How to rehabilitate capitalism (Opinion by Reuters)
The author Hugo Dixon is a Reuters Breakingviews guest columnist. The opinions expressed are his own.
Capitalism is under attack. Witness the popularity of Bernie Sanders, the socialist running neck-and-neck in the opinion polls with Hillary Clinton for the Democratic caucuses in Iowa being held on Feb. 1. To rehabilitate the system of free enterprise, it needs to be buttressed by a modern conception of fairness.
Viewed from Mars, capitalism has been a huge success. Free enterprise has generated wealth and removed hundreds of millions of people from poverty. But viewed from Earth, what often stands out is how many have been left behind by the march of globalisation and technology, while others have got ahead by methods more foul than fair.
The classic left-wing response to the perceived unfairness of capitalism has been to tax and spend. That doesn’t work well. High taxes can sap entrepreneurial spirit, while high welfare spending can leave poorer people dependent on hand-outs.
Just because the classic response has been tried and failed doesn’t mean it won’t be tried again. The success of left-wing populists such as Greece’s Syriza party and the election of Jeremy Corbyn as leader of Britain’s Labour Party show that such ideas still have appeal.
This makes it important for centrists – whether they consider themselves left-wing progressives, radical centrists or liberal conservatives – to articulate a credible middle road. This should be based less on a view that fairness is the same as equality and more on the idea that people should get a fair crack at a good standard of life.
There are two main aspects. First, it is important to tackle the foul methods by which people and companies get ahead – and, in the process, make it tougher for hard-working honest people to make progress.
One example of this is evading or avoiding tax. This is rife in some countries, such as Greece. But it is a global problem that makes people furious everywhere. Consider the anger in January in the UK over how Google, the internet giant, was seemingly able to run rings around the authorities and pay what looks like a tiny amount of tax.
Corruption, which is again widespread across the world from Asia to Latin America and pretty much everywhere in between, also sticks in the craw. Sweetheart deals between politicians and business line the pockets of the few to the detriment of the many.
Another justified target of ire is the existence of markets that favour insiders at the expense of the general public. Finance is top of the list. The global financial crisis exposed how many bankers had a one-way bet: during the good times, they raked it in; during the bad, the state picked up the pieces. This was a mockery of how capitalism is supposed to work.
Monopolies and vested interests are yet another source of resentment. Sometimes, the culprits are the big oligarchs who pull the strings in government to get the rules written in their favour, by giving bribes to politicians or senior officials.
But often the beneficiaries of vested interests aren’t particularly rich or powerful as individuals. Greece is one of the best examples of the phenomenon. Over decades, it perfected the art of doling out special privileges to such an array of groups – farmers, notaries, pharmacists, civil servants, teachers and ordinary pensioners as well as shipping magnates – that its economy gummed up.
Such practices sap entrepreneurial spirits but they do so by locking people out of opportunity rather than by using the methods of old-fashioned socialism. They also inflict bigger taxes on honest citizens and higher prices on consumers.
A modern conception of fairness would put an assault of foul methods at its heart. But it would do more than that.
Although successful societies need welfare states, most of Europe’s need refocussing. Part of the problem is that too much government spending is directed to what Europeans call the middle class rather than the needy.
The situation varies from country to country but the main goodies are generous state pensions for middle-to-high earners and tax breaks that benefit relatively well-off people. To be fair, some countries are reining these in. For example, the UK no longer offers such attractive incentives for rich people to save for their retirement. But, in many countries, there is a lot that could be done.
The money saved from funding this “middle class” welfare state could then be redeployed where it is needed. The priority will often be to invest in schools so kids get a fair start in life – and in adult education so that older people whose skills become obsolete as a result of technology can retrain.
Such a conception of fairness is not really new. It has a lot in common with classic liberalism. Nor is it dead. Successful politicians around the world – such as India’s Narendra Modi with his fight against corruption or Matteo Renzi with his willingness to confront vested interests – are deploying some strategies from this playbook.
It is a rich source of ideas with which to tackle the unfairness of capitalism without falling for the inefficiency of socialism.
http://blogs.reuters.com/hugo-dixon/2016/02/01/how-to-rehabilitate-capitalism/

An interesting piece with many good points from different points of view. We Americans have the same difficulties as any other country has with it's representative democracy in that our representatives are not working for the people, but for those with money.
Get the money out of our political/electorial system, and we have a chance to have a government that works for the people, and corporations alike.
There are many good points in the article FLY.
The current system in the US isn't working, not that it's a bad system, it isn't. It's the way it's being played by the politicians. I think that we are seeing a revolt by the people in the nominating process. There are people that they wouldn't have considered before, but with the pen up anger at the current class of politicians they are trying to send a message by voting for candidates that are the extremes. This is to upset the status quo.
The vast amounts of money in the election process is making our system nothing but a whorehouse. You don't give candidates millions of dollars and not expect something in return.
Think we the people could initiate a pledge for our federal representatives to sign to which they would't take any money from lobbyists, or corporate entities?
Their bitch would be that those running against them won't take that pledge, thus the money merry-go-round would continue. Citizens United has only helped to put our representatives further out of communication and touch with the largest proportion of voters.
Hope you're well Kavika.
No, I don't think that a pledge would work FLY, for the reason you listed.
IMO, citizens united is the biggest problem in the current elections. It added a new wave of money that expects a return on investment.
Doing fine FLY, and you?
"Think we the people could initiate a pledge for our federal representatives to sign to which they would't take any money from lobbyists, or corporate entities? "
LOL!
Well, at least you have a sense of humour! :^)
Fighting poverty just like you are my friend.....
A life long battle my friend.
Lower taxes is the best thing I can think of to boost the capitalistic spirit of the American people. Encourage capital investment without debt and encourage businesses to reinvest with profit. Capital gains taxes should be eliminated as well as estate taxes.
Bullshit Dean....
We have money pooled doing nothing to the tune of a trillion dollars sitting on the sidelines. No amount, or type of tax reduction will get that money moving. Your stated plan, which has been the one in play for the last 30 years is what we have right now.
MONEY DOES NOTHING UNLESS IT IS IN CIRCULATION AND CHANGES HANDS!
No it isn't only the large conglomerates can avoid taxes. The average business owner is stuck with some of the highest corporate taxes in the world. The government has been encouraging expansion by debt by giving tax breaks on borrowed funds and interest paid on that debt. Estate taxes have been devastating family owned businesses and need to be eliminated.
More bullshit from you Dean....
Small businesses in the United States pay an estimated average effective tax rate of approximately 19.8 percent . federal income tax at the business owner level, small business sole proprietorships face the lowest average effective tax rate at 13.3 percent .
And I know you are going to bitch because this report is from 2009, but the tax rates have not gone up to anything you are going to say they are since then. So between 13% and 20%. More businesses have been put out of business by the likes of Walmart than anything the US Tax code has imposed at those rates.
The link says page not found. Maybe they are taking an average of businesses. You only pay tax on profitt If you don't make any money you pay low taxes many businesses are poorly run and many are losing money. A well run profitable business is stuck with high taxes. Much of the growth of business in the south is due to tax breaks. GM was given huge tax breaks in the government brokered bankruptcy restructuring.
GM was given huge tax breaks in the government brokered bankruptcy restructuring.
Considering that one of every seven jobs in the US is tied back to the automotive industry, keeping them in operation, just like the banks, during the great recession was akin to life support. We would still be digging out if the domestic auto industry had failed.
Considering that one of every seven jobs in the US is tied back to the automotive industry
Is that still accurate ? I thought changes in the US economy meant more jobs in the finance industry and less in manufacturing ...
People have to accept the reality of a "welfare state" . It should be improved, it should be well run and not wasteful, but it has to be.
America prides itself on "opportunity" , but our economic system guarantees that there will be failures. The system requires a certain percentage of workers who will only be able to work for the lowest salaries going, or maybe not find work at all for long stretches. The "opportunity is all that matters" folks would presumably and indifferently have the 'failures' suffer their fate.
But everyone is part of the capitalist system . The person making the lowest wage , and even the unemployed, contribute something to the system, and the system should be required to sustain those people, in other words everyone.
When you have great success due to the system in the US, and make a lot of money, you should be required to contribute to those who have failed at the system. That doesn't mean everyone is 'equal', it means we understand the system. Personally, I don't consider it socialism, I consider it the way things need to work for everyone.
Elsewise, we have dog eat dog as the basis for society.
Well, I think you are a bit overboard about Hillary, especially thinking that her being in power would give women an advantage in our society. As for a paedarchy, we'd all end up with lord of the flies, wouldn't we?