╌>

Bernie Sanders Will fail, Because Political Campaigns Based On Ideological Purity Don't Work

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  johnrussell  •  10 years ago  •  7 comments

Bernie Sanders Will fail, Because Political Campaigns Based On Ideological Purity Don't Work

http://www.salon.com/2016/01/26/i_have_had_it_with_naive_bernie_sanders_idealists

"When Jedediah Purdy, a professor at Duke Law School,  insists that quixotic insurgent campaigns based on ideological purity work, it’s impossible to miss that he doesn’t say exactly  when.  He doesn’t cite any campaigns that back up his assertion. The reason why is simple. There are none. As much as Purdy and Sanders supporters wish it were true, this strategy has never worked and likely never will. Since the days of Ancient Greece, ideological purity in a democratic society has been the road to ruin of every political movement and every political party that has tried it.

Purdy has accidentally encapsulated not just the fatal flaw in the Sanders theory of change, but also the primary flaw of his supporters. Sanders doesn’t have supporters as much as he has  believers . Sanders’ supporters cannot call on facts to support their fervent belief that his message of radical change is possible, because the facts do not support this belief. They become belligerent and hostile any time anyone questions this belief.

That Sanders is right — and so his followers are right — is taken as an elemental matter of faith. Sanders represents the light and all that is good; anyone who questions this must be an agent of the dark and all that is bad.

Sound familiar? It should. This is precisely the impetus behind every extremist movement in history. Sanders and his supporters too often exemplify a political manifestation of this black and white ideology. One of the consistent criticisms of Bernie Sanders throughout his career is that he’s self-righteous and unwilling to entertain any position or belief that doesn’t exactly match his. Back in 1991, when Bernie was still new to Congress, progressive icon Barney Frank said of him, “Bernie alienates his natural allies. His holier-than-thou attitude—saying in a very loud voice he is smarter than everyone else and purer than everyone else—really undercuts his effectiveness.”

 

 


The problem with Bernie Sanders and his supporters isn’t ideological. The difference between Sanders and Clinton is a matter of degree more than any fundamental ideological disagreement. They both advocate moving in the same direction, but by different methods. Bernie Sanders says he will bring about a political revolution to make his dreams of a democratic socialist society come true, which seems an unlikely proposition given that the GOP is sure to control one house of Congress and may well control both. Hillary Clinton advocates a pragmatic approach: protecting the progressive gains won under the Obama administration, taking what new gains may be possible in a divided government and setting the political table to back for more later.

Historically, it is this latter approach that has produced change. In any democratic system of government, progress is incremental. Only one time in our history as a nation have we seen such sweeping ideological change at a fundamental level happen in a brief span of time, and that change came at the price of five years of bloody civil war and some 500,000 deaths.

 

 

Human attitudes — and there is no more elemental human attitude than politics — cannot be defined as simply as darkness or the light. We’ve tried this again and again, and it never ends well. This Democratic primary contest isn’t a battle of good against evil. Hillary Clinton isn’t the evil agent of the powers of greed and darkness and Bernie Sanders isn’t an avenging angel or a pious saint. This is a political campaign and they are both professional politicians. While both candidates seek to highlight their differences, they have far more in common with each other than either of them does with the extremist and often dangerous positions of the Republican contenders. Politics is the art of the possible, not the perfect. One candidate embodies the possible. One insists on nothing less than the perfect. Paul Krugman is right. The achievable possible is always preferable to the unachievable perfect."



Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    10 years ago

I think Sanders is serving a good purpose, but he is going to have to be satisfied with being a pathfinder. He cannot win the general election, and the country cannot afford to have crazy Republicans in charge of all phases of government. 

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    10 years ago

Once my new hashtag #StopTheHag goes viral Hillary will be toast. Protect White House aids keep Bill out of the cigar box. I'm pulling for Bernie. 

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell  replied to  Dean Moriarty   10 years ago

You might  be the only person on earth who thinks that keeping Bill Clinton away from White House interns is the nation's most pressing issue. 

 
 
 
PJ
Masters Silent
link   PJ    10 years ago

"Sanders doesn’t have supporters as much as he has believers."

I really liked this description.  I thought it was spot on and I agree with the ideological premise of the article in that both Bernie Sanders and Hilary Clinton do have very similar goals.   I found it interesting the statement from Barney Frank regarding Bernie’s ability, in my words, to alienate those that most support him.  For me Bernie is a symbol of political correctness and my belief is that as good as that goal is it is just as harmful maybe more so because it doesn’t allow for controversial issues or positions to find its place or work itself out but rather demands acquiescence.

 

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    10 years ago

I think it's interesting to watch democrats fret over Bernie, and republicans rejoice. The truth is, if it comes down to a Bernie vs Trump, we may have Trump as a president... which is scary. And although I am not a big fan of Hillary, she might be able to beat Trump. 

But then again... Bernie vs Trump or Cruz, will produce a third party candidate who will have investigated his chances carefully, because that is what he does,  and who has more money than Trump could wish for to spend... and then we'll have a real nail biter at the end. 

Strange times. 

 
 

Who is online

Right Down the Center
evilone


123 visitors