╌>

Republicans hope the GOP base will save their Senate majority. But Trump might blow up that plan.

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  community  •  10 years ago  •  5 comments

Republicans hope the GOP base will save their Senate majority. But Trump might blow up that plan.

March 24

Why are incumbent Republican Senators who are facing difficult reelection challenges in states carried by Barack Obama refusing to even consider Obama’s nominee to the Supreme Court? It’s all about keeping the base happy.

But there’s a potential problem with this strategy: Donald Trump may blow it to pieces.

James Hohmann has some good reporting that clearly shows that keeping the base juiced up is the driving rationale behind refusing to even consider Merrick Garland . Senator Ron Johnson of Wisconsin — one of the most vulnerable GOP incumbents of the cycle — candidly confides to Hohmann that GOP base voters are more revved up over this battle than any other voters are, because they want to prevent the Court from tilting in a liberal direction, and that this is weighing on him. Hohmann concludes that even if independents and moderates might be disturbed by the GOP refusal to consider Garland, this probably won’t matter to GOP Senators, because Republican base voters are the most energized by the standoff:


With the exception of Illinois, where Sen. Mark Kirk has already been privately written off by almost all of his Republican colleagues, members in states like New Hampshire, Pennsylvania and Ohio are making plain they won’t ultimately confirm Garland (even if they agree to sit down with him for a photo opp). Though their electorates overall may lean Democratic, each believes their priority – especially at this point in the cycle – must be keeping the base ginned up.


It seems inarguable that this is what is driving the GOP position in this fight, which means the larger point here is that Mitch McConnell’s strategy of refusing to consider Garland is all about preserving the GOP Senate majority, and that he has decided the base is crucial to that.

But even if this is the most reasonable political calculation Republicans could make under the circumstances, one Democrat points out to me that these carefully laid plans could end up getting ruptured to an untold degree by Trump. After all, if Trump wins the nomination, a nontrivial percentage of Republican voters could stay home, perhaps even in some of these swing states where control of the Senate will be decided: Wisconsin, Ohio, Pennsylvania, New Hampshire, and Florida.

Indeed, while Democrats believe all of this to be very possible, this isn’t even a partisan line of speculation: Republicans themselves are worried that Trump could have this down-ticket impact if he is the nominee. One top GOP fundraiser told the Post that this dynamic could put GOP control of the Senate at risk: “If Donald Trump is the nominee, we could see a lot of people staying home.”

Meanwhile, National Journal’s Josh Kraushaar reported recently that GOP strategists are “privately alarmed but publicly silent at the prospect of Trump making life miserable for swing-state senators,” adding that Trump could produce “depressed Republican turnout” that could compound their problems.

And conservative writer Noah Rothman today highlighted a striking finding in a new Monmouth poll that also hints at this possibility:


In the Republican contest, two-thirds (68%) of voters who back Ted Cruz for the GOP nomination say they would vote for Trump in November, while 13% would vote for Clinton and 10% would not vote. Among Republicans who back John Kasich, just 50% would vote for Trump and 19% would vote for Clinton, with 22% saying they would sit out the general election.


General election polling this early should be viewed with skepticism, but if there’s anything at all to this, it’s trouble — nontrivial numbers of Republican voters either might vote for Clinton or stay home. And again, even Republicans are worried about this scenario impacting GOP control of the Senate.

This could also end up happening even if Trump is not the nominee. If Republicans do manage to nominate someone else at a contested convention, Trump could try to run as a third party candidate in at least some states (logistics permitting) or, if not, he could call on his supporters to oppose the GOP establishment candidate, potentially depressing GOP turnout this way or otherwise producing untold ruptures among Republicans.

I have seen it reported (I cannot find the link) that some GOP leaders are hoping that, if they refuse to consider Garland, and if it’s looking likely that Republicans will lose the White House with Trump as the nominee, the specter of a President Hillary picking the next Supreme Court justice could drive up Republican turnout, as GOP voters seek to keep the Senate in GOP hands to defeat her nominee. If this is so, then some Republicans are hoping that refusing to act on Garland not only keeps the base engaged, but also gives Republicans an active reason to vote for GOP Senators, even as other Republicans worry that Trump — in one way or another — could have the opposite effect. It’s a mess.

My point isn’t to predict that Republicans will lose the Senate. Rather, it’s that, if they are hoping that not budging on Garland will help them hold it, Donald Trump is potentially a ticking time bomb at the center of that whole plan.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/plum-line/wp/2016/03/24/republicans-hope-the-gop-base-will-save-their-senate-majority-but-trump-might-blow-up-that-plan/?wpmm=1&wpisrc=nl_popns


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    10 years ago

I believe that the down ticket GOP candidates are terrified of a Trump nomination...and that they have good reason to be.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    10 years ago

Due to the present anticipation of Clinton's becoming POTUS the Republicans are making a huge mistake in not approving Garland who is a moderate. Clinton, who I now believe is most likely to be POTUS, may well bypass him and nominate someone even more liberal. That will have ramifications for years. It is only wishful thinking on the part of the Republican establishment to hope that refusing Garland may help retain support for a Republican Senate because I think the damage that Trump is doing could already be irreversible.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy  replied to  Buzz of the Orient   10 years ago

I couldn't agree more. If the GOP Senate were smart, they would take the moderate they have in front of them rather then take the very, very real chance of having Clinton win and have them lose control of the Senate, in which case she may ask Garland to step aside and nominate an out and out young liberal that they won't be to stop. I also believe that if Clinton wins and the Democrats control the Senate that Ruth Bader Ginsburg will take the opportunity to retire and the GOP will lose the chance to replace her with a conservative. Hilary, no doubt, will no doubt nominate a very young liberal for that seat who will be there a very long time.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell    10 years ago

a well known conservative election forecaster, Jay Cost (formerly of RealClearPolitics) , gave his assessment of the general election for the Weekly Standard in a podcast

 

 

 

"Let me state flatly and unequivocally that if Donald Trump is the nominee, Hillary Clinton’s floor in the electoral college is 400 votes. That’s the floor, number one. Number two, kiss the Senate goodbye. I mean, it’s not even going to be a close call. It will be a bloodbath. Number three, and this is a little more controversial at this point, but I would give the Republicans no better than 40 percent odds hold the House of Representatives.

 

This guy is an abject disaster for the Republican Party in November, there is no other way to put it. And the notion that he’s going to bring in some tranche of voters is just a complete fiction, for two reasons: number one, there aren’t enough of them, okay?

 

I live in Western Pennsylvania. I live right near places that, up until very recently, were voting Democratic. And yeah, can Trump bring some new voters in from Beaver County? Yeah, maybe he can. But I’m telling you what, I live in Butler County, which has been voting Republican since 1856, and he’s going to get killed in Butler County. He is going to get killed in the Cranberry Township suburbs in Butler County. Because people are going to look at him and they are going to think, “No Way.”  You watch, suburban women in Cranberry Township are going to bolt [from] him in droves. And the same thing’s going to happen… replicate that times 100 in the Philadelphia suburbs. It’s going to be an absolute slaughter.

 

And I think that he can hold the line, maybe, in the South. I see him winning Mississippi and Alabama, and maybe Louisiana. I think he loses Georgia, I think he loses North Carolina. But I think… that’s only one area where the Republican Party is strong. You go to the Great Plains, right… So the Great Plains starts with Texas and then goes up to the Canadian border, and then it goes west up though Montana, Idaho, Wyoming, Utah. He is going to punk out all through that region. These people want nothing to do with this guy. Maybe they’ll vote for him over Hillary Clinton, because they find Hillary Clinton so objectionable, but he is not going to win those states by anything approaching a solid margin.

If you want a view of what Trump looks like on election day, I think the best map you can look at is probably the 1928 map between Al Smith and Herbert Hoover. And Herbert Hoover massacred Al Smith. It is going to be an absolute, total bloodbath for Republicans. It will give the Democrats not only control of the White House and the Senate, but very possibly the House of Representatives"

 

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

I agree, but I think it'll be a landslide on the order of Nixon over McGovern in 1972. Still, it'll be a complete disaster for the GOP and I see many of GOP Senators and Congressmen actively running against Donald Trump, distancing themselves from him as much as possible.

 
 

Who is online




Right Down the Center


67 visitors