Muslim Student Who Was Kicked Off Southwest Flight After Speaking Arabic Just Wants An Apology
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/muslim-student-kicked-off-southwest_us_57140cdde4b0060ccda38e51
He was talking to his uncle on the phone.
A University of California student says he was removed from a Southwest Airlines flight after another passenger raised suspicions about him speaking Arabic.
Khairuldeen Makhzoomi, a 26-year-old political science and Near Eastern literature student at UC Berkeley, is speaking out now about his experience with the airline on April 6. Makhzoomi, a Muslim Iraqi refugee who fled the country in 2002 after his Iraqi diplomat father was killed under Saddam Hussein’s regime, said he was seated on a flight going from Los Angeles to Oakland and speaking Arabic on the phone with his uncle before takeoff when a nearby passenger made eye contact with him and got up from her seat.
That’s when he thought, “I hope she’s not reporting me,” he told The Huffington Post.
Within minutes, a Southwest employee approached Makhzoomi and escorted him off the plane and back into the airport, where he was detained and questioned by multiple security guards with police dogs and FBI officers about his phone call and his luggage, all in front of dozens of onlookers.
When the officers searched his genital area and asked if he was hiding a knife, Makhzoomi said the situation became overwhelming.
“At that moment, it was the maximum point of humiliation, he said. “My eyes began to water.”
He learned during questioning that the passenger who reported him thought he said the word “shahid,” which means martyr, and associated it with terrorism. Makhzoomi had been telling his uncle about a dinner he was returning from at the Los Angeles World Affairs Council with Secretary-General of the United Nations Ban Ki-moon and said “inshallah,” meaning “if God is willing” when he hung up.
Khairuldeen Makhzoomi, 26, said he was overwhelmed as officers searched him in the airport after he was kicked off his plane.
At the end of the ordeal, Makhzoomi says an agent told him that Southwest would not be able to fly him back to Oakland, and suggested he apologize. “My dignity comes first. I will just get my refund and leave,” Makhzoomi told the agent. He ended up catching a later flight back with Delta Air Lines.
Southwest told The Huffington Post in a statement:
Prior to the departure of Flight 4620, our Crew made the decision to investigate a passenger report of potentially threatening comments overheard onboard our aircraft. Our Employees followed protocol by reviewing the situation with the passenger in question, as it is the responsibility of our Employees to respond to Customer concerns. While local law enforcement followed up with that passenger in our gate area, the flight departed.
We regret any less than positive experience a Customer has on Southwest.
But Makhzoomi just wants Southwest to say they’re sorry.
“I want Southwest to apologize publicly,” he said. “I want them to apologize for the mistreatment, and how they singled me out, that they cannot report anyone without consequences. This is a country that respects the rule of law, and we must all together respect the rule of law.”
Last week, a Muslim woman was reportedly kicked off her Southwest flight during a layover in Chicago after asking to switch seats.
For Makhzoomi, who says terrorism thrives on Islamophobia, this is not the way to fight terrorism.
“I only hate one thing in my life: Islamic State,” he said. “We should challenge terrorism not with ignorance but with education and knowledge.”
Tags
Who is online
113 visitors

SW did a piss poor job on this.
SW did a piss poor job on this.
It's the only thing they excel at, doing piss poor jobs of things.
SW did a piss poor job on this.
It's the only thing they excel at, doing piss poor jobs of things.
And its been like that for years. And not just the airline-- the TSA is even worse!
Here's a satirical video about that-- its an old one, but the point it makes is valid (The incidents they mention all really did happen, but many people may now have forgotten them since it is an old video)
"He learned during questioning that the passenger who reported him thought he said the word “shahid,” which means martyr, and associated it with terrorism. Makhzoomi had been telling his uncle about a dinner he was returning from at the Los Angeles World Affairs Council with Secretary-General of the United Nations Ban Ki-moon and said “inshallah,” meaning “if God is willing” when he hung up. "
Another mentioning of God goes awry. Although, as he has probably learned by now, when you are sitting on place, either speak English or wait until you are off the plane to make your foreign language phone calls.
Unfortunately, this is easily spun into a terrorist recruiting tool. Now the terrorists can claim that the infidels are not only at war with Islam, they also revile the name of Allah and even forbid you to speak your language in public.
Agreed, especially when it could have been used as an example of greatness.
We are living in a very sad place today.
Unfortunately, this is easily spun into a terrorist recruiting tool. Now the terrorists can claim that the infidels are not only at war with Islam, they also revile the name of Allah and even forbid you to speak your language in public
Perhaps. But there have so many other things before that-- they already have more than they need for that. War in iraq-- that was good for years! And Obama just sent in a few more "boots on the ground" (with armed military personnel inside those boots!)
And there are so many more. Remember the "Mohammed Cartoon Crisis"? That really inflammed passions-- a wonderful terrorist recruiting tool! And it worked--over 120 people died over that one:
The Jyllands-Posten Cartoons
The Danish newspaper Jyllands-Posten created the furor over depictions of Mohammed by publishing a series of 12 drawings after a local author said he was unable to find any artist willing to depict Mohammed for his upcoming illustrated book. The publication of the images in Jyllands-Posten has been condemned around the Islamic world, and has led to the burning of embassies and a boycott of Denmark by Muslim nations.
Here are the Jyllands-Posten drawings, for the record. Each image is an individual jpeg file, courtesy of the Face of Muhammed site. (If you would like to have one jpeg containing all 12 images together, click here .) Scroll down below the 12 original cartoon images on this page to find additional information about the fake Mohammed images distributed in the Middle East to incite outrage, and a detailed follow-up on the illustrated book that started the fuss (LINK)
Unfortunately, this is easily spun into a terrorist recruiting tool. Now the terrorists can claim that the infidels are not only at war with Islam, they also revile the name of Allah and even forbid you to speak your language in public
Perhaps. But there have so many other things before that-- they already have more than they need for that. War in iraq-- that was good for years! And Obama just sent in a few more "boots on the ground" (with armed military personnel inside those boots!)
And there are so many more. Remember the "Mohammed Cartoon Crisis"? That really inflammed passions-- a wonderful terrorist recruiting tool! And it worked--over 120 people died over that one:
The Jyllands-Posten Cartoons
The Danish newspaper Jyllands-Posten created the furor over depictions of Mohammed by publishing a series of 12 drawings after a local author said he was unable to find any artist willing to depict Mohammed for his upcoming illustrated book. The publication of the images in Jyllands-Posten has been condemned around the Islamic world, and has led to the burning of embassies and a boycott of Denmark by Muslim nations.
Here are the Jyllands-Posten drawings, for the record. Each image is an individual jpeg file, courtesy of the Face of Muhammed site. (If you would like to have one jpeg containing all 12 images together, click here .) Scroll down below the 12 original cartoon images on this page to find additional information about the fake Mohammed images distributed in the Middle East to incite outrage, and a detailed follow-up on the illustrated book that started the fuss (LINK)
My point? While the way the airline acted was totally wrong (& quite stupid in fact), if someone want to find something to arose hatred of the U.S. its not hard-- this incident is just a drop in the bucket.
Completely off topic.
Completely off topic.
People here often attack you-- unfairly IMO. Your presence actually does a lot of good here-- comments like that provide the type of humour we need here when things become boring!
That's off topic too !
I agree that this is a drop in the bucket but this is, to me, heading in a slightly different direction. It raises the threat of open discrimination in public accommodation. In conjunction with statements by people like Trump, it can negatively affect groups that were relatively unphased before.
The really huge thing is this: They refunded his money for the LA-Oakland flight immediately, and then he was told that he would not be welcomed to fly Southwest in the future. If there was any possibility, no matter how remote, that there may have been a misunderstanding, the harsh sanction would never have been considered. And the lady who reported him? She knew exactly what he was saying because SHE SPEAKS FREAKING ARABIC.
From this article:
For Makhzoomi, who says terrorism thrives on Islamophobia, this is not the way to fight terrorism.
“I only hate one thing in my life: Islamic State,” he said. “We should challenge terrorism not with ignorance but with education and knowledge.”
Then I suggest that the next time he flies and decides to 'accidentally' make public his extremist Islamic tendencies, he might want to take better inventory of those sitting around him. She may have been white. She may have been only a woman. But her language skills were pretty much in his face.
Then I suggest that the next time he flies and decides to 'accidentally' make public his extremist Islamic tendencies, he might want to take better inventory of those sitting around him. She may have been white. She may have been only a woman.
Pure speculation.
As for Southwest banning him, most likely it is a response to a presumed public reaction - to wit, others among Southwest customers would not want to fly with him no matter how innocent he may be. Banning him is "good" public relations.
You could be right and maybe he does have "extreme Islamic tendencies", but there is no way to tell that from this article.
Speaking a language doesn't mean she can't misunderstand what he said. He said he didn't say what she thought she heard and she is no more believable than he is. If he were a danger and anybody could prove it, then he wouldn't be free now.
BTW, even if he said the word martyr (and he says he didn't) just saying the word is not a threat of any kind. He is free to say it as much as he likes in as many languages as he chooses. It's called free speech.
Speaking a language doesn't mean she can't misunderstand what he said.
That's true. I was born and raised speaking American English and I don't understand a lot of the stupid shit some of the right wingers on here say. Pure gibberish and nonsense, mixed in with quite a few lies and a LOT (AND I MEAN A LOT) of myths.
Totally disagree sister. First off their are a multitude of Arabic dialects, much like Spanish. So there is no evidence that she really understood what he was saying.
Second, any American is allowed to speak any damn language that they choose at any time that they choose to do so. Airplane, airport, freeway, movie it doesn't matter one twit. The 1st amendment still applies in this country.
If this man was a danger, I doubt that he would have walked away from the airport. SW is way off base one this one.
I think you're missing the perception of the other SW customers . That was probably the motivation for the actions taken by SW .
Good grief, Kavika. He wasn't removed from the plane for speaking Arabic. He was removed from the plane for using Jihadist-related speech loud enough for others to hear. The First Amendment does not protect those who use certain words and phrases spoken on any and all airport property, which includes remote parking areas, the terminals, the aircraft, or the 3rd urinal on the left in the employee men's restroom. There are warning signs posted everywhere which make the federal regulations regarding this very thing clear. Even flight personnel and airport staff are prohibited from expressing any words or phrases that can be considered antagonistic or cause fear...not even in jest. Besides, he is the only person declaring that the word in question was 'shahid". If that were truly the case, we wouldn't be having this discussion, and he wouldn't be on the Southwest no-fly list.
I find it interesting that he said this in a media interview:
This is a country that respects the rule of law, and we must all together respect the rule of law
Whether one likes it or not, they must respect the federal laws pertaining to airline comportment. If you or I or the 1.73 million passengers who fly daily must, by law, follow directives created specifically in response to a global terrorist climate, what makes this guy exempt?
Whether one likes it or not, they must respect the federal laws pertaining to airline comportment. If you or I or the 1.73 million passengers who fly daily must, by law, follow directives created specifically in response to a global terrorist climate, what makes this guy exempt?
Neither you nor anyone else has cited "ANY" federal regulation that is violated simply by saying the word "martyr" either in Arabic or any other language. He obviously can't make threats on an airline and there is absolutely no proof that he did. The word "martyr" in and of itself is not a threat. He's not doing anything wrong simply because some idiot next to him was eavesdropping on his telephone call and thought she heard a word that he says he didn't use, spoken in a context that this article doesn't provide (and that the eavesdropper couldn't know because he wasn't talking to her).
There are so many FAA, NTSB, TSA, and HLS regulations and statutes and whatever else pertaining to this subject, that a person can't swing a spicey السلامي without hitting something that will stick in court.
So... start here . You'll also find what happens to any American-based airline who unjustly persecutes a passenger, or group of passengers. It's actually pretty compelling. It contains federal and state statutes. This will also be helpful. Painfully verbose, but helpful.
Just for the record, I'm not making this crap up. I lived it. The procedures aren't always flight crew friendly. There could be a ghost rider on the plane at any time who is there for the express purpose of trying to trip somebody up. Their role could be anything from the obnoxious passenger from hell, to someone behaving in a manner that would arouse the kind of suspicion often seen in the situation with Southwest. If you miss a procedure or lose your cool, you lose your job. Believe it or not, there really are checks and balances.
Perhaps I may have watched those planes crash into the WTC towers one too many times. It's incredibly easy to see my friends working those flights, and the only thing sent home to their families was a pinkie toe and half of an airport ID. I also volunteered to work the military flights (government chartered commercial jetliners) that brought the troops home from Desert Storm/Shield. For crying out loud, we had to have fighter escorts just to land, load the plane, and haul ass out of there. Although the experience was rewarding, it was mentally exhausting. I will admit that those things might have played more of a negative role than I thought they did.
In any event, happy reading.
Sister, your problem is you assume facts not in evidence. Your assumption that he is an actual Islamic jihadist extremist is not borne out by anything in the story, but is on your say so. That may work for you, but the rest of us want to see more proof he was a threat.
John, I know how to pick up a phone. I knew exactly who to call, and exactly what to ask. It's that simple. I was able to learn the name of the female involved, and what she does for a living (and it's really good). Whether she wants to come forward or not, is up to her. One thing I can tell you is that she was frightened by the experience and did not want Mr. Makhzoomi knowing her name or anything about her. That is the reason he was free to leave and book another flight on another airline. Without her, there was no cause for formal action, apart from being banned from ever flying Southwest again.
It's your choice to believe or disbelieve the facts that I've offered, and they are facts, not speculation. But one thing you can believe is that I will remain unaffected by your decision.
What does the woman say he said ?, if she speaks Arabic and heard him, then she knows the context of his words into the phone. What was it? If she does not know that, then she does not have sufficient information to implicate him. If you don't know exactly what her specific concerns were, then you don't have sufficient information to implicate him.
So what does she say he said?
I was wondering why the person who reported wasn't removed from the plane as well as the student. Wouldn't local authorities need a statement from the woman who reported to determine if the "suspected" bad guy was telling the truth?
In normal conversation, I've used the word martyr. I know not to utter "bomb" in an airport, even jokingly, perhaps Homeland should publish a list of forbidden words to speak in and around airports!
There are so many FAA, NTSB, TSA, and HLS regulations and statutes and whatever else pertaining to this subject, that a person can't swing a spicey السلامي without hitting something that will stick in court . . .
I read through this and don't see a single provision that was violated in this case.
I read through this and don't see a single provision that was violated in this case.
Unable to open the links I provided, or just didn't bother?
I read through this and don't see a single provision that was violated in this case.
Unable to open the links I provided or just didn't bother.
I opened and read them. Let me repeat -- I didn't see a single provision that was violated by the conduct described in this article. Although the provisions authorize officials to keep a plane safe (if that's what you mean), there is nothing in them that remotely suggests this particular behavior was dangerous. To be clear, the issue is not what officials can do about dangerous behavior. Instead, the issue is whether the behavior is dangerous in the first place. Saying the word martyr, even if he said it, is not dangerous. And it doesn't become dangerous simply because some people are irrationally afraid of the word or fear Arabs or fear Arabs speaking Arabic etc.
Oy.
Both links address the issues at hand. What you want will not be found on page one. In their entirety, those links will give you an understanding of that which you fail to understand now. Both documents give federal authority to airline and airport officials to determine what is a credible threat and what isn't, and those threats include, but are not limited to specific patterns in speech and behavior. However, you are free to try this shortcut: On your next flight, as you are standing at the counter checking your bags, make a joke about a bomb, or a knife, or any easily concealed weapon or that you are on your way to meet your ISIS recruiter, and see how far it gets you to your destination. It will not take you long to figure out that there's not thing one you can do about what's headed your way.
And most importantly, this mess is not about the term 'martyr'. That was nothing more than a weak, victim mentality excuse made by a guy who knew exactly what time it was. He said it himself. "I think I'm about to be reported." There is only one reason as to why he would think such a thing.
Both links address the issues at hand. What you want will not be found on page one. In their entirety, those links will give you an understanding of that which you fail to understand now. Both documents give federal authority to airline and airport officials to determine what is a credible threat and what isn't, and those threats include, but are not limited to specific patterns in speech and behavior. However, you are free to try this shortcut: On your next flight, as you are standing at the counter checking your bags, make a joke about a bomb, or a knife, or any easily concealed weapon or that you are on your way to meet your ISIS recruiter, and see how far it gets you to your destination
Now it becomes apparent what you see in these provisions that I do not. I interpret a credible threat to be one that rational people would see as posing a danger to flight safety. Obviously, stating that you are concealing illegal weapons and/or stating that you're a member of a terrorist organization poses a credible threat.
This article only says that he used the word martyr in a telephone conversation (no context is provided) and it was overheard by a passenger eavesdropping nearby. To you, that is the same as saying he's armed and/or a terrorist simply because he is an Arab speaking in Arabic. To me, using the word martyr (which he denies saying) is not, standing alone, part of a pattern of speech or behavior that poses a threat, credible or otherwise. If a catholic priest were on the flight and used the word martyr in a private telephone conversation, it wouldn't have raised one eyebrow. Federal law cannot prohibit non-threatening speech without violating the First Amandment and speech cannot be viewed as threatening based simply on the race or nationality of the speaker without being discriminatory. I don't really have a problem with questioning this guy but you take it further to suggest that he was actually guilty of something when there is no evidence of it.
federal regulation that is violated simply by saying the word "martyr" either in Arabic or any other language.
The Patriot Act would be the law I would cite .
The Patriot Act would be the law I would cite .
And what specific provision under the Patriot Act was violated?
The "go fuck yourself" provision ...
The "go fuck yourself" provision
Perhaps they have an illustrated version in crayon that you can read along with your kindergarten teacher.
UPDATE
Southwest Airlines has released a statement on why it removed Khairuldeen Makhzoomi, a Iraqi asylee and student at the University of California, Berkeley, from a flight on April 6. It says the passenger who reported Makhzoomi for making comments in Arabic that were “perceived to be threatening” during a phone conversation with his uncle in Baghdad was also an Arabic-speaker.
The nuance is important because many people on social media assumed that Makhzoomi was singled out for racist reasons, or for simply speaking Arabic. The airline says, “It was the content of the passenger’s conversation, not the language used, that prompted the report leading to our investigation.”
It is unclear, however, just how much Arabic the passenger who reported him speaks, or whether Southwest knew it, then or now. Multiple requests to the airline seeking to clarify this have yet to be returned.
Since the beginning, it’s been suggested that a linguistic misunderstanding was to blame. In the first report of the incident, Makhzoomi told the The Daily Californian that, after being taken off the plane, “[h]e learned the passenger thought she had heard the word ‘Shahid,’ meaning martyr, which is associated with jihad and has been associated with terrorists.”
But shahid— literally “witness” in Quranic Arabic—has a much wider connotation than that. Among Palestinians, for instance, anybody killed by Israeli security forces, and, in some cases even by the Palestinian security forces, is often called a shahid , whether militant or civilian or even a child. Around the world, Muslims may refer to someone who has died in natural disasters, in childbirth, of drowning, or even of stomach illness as a shahid .
News reports have also picked up (paywall) on Makhzoomi’s mention of the fact that he ended the phone call by saying he would call again when he landed “ inshallah ,” or “God willing.” In Arabic, inshallah is used liberally in all sorts of settings; for some Arabic-speakers, it’s practically a grammatical marker of the future tense.
Yes, this information is important. How do we balance situations like these? This situation has so many different angles. Is it profiling or racism or is it being safe rather than sorry. That is the challenge.
“inshallah,” or “God willing.” In Arabic, inshallah is used liberally in all sorts of settings; for some Arabic-speakers, it’s practically a grammatical marker of the future tense.
Well there's the problem. Durn fool didn't finish his sentence in proper Southern.
Inshallah, (god willing), & the creek don't rise, I'll call you tomorrow Uncle.
Perfect!
Imagine the conversation we would be having if a terrorist successfully took down a plane, and evidence is found of a passenger expressing concern over something the guy was heard to say on the phone in Farsi. We would be beating ourselves up about how and why this was allowed to happen. As much as it sucked for him, he needs to understand how his actions spooked someone and put himself in that position.