Wiles : We have been taken over. We have been taken over. Bakker : Aren’t you afraid to say that? Wiles : No! They are going to kill us, Jim! My God Jim, they are going to kill us some day! They kill us now or later, when do you want to die? When do you want to die, later or now? Bakker : But the church is denying what you’re saying. I know it’s true. You know it’s true. But the church don’t want to hear that. Wiles : I’ve got a granddaughter, two years old. I am not surrendering this nation to Muslims!
Although it is wrong to say or even think that just because a person is a Muslim he is a danger to the community, it is just as wrong to whitewash fundamentalist extremist Islamists and say they are not Muslims, as Obama tends to do.
And, in fact, Americans are more inclined to disagree with Obama on this point. A Pew ... with that statement. Obama 's statement that the Islamic State " is not Islamic " will surely ...
Throughout his presidency, President Obama has emphasized one point while talking about Islamist extremists: They are not practicing Islam, he has said, they are perverting it.
He took that a step further Wednesday night. While announcing that he's expanding the campaign against the Islamic State extremist group into Syria, Obama said flatly that this group, which is trying to install a caliphate in the Middle East, " is not Islamic ." He didn't say they are perverting their religion; he said they're not even part of that religion.
"No religion condones the killing of innocents, and the vast majority of [the Islamic State's] victims have been Muslim," Obama said. (Obama refers to the group as ISIL; more on that here .)
The group, ISIS, is not Islamic. They are a perversion of Islam, so why insult Muslims by saying they are the same? If the President refers to them as Islamic terrorists or Muslims, then it plays into the terrorists hands by giving them the chance to say this is a war between the Western world and Islam, when it is not. We are at with war with terrorists some of whom happen to be Islamic.
What does President Obama think about Islam and terrorism?
Many Republicans think he’s unable to see, or unwilling to acknowledge , that the vast majority of terrorism in recent years has been perpetrated by Muslims. This view of Obama is mistaken. There’s a difference between what he says about Islam and what he thinks about it. The difference isn’t dishonesty. It’s prudence.
Obama understands that today’s terrorism is profoundly connected to the Muslim world. But the connections are manufactured and destructible. To break them, we have to deny terrorists what they want: crude associations of Islam with violence. On Wednesday and Thursday, Obama explained his thinking in two speeches at his summit on violent extremism . Here’s a translation of what he said.
1. Today’s terrorism is overwhelmingly Muslim, and its roots pervade the Muslim world. Obama didn’t say this explicitly, but his words make clear that he understands it. In both speeches, he cited the “deadly attacks in Ottawa, Sydney, Paris, and now Copenhagen.” All four attacks were by Muslims. Obama didn’t use that word in describing the attacks. But his examples tell you plenty.
The more interesting pattern in Obama’s speeches is his repeated reference to the “over a billion Muslims” who reject terrorist ideology. By most estimates, there are about 1.6 billion Muslims in the world. Obama’s phrase leaves as many as half a billion Muslims unaccounted for. That’s significant, because when he wants to make an ethnic or religious group look good—as he does here—he describes the numbers as generously as he can. If he thought only a tiny fraction of Muslims were extremists, he’d say so. But that isn’t what the numbers show. According to a 2013 Pew survey , many Muslims in some countries—25 percent in Egypt, 27 percent in Malaysia, 33 percent in Lebanon, and 62 percent in the Palestinian territories—think suicide bombing against civilian targets is often or sometimes justified. Among Muslims in 11 countries, the median favorable ratings for extremist groups range from 13 percent for al-Qaida to 26 percent for Hezbollah and 32 percent for Hamas.
Again, perfect. Why insult the Islamic world by giving the Islamic terrorists the legitimatization of saying they are real Islamic or Muslims? It makes them equal to real Muslims and they are not. The are terrorists. Does the President know that TECHNICALLY the Islamic terrorists are Muslim, but why give those who pervert the religion the satisfaction of being described as equals to regular Muslims. It would be like saying the rebels in the Civil War were a legitimate nation by calling the Americans, when for the time during the war, they were not. They were rebels and terrorists.
Labeling Terrorism As "Islamic" Plays Into Hands Of Terrorists. The New York Times reported February 18 that the White House believes labeling acts of terror as "Islamic" would "play right into the hands of terrorists who claim that the United States is at war with Islam itself." The Times added that Obama aides say "the last thing the president should do ... is imply that the United States lumps the world's 1.5 billion Muslims with vicious terrorist groups." [The New York Times, 2/18/15 ]
Former State Dept. Counterterrorism Official: Trumpeting "Islamic Radicalism" Would Damage Ally Relationships And Do More Harm Than Good. Daniel Benjamin, the State Department's top counterterrorism official from 2009-2012, said that throwing around the phrase "Islamic radicalism" would damage to efforts to combat terror by undermining relationships with allies:
"Our allies against ISIS in the region are out there every day saying, 'This is not Islam,' " said Mr. Benjamin, now at Dartmouth. "We don't want to undermine them. Any good it would do to trumpet 'Islamic radicalism' would be overwhelmed by the damage it would do to those relationships." [The New York Times, 2/18/15 ]
Foreign Policy: Efforts To Address Terrorism By Focusing On Islam Have Backfired. Foreign Policy explained that programs that have attempted to combat terrorism by focusing exclusively on Islamic extremism have failed. Britain launched "an Islamic-centric counter-extremism effort" in 2005 called the "Prevent Program" that, according to Foreign Policy, "backfired by alienating Muslims and making cooperation with law enforcement officials even more difficult." [Foreign Policy, 2/17/15 ]
The Week: Describing Terrorism As Islamic Alienates Allies And Dignifies Terrorists. In a February 18 post for The Week, Marc Ambinder wrote, "Calling terrorism Islamic terrorism ... doesn't serve the purposes of a president who has to work with countries that have a studiously complicated relationship with the purveyors of terror," meaning it could backfire by offending and alienating countries the president needs cooperation from in order to fight terrorism. Ambinder also noted that Obama's strategy behind not using the term "Islamic terrorism" is to avoid "dignify[ing] that movement by calling it what it calls itself." Ambinder added that "Osama bin Laden himself said that Obama's refusal to join the language fight made it more difficult to generate recruits." [The Week, 2/18/15 ]
The Atlantic: Obama Cannot Adequately Combat Violent Extremism If He Alienates Muslim Communities. David Frum explained in a February 16 post for The Atlantic that by refusing to conflate terrorism with all Muslims, Obama is not ignoring the threat, but rather working not to alienate Muslim leaders who "may be our best allies in the struggle against violence, precisely because they have the most credibility with the people who might otherwise turn to violence." Frum went on to sum up a statement by former White House chief of staff Denis McDonough: "[I]n order to empower Muslim communities to take the lead against violence, the government and the larger society must refrain from actions that alienate or offend community leaders." [The Atlantic, 2/16/15 ]
He does not call them Muslim, because they are not. They are terrorists.
No. I say that not all terrorists are Muslim and not all Muslims are terrorist. Therefore terrorists are just terrorists. If the are Muslim or not is immaterial.
No. I say that not all terrorists are Muslim and not all Muslims are terrorist.
Agreed .
If the are Muslim or not is immaterial.
In the middle east they government attitude is often that of terrorists . In some countries there it is nearly identical to those of terrorists . In Pakistan for example it is hard to find non-terrorists . Anyone who declares an anti-terrorist attitude is often assassinated . And in other countries there one cannot declare himself to be a non-Muslim without violating laws .
The range of laws in the Muslim world rages across the spectrum. Certainly in most Western countries such as England and the US Muslims have the right to change religions or to leave religion altogether without fear of execution or retaliation. In some Muslim nations however even the mention of such an idea would result in instant death. That's why we must be very, very careful not to judge all Muslims as being some sort of a monolithic group or religion, all following the same religious tenets, anymore then we would judge all Christians as evil or racist or violent just because there are some so-called Christian Churches that are very violent and are completely white supremacist churches.
There are 13 people killed today that would agree that Muslims want to kill. To say thatt ISIS is not mot Islam is incorrect . They are following what their religion tells them to do, killing those who do not follow. If muslims here do believe that their religion is being perverted then they must become more outspoken about distancing from them.
Rabbi Schneier is being generous. I saw photos of the Muslims surrounding the synagogue - 100 would be an exaggeration if 1000 is not. As well, he is correct that the majority of Muslims probably abhor violence and disconnect themselves from the radical Islamists. However, even if only a minority were or supported or agreed with the terrorism we see reported every single day, what number can a minority of 1,600,000,000 be? Even a tiny 1% is 16,000,000.
Unfortunately, the Muslims who are speaking out against radical violent Islam are a considerably smaller percentage than the number of those who preach otherwise, or they could be more effective in reversing the problem. There needs to be a lot more Dr. Jassers, Salmann Rushdies, Ayan Hirsis than there are now.
Lets put that in a similar scale Buzz..... There are 15,000,000 Jews in the world. Do we hear 15,000 calling out the government of Israel about the treatment of Palestinians on a daily basis?
Cerenkov is correct Fly, unless you want to believe the Palestinian propaganda. Do you read about acts of terrorism committed by Jews every day? As it happens there ARE many Jews who are unhappy about the treatment of the Palestinians (Jstreet is an example), and many Israeli citizens who are unhappy with their government and vote accordingly. If there were not, a coalition would not have been needed.
Well that the real trick now isn't it..... filtering out the bull-shit propaganda to get to the truth.
That's why both of you should guard against making blanket statements..... Lets all face it, the lies and propaganda have been going on so long that it is nearly impossible to get to the truth.
Now here is a truth.... People on both sides are dying in that part of the world.
Wiles : We have been taken over. We have been taken over.
Bakker : Aren’t you afraid to say that?
Wiles : No! They are going to kill us, Jim! My God Jim, they are going to kill us some day! They kill us now or later, when do you want to die? When do you want to die, later or now?
Bakker : But the church is denying what you’re saying. I know it’s true. You know it’s true. But the church don’t want to hear that.
Wiles : I’ve got a granddaughter, two years old. I am not surrendering this nation to Muslims!
Lunacy. Raw, ignorant lunacy.
Just imagine, if Trump is elected President we will have people like this to thank for it.
That's how democracy works.
People who give money to televangelist con men like Jim Baker should voluntarily refrain from voting.
Sorry. They have equal rights.
Every one has the right to be the ignorant victim of a con man. Sadly. Buyer beware.
― H.L. Mencken
I don't think there was a person in that audience under 65.
Although it is wrong to say or even think that just because a person is a Muslim he is a danger to the community, it is just as wrong to whitewash fundamentalist extremist Islamists and say they are not Muslims, as Obama tends to do.
True Scotsman fallacy.
Scotsman fallacy?
Please explain.
Actually the correct term is ''No True Scotsman Fallacy''.
it is just as wrong to whitewash fundamentalist extremist Islamists and say they are not Muslims, as Obama tends to do.
I have never heard him say that they were not Muslims or express that in any manner? Example?
I my internet wouldn't open this site, but perhaps you can:
Obama says the Islamic State ' is not Islamic. ' Americans disagree. - ...
Throughout his presidency, President Obama has emphasized one point while talking about Islamist extremists: They are not practicing Islam, he has said, they are perverting it.
He took that a step further Wednesday night. While announcing that he's expanding the campaign against the Islamic State extremist group into Syria, Obama said flatly that this group, which is trying to install a caliphate in the Middle East, " is not Islamic ." He didn't say they are perverting their religion; he said they're not even part of that religion.
"No religion condones the killing of innocents, and the vast majority of [the Islamic State's] victims have been Muslim," Obama said. (Obama refers to the group as ISIL; more on that here .)
The group, ISIS, is not Islamic. They are a perversion of Islam, so why insult Muslims by saying they are the same? If the President refers to them as Islamic terrorists or Muslims, then it plays into the terrorists hands by giving them the chance to say this is a war between the Western world and Islam, when it is not. We are at with war with terrorists some of whom happen to be Islamic.
What does President Obama think about Islam and terrorism?
Many Republicans think he’s unable to see, or unwilling to acknowledge , that the vast majority of terrorism in recent years has been perpetrated by Muslims. This view of Obama is mistaken. There’s a difference between what he says about Islam and what he thinks about it. The difference isn’t dishonesty. It’s prudence.
Obama understands that today’s terrorism is profoundly connected to the Muslim world. But the connections are manufactured and destructible. To break them, we have to deny terrorists what they want: crude associations of Islam with violence. On Wednesday and Thursday, Obama explained his thinking in two speeches at his summit on violent extremism . Here’s a translation of what he said.
1. Today’s terrorism is overwhelmingly Muslim, and its roots pervade the Muslim world. Obama didn’t say this explicitly, but his words make clear that he understands it. In both speeches, he cited the “deadly attacks in Ottawa, Sydney, Paris, and now Copenhagen.” All four attacks were by Muslims. Obama didn’t use that word in describing the attacks. But his examples tell you plenty.
The more interesting pattern in Obama’s speeches is his repeated reference to the “over a billion Muslims” who reject terrorist ideology. By most estimates, there are about 1.6 billion Muslims in the world. Obama’s phrase leaves as many as half a billion Muslims unaccounted for. That’s significant, because when he wants to make an ethnic or religious group look good—as he does here—he describes the numbers as generously as he can. If he thought only a tiny fraction of Muslims were extremists, he’d say so. But that isn’t what the numbers show. According to a 2013 Pew survey , many Muslims in some countries—25 percent in Egypt, 27 percent in Malaysia, 33 percent in Lebanon, and 62 percent in the Palestinian territories—think suicide bombing against civilian targets is often or sometimes justified. Among Muslims in 11 countries, the median favorable ratings for extremist groups range from 13 percent for al-Qaida to 26 percent for Hezbollah and 32 percent for Hamas.
Again, perfect. Why insult the Islamic world by giving the Islamic terrorists the legitimatization of saying they are real Islamic or Muslims? It makes them equal to real Muslims and they are not. The are terrorists. Does the President know that TECHNICALLY the Islamic terrorists are Muslim, but why give those who pervert the religion the satisfaction of being described as equals to regular Muslims. It would be like saying the rebels in the Civil War were a legitimate nation by calling the Americans, when for the time during the war, they were not. They were rebels and terrorists.
Labeling Terrorism As "Islamic" Plays Into Hands Of Terrorists. The New York Times reported February 18 that the White House believes labeling acts of terror as "Islamic" would "play right into the hands of terrorists who claim that the United States is at war with Islam itself." The Times added that Obama aides say "the last thing the president should do ... is imply that the United States lumps the world's 1.5 billion Muslims with vicious terrorist groups." [The New York Times, 2/18/15 ]
Former State Dept. Counterterrorism Official: Trumpeting "Islamic Radicalism" Would Damage Ally Relationships And Do More Harm Than Good. Daniel Benjamin, the State Department's top counterterrorism official from 2009-2012, said that throwing around the phrase "Islamic radicalism" would damage to efforts to combat terror by undermining relationships with allies:
Foreign Policy: Efforts To Address Terrorism By Focusing On Islam Have Backfired. Foreign Policy explained that programs that have attempted to combat terrorism by focusing exclusively on Islamic extremism have failed. Britain launched "an Islamic-centric counter-extremism effort" in 2005 called the "Prevent Program" that, according to Foreign Policy, "backfired by alienating Muslims and making cooperation with law enforcement officials even more difficult." [Foreign Policy, 2/17/15 ]
The Week: Describing Terrorism As Islamic Alienates Allies And Dignifies Terrorists. In a February 18 post for The Week, Marc Ambinder wrote, "Calling terrorism Islamic terrorism ... doesn't serve the purposes of a president who has to work with countries that have a studiously complicated relationship with the purveyors of terror," meaning it could backfire by offending and alienating countries the president needs cooperation from in order to fight terrorism. Ambinder also noted that Obama's strategy behind not using the term "Islamic terrorism" is to avoid "dignify[ing] that movement by calling it what it calls itself." Ambinder added that "Osama bin Laden himself said that Obama's refusal to join the language fight made it more difficult to generate recruits." [The Week, 2/18/15 ]
The Atlantic: Obama Cannot Adequately Combat Violent Extremism If He Alienates Muslim Communities. David Frum explained in a February 16 post for The Atlantic that by refusing to conflate terrorism with all Muslims, Obama is not ignoring the threat, but rather working not to alienate Muslim leaders who "may be our best allies in the struggle against violence, precisely because they have the most credibility with the people who might otherwise turn to violence." Frum went on to sum up a statement by former White House chief of staff Denis McDonough: "[I]n order to empower Muslim communities to take the lead against violence, the government and the larger society must refrain from actions that alienate or offend community leaders." [The Atlantic, 2/16/15 ]
He does not call them Muslim, because they are not. They are terrorists.
He does not call them Muslim, because they are not. They are terrorists.
You imply those 2 groups are mutually exclusive . They're not .
No. I say that not all terrorists are Muslim and not all Muslims are terrorist. Therefore terrorists are just terrorists. If the are Muslim or not is immaterial.
No. I say that not all terrorists are Muslim and not all Muslims are terrorist.
Agreed .
If the are Muslim or not is immaterial.
In the middle east they government attitude is often that of terrorists . In some countries there it is nearly identical to those of terrorists . In Pakistan for example it is hard to find non-terrorists . Anyone who declares an anti-terrorist attitude is often assassinated . And in other countries there one cannot declare himself to be a non-Muslim without violating laws .
The range of laws in the Muslim world rages across the spectrum. Certainly in most Western countries such as England and the US Muslims have the right to change religions or to leave religion altogether without fear of execution or retaliation. In some Muslim nations however even the mention of such an idea would result in instant death. That's why we must be very, very careful not to judge all Muslims as being some sort of a monolithic group or religion, all following the same religious tenets, anymore then we would judge all Christians as evil or racist or violent just because there are some so-called Christian Churches that are very violent and are completely white supremacist churches.
There are 13 people killed today that would agree that Muslims want to kill. To say thatt ISIS is not mot Islam is incorrect . They are following what their religion tells them to do, killing those who do not follow. If muslims here do believe that their religion is being perverted then they must become more outspoken about distancing from them.
they must become more outspoken about distancing from them.
Would you hear them if they did Jennilee?
Rabbi Schneier is being generous. I saw photos of the Muslims surrounding the synagogue - 100 would be an exaggeration if 1000 is not. As well, he is correct that the majority of Muslims probably abhor violence and disconnect themselves from the radical Islamists. However, even if only a minority were or supported or agreed with the terrorism we see reported every single day, what number can a minority of 1,600,000,000 be? Even a tiny 1% is 16,000,000.
Unfortunately, the Muslims who are speaking out against radical violent Islam are a considerably smaller percentage than the number of those who preach otherwise, or they could be more effective in reversing the problem. There needs to be a lot more Dr. Jassers, Salmann Rushdies, Ayan Hirsis than there are now.
Lets put that in a similar scale Buzz..... There are 15,000,000 Jews in the world. Do we hear 15,000 calling out the government of Israel about the treatment of Palestinians on a daily basis?
Why would we? Israel treats them better than the Arab world.
Cerenkov is correct Fly, unless you want to believe the Palestinian propaganda. Do you read about acts of terrorism committed by Jews every day? As it happens there ARE many Jews who are unhappy about the treatment of the Palestinians (Jstreet is an example), and many Israeli citizens who are unhappy with their government and vote accordingly. If there were not, a coalition would not have been needed.
Well that the real trick now isn't it..... filtering out the bull-shit propaganda to get to the truth.
That's why both of you should guard against making blanket statements..... Lets all face it, the lies and propaganda have been going on so long that it is nearly impossible to get to the truth.
Now here is a truth.... People on both sides are dying in that part of the world.
"That's why both of you should guard against making blanket statements..."
So should you.
"They will not assimilate..... period."
Point taken Buzz. Thanks.
Five bucks says the terrorists attacks today are done by Muslims. These guys see the handwriting on the walls.