The GOP might soon reconsider if they see the implications of refusing to allow Obama to replace Scalia
"...the GOP might soon reconsider if they see the implications of refusing to allow Obama to replace Scalia: A divided court leaves lower court rulings in place. And the lower courts are blue . Nine of the 13 U.S. Courts of Appeals have a majority of Democratic appointees. That means liberal rulings conservatives were hoping the Supreme Court would overturn remain law. So if Scalia had cast the deciding vote on a case before he died, but the court rehears it and divides 4 to 4, that would leave the lower court decision in place. That’s what would happen with a proposal to apportion Congress in an entirely new way that would heavily favor Republican districts, which was argued recently. The lower court (in this case a district court which went directly to the Supreme Court for technical reasons) tossed the plan out; conservatives had been hoping the justices would restore it.
Most ofthe country is governed by appeals courts dominated by Democrats. The suit against Obama’s environmental initiative, which the Supreme Court just stayed , came from the liberal D.C. Circuit, which had unanimously refused to grant the stay. Now the Obama administration can simply have the Environmental Protection Agency come up with a slightly different new plan and run to the liberal D.C. courts to bless it and refuse to stay it. It’s unlikely the now-divided Supreme Court would come up with a majority to stay the new rules: The vote to stay the old ones was (naturally) 5 to 4.
That’s why the effect of an equally divided court has enormous potential to strengthen Obama’s hand in dealing with the Republican Senate in picking a replacement: Even if the GOP blocks his nominee, the policy outcomes would be very similar to what they’d be if the court had a liberal majority. "
Tags
Who is online
105 visitors

The right would rather lose on the substance than give Obama anything. They've been that way for 7 years, why change now ?
John
Is it at all possible that people on the right, left and in the middle might view the delay of the SCOTUS appointment until the new president is seated as a referendum on what "we the people" want the court to look like and thus a valid issue in the election and likely to motivate higher turnout of the electorate regardless of party affiliation?
Obama will be the president for almost another year. It is pretty outrageous that the Senate will not hold hearings on the nomination to replace Scalia. The country is being brainwashed to accept such though.
"In the wake of Antonin Scalia's sudden death, the Beltway press almost immediately began to seamlessly frame the unfolding debate about the Supreme Court Justice's replacement along the contours of Republican talking points. To do so, the press continued its habit of looking away from the GOP's stunning record of institutional obstructionism since 2009.
..The framework for much of the coverage regarding the GOP's radical demand that Scalia's seat sit empty for a year is this: It's Obama's behavior that's setting off a showdown, and of course Republicans would categorically oppose anyone Obama nominates. But journalists often don't explain why: Why is it obvious Obama would have zero chance of getting a Supreme Court nominee confirmed when every president in the past has been able to fill vacancies?
It is unusual for a president to face a Supreme Court vacancy his final year in office? It is. But there's nothing in the Constitution to suggest the rules change under the current circumstances. (Obama still has 50 weeks left in office.) It's Republicans who have declared that all new rules must apply. And it's the press that has rather meekly accepted the extreme premise.
Note that Republicans and their conservative fans in the media aren't telling Obama that a particular nominee he selects to become the next justice is flawed and will likely be rejected after hearings are held. Republicans are telling Obama that there's no point in even bothering to make a selection because the Senate will reject anyone the president names. Period. The seat will remain vacant for an entire year. That is the definition of radical. But the press still looks away.
...But Obama faces no real "choice," and he isn't the one who decided to pick a "fight." As president of the United States he's obligated to fill Supreme Court vacancies.
The New York Times stressed Scalia's death had sparked "an immediate partisan battle," suggesting the warfare ran both ways. But how, by doing what he's supposed to do as president, is Obama sparking a "partisan battle"?
If Obama eventually decided to nominate an extremely liberal justice to replace the extremely conservative Scalia, then yes, that could accurately be described as sparking a "partisan battle." But what could be "partisan" about the president simply doing what the Constitution instructs him to do?
...Again and again, the press has depicted Obama's expected action in the wake of Scalia's death as being highly controversial or partisan, when in fact it's Republicans who are acting in erratic ways by categorically announcing they'll refuse to even consider Obama's next Supreme Court pick.
The sad part is this type of media acquiescence has become a hallmark of the Obama era. Republicans have routinely obliterated Beltway precedents when it comes to granting Obama the leeway that previous presidents were given by their partisan foes in Congress."
If it were 4 or 5 months closer to the election you might have a better point. It is a year until Obama will leave office.
John
Ok I see your point
What are the chances that President Obama could nominate a moderate that might have appeal to both sides of the aisle.
I agree with you that is "pure politics" to not want the conservative/liberal composition/leaning of the court to change, but it is also "pure politics" to want to configure the court to further one's own agenda.
Would you agree?
Nominate a moderate like Roberts or kennedy and the senate will seat him. Nominate a third highly partisan liberal and the senate has every right to withold its consent. Ask chuck schumer, He made it clear the democrats wouldn't confirm a bush nominee after 2007.
If and when the Republicans refuse to give a hearing to the Obama nominee , they will set in motion Democratic refusal to approve a Republican nominee should Cruz or trump become president.
As for nominating a moderate, maybe so, but it would have to be a liberal leaning moderate, which is not Roberts or Kennedy.
The Republicans will of course be following the example of the Democrats. As Kevin Williamson wrote today:
"The belief that the Constitution says whatever it is that Democrats want it to say at any given moment is illegitimate as a legal philosophy for Supreme Court justices. Democrats long ago established that ideological disagreement is a perfectly valid reason for blocking a Supreme Court appointee. Senator Schumer spelled out the political case for preventing a lame-duck president from filling a vacancy. Senator Obama demonstrated the technique
Your rules, gentlemen. Your rules."
Nominate a moderate like Roberts or kennedy and the senate will seat him.
I happen to agree with Sean on this. I think the American public want moderation, too. Of course all nominees to the SCOTUS are trojan horses. You never know what you are going to get, until they get in the job.
Roberts is not a moderate, he he extremely pro-corporate.
Kennedy is seen as a swing vote, but I believe his votes tend consistently to the "right".
Not impressed with his pick of Sonia Sodomizer so it wouldn't bother me if we wait until someone who doesn't hate America can make the pick.
Sonya Sodomizer
Not that good at spelling are ya?