Two Arizona congressional representatives are angry that President Barack Obama has intervened to prevent sacred Apache land from being sold off to foreign business interests, according to Tucson Weekly .
Republican Congressman Paul Gosar had joined forces with Democratic U.S. Rep. Ann Kirkpatrick in an effort to sell off the ancestral Native American land, known as Oak Flat or Chi’chil Bildagoteel to the Apache community, to mining firm Resolution Copper, owned by an Australian-British corporation. According to the New York Times , it would have been the first time in history Native American lands would have been handed over to a foreign company by Congress.
The land was set to be handed over due to last-minute language added to a must-pass military spending bill. But according to the Weekly, the Obama administration prevented that from happening. The site has long been used for Apache coming-of-age ceremonies, particularly for girls.
“This fraudulent action is the latest in a long list of egregious bureaucratic abuses of power by the Obama Administration. I will continue to fight this overreach,” Gosar wrote in a statement.
“Shame on the Park Service and Forest Service for ramming a bogus historic place listing down the throats of Arizonans,” Gosar continued. “Clearly, the Obama Administration cares more about pandering to extremist environmental groups and a D.C. lobbyist from the Clinton Administration than following the law and listening to the American public.”
In response to the proposed sale of the publicly-held ancestral grounds, the Apache people had been occupying the land, according to the Times. About 300 people marched 44 miles from tribal headquarters to occupy the site, beginning on February 9.
“Why is this place sacred?” Wendsler Nosie Sr., former chairman of the San Carlos Apache, told Cronkite News. “No difference to Mount Sinai. How the holy spirit came to be.”
Scientists for the Society for American Archaeology corroborate this, and testified before Congress that archaeological evidence of Apache occupation and use of the site go back before recorded history.
Gosar claims it is not a holy site, despite Apache claims to it and historical evidence.
“Oak Flat has never been a sacred site, as confirmed by the local tribe’s own former historian,” Gosar wrote. “Yet, Obama’s minions are hell-bent on sabotaging an important mining effort by listing a small, public campground 20 miles away from the nearest tribe’s reservation as a historic site.”
But the Times said the sale of the land was corrupt.
“If Oak Flat were a Christian holy site, or for that matter Jewish or Muslim, no senator who wished to remain in office would dare to sneak a backdoor deal for its destruction into a spending bill — no matter what mining-company profits or jobs might result,” the Times’ Lydia Millet notes. “But this is Indian religion. Clearly the Arizona congressional delegation isn’t afraid of a couple of million conquered natives.”
Millet called it a “new low” in congressional corruption.
But as of now, the site will remain under federal protection and listed under the National Register of Historic Places, according to the Weekly.
“Oak Flat, known to us Chi’chil Bildagoteel, has always been our connection to our Mother, our right to exist, a central part of our prayers, songs, stories and spiritual practices. It is from here that we emerged. It is who we are,” Nosie wrote in a press release. “Chi’chil Bildagoteel, our holy land, was put under the care of the U.S. government, and because of its uniqueness, the great value of maintaining its ecological and cultural integrity, protected by its laws.”


"“Shame on the Park Service and Forest Service for ramming a bogus historic place listing down the throats of Arizonans,” Gosar continued. “Clearly, the Obama Administration cares more about pandering to extremist environmental groups and a D.C. lobbyist from the Clinton Administration than following the law and listening to the American public.”
These two pieces of shit need to have their azzes in jail - with some of the Indian prisoners they've placed there.
"Bogus historic place"????? What's so bogus 'bout 20,000 years???
Guess the politico's are running NT for now - sorry 'bout a story of true interest.
Oh man, McCain and Flake retirement is ''gone with the wind''....
This is great news.
What about Kirkpatrick and Gosar?
Democrat and Republican
Looks like the tribe was getting screwed from both sides....
Although being named Kirkpatrick doesn't get any further mention.....
So i guess Democrat vaseline is ok. (we just won't mention it)
I'm happy the tribe keeps their land and one shafting is cut off before it started.
Maybe we can start a progression.
Being screwed is bi-partisan for Indians.
This is the type of thing I was mentioning in my comment on your other article, 1stwarrior; whenever someone talks about the "dependency" of the American Indian on the government.
The government is much more dependent on American Indian resources... and the kicker is the US government keeps it under wraps that these resources are being sold and leased (for 99 years at a time) to FOREIGN INTERESTS, not for the good of American citizens, as is slyly insinuated in order to rile the people against Indians and their resources.
Girl, corruption riles me wherever it is found. no matter who is doing it to who.
Greed and the abuses it leads to needs to be exposed everywhere it is found ESPECIALLY where government is complicit in it.
Just do me a favor and keep it balanced. The Democrats were just as much a part of this corruption as the Republicans were.
Girl, corruption riles me wherever it is found. no matter who is doing it to who.
Greed and the abuses it leads to needs to be exposed everywhere it is found ESPECIALLY where government is complicit in it.
Just do me a favor and keep it balanced. The Democrats were just as much a part of this corruption as the Republicans were.
Boy, I believe the article states that BOTH a Republican AND a Democrat were involved in this despicable underhanded back room deal.
AND, I did not specify a political party in my comment, NWM.... I definitely stated "the government" which includes every fricking member of Congress regardless of the party involved.
Evidently you have a reading comprehension problem today. They have both medicine and therapy for that these days....
I don't have a reading comprehension problem I referenced two things in my comment to you.
Your comment and the original posting that inspired your comment.
The response is broken into two separate parts, that of agreeing with you about corruption, and exposing it where ever it rears it ugly head. Also, bringing it back to the original article which seems to go light on one political side.
Nowhere did I say you were light on one political side. But still, the article is.
Maybe we both have the same problem, ya think?
Nothin but love for ya sweets.
Two Arizona congressional representatives are angry that President Barack Obama has intervened to prevent sacred Apache land from being sold off to foreign business interests, according to Tucson Weekly .
Republican Congressman Paul Gosar had joined forces with Democratic U.S. Rep. Ann Kirkpatrick in an effort to sell off the ancestral Native American land, known as Oak Flat or Chi’chil Bildagoteel to the Apache community, to mining firm Resolution Copper, owned by an Australian-British corporation.
This is what I was referring to; it's in the body of the article.
Have a nice evening, NWM.
Gosar claims it is not a holy site, despite Apache claims to it and historical evidence.
“Oak Flat has never been a sacred site, as confirmed by the local tribe’s own former historian,” Gosar wrote. “Yet, Obama’s minions are hell-bent on sabotaging an important mining effort by listing a small, public campground 20 miles away from the nearest tribe’s reservation as a historic site.”
Asshole!
This is the type of thing I was mentioning in my comment on your other article, 1stwarrior; whenever someone talks about the "dependency" of the American Indian on the government.
The government is much more dependent on American Indian resources... and the kicker is the US government keeps it under wraps that these resources are being sold and leased (for 99 years at a time) to FOREIGN INTERESTS, not for the good of American citizens, as is slyly insinuated in order to rile the people against Indians and their resources.
I just had to repost this since you said it so perfectly Mimi. Who stealing from who?
Just for the heck of it, here is a counter opinion
Oak Flat is a sacred site? It never was before
Former tribe historian: An mining shaft was built there in the 1970s with no protest from the tribe.
It was with great interest that my son, who just graduated from Arizona State University, showed me a recent story regarding the controversy around Oak Flat, near the small mining town of Superior.
As a San Carlos tribal member and Apache historian, I was surprised by some of the misinformation contained within the op-ed.
My book, “The History of the San Carlos Apache,” published by the San Carlos Apache Historic and Cultural Preservation Office in 1997, offers a much different perspective. There has not been a long history of ceremonial or cultural activities such as Sunrise or Holy Ground ceremonies taking place at Oak Flat.
From my personal perspective, the thought of having such a ceremony at Oak Flat, far from the support of relatives, clan members and friends in the San Carlos tribal area is almost unthinkable.
My uncle, who lived in Superior, would regularly attend most tribal ceremonies. He would travel to the San Carlos Apache reservation or the White Mountain Apache reservation. I attended my first tribal Sunrise ceremony at Cibecue, in the White Mountains; the idea of having a sunrise ceremony at Oak Flat was never considered.
Such an event requires the support of family, relatives and friends plus the input of the medicine man or spiritual person who performs the complex ceremony. He has much to say about the site, and choosing the right place is important because the dance often becomes a community event.
Evidently the person who wrote the op-ed didn’t have much knowledge on what the ceremony involves in commitment, logistics and preparation.
In 1970, the Magma Copper Company built a mine shaft on Oak Flat that you can see from the passing highway. No member of the San Carlos Apache Tribe said anything about it being a sacred site. I know because I was living in Superior at the time. Some tribal people from San Carlos even talked about getting employment with the mine.
There were no protests, no publicity of any kind. Why not? If this area was sacred, wouldn’t opposition arise many years before today? There was never any statement made by tribal members or tribal leadership.
It wasn’t until recent years that the site of Oak Flat was called sacred in any kind of way. All one has to do is examine the records to see if the word sacred was ever used for the site.
However, the real truth about speaking out with an opinion on Oak Flat contrary to the tribal government’s stance is fear. People working for the tribe will often say (to me and others) that if they go against what the tribal council supports, they will be fired.
Dale Miles of San Carlos is a member and former tribal historian of the San Carlos Apache Tribe. (Photo: handout)
Does it not bother anyone that rarely do we hear a voice of someone on the street who doesn’t support tribal government’s view on Oak Flat? If people have a different opinion on a subject they should not have to be called traitors or be accused of being against their own people.
Before making any kind of judgment on a subject of importance, all the facts should be studied and examined to the utmost for the good of all concerned.
Dale Miles of San Carlos is a member and former tribal historian of the San Carlos Apache Tribe.
This article perhaps places a different perspective on the location of Oaks Flat, but there is also another way of looking at it as well.
Indians well know that what starts out as mining anywhere around their reservations, especially by foreign interests, has a tendency to expand with the federal government confiscating reservation land to accommodate the expansion in the name of "public interest." It just doesn't specify that it isn't the American public that has the interest.
In addition, heavy mining, as we have seen in the media lately and read in articles here on NT, is not regulated properly nor overseen with any foresight given to the immediate nor the future health of the surrounding people living in the area nor of the environment.
Especially with foreign interests, they ravage, destroy and pollute the land both above and below ground beyond redemption then leave without the local people being able to recover either their health nor their finances from the devastation, nor will the federal or state governments do anything but say it is "out of their hands."
Perhaps the only protection the Indians have discovered they have in the courts or on Capitol Hill is to proclaim "sacred land" and hope for the best in the way the governments.... local, state and federal... claim "imminent domain" and steal from all of us giving us no recourse.
What' good for the goose....
In addition, John, historical and scientific evidence shows that the Apache did use the site as sacred ground.
So this author gave a single opinion opposing two bodies whose testimony before Congressional hearings influenced the decision..... TWICE!
And the senators who keep trying to do the back door deal on this land KNOW the history on it which is why they keep trying to do it in the dead of night, behind closed doors; and the resources must be worth billions with millions going into their off-shore accounts since both Republican and Democrat white trash are willing to crawl into the gutter together to get it done.
May they all burn in their Christian hellfire after they have endured the torture of the Oriental Curse of the Thousand Cuts (it may One Hundred Cuts, I'm so ticked off I didn't take time to refresh my memory).
Better yet, wasn't it the Apache who used to bury the enemy up to their necks near an ant bed and pour honey over the head?
That works for me... where can we find the damn Senators?????
Thank you, President Obama.
At least this was stopped. I'm so glad, and hope that this will signal a change in the way the government treats our Indian friends.
I know, and can understand the Indian point of view, and only hope that my comment does not offend, in any way. It was made sincerely. It is LONG past due for a change.
Dowser,
He has blocked this despicable deal twice from four different senators hell-bent on selling this land to foreign interests.
Isn't it amazing that Indians are prohibited from selling their land or even leasing it to anyone but the US government (they can't even sell or lease it to US businesses) but the government (individual US senators at that) can sell or lease it out from under them in back-room deals?
Amazing is not the word I would choose. I would choose patently unfair, not right, wrong, horrendous, etc...
But then, that is me. I stand beside all of you. Always.
Let's get a few thing straight....First off Oak Flat is part of the Tonto National Forest, set up by Teddy Roosevelt and Oak Flat has been protected by a number of U.S. Presidents, including Richard Nixon.
Remember this is the people land, not a politicians. It's a National Forest.
Next up Kirkpatrick lost her election when she first sponsored this bill, I believe that it was 2010. She has since been reelected.
It was Rep. Paul Grijialva (dem AZ) that introduced HR2811 to stop the land transfer to Resolution Mining (a foreign corporation)
It was Senator Bernie Sanders (I) that sponsored a bill in the senate to stop this land transfer.
Mr. Sanders wife will be visiting Oak Flat, March 13th and meeting with the San Carlos Apache and the White Mountain Apache.
Within Oak Flat, is an area called, ''Apache Leap'', a little study of history will tell you that Apache Warriors jumped from this cliff instead of surrendering to the U.S. Army after decades of battling them.
I do not know Mr. Miles, but I do know member of both the San Carlos and White Mountain Apache and they have a much different opinion than Mr. Miles
In the end, two Senators, both republican, slide this rider in at the 11th hour on the DOD bill.
That is what is called padding your pockets at the expense of the American people.
It's the American peoples land folks. It doesn't belong to McCain or Flake or any other politician.
I know you told us this before, Kavika, when this Oak Flats deal came up with McCain, but I forgot. Thanks for the reminder.
(Still think all the Senators should be buried near the ant bed up to the neck with honey poured over the head....
Fire ants.
Yes!! Fire ants!!
I will bring the Q-tips so we can swab the inside of their ear canal with the honey....
(see, some people think I'm kidding here, but bury them in the desert and watch me... evil deserves no consideration and what they are doing for their own greed is evil. Greed is one of the Seven Deadly Sins found in all spiritual beliefs.)
I don't think you're kidding and neither am I. Just don't forget to swab some honey up their noses too.
OK, this is scary...
we are agreeing on everything here and that's .... well... we're friends, but we don't usually go all the way like this. Should we get a room?
Only so we can watch the whole process via remote camera, with microphones on the scene of course. Image, ear canals and sinus' filled with Fire ants!
You're right. Usually we've disagreed on something by now!
LOL....
I know. How about this "Why don't all you Native 'mericans go back where you came from!" lol
The last time someone told me to go back to where I came from, I moved into their house.
ROFLMAO....
LLAP, Kavika!!!!
When I started inviting all my rellies to my new/old house, the neighborhood got kind of upset. Especially when I started yelling, ''we're home again''.....LOL
''we're home again''.....LOL
The next relative it happens to, be sure to invite me to the block party....
The last time someone told me to go back to where I came from, I moved into their house.
Well, we can't have that. What would the neighbors say to NA's in the Southern CA desert?
Well, we can't have that. What would the neighbors say to NA's in the Southern CA desert?
LOLOLOLOLOL...
You guys have been such good medicine for my soul the last few days. Thank you!
I'm co opting the Tea Party motto....''Take Back Our Country''....
I'm co opting the Tea Party motto....''Take Back Our Country''.
Works for me... I have war pony and firearm, where and when do we meet?
Meet us at O dark thirty at the corner of here and there streets.
Wouldn't it be neat to watch some being anally introduced???? WOW!!!!!!
Wouldn't it be neat to watch some being anally introduced???? WOW!!!!!
LOL...
1stwarrior, it is easy to see why your Tribe sent DeSoto running for their boats...
And, he did die as a result of our "meeting" - Oooops - did I say that?
And, he did die as a result of our "meeting" - Oooops - did I say that?
Hey, when you deserve bragging rights, take the bow...
Here is another situation involving the Tohono O'odham tribe. Yup, a copper mine and a foreign corporation. Oh yes, it's Arizona again.
Seems that we sell of our land to foreign entities and they benefit from it and leave a mess behind.
Arizona...
given to the Indians because it was "wasteland" nobody wanted three centuries ago.....
first it was the water rights that were stolen when the settlers saw how the Indians created "ditches" to divert enough water to grow crops to feed themselves....
.....now it's the mineral rights....
We sell to foreign entities, sometimes shadow corporations created by greedy US businessmen who want to get around the federal requirements (lame as they are) for maintaining any controls on pollution. The requirements are even more lax (or non-existent) for foreign corporations, or the foreign corps ignore them and keep putting off court proceedings until they have extracted all they want from the mines.. then they run for their home land and the protection of their own nationalities and courts.
The US businessmen who created joint ventures with them are also protected by calling it a "foreign investment." And who allows all this rot and gangrene within our government structure?
Why, the US Supreme Court and the laws they uphold... when they deign to hear a case, that is. The Supreme Court has too much power and little to no oversight. It was not supposed to be this way. It is outside the laws and morals of this country and its people and needs to be redefined and restructured to reflect some protection for the people of the United States of America, including American Indians and their holdings.
Bernie’s Wife, Jane Sanders, Visits Oak Flat
by Levi RickertPhoto courtesy: Nicholet Deschine Parkhurst
Published March 14, 2016
OAK FLAT —The 2016 presidential campaign stopped by Indian Country yesterday, Sunday, March 13, as Jane Sanders, the wife of Democratic presidential candidate U.S. Senator Bernie Sanders made a visit to Oak Flat.
Leaders and tribal citizens of the San Carlos Apache Tribe of Arizona welcomed her to Oak Flat, which has been a source of controversy because of federal legislation that will allow a copper mine to be constructed and operated on the sacred ground. Oak Flat is a site of immense religious and historical meaning, awe-inspiring scenery, and vital to the spiritual life of the Apache people.is of special importance to Senator Sanders.
In November Senator Sanders introduced a bill, the Save Oak Flat Bill, to repeal the land transfer to the mining conglomerate, which was slipped in, through backroom deals, as a midnight rider to the must-pass NDAA in the end of 2014.
“I’m so excited that presidential candidate Bernie Sanders’ wife, Jane, has committed to visit Oak Flat to discuss the occupation by the Stronghold,” stated San Carlos Apache Tribal Council Member Wendsler Nosie, Sr. last week.
“Federal policies must change for us and all Americans in this country in order to secure the future for those yet to be born. We must not lose these holy places, for they are the fabric of who we are to Mother Earth.”
Ms. Sanders’ visit came just two days after the National Park Service announced Friday that it has listed Oak Flat on the National Register of Historic Places.
Kavika,
Since this underhanded deal has been tried two times in less than a year by a collaboration of both parties and had to be stopped by no less than Presidential intervention, I fear what will happen with the change of regime in the administration.
Would that there were some way for the president to find a solution to permanently barring the sale of this land at any time in the future.
It is nauseating beyond comprehension that Native Americans must every day of their lives wake with the sunrise and cry with the rising moon, wondering every minute of their existence which piece of themselves and their history and culture will be missing, stolen as the darkness infesting Washington steals even the shade of honest shadows, leaving only the oily abyss of nothingness to hide the evil and greed that prevades our government.
Would that the Weendigo of the Ojibwe come forth to stalk America, until its appetite is sated with the filth of perverted souls no longer fit to be called "human" in the context in which we claim it. I would wish for Stone Hand and his Sacred Wolves, but this endeavor may require the monster... to deal with the monsters.
Meet us at O dark thirty at the corner of here and there streets.
The Weendigo's are waiting in the wings and they are very hungry, Mimi.
Bring them on - they are surely needed.
We could always do the Annie get your gun routine.
I always thought that it was absolute insanity to exchange raped land for good land.
The issue with this stuff is that the actual sale/lease took place generations ago, all they are doing is a land exchange. Good land with bountiful resources being exchanged for land that has been raped and exploited to the point it's worth nothing. I mean you can't build houses on it cause it is so polluted that nothing can live there. Nothing grows on it not even scrub cactus. It suffers from erosion that clogs waterways for hundred of miles downstream. carrying heavy metals which make the land infertile. (along with the biological disaster that propagates from such)
AND IT IS PUBLIC LAND! This is the stuff the EPA was supposed to stop!
Doesn't matter who is in power in Congress.
The rape of America.
It's an issue that crosses all political demarcations.
If that isn't worth fighting over then what is?
" The land has been home to Indigenous Peoples since pre-historic times, according to the Forest Service. “A twenty-year struggle with the U.S. Army ensued (approximately 1866-1886), resulting in the removal of both the Apache and Yavapai to reservations at San Carlos and Fort Apache. Today the White Mountain and San Carlos Apache reservations border the forest on the east with the Tonto Apache Reservation located inside the forest at Payson, and the Fort McDowell Yavapai Reservation situated along the southwest edge. The Apache in particular still use the forest for gathering wild plants and other traditional practices. ”
Read more at " The most important historic site is called the Apache Leap, where a group of Apache who were being pursued by U.S. cavalry plunged off a cliff to their deaths rather than be captured. The land exchange rider exempts Apache Leap from becoming part of the copper mine, but it’s right next door, says Vernelda Grant, who is the tribal historic preservation officer for the San Carlos Apache Tribe. She says that having a working copper mine next to the site will change how people experience it. The same holds true for other culturally sensitive sites nearby, such as a place called Devil’s Canyon “where the spiritual beings that represent healing live,” Grant says. “We have songs and ceremonies that are sung there—it’s a place to just pray and pray for healing. ” - - and Gosar sez the land has never been used?????1stwarrior...
This comment is to assure you in all sincerity, that it would not surprise me to wake one morning and find Mt. Rushmore was sold to a foreign entity, already half demolished, because a precious mineral was found to be lurking within the faces, and that an "expert" has testified before Congress (who approved the deal) that the site was never a special monument to the American people and the faces engraved there were of no historical relevance to America.
(I will forego any discussion here my feelings of how the mountain should never have been desecrated with those faces and how they should be blasted away as they are more offensive and demeaning to American Indians than a Confederate Flag could ever be to a Black person, especially as the monument was placed so in-your-face and on sacred land.)