╌>

Reports Possible 15 Dead In Mass Shooting At College

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  lets-get-lost  •  11 years ago  •  91 comments

Reports Possible 15 Dead In Mass Shooting At College

Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

Once again, America is waiting for more details of a mass shooting. Fifteen people are reported dead and more wounded in a shooting at Umpqua Community College in Roseburg, Oregon.

We'll update as details become available.

...

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    11 years ago

According to CNN, 10 dead, average age of students is 38.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     11 years ago

AP just reported 15 confirmed dead, multiple others wounded.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

PRELIMINARY REPORTS OF 10 KILLED IN SHOOTING AT COMMUNITY COLLEGE IN OREGON, STATE POLICE SPOKESMAN SAYS. SUSPECT IN CUSTODY, COUNTY OFFICIAL SAYS. WATCH CNNgo.

Preliminary information indicates 10 people were killed and more than 20 others injured in a shooting at Oregon's Umpqua Community College on Thursday, says Oregon State Police spokesman Bill Fugate.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

And here we go again. American will be shocked for a few weeks and not another fucking thing will be done about gun control. We are just getting far too used to this happening, so we bleat out a lot of noise, it all dies down and then we shut up until the next one. And there will always be a next one, just as long as the NRA PR Department does it's job and pays off the right people in Washington!

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

It seems to be taking a long time to determine how many victims there are.

 
 
 
Uncle Bruce
Professor Silent
link   Uncle Bruce    11 years ago
 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

As I said...

 
 
 
Uncle Bruce
Professor Silent
link   Uncle Bruce    11 years ago

Comment removed for CoC violation [ph]

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    11 years ago
Often the term "causality" is used indeterminately. That often causes confusion.
 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    11 years ago
Comment removed for context [ph]

Look whose talking! Your poster indicates you are taking issue with the fact that the reports are saying something about a gun being used in a shooting.

You think someone can go on a shooting spree, killing and wounding 3 dozen people without using a gun and your'e calling Randy a dumbass?!

You're right about one thing Bruce, the pro-gun community had best brace themselves. This shit is happening way too often and the anti-gun crowd is going to be pressing real hard for some kind of reform.

I think you might be better off if you start putting your efforts towardpromoting gun safety, and better regulation, because it's gonna happen sooner or later, so you might as well put in your two cents and help control the fallout.

Jus' sayin' Bruce.

 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   J Martin    11 years ago

"You're a dumbass."

This is not a contribution to an adult conversation and so deserves absolutely no response whatsoever. Folks: Don't be sucked in to such childish remarks.

 
 
 
Uncle Bruce
Professor Silent
link   Uncle Bruce    11 years ago

The meme, Jerry, is a perfect response to Randy, and to you. Everytime some one is murdered by a firearm, you dipshits want to pass more laws designed to prohibit the natural right to bear arms. You blame THE GUN. Try blaming the dumbass that pulled the trigger. Try blaming the college that banned firearms.

Oh yeah. The campus is a gun free zone Jerry. How'd that work out for the 13 dead? Did it stop the gunman? Do you seriously think passing any more laws is going to stop criminals?

We passed laws against Meth. Didn't stop the meth heads or meth labs did it. Then we passed laws restricting the availability of over the counter meds with the ingredients used to make meth. Has that stopped meth labs from springing up all over America?

When are you fuckers going to learn that gun laws do not apply to criminals?

 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   J Martin    11 years ago

"When are you fuckers going to learn that gun laws do not apply to criminals?"

Perhaps some effort should be made to make it much more challenging for the mentally ill to acquire guns?

Just a thought.

 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   J Martin    11 years ago

At least 13 killed in college shooting in Oregon

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

You're a dumbass.

And I feel sorry for you. I pity you because you are a member of a gun cult. When it comes to guns you are no longer able to think for yourself anymore then anyone who followed Jim Jones or David Koresh could. When something happens all you can do is to reflexively bleat out the same slogans and words and comments and insults that you have been taught to say. No matter if it's a mass shooting at a college or a shopping mall or a movie theater, or even slaughtered 5 and 6 year old school children in a school in Sandy Hook, it does not move you in any kind of human way any longer. They all involved guns and your humanity has been brainwashed out of you in those kind of cases. It only puts you into a defensive posture, protecting the gun cult at all cost, even at the cost of any empathy or your own soul.

You are brainwashed by the current NRA leadership. Owned by them. A part of their structure and essence of being. Part of the very physical body of them. One of their machines. When it comes to guns and mass murders they own you completely and that is a very sad thing to see happen to what one would presume was once a rational human being with a heart. Perhaps you still do have some humanity left in you, but not when it comes to guns. Never when it comes to guns. When it comes to guns you are nothing more then a robotic machine repeating the same things you always do and have always been taught to you by the leaders of your cult. You are only just short of being so cultish as to be a follower as much as one of someone like a Charles Manson, Jim Jones or a Marshal Applewhite.

I pity you. I really honestly pity you. You're incomplete. Many of the human parts of you are missing.

 
 
 
Uncle Bruce
Professor Silent
link   Uncle Bruce    11 years ago

Save it for someone who gives a shit.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

I envy you for your ability to avoid the seedy geographies where gun violence is more prevalent . The only reason this item is news is that it was supposed to be a violence free zone ...

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

First of all, the idea of a "natural right" to own weapons.

It doesn't exist. Such a "right" is conferred by a government or controlling body such as a tribe. Imagine you are back in a "cave man" tribe and the chief tells you that you have to fight another tribesman. The other guy is much bigger than you so you pick up a big rock to hit him with. But the chief says no , no rock. What are you going to do, tell the chief you have a "natural right" to use the rock against a bigger opponent ? lol.

"Rights" are conferred by governments or other agencies, they don't come from thin air. Now, if you are operating in a framework without government or another controlling agency, then you can pick up whatever weapon you can lay your hand on, and that is where the "natural right" is in effect.

Nonetheless, in the US, the Supreme Court presently interprets the law (constitution) to mean that people can own firearms. The regulation of them appears to be somewhat in flux.

The problem is not people owning guns, it is the national cult of obsession and fascination with guns. America romances guns and gun violence in the media and stories and songs, etc, to the point where we fairly regularly hear stories of people shooting someone because they were PLAYING with a gun.

The only way to lessen and get rid of much of these shootings is to debilitate this gun culture.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

Save it for someone who gives a shit.

Thank you for confirming what I said. When it comes to mass shootings, even 6 adults and 20, 5 and 6 year old children being slaughtered, you just don't give "a shit" about them dying or how horribly they died, how terrified those children were as their bodies were being torn apart. You don't care about it at all. ALL you do care about is how will it effect the gun cult that the NRA has become and who you follow like a church member. ALL you do care about is will it lead to gun control. Not a single thought for the dead beyond how much it might change minds in Washington concerning the cult you are a devoted follower and member of. Like I said, many of the human parts of you are missing. And that is why I pity you. I really, really am genuinely sad for you.

 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   J Martin    11 years ago

Wow. If a discrepancy in victim numbers is obvious in the text of the conversation, and someone here contributes speculative data to the discussion about numbers of victims, that person is here called an "asshat".

I think the adults here can see who the real "asshat" is. And I must wonder how it is that such verbal behavior can be tolerated in an ostensibly adult discussion forum.

 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   J Martin    11 years ago

By the way, Churro, congratulations to you for your graduation from second grade! Good on you!

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    11 years ago

Try blaming the dumbass that pulled the trigger.

Pulled the trigger on what?

Oh yeah. The campus is a gun free zone Jerry.

I know, I shudder every time I see one of those signs.

It just goes to prove you guys aren't the only ones that do stupid things. Maybe someone will take this tragedy as message that GFZs do nothing more than a provide shooters with a safe zone.

Meanwhile, something must be done to reduce the number of gun deaths in America. We're beginning tolooklike aBananaRepublic.

 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   J Martin    11 years ago

When will the fart jokes begin?

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    11 years ago

Save it for someone who gives a shit.

If you don't give a shit, why don't you just get lost? You obviously have nothing to contribute to this discussion.

(or any other for that matter)

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

I envy you for your ability to avoid the seedy geographies where gun violence is more prevalent . The only reason this item is news is that it was supposed to be a violence free zone ...

Another thoughtless, pretty much nonsensical comment. If someone walked into Kennedy King College , 6301 S.HalstedSt. , in the HEART of Englewood, the most dangerous neighborhood in "Chiraq" , and shot 25 people, killing 13 of them, you don't think the incident would be on the news? Is that "your story and you're sticking to it" Petey ? rofl

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    11 years ago

Is the person mentally disturbed or emotionally disturbed? Were there signs pointing to abnormal behavior? Did anyone try to report it and was it ignored or did the family not have the resources to handle it?

Anyone with any information?

 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   J Martin    11 years ago

'I'm so insignificant'

According to the source close to the investigation, authorities are looking at social media posts between a person they believe may have been the shooter, and others.

The conversation happened Wednesday night on 4chan.

In it, the writer talks about planning to carry out a shooting. Others egg him on, giving him suggestions on how to do it, and the type of weapons to use.

The responses are mixed -- with some users characterizing the would-be gunman as a pathetic loser. Others called him a twisted hero.

In the posts, there is a reference to the UC Santa Barbara shooter, who wrote a manifesto and videoed himself before opening fire a year ago.

"This is the only time I'll ever be in the news. I'm so insignificant," reads an apparent post by the would-be Oregon gunman.

from

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

We have a presidential candidate and billionaire who loves to call other people losers. It is no surprise that the disturbed are also wrapped up in that.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

Others egg him on, giving him suggestions on how to do it, and the type of weapons to use.

They need to be tracked down and charged with conspiracy to commit murder.

 
 
 
J Martin
Freshman Silent
link   J Martin    11 years ago

"We have a presidential candidate and billionaire wholovesto call other people losers. It is no surprise that the disturbed are also wrapped up in that."

Yeah, and we can find many other examples, such as the bullying which children do to one another in our schools, the vicious and ugly kind of competition many view on "reality tv," etc. We seem to be a culture which encourages nasty, mean and rude behavior toward some people. And it is not surprising to me that some of those some people begin to suffer from emotional and psychological distress. And we as a society don't do enough to help people in such distress, I'd say.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

A certain type of inanimate object killed ten people today,

Another type of inanimate object killed over 100 in the last hour.

I wish you all who think that getting rid of guns (inanimate object #1) will stop the killing, would apply themselves to the problem of the automobile (inanimate object #2) which kills ten time more people on an annual basis than guns ever do.

And this is NOT an apples to oranges comparison.

they are both inanimate objects, if you can impart the ability to kill at will on the gun, then you have to impart the same ability on the automobile, or any other inanimate object. (baseball bats, lead pipes, knifes, Brass knuckles, saps, nunchuka's, etc etc etc.)

Bruce is right, when are we going to put the blame squarely where it belongs, the operator? and not the tool he chooses to use.

Guns do not kill people, people kill people.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

Guns do not kill people, people kill people.

People kill other people with guns, on purpose. Not so much with automobiles.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

Yeah, and the 30,000 annual gun deaths in this country are mostly people choosing not to kill anyone but themselves.

Criminal gun deaths have been declining for over five years now. And it was about three years ago that all the liberal anti gun types started including suicides with guns in the numbers, to make the real point that criminal killings are way down go away.

They gotta pump the numbers to support their failed ideological drivel.

the real point of the matter is this, the tech exists to completely eliminate the background check issue, and has been around for almost 40 years.

WHY hasn't it been implemented?

Because gun rights is more important to the political parties as an issue to bounce back and forth over than the deaths inadequate implementation of the existing laws cause. WE DO NOT NEED MORE LAWS, we only need to actually enforce the ones we already have.

You might want to bring that up at the next political meeting you attend. someone aught to suggest on the liberal side that it might be a good idea to enforce the laws you pass.

 
 
 
Uncle Bruce
Professor Silent
link   Uncle Bruce    11 years ago

It doesn't exist. Such a "right" is conferred by a government or controlling body such as a tribe. Imagine you are back in a "cave man" tribe and the chief tells you that you have to fight another tribesman. The other guy is much bigger than you so you pick up a big rock to hit him with. But the chief says no , no rock. What are you going to do, tell the chief you have a "natural right" to use the rock against a bigger opponent ? lol.

"Rights" are conferred by governments or other agencies, they don't come from thin air.

Seriously John? You need a lesson on the Constitution and the Bill of Rights.

So, let the lesson begin.

The Constitution, John, is the contract between WE the PEOPLE and the federal government. It was written to define those powers WE the PEOPLE allowed the government to have.

The Bill of Rights, or the first 10 Amendments to the Constitution were SPECIFICLYwritten to ENSURE that certain God Given Rights were never fucked with by the Government. They almost didn't happen. There was great debate within the first Congress as to the need to specificly address rights that the colonist has fought so hard enjoy. There was a considerable faction within the Congress that felt that the Constitution itself would never allow the encroachment on such simple God Given rights, such as the freedom of speech, the freedom to worship, and the freedom to prtect oneself from an oppressive government. THANK GOD Thomas Jefferson won out. He knew that as the country grew, the government would (and has on many occasions) lose sight of the basic rights given by our Maker.

So you see John, there is a natural right to own weapons, in order to provide for our self preservation, both personal, and against an oppressive government. The 2nd amendment did not GIVE that to us, it defined it as natural, and beyond the authority of the government to fuck with.

Class dismissed.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    11 years ago
"I wish you all who think that getting rid of guns (inanimate object #1) will stop the killing, would apply themselves to the problem of the automobile (inanimate object #2) which kills ten time more people on an annual basis than guns ever do."STOP the killing? If you want to be taken seriously, then make accurate statements. There are exactly zero people in this country who think it is feasible to stop death due to gun violence. The goal is to reduce it.Your comparison of gun deaths to car deaths is about as apples and oranges, and vacuous, as it gets. Since you equate the two when it comes to deaths, can I assume that they are equal in other terms?Do your guns have a purpose other than killing? Do you get to work in your gun? Do you travel substantially faster and farther in your gun than on your feet or bicycle? How many bags of groceries does your gun hold? When your wife's water breaks, how fast can your gun get her to the hospital?
 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

Yeah, and the 30,000 annual gun deaths in this country are mostly people choosing not to kill anyone but themselves.

MOST? Most gun deaths in this country are suicides? Now that is a link I'd really like to see. A lot yes, but MOST?

the real point of the matter is this, the tech exists to completely eliminate the background check issue, and has been around for almost 40 years.

WHY hasn't it been implemented?

No funding from Congress to enforce it, especially as it comes to unregulated "gun shows" (the laws don't cover them), which are really nothing more then markets to buy weapons illegally.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

You have it backwards, the right (at least as far as is presently interpreted) was included in the "Bill of Rights" . That is why you have the right to own guns. "Natural rights" is a theory, it is not a practice. I suppose you think you have "natural" property rights too.

You may believe you have "rights" in a philosophical sense, but until they are affirmed by a controlling authority, doesn't mean a thing in practice.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

First of all, the idea of a "natural right" to own weapons.

Absolutely 100% correct. There is no "natural right" to own a gun in or out of the US Constitution and anyone who says there is, is lying about it. I'd like them to point out that wording in the Constitution. If they can't, then they should have the good graces to admit themselves an ass.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    11 years ago

I wish you all who think that getting rid of guns (inanimate object #1) will stop the killing, would apply themselves to the problem of the automobile (inanimate object #2) which kills ten time more people on an annual basis than guns ever do.

There ya go! Proof the pro-gun crowd people have been brainwashed!

The auto kills 10 times more people than firearms??!! You really need to bring your argument up to speed NWM.

There was an article posted right here on NT not long ago pointing out out thatvehicular deaths numbers and gun death numbers are about to converge.

I can't find that particular article, but I did find this;

NYTLogo.jpg?width=150




Gun Deaths Versus Car Deaths

By Dorothy J. Samuels July 16, 2014
[ Link ]

Excerpts;

The report contains the striking finding that gun deaths exceeded motor vehicle deaths in 14 states and the District of Columbia in 2011, the latest year for which the relevant data are available from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

In Alaska, for example, there were 126 gun deaths and 87 motor vehicle deaths. The numbers in Ohio were 1,227 gun deaths and 1,178 motor vehicle deaths.

Nationwide, the number of motor vehicle deaths still exceeded gun deaths: 35,543 to 32,351 .

Does that look like 10 times more to you NWM?

You guys need to wake the fuck up and realize we have a serious problem in this country regarding firearms, and you guys are a part of it.

If you really want to preserve the Rights granted to us by the 2nd Amendment, you need to start advocating for more gun safety and better regulation regarding the circulation of firearms and/or their proper storage.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    11 years ago

The only reason this item is news is that it was supposed to be a violence free zone ...

Don't be fucking ridicules. The fact that he was in a so called "GFZ" had nothing to do with the massacre the crackpotperpetrated.

Ten innocent people, attending school and minding their own business, have been brutally murdered in cold blood by a lunaticwith a fucking gun!! And scores more are wounded, some of whom may still die,and you think the only reason the story is news is because the incident occurred in a "GFZ"?

Go home Petey.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    11 years ago

I think we figured that out when it was seeded the first time Asshat!

You think we figured what out? And who is it you're referring to as "Asshat"

You guys really need to start putting the comments you're referring to in block-quotes, so people will WTF you're talking about.

(or maybe it's that you just don't know wtf you're talking about - can't fix stupid)

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    11 years ago

I live alone in the woods with my dog and horse. My mailbox is a quarter mile from my home. On a good day or evening it takes law enforcement twenty or thirty minutes to get to me.

There is no animal control to take care of feral or rabid dogs out here, let alone rabid wild animals that attack my livestock.

I was awakened a month ago by the sound of two men trying to steal my car. When I opened my door and they saw me, they began to approach me; whether it was my dog or my rifle that made them retreat and leave is open to debate.

Do you suggest I be refused the right to have my rifle in my home, or my handgun in my car when I return to my home at night? Should I give up my home and lifestyle, relinquish my firearms and animal friends, and move into town into an apartment that I would despise, so that you would feel more comfortable in the thought that at least two more guns were out of circulation? If I told you that such a life would stifle me, deprive me of my pursuit of happiness, stifle my joy of living, make me want to lie down and die, would you tell me it would be better for me to die in my apartment of misery and boredom than to possibly one day have to take the life of an intruder hell-bent on harming me because he thought me and old woman, alone and helpless, easy prey?

My guns allow me to choose the life I live rather than the one many women my age are FORCED to live when on their own. Should I give up that choice to make you feel better, though you and I will never meet, though our footprints will never cross? Where did you come by such arrogance?

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

Who are you talking to ?

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    11 years ago

And I must wonder how it is that such verbal behavior can be tolerated in an ostensibly adult discussion forum.

Ostensibly adult discussion forums, get a little dry sometimes, especially when people start throwing aroundadjectives like 'ostensibly'. The asshats that are constantly prevaricating in their comments, IMO, add a degree of entertainment value to the discussions.

 
 
 
Uncle Bruce
Professor Silent
link   Uncle Bruce    11 years ago

You have it backwards, the right (at least as far as is presently interpreted) was included in the "Bill of Rights" . That is why you have the right to own guns. "Natural rights" is a theory, it is not a practice. I suppose you think you have "natural" property rights too.

You may believe you have "rights" in a philosophical sense, but until they are affirmed by a controlling authority, doesn't mean a thing in practice.

You're wrong. The devil is in the details. Let's review.

The first amendment begins with "Congress shall make no law..." The very first sentance LIMITS government control on the natural right of a citizen to speak his/her/confused him/her mind, print his/her/confused him/her mind, or worship as he/she/it desires. It limit's the government's ability to control the natural right to expression.

Now, let's look at the 2nd Amendment. We wont bother arguing the first clause, SCOTUS already handled that unpopular interpretation (too bad Randy. STFU.) But lets look at the last few words: "Shall not be infringed". What shall not be infringed? Go back a few words: "The Right". Yep, the right shall not be infringed.

Now, you say that right was granted by the government. Well, where was it granted? The 2nd Amendment didn't grant it. The 2nd Amendment identified it as a right already in place. And it says "The right...Shall not be INFRINGED".

Understand, John, the Bill of Rights DOES NOT GRANT RIGHTS. They are rights you already have. The Bill of Rights PROTECTS those rights by limiting Government control.

Think of it this way John. Do you have a right to drive a car? Does the government have theauthority to control your ability to drive a car?

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

WE DO NOT NEED MORE LAWS, we only need to actually enforce the ones we already have.

WE NEED TO FUND THE ENFORCEMENT OF THE ONES WE ALREADY HAVE!!! HAVING THEM ON THE BOOKS MEANS EXACTLY SHIT IF THEIR ENFORCEMENT IS NOT FUNDED BY CONGRESS!!! AND THEY ARE NOT!!! WHAT PART OF THAT ARE YOU IGNORING???

 
 
 
Jason T
Freshman Silent
link   Jason T    11 years ago

I have spent the past two months working in the Henry county jail in Missouri. We have everything here from rapist, dealers, users, thieves and a few killers. The one inmate that disgust me the most is a lady here for kidnapping, two counts of burglary, possession, steeling a vehicle, robbery, attempted murder and serious bodily harm. Her and her nut case husband in the middle of the night made their way into some guys house knocked him out, cut open his face, tied his hands behind his back then used a torch to burn his hands trying to get his combinations for his safe. once they had broken into his safe, they left him for dead. He sat on the edge of death for about two days until his daughter came to see why she hadn't heard from him. If this gentleman had a gun he might still have his hands. You can enjoy your police protection in your big cities. Here in this county during the night shift we might have two deputies to cover the entire county. Thats including the two small small towns they have to place police officer in. So are you safer waiting for a officer to make it from the other side of county or protecting yourself.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

"Congress shall make no law..."

is a "law" itself.

"Natural rights" is a theoretical concept created by Enlightenment philosophers. If there are "natural rights" that have always existed, why is there no record or mention of the concept prior to the 17th or 18th centuries?

All "rights" that are enforced exist where there is government or some controlling authority.

Look at "property rights" . Without government you don't own any property in any legal sense. Without that authority that verifies that horse or barn or car is yours, your "ownership" of it depends on your ability to protect it. If you can't it no longer "belongs" to you.

"Natural rights" is a theory or social construct. It is not an objective reality.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    11 years ago

By the way, Churro, congratulations to you for your graduation from second grade! Good on you!

When will the fart jokes begin?

Enough James. Petey Coober has the worthless comment department pretty much covered, we don't need two of you.

You also may want to take a moment to review the NT Code of Conduct , your "2nd grade" comment to Churro is an unnecessary and unproductive CoC violation.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    11 years ago

Is the person mentally disturbed or emotionally disturbed? Were there signs pointing to abnormal behavior? Did anyone try to report it and was it ignored or did the family not have the resources to handle it?

I heard a report on CNN that the guy had discussions on line regarding what he planned to do, and that there were comments posted by people actually encouraging him to carry them out.

However, even though CNN is usually very accurate with their reporting, keep in mind the investigation is still in it's early stages, and early reports are sometimes incomplete.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    11 years ago

Do you suggest I be refused the right to have my rifle in my home, or my handgun in my car when I return to my home at night?

No, of course not. Why do you even think that?! The people that are telling you the Left Wingers are out to get your guns are lying to you. Except for a few far Left, flaming liberal, moonbat wingnuts, no one is advocating the confiscation of your firearms or the abolishment of the 2nd Amendment.

The issue is simply that there are way too many guns (350 million +-) in this nation and not hardly sufficient controls regarding who should be allowed to possess them. Many Americans live in rural setting where is a good idea to have a firearm handy, if for no other purpose than peace of mind.

Actually IMO, living 'in town' increases the need to have a firearm nearby. I too live in a very rural setting and even though I have never had, and don't expect I will ever have, the need to protect myself with it, I have no intention of ever giving up my model 336CMarlin30/30. I just feel comfortable having it around.

But none of that matters, you and I have a Right to own our firearms, and as long as we don't abuse that right by infringing on anothers Right to life and liberty, we will continue to own our firearms.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    11 years ago

WE DO NOT NEED MORE LAWS, we only need to actually enforce the ones we already have.

WE NEED TO FUND THE ENFORCEMENT OF THE ONES WE ALREADY HAVE!!! HAVING THEM ON THE BOOKS MEANS EXACTLY SHIT IF THEIR ENFORCEMENT IS NOT FUNDED BY CONGRESS!!! AND THEY ARE NOT!!! WHAT PART OF THAT ARE YOU IGNORING???

You know, Randy, that's almost exactly what most Americans feel about all the crap about "fixing" the "broken" immigration laws.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    11 years ago

The FBI says your best chance of surviving an attack by someone determined to harm you or your family is your personal means of self-protection, because depending upon law enforcement to arrive in time to save you from serious harm is unrealistic.

This is in an official FBI report that is never mentioned in any of Obama's rants about guns, or Clinton's or Biden's or anyone else's. The report goes on to tell of the number of cases where having a gun for home protection has saved lives.

When these politicians tell their personal bodyguards, and those of their family members, to throw away their guns, and walk the streets and sleep in their beds, and shop in the local stores, and visit the local theaters, and attend the local schools, the same way the rest of us do, then they can talk about strict gun control.

When they can guarantee they have removed the guns from the hands of gangs; when they have adequately funded mental health care and facilities to deal with disturbed individuals whose families cannot care for them; heck, when South Chicago can clock a full month of less than five shootings in its residential area.... then they can talk about strict gun control.

When they can explain the newly released report detailing the effects of the chemicals we use in pesticides, flame retardants, and GMO additives on the cognitive and reasoning functions of the brain, and why steps haven't been taken to remove them from our environment as they can be affecting the mental health of everyone in contact with them... then they can talk about strict gun control.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    11 years ago

Natural rights are like "human right." There is no such thing. They only exist if the ruler of the country in which you reside says they do. Otherwise, you have no rights.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

So in essence, we only have the rights a government grants us.

We are already lost.

If that is what is believed, that the government has absolute domination over all, then the ideals of the founders are dead.

And we are nothing but slaves.

I'm glad I will be dead when the revolution comes. To see the final loss of freedom and subjugation of man to government would be too much for me.

What is REAL sad, is people willingly believe they have no choice.

Yeah, in a nation founded upon individual choice.

WE, EVERYONE, in this nation has lost, that which our forefathers died to attain.

And have done so willingly, Happily in fact.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    11 years ago

It has always been that way; they have just carefully led us to believe otherwise. That's why it has taken over two centuries for the absolute corruption in Washington and local politics to become so publicized. And look at how apathetic we are about it, electing the same crooks year after year.

It's why the Electoral College was put in place at the outset of our birth as a nation and why it is the EC that actually elects the president, and NOT the people of this country.

You don't choose the members of the EC. You can't even find out who they are and every move to try and abolish it is quickly and quietly shut down.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

The government doesn't grant rights, like a gift to a child. The rights are discussed, debated, and then incorporated into the governing documents.

All I said to him is that the concept of "natural rights" is a social construct. They don't exist objectively the way the rotation of the earth exists objectively.

Does everyone have a "natural right" to say whatever they want ? In theory, yes, perhaps, in reality, no. If you live in a country that restricts speech for whatever reason , then you don't have the right to say whatever you want without repercussion. If and when the laws are changed, then you will.

You are the person who is well versed in history. I read that the concept of "natural rights" does not appear in political philosophy until the Enlightenment. If that is the case it would be hard to argue that such rights have always objectively existed.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    11 years ago

As do I, Woodie.Smile.gif

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

Then you misunderstand the enlightenment and what it represented John.

The enlightenment states that there are certain rights that man has always had since the beginning of man's existence. The Animal rights people extrapolate those right to animals as well.

The Founders, all enlightenment thinkers, (well for the most part) attempted to put them into the realm of written law.

If all rights stem from government then all rights are dead, as the enlightenment philosophy clearly states.

Just by being, a living being has rights, especially a cognizant one such as humans. If others (government) have the right to deny you yours, who has any?

No one does.

Stating that all rights extend from the good graces of organized peoples judgment is exactly the mind of a statist.

The enlightenment was a statement of man's expansion of understanding the nature of man. Humans have rights as sentient beings, always have, always will. Just because that understanding didn't come about until the 15th century doesn't mean that it didn't exist beforehand, just means that it wasn't recognized as one of the conditions of man until that time.

Humans are constantly growing and evolving, recognizing things that they didn't before. Hopefully building upon the new knowledge to a new paradigm of existence.

This nation was the great experiment because this understanding was never incorporated into the formation of a nation before. Enlightenment philosophy as a governing principle wasn't established as better and valid during the revolutionary war or with the win. What was won, was the chance to see if it IS ACTUALLY BETTER than everything that came before.

And that experiment isn't over yet.

Despite the forces that want it to be, or are willing to do away with it to go back to the old ways.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

Does someone have the "natural right" to take a brick and bash in the head of someone that annoys them ?

It doesn't get much more "natural" than that.
 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

And should be shut down. Without the electoral college, the only presidents elected would be the ones from the cities.

The electoral college was designed so one part of the population could not take control of the election process disenfranchising the rest.

Without it we would have a situation like in Upstate New York,anywhere in Washington not located outside of Puget Sound, Northern California, etc etc.

Small areas with huge populations that control the rest of the state. the founders had the foresight to see that problem on a national level and fixed it.

We lose the electoral college, we lose our freedom to the statists (liberals) inhabiting the cities and the rest of us are silenced.

And the great experiment will be over.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

And this answer John exemplifies your misunderstanding of Natural Rights. Or the enlightenment.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    11 years ago
Very well said, mimi. I particularly liked the characterization of arrogance. That's too true for the folks that want to save us from ourselves.
 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    11 years ago

Natural rights are a social construction.

In "nature" there are not rights, there are simply actions and reactions.

Of course , our rights are a good thing, but they only exist where there is government.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    11 years ago

The EC was instituted because only a handful of people in the country were educated enough to have the intelligence to evaluate the candidates and their qualifications and choose someone with the ability to guide the nation. There was no guarantee there was ever going to be a fully educated nation.

Look at us now. Every time a budget needs to be brought into line the first thing to be cut and sacrificed is education and the children, the future of the nation. At the time the idea that women had more than one fourth the brain of a man was laughable. They could not own property, in a divorce the children were automatically the property of the man... if he wanted them. If he didn't they were thrown into the street with the discarded wife, left in poverty to die of starvation and disease while the man went on to younger, richer pastures and a new family.

Votes could be bought for a shot of whiskey.

The EC had nothing at all to do with equalizing the representation of the citizens. Hell, the people elected now don't even represent the citizens.

 
 
 
Uncle Bruce
Professor Silent
link   Uncle Bruce    11 years ago

Does someone have the "natural right" to take a brick and bash in the head of someone that annoys them ?

Flip that around John. Do you have a natural right to defend yourself from someone taking a brick and trying to bash your head in?

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

Reread what I said mimi, I agree it has nothing to do with representation. it has everything to do with a fair and impartial voting procedure preventing a minority of a nation to control an entire nation because of a simple majority.

This is not a true democracy and was deliberately set up to NOT be one, because every true democracy in history has failed by the simple majority.

All voices need to be heard to be effective.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

Or, ask him this one,

Does a wolf have the natural right to kill a sheep?

Does the Sheep have a natural right to flock together in effort to stop the wolf?

Does flocking together prevent the sheep from being killed by the wolf? No, but it helps keep the number of sheep killed to a minimum.

Natural rights are those rights that everyone has just by being alive and needing to survive.

Everyone has the natural right to defend themselves from the wolves. Man is smart enough to develop tools to help him in that endeavor.

What John advocates is taking away the most efficient tool available to do the job, but to do that, he has to destroy the basis for possession of the tool first. Our natural right to defend ourselves.

You think a wolf isn't going to use hie most efficient weapon in defending himself? (his teeth and powerful jaws?)

Of course he will. What John is advocating is that we need to remove the Wolf's teeth cause they are too efficient at doing their job. Then the wolf can flock like sheep, cause that is the only defense they will have left.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    11 years ago

By the law of Nature, the wolf has the natural right to kill the sheep.

But the people who have gathered the sheep, upon sighting the wolf and before the wolf can even take his meal, will kill the wolf, denying him his natural right and justifying their murder by saying it is THEIR right to harvest the sheep.

Do the sheep have a natural right to flock together in an effort to stop the wolf?

The laws of nature say they do. But the people who have gathered the sheep will often force one of them from the flock, stake it out as bait, and wait for the wolf to kill it, thereby being a party to murder because the people are outside the law of Nature.

So where is the "natural right except where it is expressly given by the government which presides over the man? If that government says, "You may not kill the wolf.. he is protected by law as an endangered species," then the man has no right.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

And you only have those rights which you can defend.

Sheep have very few rights allowed by others.

Wolves fave a few more cause they are capable of defending some of them, probably a lot more if they were even more sentient.

Humans are capable of defending most of them, except from other people.

The natural order makes up for that with genetic adaptation.

But man has been manipulating genetics for millenia.

So I guess by the laws of nature making Man even more sentient than any other animal has caused man to rise above the animal world.

The only thing we have to fear and respect in our environment is other humans.

Natural law and natural rights go hand in hand.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    11 years ago

NM,

If you haven't seen the TV series Zoo, give it a view.

When the animal kingdom awakens, and the animals unite to mend the rip in the fabric of the laws of nature, man is no longer the "apex predator."

Natural law asserts itself and "natural rights" of man are nothing but a forgotten has-been joke. Even now, Nature is pushing her "Reset" buttons... storms, floods, droughts, wildfires, mutations, erratic and abnormal animal behavior, erratic and abnormal human behavior (more so than ever), new and once thought extinct animal and plant species discovered, scientific theories of human evolution and migration once thought immutable being proved in error...

man has no "natural" or "human rights" except those accorded him by the government under which he lives.

Ask any Muslim, anyone in China, anyone living under the rule of an African war lord, a gay person living in Russia...

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

We are going to have to differ on this one mimi, man is subject to the same natural laws all the critters on the planet are, and all critters are slaves to mother nature.

But as far as governments, people are subject to them as long as they choose to be. And all those governmental bodies you use as proof, destroy those to disagree with them by rule.

So ergo sum, you are intimating that the US government is no different. But governments are made up of the people that live under them. some by consent, some by force.

But in all cases they are formed and exist by the choice of the people that allow them to rule instead of govern.

This nation is not supposed to be that way. At least not the ideal it was founded upon.

But unfortunately there are a lot of people that think it has become such a government.

I being one of them.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    11 years ago

(smile)

NW, we are using different terms, I think.

There is a difference between natural law, and natural right. It is the term "right" that I have issue with.

No person nor animal has a "right" to anything unless the government of that country in which the human or animal lives bestows it upon them.

We have a Constitution that we feels bestows us with "certain unalienable rights; among them life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness."

Yet during the writing of this document and for over a century afterward there were both white and black slaves who were not accorded either liberty nor the pursuit of any happiness. Even today we cannot agree what the term means. Therefore we have a government that bestows upon us ITS determination what that term means and what it will grant us within ITS determination of that meaning.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

mimi said,

We have a Constitution that we feels bestows us with "certain unalienable rights; among them life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness."

I have to disagree as a matter of course with this statement. we do not have a Constitution that says any such thing.

We do have a Declaration of Independence that does though.

Your confusing two documents sweets. The first documents is a clear statement of the founders ideals on the rights of man in the colonies and how they felt about the dictates of the government in England.

The second document written fifteen years later is a statement of how to effectuate a government based upon the ideals of the first. (given that the first attempt to create a government on those principles failed so miserably)

That the constitution as written is a flawed document is plain. but one has to understand the times it was written in. The constitutional convention wasn't a group of people with a strongly held idea of purpose like the continental congress was. Second they were actually operating outside the articles of confederation, illegally I might add. If the government under the articles of confederation were stronger they would have arrested all the constitutional convention participants as traitors.

I'm sure if the constitution was written by Jefferson, instead of Madison it would have been much clearer, also if Jefferson had participated in the convention there wouldn't have been as many flaws.

But fifteen years after those words you quote, powerful commercial interests were already building in the nation. the flaws of that document (the constitution) are all based upon commercial interests. Jefferson no less view the commerce clause as the worst flaw of the whole document, stating that it gave more rights to the wealthy to eventually pervert it's intent. He was right. Jefferson also took great umbrage at the 3/5ths clause and the fact that it did not banish slavery outright.

In the context of the times it is easily said that the Constitution does not rise to the level of enlightenment the Declaration of Independence does. There are just too many compromises.

But in no place does the constitution say anything about life liberty and the pursuit of happiness.

Your juxtaposing the purpose of two different documents.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    11 years ago

But in no place does the constitution say anything about life liberty and the pursuit of happiness.

That's true, as you said, that comment is in theDeclaration. But the Declaration only declares for the pursuit of happiness, you have to catch it on you own.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    11 years ago

You are correct NM.. and I chastised someone else for doing that a few months ago.

I would like my Humble Pie with cold milk, please. Smile.gif

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    11 years ago

While I consume NM's Humble Pie, Jerry, you can ready the stake and kindling... don't forget the torches to light the fire.Smile.gif

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    11 years ago

When these politicians tell their personal bodyguards, and those of their family members, to throw away their guns,

(?!)

What politician or politicians are saying any such thing!!!??

Time and time again in these discussions have I and others had to say;

"NO ONE IS ADVOCATING ORDECLARINGTHAT AMERICANS SHOULD NOT HAVE A RIGHT TO OWN AND/ORCARRY A FIREARM!

We have a Right to defend ourselves, we have a Right to own firearms. No one is disputing that. The problem is Americans do not have to demonstrate they are sufficiently mentallyand psychologically stable, so as to insure they to be trusted with a firearm.

Of course we cannot stop all crackpots from obtaining guns, but it's clear that something must be done to reduce the ever increasing carnage occurring in our country.

I cannot understand why you waste your time arguing against a threat that does not exist. The problem is too many unstable people have been able to acquire firearms and go on killing sprees, and we as society have an obligation to do something about that problem.

It seems to me that gun owners should be running point on improving the controls regarding screening those that are not sufficiently stable to own a firearm. Because, as sure as this Republic was formed by a group of liberals debating in that room in Independence Hall, the liberals of today will get sufficient BG checks and other screens in place in order to reduce the gun violence in this country. IMO, it would be in the best interest of gun owners to help shape the reforms that are sure to come,sooner rather than later.

The question is not a matter of being pro-gun or anti-gun, the question is are you pro-violence or are you anti-violence?

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    11 years ago

Jason,

Christopher Merrill: " Avoid posting long stretches of unbroken text. Users will shy away from reading your material,...... " - See more :

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    11 years ago

Jerry, you can ready the stake and kindling... don't forget the torches to light the fire. Smile.gif

I don't have time for bon-firesrightnow, anyway they cause unnecessary carbonemissions.

What I do have the time for is to read your response to this comment;

" I cannot understand why you waste your time arguing against a threat that does not exist. The problem is too many unstable people have been able to acquire firearms and go on killing sprees, and we as society have an obligation to do something about that problem. "

And to this comment:

" We have a Right to defend ourselves, we have a Right to own firearms. No one is disputing that. The problem is Americans do not have to demonstrate they are sufficiently mentallyand psychologically stable, so as to insure they to be trusted with a firearm. "

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    11 years ago

Very eloquently said Mimi. Many gun grabbers do not care of our freedoms our persuit of happiness that is guarrenteed in the Constitution.

" Gun grabbers " ... Really?!

In the first place, people that are advocating for better BG checks and better screening for people with unstable mentalities, are NOTadvocatingfor any gunconfiscations. You all should stop fighting a threat that doesn'texist, and help to the address the real problem of crackpots with firearms!

In the second place the Right to Pursue Happiness is not mentioned in theConstitution, it's only written in the Declaration of Independence .

But if you want to go there, how about, " We hold these truths to be self-evident, that ....... [all people] are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit..... "?

When the wrong people get their hands on a gun they often use that gun to impose on the life and liberty of other people, sometimes even taking the life of people.

Why are you in favor of protecting the Rights of a few unbalanced people to possess firearms and allowing them to become a threat to the other320 million Americans? Why?!

Does that really make good sense to you? You are one of the people that will be better protected if we improve the screening for gun ownership.

You've got to look at this problem through a different perspective Woodie .

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    11 years ago

I particularly liked the characterization of arrogance.

You would, you'retheNT Poster Boy of arrogance.

The people that want to 'save us from ourselves' are simply trying to keep guns out of the hands of crackpots. You seem awfully upset about the potential of that happening, are you concerned you would be deemed unfit to be trusted with a firearm?

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    11 years ago

Think of it this way John. Do you have a right to drive a car?

Only on your own property.

To be allowed to drive on public roads is considered aprivilege.

If your licence to drive is revoked, it is said that your driving 'privileges' have be been revoked.

Does the government have theauthority to control your ability to drive a car?

Yes. At least when it comes to driving on public roads and highways.

The government builds the roads, and the government sets the rules and regulations regarding what standards must be met in order to drive on them.

 
 

Who is online







95 visitors