Sean, bolster your weak present case with a flood of weak evidence from previous cases and incarnations.
You are such a dazzling debater ! s.
As a Chicago democrat, it's no wonder you support HRC so blindly. Lying, ripping off taxpayers for private gain, cronyism, obstructing independent investigations and supporting separate laws for the rich and powerful is what Chicago Democrats do. Hell, if she can figure out a way to build interstates across the country to keep blacks isolated in ghettos, she'd be the perfect Chicago Democratic politician.
As a Chicago democrat, it's no wonder you support HRC so blindly.
Wow! You really support the premise!
Not.
Learn the difference between pronouncements and making viable arguments, Sean.
Well, when someone makes a substance free response to one of my posts, I'm required to make "viable arguments."
Going forward if I respond thusly:
FACT: Chicago Democrats are corrupt
Does that make it a viable argument? I didn't realize putting FACT before opinions or falsehoods magically turns debatable opinions into a"viable argument"
As a Chicago democrat, it's no wonder you support HRC so blindly. Lying, ripping off taxpayers for private gain, cronyism, obstructing independent investigations and supporting separate laws for the rich and powerful is what Chicago Democrats do. Hell, if she can figure out a way to build interstates across the country to keep blacks isolated in ghettos, she'd be the perfect Chicago Democratic politician.
Well, when someone makes a substance free response to one of my posts, I'm required to make "viable arguments."
All one needs to do is validate the allegations … it's referred to as satisfying the "burden of proof."
And the portion of your quote in red … is that a "viable" response?
Going forward if I respond thusly:
FACT: Chicago Democrats are corrupt
Does that make it a viable argument? I didn't realize putting FACT before opinions or falsehoods magically turns debatable opinions into a"viable argument"
It's a fact that some, possibly many Chicago Democrats are corrupt … no argument from me … but if you imply that they're ALL corrupt, that's not a viable response either. If you tell me where you live … just the state will do, I'll likely be able to cite a politician or two … Republicans only of course … who are also corrupt.
A "viable" argument can be made even in response to flawed opinions and falsehoods, in fact, the more bogus they are, the easier it is to show the "truths" and thus be "Mr. Viable."
Again, Sean … just cite the indictments, trials and convictions and you've made your case.
FACT: There Is No Evidence That Clinton Personally Signed Off On A Cable Reducing Security In Benghazi
FACT: The State Department Did Not Watch The Benghazi Attacks Unfold In Real Time
FACT: Hillary Clinton Was Not Unaccounted For During The Attacks, She Was In Continuous Contact With Administration Officials
FACT: Contrary To Conservative Conspiracies, Clinton Missed A Scheduled Benghazi Hearing After Being Injured
FACT: Clinton's "What Difference, At This Point, Does It Make" Comment Was Referring To The Administration's Post-Attack Talking Points, Not Tragic Consequences Of Attack
FACT: Intelligence Community, The Suspected Attackers, And Eyewitnesses All Linked The Inflammatory Anti-Islam Video To The Attacks
FACT: There Is No Proof Clinton's State Department Scrubbed, Altered, Or Covered Up Any Benghazi Documents
FACT: Benghazi Witnesses Spoke To Federal Officials And Congress, And Were Not Blocked From Coming Forward By Clinton
FACT: Contrary To Consevative Media Smears, Clinton Said She Took Responsibility For The Benghazi Attack
FACT: While Conservatives Claimed She Was Silent, Clinton Spoke Extensively About Benghazi Following Attack
FACT: Clinton's Use Of A Personal Email Account Was Legal And Did Not Violate State Department Policy
FACT: Clinton Is Not The Subject Of A Criminal Investigation Over Her Emails
FACT: Clinton Did Not Receive Any Emails Labeled As "Classified" Or "Top Secret" At The Time They Were Sent
FACT:Clinton's Use Of A Private Server Did Not Raise Additional Questions About The Retroactive Classification Of Her Emails
FACT: Conservative Comparisons Of Clinton To Petraeus Ignore The Fact That Unlike Petraeus, There's No Evidence Clinton Knowingly Emailed Classified Information
FACT: CIA Says Clinton Did Not Expose Classified Information About Libyan Intelligence Source With Email Contrary To Conservative Claims
MYTH: Clinton Personally Signed-Off On Order To Reduce Security At U.S. Diplomatic Facilities In Benghazi
With the media understandably focused on the hottest story in politics this week, Hillary Clinton's email troubles have continued to spiral. Lie after provable lie has been exposed over recent weeks, with Team Clinton deflecting, distorting and lashing out with each development. Their latest hobby horse has been flogging the New York Times for 'erroneously' reporting that the Inspectors General-referred federal investigation into Mrs. Clinton's unsecure email scheme is criminal in nature. The Times botched the story, the Clinton camp says, because (a) the probe isn't "criminal," and (b) it's not technically investigating her -- but rather her email arrangement. The latter point is a distinction without a meaningful difference. She ordered the secret server to be set up. She ordered it to be culled. Her inner circle destroyed evidence without supervision. And she's personally made demonstrably false claims about the entire imbroglio at every step. Earlier this week, the New York Post tossed cold water on the former point as well:
But she did send and store classified material on her server, in clear violation of the law. She claimed in March that there was " no classified material " whatsoever. The evidence -- incomplete as it is -- proves otherwise. That's why two Inspectors General referred the case to the feds for investigation. The Associated Press and Washington Post have confirmed the FBI's involvement in the probe, with which Team Hillary says they're "actively cooperating:"
They're "not targeting Clinton," you see. They're just investigating the national security implications of the secret server she operated in violation of the rules, then lied about. Got it. Last month, we discovered China's breathtaking hack of reams of OPM files and data, a data security penetration characterized as a "Pearl Harbor" of cyber warfare. This week, we learned that the Russians hacked the Pentagon's email system , shutting down email for two weeks. If our more sophisticated adversaries managed to break through several sensitive government firewalls, one wonders who didn't have unfettered access to the communications of our nation's top diplomat, which were sitting exposed on a comprehensively under-secure private server. And why did Mrs. Clinton hatch this national security-compromising scheme? As we recently relayed, Andrea Mitchell's intelligence sources reached the same inexorable conclusion as many laypeople: She did it to wield total political control over her communications, in order to thwart transparency and accountability rules. One last point on the Clinton campaign's "the FBI investigation isn't criminal" hair-splitting. Over to you , er, FBI spokesman:
Bruce,
You have your sources, I have mine; clearly we're at an impasse on this.
Hard to tell where it will end with the "issues" -- if in fact from a legal, protocol perspective, there actually "issues."
We'll see …
Maybe.
I agree. I would remind you and the others that this is still an ongoing investigation. Charges, if any will have to come from a Federal Grand Jury. One of the obstacles to overcome in cases like this is the very issue of classified information. How much do you unclassify even if you can, to allow as evidence in the Grand Jury procedings?
For example: The Walker spy ring. Then Sec of the Navy John Lehman wanted Walker to face the death penalty for the magnatude of secrets and their impact on our Navy that he sold to the Soviets. However, this would have required a criminal trial, and the information could not at that time be declassified in order to present to a Grand Jury or at trial. Instead, they plea bargained a confession from him in return for a lighter sentence for his son.
Let us not forget that the investigation into Gen Petraeus by the FBI began in 2012, but recomendations for felony charges were not made until 2015.