Is this ad racist?
While the three other white girls in the photo were striking powerful, strong poses, some people complained that the black girl appeared passive, more of a “prop” and a token than anything else. In the video component of the ad, too, she seemed detached and largely silent, while her white group members did most of the talking.
“It becomes problematic when the black child is positioned to be a white child’s prop,” explained Kirsten West Savali of The Root , in the wake of the controversy.
Tags
Who is online
104 visitors

Racism-- or political correctness gone amok?
"It seems to me that this photo is a sort of Rorschach test where people can see what they want to see. At best, this photo might deserve some form of "ugh" until quickly being forgotten because humanity has real shit to deal with."
Agree with you John.
The "racism" is that there are no brown (hispanic), yellow or red people in the ad - if you really, really wanted to search for something to be offended about.
I took my comment down because something that I said was not accurate when I went back and looked at one of the videos a second time.
This is a difficult question. There are a number of videos, that show a number of girls of various ethnic appearance. It does appear that the little black girl takes kind of a backseat role to the others, but why that is , I have no idea. People on You Tube thought it was wrong , and since the videos are highly edited, must be intentional.
I really don't know. I don't know why they would hire a black girl and then not use her much. Someone on You Tube said that the girl's mother said she turned out to be camera shy. Maybe so.
Yep. It is.
In what way?
It's tokenism. Same dif.
Approx 1/8th of the U.S. population is black. but in this ad, 1/4 of the kids are black. In other words, blacks are over-represented by 2X-- hardly "tokenism"!
Ellen DeGeneres is overly represented.
Actually the fraction is accurate. The black kid is half the size of the others.
Actually the fraction is accurate. The black kid is half the size of the others.
Perhaps. (It all depends upon whether you are using the Metric system or not).
You can say that again.
Oh! You did.
Actually the fraction is accurate. The black kid is half the size of the others.
Perhaps. (It all depends upon whether you are using the Metric system or not).
Nothing is ever good enough - PC and Affirmative Action are unrealistic and will always be liars.
Where is the Asian? Where is the NA?
- PC and Affirmative Action are unrealistic and will always be liars.
?
PC and affirmative action are not people.
Okay John, I will clarify to make you happy. They are programs that have caused untold turmoil in the world by fabricating false standards. They would not have done much harm if they had not been extended to extremes.
Where is the Asian?
Ask and ye shall receive:
Is this Gap Kids ad racist, or empowering?
Really @GapKids !? So are you proving that Black girls can be arm rests? #FAIL
— Fatima La'Juan Muse (@TheTherapyDiva) April 2, 2016
______________________
As it turns out, an older, Gap Kids had run a similar ad "the other way," sparking a new round of reaction.
Is this argument valid?
Not everyone is satisfied with Smith's explanation. Sisters or not, the positioning of these two girls only reinforces an all-too-common portrayal of black people in American society, some said .
The positioning of the two...?
Is there an ad that doesn't offend someone?
I'm offended by that comment!
And I'm offended by yours.
This is the most ridiculous thing I have heard lately. Proof that those who want to be offended will be offended by anything.