A community college in Oregon has set aside April to look at "whiteness" — but not to celebrate what it's described as a social construct which leads to inequality.
Portland Community College's Diversity Council is behind the event, which it called a " bold adventure " to examine "race and racism through an exploration of the construction of whiteness, its origins and heritage."
The project is "not a celebratory endeavor" but an "effort to change our campus climate," the school said on its website.
Sixty-eight percent of the school's 90,000-strong student body is Caucasian, according to PCC's website .
"Whiteness refers to the construction of the white race, white culture, and the system of privileges and advantages afforded to white people," a definition on the school's event page reads .
The month of April will be dedicated to the project, which "seeks to inspire innovative and practical solutions to community issues and social problems that stem from racism," the school said.
Among the questions that will be asked:
- What is whiteness and how is it socially constructed?
- In what ways does whiteness emerge from a legacy of imperialism, conquest, colonialism and the American enterprise?
- Who benefits from the consequences of whiteness? Who loses from whiteness? How?
- What are alternatives to the culture of white supremacy?
- What are approaches and strategies to dismantling whiteness?
News of the plans has provoked some controversy and criticism. One far-right website accused PCC of looking to "trash White Americans," while Campus Reform ran a headline "Portland Community College to Devote an Entire Month to 'Whiteness' Shaming."
The school's interim president Sylvia Kelley said there was "no intention, as some may have feared, to 'shame or blame' anyone" during the project.
"We view this project as part of a larger national conversation around race and social justice on America's college campuses," she said in a statement .
http://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/oregon-s-portland-community-college-mark-whiteness-history-month-n500981

Among the questions that will be asked:
I'm not sure how I feel about this "bold adventure" as the college has labeled it. I'll be interested in hearing the outcome. Just reading what little has been offered in this article leaves me perplexed as to what exactly the objective is. As someone who is white and has always been a proponent for equal rights I'm a little disturbed that there seems to be a constant focus on the negativity. I would imagine that this perception is partly to blame for the elevated tensions between races. No one likes to be continuously told how horrible they are.
Probably be a lot better if they talked with professional anthropologists and archaeologists to find the answers they're looking for, since all of the questions deal with cultural differences.
"Whiteness" studies are appropriate. Large numbers of Americans are not assimilated ( or don't want to assimilate) into "white" America. Eventually this has to be reconciled somehow.
Where the culture is going wrong is in making a big deal out these whiteness studies, as if every time the topic comes up on a university campus there has to be a big confrontation about it. The confrontation causes the hard feelings more so than the content of the courses does.
I agree, the studies are appropriate but I don't agree with the lopsidedness of the studies. Of course, I also will acknowledge that the study hasn't begun and I don't know the outcome and whether they'll need to make adjustments along the way. I do think you've actually brought up a very good point about how part of this feeling I'm having is because of all the press this topic is getting. I'll have to consider that more.
By inference, I'm not too impressed with their course load if they waste time on silly "bold adventures". Lol. Real life is going to be such a surprise to these snowflakes...
As an educator, I am don't like the construct of this program. I feel it is very counter productive. Black History Month celebrates what blacks have done and how the overcame adversity. What should follow are other minorities achievements and how they overcame adversity, ie, Indians, Chinese, Japanese etc. Part of all these stories is the social construct that lead to adversity that they had to overcome. School is supposed to be a positive experience for all, and I don't see how "Whiteness History Month" achieves that.
Perrie, in the US, and other countries, "white" skin has been the presumed norm. Historically this was seen in the "passing for white" and "acting white" phenomena. For many many many decades being white meant being American, and being accepted before you did anything to merit acceptance. We all know the old story about how the conversation changed when a black person or another person of color walked into a room that was previously all white.
The issue now is whether or not society has changed enough that such things as "white studies" are no longer warranted. The jury is out on that. Sometimes it seems there is progress, and sometimes not.
I think the best thing would be for these programs to exist and function without all the divisive publicity they attract.
Something else to consider is Political Correctness. It seems these days that there is this huge push to jump on that ever moving target of PC. So, it raises another question which is, is there really a desire to learn or is this just something to flaunt out there to say "see, we're PC. We're doing these studies". It's almost like saying, I'm not a racist because I have a black friend. I don't know what the answer is.......I just know that I'm frustrated.
John,
I am not going to deny that historically, whites have had a foot up. But a program like this, is counter productive. Negative reinforcement has been proven over and over again, to create angst and fear.. even in animals. The proper course is to teach about all minorities and their struggle towards equality, and naturally, the issue of skin color will come up.
I can tell you, that since there "Black life Matters" movement, there has been an increasing amount of animosity on the Hopkins campus between the black and the white students than before. It started off all well and good with the black and white students protesting together over the riots, but it has evolved into the black students being very confrontational with what they perceive as white students. When my daughters told them that they were part Indian, their black friends actually had the nerve to say that Indians were never slaves. I mean WTF? It is better to educate and let students come to their own conclusions, than to indoctrinate and part of that is letting blacks know that other races suffered to, and how they handled it.
It is better to educate and let students come to their own conclusions, than to indoctrinate and part of that is letting blacks know that other races suffered to, and how they handled it.
Thank you Perrie. You captured what I was trying to say.
The reason that "white privilege" evolved into a topic used in education is because "white" was the default skin color of the "real American". It wasn't whites that wanted "special" treatment, according to the detractors, it was the minorities that were always whining about something and making demands. Whites were always just normal people.
-
anyway - I don't really vouch for these videos, but they do show the lay of the land
Perrie, anecdotes about your daughters experiences with black people don't really have a bearing on "white privilege", although I can see why you then think talking about race is counter productive.
I don't like to use personal anecdotes to explain societal wide issues, but maybe that is just me.
John,
So you post a pile of videos that are also anecdotal and we should feel any differently than my story? How does that relate to teaching about other minorities getting their fair due? Gee, I would love to be a Mexican right now/sarc. Where is the Mexican life Matters movement? How about a month for Indigenous people History? How about a positive way of teaching this on campus, as in how to increase understanding of all minorities?
The videos are not anecdotal, other than part of what Chris Rock was saying. The other three are people giving an opinion about white privilege, but not anecdotal opinions.
I don't understand where "Mexicans" are coming from in this. "White privilege" relates to the advantages that have accrued to white people as a result of being the default skin color of "Americans" for the past 400 years. As I said, it is changing, whether it is fast enough is the open question. But the "victims of "white privilege" are all non-white people, not just blacks.
That isn't how it plays out on college campuses John. All the articles are dominated by black students in campus papers. Not Asians, or Latinos, or Indians.
Don't think that started 'til 'bout 1789 John - when America started.
"White" dominance has been around for thousands of years - way before America.
A fascinating article by @SeanMcElwee who crunched the data on millennial racial attitudes. Key Graph:
"The fact that millennials perceive themselves as uniquely tolerant may make them more likely to practice or accept discriminatory behavior. “A representative panel of Americans interviewed immediately before and after the election [of Barack Obama] reveals a roughly 10 percent decline in perceptions of racial discrimination,” Nicholas A. Valentino and Ted Brader, wrote in a 2011 study in the journal Public Opinion Quarterly. But the dramatic change in perceptions was clearly symbolic. Valentino and Brader found that “declines in perceived discrimination were associated with increases in negative opinions of blacks and heightened opposition to both affirmative action and immigration.”
A large body of research supports this finding. For instance, a 2009 study by Vincent Hutchings found (PDF) “scant evidence of a decline in the racial divide” from 1988 to 2008 on policies that would alleviate racial inequality. Even more startling, Hutchings noted, “younger cohorts of whites are no more racially liberal in 2008 than they were in 1988.” Read whole thing Here -
See more at: