New LA Law: Homeless People Can Only Own A Trashcan's Worth Of Belongings
The city of LA just passed a law limiting the possessions of homeless people to one trashcan’s worth of things.
As though homeless people don’t already own so little possessions, the city of Los Angeles just passed a law saying that the amount of things a homeless person can own must fit inside of a trashcan. They even have size dimensions for the trashcan, noting that the items must fit in a 60-gallon trashcan and the lid must close over it.
The new law allows police to even confiscate tents that are still standing on public property during daylight hours. Taking away a homeless person’s shelter is not constructive, and in fact only makes them feel less secure in a time when they need a solid foundation to get back on their feet.
Tags
Who is online
110 visitors

Just gonna leave this right here:
"...When we finish, everyone remains in his own corner and we do dare lift our eyes to look at one another. There is nowhere to look in a mirror but our appearance stands in front of us, reflected in a hundred miserable and sordid puppets. We are transformed into the phantoms glimpsed yesterday evening.
Then for the first time we became aware that our language lacks words to express this offense, the demolition of a man. In a moment, with almost prophetic intuition, the reality was revealed to us: we had reached the bottom. It is not possible to sink lower than this; no human condition is more miserable than this, nor could it conceivable be so. Nothing belongs to us anymore; they have taken away our clothes, our shoes, even our hair; if we speak they will not listen to us, and if they listen they will not understand. They will even take away our name; and if we want to keep it, we will have to find ourselves the strength to do so, to manage somehow so that behind the name something of us, of us as we were, still remains.
We know that we will have difficulty being understood, and this is as it should be. But consider what value, what meaning is enclosed even in the smallest of our daily habits, in the hundred possessions which even the poorest beggar owns: a handkerchief, an old letter, the photo of a cherished person. These things are part of us, almost like the limbs of our body; nor is it conceivable that we can be deprived of them in our world, for we immediately find others to substitute the old ones, other objects which are ours in their personification and evocation of our memories.
Imagine now a man who is deprived of everyone he loves, and at the same time of his house, his habits, his clothes, in short, of everything he possesses: he will be a hollow man, reduced to suffering and needs, forgetful of dignity and restraint, for he who loses all often easily loses himself. He will be a man whose life of death can be lightly decided with no sense of human affinity, in the most fortunate of cases, on the basis of a pure judgement of utility. ..."
Survival in Auschwitz - Primo Levi
Wheel - Thank you for posting this issue. This is a terrible situation and one I admit I don't know too much about. I know that mental health is one of the contributors to homelessness other than just being jobless or financial aid being cut.
I noticed in the article that the homeless rate increased 20% in the last 2 years. I wonder what demographic is making up the 20%
I noticed in the article that the homeless rate increased 20% in the last 2 years. I wonder what demographic is making up the 20%
I don't know all of it, but I do know the number of homeless families had increased in the last few years. That probably has something to do with it.
I was wondering whether part of the reason why there was such a significant increase was maybe due to more Vets becoming homeless because of PTSD and other trauma.
What a heartless and horrible law! It astounds me that the size of the container they use is a trash can... As if a homeless person's belongings, which are their only "assets", sense of self, etc., is dubbed fit for trash. If they had said, 60 gallons worth, that would not be so demeaning. But no, they had to say a "60 gallon trash can"...
I find this to be disgusting. In all ways. There is no need to dehumanize the homeless further. They're already at the end of their rope. At least afford them the dignity of having some of their own things-- and don't label it "trash".
Utterly unconscionable!
As if a homeless person's belongings, which are their only "assets", sense of self, etc., is dubbed fit for trash. If they had said, 60 gallons worth, that would not be so demeaning. But no, they had to say a "60 gallon trash can"..
Exactly. I saw a picture of a city councilman in Fla. destroying the belonging of some homeless people and putting it out as something he was proud of.
I read another story about cops taking the possessions, backpacks, bags, etc. of homeless people and destroying them for no reason.
That's NOT something to be proud of! Horrible!
I realize that homelessness is a significant problem if people are camped out blocking sidewalks and urinating everywhere. However, trying to limit the possessions of the homeless is just going to trigger a lawsuit that I doubt the city can win. If the city wants the homeless off the street, then build them somewhere to live and keep their belongings (other than prison).
I think part of the challenge with some homeless people is they don't want to live in a dwelling. So the City can build lodging for them but not all will get off the street. Some homeless have mental illness and getting jobs or a place to live isn't the answer for them.
Part of the solution is our country has to address the mental health issues we have. Unfortunately, we have many that don't believe in social programs. They have a "you're on your own" mentality. Others think help is sufficiently given through charity and church programs but not everyone is amenable to joining a cult.
Part of the solution is our country has to address the mental health issues we have.
One of the many reasons that I curse Ronnie Raygun every day is because of what he did to the mentally ill in this country.
One of the many reasons that I curse Ronnie Raygun every day is because of what he did to the mentally ill in this country.
Well I guess Karma does exist since Ronnie lost HIS mind in the end. Strange how Nancy quickly decided stem cell research wasn't so bad after all.........I hate hypocrisy but it's everywhere even with me at times but I'm working on it. I like to think half the battle is knowing it exists. :o)
Well I guess Karma does exist since Ronnie lost HIS mind in the end.
Yes. But was rich and pampered and protected. Not homeless, friendless and familyless.
I think part of the challenge with some homeless people is they don't want to live in a dwelling. So the City can build lodging for them but not all will get off the street. Some homeless have mental illness and getting jobs or a place to live isn't the answer for them.
This is a difficult issue. One of the reasons people with mental illness are on the street in the first place is that it was seen as inhuman to institutionalize them if they are no danger to themselves or others. I've noticed that single homeless women prefer to be outside of facilities where they can be preyed upon by homeless men. A case in point is an older homeless woman who basically lives on the street near my building. She moves from site to site in a small radius every couple of hours; I presume to avoid being charged with loitering. By 4:00 pm every day, she is sitting on the plant stand in front of my building. She has much more stuff than would fit in a trash can and maneuvers them in a combination of push carts and rolling luggage. She is very intelligent and quite harmless; charming really.
I commute to work on a scooter and she and I initially didn't get along because I chained the scooter to the spot she viewed as reserved for her rolling collection of stuff. She has more things than she can maneuver at once so she pushes some ahead, then goes back to get the rest, and slowly moves her possessions down the street. I quickly learned that she is also quite crazy. She says that she works for NASA or that she's on stakeout for the CIA and many other delusions. Still, as I said, she is charming. She has come to accept my scooter and we talk every day as I unchain it to leave. A couple of weeks ago, I was rushing to the DMV and saw her sitting up the block. A homeless man was harassing her . . . pulling his shirt up, opening his pants and thrusting his pelvis, trying to move her cart, yelling at her and lunging etc. He looked drunk and, although there were many people on the street (walking and sitting outside in a café) no one offered any assistance. I asked her if she was OK and she yes but looked pensive. The guy tried to lunge at her again so I stepped between them. I asked if she wanted me to call the police. She didn't answer but her eyes said yes. I saw a cop car on the next corner so I went to get him. When the cop saw that she was homeless, he looed like he was going to turn around. I told him to do something now before the clown hits her and if he doesn't do something, then I'll have to do it. That's when he made the guy leave her alone and move on. I don't think he would have done anything otherwise. The homeless are on their own in every respect and to take what little they can accumulate and treat it as trash is beyond cruel.
When the cop saw that she was homeless, he looed like he was going to turn around.
he will be a hollow man, reduced to suffering and needs, forgetful of dignity and restraint, for he who loses all often easily loses himself. He will be a man whose life of death can be lightly decided with no sense of human affinity, in the most fortunate of cases, on the basis of a pure judgement of utility. ..."
Thanks for bringing this to our attention, Wheel. The quotation you provided is so appropriate to the issue.
I just want to say it is good to see you again - it's been too long since you posted anything, at least anything that I have had the benefit of seeing.
Hi Buzz. I've been seeing all these stories about cops depriving homeless people of their needed possessions, for example the city that passed a law saying the homeless were not allowed to have blankets.
I read that book in jr. high. I was really into books about WWII back then and read a lot of books about the war and the aftermath. This one stuck in my mind and when I ran across it again a few months ago in a used book store I bought it and re-read. I recommend everyone try to find a copy. It's a cautionary tale for these days and times. One of the things I found remarkable is how he doesn't call names and place blame or accusations. He just tells his story, bang! Just like that. No recrimination, just facts. I don't know how he had the emotional detachment to do that after all he went through.
Nice seed wheel. Gives one pause to reflect on how good we have it, even when we may think we don"t.
Gives one pause to reflect on how good we have it, even when we may think we don"t.
Civilization is a thin and fragile cloth. On the other side are ignorance, want, poverty, violence, disease, hunger and all the enemies of life and civilization. Everyone is susceptible to those things and any one of us could wind up being ruined by one or more of them.
I have a reoccurring dream where I end up living out of a cardboard box under an overpass. My knowledge, experience, and work ethic aren't enough to avoid this dream. I hope those qualities can avoid it in reality.
That nightmare is a fact of life for all too many people in this country.
I have a reoccurring dream where I end up living out of a cardboard box under an overpass. My knowledge, experience, and work ethic aren't enough to avoid this dream. I hope those qualities can avoid it in reality.
I hope you can too but, unfortunately, many people are only a couple of paychecks away from homelessness and it can be a quick slide. When I was in college, I worked part time in a shoe store. I worked as much as I could because I lived on my own with no financial assistance. It was difficult making ends meet but I was young and I was determined. One of my co-workers (who wasn't in school) told me that he thought we should quit and go to work in the nearby department store because we could work full time over the Christmas holidays with a good chance of being full time thereafter. I said I thought we could work full time in the shoe store during that same period and, if we left, the manager would never let us return just out of sheer spite. Plus, I needed to be sure I could work until I graduated (which wasn't that far off). He thought I was stupid and left. The department store kept him on after the holidays for a month or so and then laid him off. He tried to come back to the shoe store but the manager refused to re-hire him. He asked me for some money and I gave him what I could spare. Shortly thereafter, he told me that he no longer had a place to stay because he couldn't pay for his room. The landlord had locked him out and seized all his belongings until he paid his back rent. He said he was thinking about staying with his sister but she lived in another city (I couldn't offer anything because I was living with my girlfriend and she would have never consented to him being there). I gave him some more money because I thought he was catching the bus to his sister's place. A couple of weeks later, I thought I saw him in a doorway down the street before the downtown stores opened but, when I walked over to check, nobody was there. I mentioned it to my other co-workers and they said he was homeless and looked terrible. As it turned out, everyone was giving him money at different times but nobody had seen him lately and speculated that he now looked so bad that he was embarrassed to be seen. I went looking for him but never saw him again. That's the first I realized how devastating this can be. With no income, he was almost immediately homeless. With no home, he couldn't clean up or change clothes. Unable to clean up, he couldn't look for work. I always knew that I could go live with my parents if necessary but, if you don't have anybody to fall back on, you just fall . . . and hard.
, he was almost immediately homeless. With no home, he couldn't clean up or change clothes. Unable to clean up, he couldn't look for work. I always knew that I could go live with my parents if necessary but, if you don't have anybody to fall back on, you just fall . . . and hard.
Exactly. If the homeless had a place to bathe regularly and wash their clothes, they would stand a much better chance of improving themselves.
When my wife was a Psychiatric RN for L.A. County she was on a PET team, which is usually two county employees, one of whom must be "designated" meaning they have the authority to force a person into a psychiatric hospital or ward against their will for a 72 hour evaluation (a 5150). That's the part my wife did. She decided on who did or did not "meet criteria" to be forced against their will into a hospital. In order to meet criteria they have to be an immediate danger to themselves, an immediate danger to others or what's known as "gravely disabled". That last one is the tricky one and can get you sued or even get your nursing license taken away. A person living in a cardboard box, even if they are obviously mentally ill, is not gravely disabled if they have shelter (cardboard box or access to a city or church shelter) and access to food. So, even if a person is obviously mentally ill, they can not be taken of the streets against their will, except under a very tight set of rules, so most of them are not. It's not illegal in California to be homeless, even if you are homeless because you are mentally ill.
The county hospital does not have enough room for them, but those are often the only beds in town if she decided that a person was gravely disabled or so mentally ill that they were an immediate danger to themselves. The county hospital would get them, feed them, try to clean them up, try to find clean clothes for them and instead of the 72 hours a doctor would usually find they were no longer a danger to themselves and discharge them within 24 hours. If the person had Medi-Cal and Medicare they usually stayed in a private hospital for the full 72 hours because the state would pay for it and then they were out the door.
The VA has a huge campus and hospital with all kinds of buildings they could house homeless veterans in EXCEPT the buildings are WWII era and have not been retro-fitted for earthquakes (which would cost a lot). PLUS there is a private group that has been trying for years to buy the section of prime real estate where the old hospital is, tear down the buildings and convert it to a combination condo/shopping center. The war over the land has been going on for more then a decade with no end in sight. The VA keeps saying they're not going to sell, then they get ready to sell, then a bunch of homeless vets descend on the area and camp out until the VA backs down and the whole thing then starts all over again. The problem is that the land was donated to the city FOR a veterans hospital and the lawyers are fighting it out over if the fact that the VA built a new hospital several years ago on part of the land, then does that mean the rest can be sold. Lawyers are getting rich and the buildings stay empty and the vets stay homeless. Personally I support it staying part of the VA and the buildings getting retro-fitted so homeless vets can live there, but it is very, very valuable land, so....
I tried to kill myself with an over dose of sleeping pills (Ambien. Fuckers should only be allowed for use in a hospital because they are waaaaaay too strong!) five years ago this Aug 4th. I was lucky and was taken to UCLA (though I hated the fact that the hospital was named for Ronald Reagan) and after being in ICU with a machine doing my breathing for me they had an opening in the in house psychiatric hospital, which was great (though it's not like I had a choice since I was on a 5150). I also had great insurance through my wife's policy for L.A. County so I had my own room and TV and shower, etc. so when my 5150 was up I was able to sign in voluntarily instead of being kicked out.
So, when you see people on the streets of a major city and you know most of them are mentally ill, understand that the law stops most places from doing anything about it. It's not illegal to be homeless and crazy, though I sometimes think it should be.
Thank you. That took a great deal of courage. I appreciate you sharing your story with us.
LA is one strange place. It's supposed to be so liberal, yet they don't care about the people who have fallen through the social net.
Earlier this year, they took away all the tiny houses from the homeless. This actually gave the homeless a place to live, and they loved it. Most of the homes were in skid row anyway, so why should they care?
Here is an interesting article about the situation. People are fighting back, but I have to say I am disgusted with the treatment of the homeless there.
Earlier this year, they took away all the tiny houses from the homeless. This actually gave the homeless a place to live, and they loved it. Most of the homes were in skid row anyway, so why should they care?
I can see why the city doesn't want these tiny houses on sidewalks, or under bridges, or in parks but why can't they just zone a tiny house area and make it like a trailer park? Incidentally, these tiny houses may be too small to be "buildings" subject to safety codes. Cooking and heating in such a tiny space (especially if constructed of material that's even partially combustible) could be a serious safety hazard for the occupant.
I agree that you can't have tiny houses all over the place, but there could be a zone for them. As for them dangerous, how much more dangerous could it be, then how they are living now? BTW, there is a big Tiny House movement going on across the US with people buying them to live in, so that they are not burdened with big mortgage payments. Some of them are really cool and I would live in them, too.
As for them dangerous, how much more dangerous could it be, then how they are living now?
If they're composed of combustible material and heated by propane, then they could be a deathtrap . . . but I'd have to read more about it. If it is a deathtrap, then I wonder who (if anyone) is liable.
Well this is in CA so they are probably just trying to discourage people from being homeless and get them on the system.