Paul Krugman, Bernie Sanders, and the Experts
Paul Krugman, Bernie Sanders, and the Experts
original article by Dean Baker, Center for Economic and Policy Research / Beat the Press
-------------------------------------------------
I have tremendous respect for Paul Krugman. I also consider him a friend. For these reasons I am not eager to pick a fight with him, but there is something about his criticisms of Bernie Sanders that continues to bother me.
In a blog post last week, Krugman told readers:
“As far as I can tell, every serious progressive policy expert on either health care or financial reform who has weighed in on the primary seems to lean Hillary.”
While I already had some fun with the idea of Krugman revoking the credentials of everyone who works in these areas who does not back Clinton, the appeal to the authority of the “experts” is more than a bit annoying. The reason is that the “experts” do not have a very good track record of late and still have a long way to go to win back the public’s trust.
To start with the obvious, almost none of the experts saw the 2008 collapse coming. Almost all of them dismissed the idea that there was a housing bubble and even the few that grudgingly acknowledged the possibility of a bubble insisted that it could not have much consequence for the economy.
Given the devastation wreaked by the collapse of this bubble, this failure is comparable to weather forecasters missing Hurricane Katrina. Just to be clear, I don’t mean failing to recognize the full severity of the storm, I mean missing the hurricane altogether and forecasting nothing but blue skies for the day it hit. The public could be forgiven for not wanting to trust future forecasts.
The list goes on. The experts insisted that we would have a Second Great Depression if we didn’t bail out the Wall Street banks. Really? Was there some magical curse that would overcome the country if Goldman Sachs and Citigroup went out of business? Would Keynesian stimulus no longer work? We got out of the first Great Depression in 1941 by spending a ton of money fighting World War II. It is hard to see any reason why we couldn’t have ended the depression a decade sooner by spending a ton of money in 1931 on infrastructure, health care, and education. The same story would have applied in 2009.
Today most of the experts are telling us the economy is near full employment. To accept this view we have to believe that millions of prime age workers (between the ages of 25-54), just decided they don’t feel like working any more. The drop in labor force participation rates occurred at all education levels, including people with college and advance degrees. This massive loss of interest in working was completely unpredicted by the experts just a few years ago.
The experts have not done notably better on health care. We have seen a huge decline in the rate of health care cost growth. While this is a great development from an economic standpoint, it was completely unforeseen by the experts and still largely unexplained.
The experts even managed to get some of the basics of Obamacare wrong, falsely warning us about the importance of the “young invincibles,” convincing the public the that the success of the program somehow depended on the willingness of twenty somethings to sign up for insurance. As a simple analysis by the Kaiser Family Foundation showed, skewing by age makes little difference to the finances of the program. What matters is skewing by health condition. In other words, it matters much more for the finances of the program if healthy 60-year-olds sign up. There is no special importance to people being young.
Given their track record, the public has some cause for skepticism when being told that the experts all line up behind a particular candidate (which happens not to be true). It is certainly the case that Sanders’ proposals are campaign planks, not fully worked out programs. I will also be the first to say that I would be more than shocked if we managed to get a universal Medicare system in two terms of a Sanders administration.
But does Sanders agenda offer less prospect of moving the ball forward than Clinton’s? This is very much a political question, where one’s status as an expert on health care or finance may not be all that useful. I gave my answer last week. People may disagree, but they should at least understand the nature of the question.
One final point, many Sanders supporters seem to believe that Krugman is looking for a job in a Clinton administration. I am quite certain Krugman would turn down any job Clinton might offer. Krugman believes what he is writing, he just happens to be mistaken.

Dean Baker tackles Paul Krugman. In this case, I side with Baker.
I'm going with Baker on this.
As a general rule, I am wary of "argument from authority". While Krugman puts a pretty bow on his arguments, inside the package it's still an argument from authority.
The country cannot afford to have Republicans win the next two presidential elections. All of the major Republican candidates will appoint ideologically rightist judges to Supreme Court vacancies, of which there will be a number over the next 8 years. Ted Cruz has said that he will create the most conservative Supreme Court in history.
Bernie Sanders candidacy is a version of the old adage "you are trying to run before you walk". Progressives do not have the national underpinning in elected offices, statewide and in the US Congress, that would allow sanders to succeed in passing legislation. For progressive legislation to pass, the Democrats will have to control both the House and the Senate. That is not going to happen in 2016. Sanders is a first step.
The country cannot afford to have Republicans win the next two presidential elections.
I am much more pessimistic.
Having a Democratic victory in the 2016 Presidential is just putting off the inevitable. Republican control of the House is now permanent, because Republicans also control enough statehouses to gerrymander whatever they need.
The Senate, being profoundly anti-democratic, can be controlled by a relatively small number of Red states.
So... if not in 2016, then four or eight or twelve years later, the Presidency will fall to the Republicans, too... along with the last pretense of American "democracy".
Nothing is permanent, although it would probably take 10 years for Democrats to retake the house. If demographics change the way everyone is predicting, "right wing" Republicanism is a dodo bird waiting to happen. They won't have the bodies to control the Congress in perpetuity.
You do wonder what the country will look like in 20 or 30 years. I think, technology will make politics obsolete within the next half century.
John,
If demographics change the way everyone is predicting, "right wing" Republicanism is a dodo bird waiting to happen.
By the time "those people" have the numbers to be politically significant, the Republicans will have found enough voting-rights restrictions to prevent their opponents from ever winning a Red state election... and those states are sufficient to maintain a stranglehold on the entire nation.
Democracy in America is a zombie. It shambles on in imitation of life... but it is dead.
Even if he got 80% of the vote, as long as the right controls both houses nothing will get done for the American people.
Do you think they will behave for Clinton? I doubt it.
To me, the issue is not would the Republican congress pass legislation put forth by Sanders or Clinton ( probably not in both cases) but what risk the Democrats would be taking by nominating Sanders. Sanders likes to talk about how well he does in the polls vs. Trump or Cruz. That is all well and good but leaves out a very key detail. - No Republican candidate has said a bad word about Bernie Sanders YET. They have held their fire because they would rather face him in the fall. If he gets the nomination, the allegations about socialism and communism and collectivism will pile up faster from the Republicans than anyone could respond to.
Geeze Louise - the political right goes off on the un-American and socialist and communist Obama, and Clinton, fairly regularly, what will they do when the have an actual "socialist" in their sights?
People need to be sober minded and serious about this election and sanders is not electable in 2016.
People need to be sober minded and serious about this election and sanders is not electable in 2016.
How about against Trump. I think he is electable.
Trump can beat both the crook and the socialist.
Dean,
I think you are dreaming. He is a blowhard without an actual policy on anything. So you can name call as much as you like, but with democrats having 30% of the electorate over the republicans having 20%.... and independents at 40%, this election is a total wildcard.