The Plain Truth - Bernie Sanders Is Not A Socialist, According To Actual Socialists
http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2016/05/the-socialist-case-against-bernie/476409/
But as it happens, the real socialists—the ones toiling, lonely, in the trenches; the ones who never felt a need to temper their philosophy with a mitigating adjective like democratic , as Sanders does—are strikingly ungrateful. Puryear’s party, the PSL, issued a statement last August, when Sanders began to gain traction, tartly rejecting his campaign. “His program is not socialist,” it noted.
"...Until recently, socialist was effectively a slur in political circles. (In 2011, a formal complaint was lodged against a Republican congressman who referred to Democrats using the term, and it was struck from the Congressional Record.) But this year, Sanders, with his youth movement and his calls for “political revolution,” reintroduced the label to polite company. At enormous rallies across the country, his fans told journalists they were proud to call themselves socialists. For a political movement long confined to the fringes of American discourse, Sanders would seem to have done an enormous service.
...the Party For Socialism And Liberation issued a statement last August, when Sanders began to gain traction, tartly rejecting his campaign. “His program is not socialist,” it noted. . ....He does not call for nationalizing the corporations and banks, without which the reorganization of the economy to meet people’s needs rather than maximizing the profits of capitalist investors could not take place … He is clearly seeking to reform the existing capitalist system.
The crowds at Sanders’s events, the PSL contended, showed popular hunger for a far-left platform. But Sanders wasn’t really providing one—he was, they implied, guilty of a bait and switch. Some in the socialist blogosphere (like all fringe political movements, socialism has a lively and disputatious Internet presence) have gone further. Socialist Action, a Trotskyist organization, accused Sanders of a pernicious “lesser-evil politics” designed to hoodwink workers into supporting the corrupt Democrats.
Puryear isn’t so antagonistic. Some effects of Sanders’s rise are, he told me, worth applauding. “He has revealed that there are millions of people who not only are progressive on the issues, but in a more holistic way are willing to refer to themselves as socialist,” he said. “It’s exciting to know that young people haven’t lost all hope.” And yet, when it comes to substance, Puryear considers Sanders’s policy ideas inadequate. “Our economy as it’s currently constructed cannot possibly provide enough decent employment for the number of people being born every single day,” Puryear said. The solution, in his view, is to take the aggregate product of society’s labor and, rather than let the market allocate it mostly to the upper classes, divide it to meet everybody’s needs.
Puryear, who grew up in Charlottesville, Virginia, a couple of hours south of D.C., has always been political. “The feeling that, if you think something’s wrong, you’d better do something about it is strong in my family,” he told me. According to family lore, a maternal ancestor was a Reconstruction legislator; a grandfather was active in the Communist Party–affiliated Popular Front; his father was a civil-rights activist. Puryear protested the Iraq War when he was 16 and plunged into activism at Howard University, getting involved with the Latin American–solidarity and pro-Palestinian movements.
Along the way, Puryear came to think of himself as a socialist, and while he was vaguely aware that some people might consider his identification outré, in his circles it was pretty acceptable. This was not entirely because of the company he kept; it was also a reflection of his generation. Millennials, he told me, don’t have the same hang-ups about socialism that their parents once did.
Surveys back up Puryear’s impression. A January poll by YouGov found that 43 percent of Americans ages 18 to 29 have a favorable view of socialism—nearly double the proportion of those 65 and older. That may be because they didn’t grow up in the shadow of the Cold War. But having come of age in the time of financial crashes and Occupy Wall Street, young people may also be more skeptical of free markets. In the same poll, just 32 percent of young people had a favorable view of capitalism, versus 63 percent of seniors.
Sanders himself never sought to identify as a socialist: Only when his enemies started accusing him of being one did he, in characteristically pugnacious fashion, reappropriate the insult as a badge of pride. Some critics have pointed out that it would be more accurate to call him a social democrat, rather than a democratic socialist. After all, Sanders has said he defines democratic socialism as something akin to the systems in Denmark or Finland—countries with high taxes and a capacious welfare state, but relatively free markets.
“The ideology of the Scandinavian governments is really just a more fair capitalist society,” Puryear told me. True socialism as Marx and Engels envisioned it, by contrast, was intended as a way station on the road to full-fledged communism. “We refer to ourselves as socialists because what we’re trying to promote is the move from capitalism to socialism,” he said. But the ultimate goal is not Finland. It is a fully classless society in which the state has withered away to nothing.
Tags
Who is online
113 visitors

Sanders himself never sought to identify as a socialist: Only when his enemies started accusing him of being one did he, in characteristically pugnacious fashion, reappropriate the insult as a badge of pride.
Who doesn't know this already? He uses the socialist tag as re-stated sarcasm at the establishment.
"But the ultimate goal is ............. a fully classless society in which the state has withered away to nothing."
And that is why he is not and never will be a full fledged democrat. Democrats depend upon the police power of the state to enact by force their socialist ideals upon pseudo classes of citizens artificially divided against one another while claiming unity.
If socialism means nationalizing all corporations and institutions then I guess the difference between Marxism and the kind of socialism currently in most western countries is democratic government, which can change who runs the show. I wonder, since true socialism is not the case in most western countries, why there are NT members who think Canada is a pinko socialist country because it has universal health care.
because it has universal health care.
That's all it takes. for some. They are the same types who want to get rid of Social Security and Medicare completely and fuck you if you can afford to live or starve or get sick or die of an illness. There are a huge number of "Social Darwinists" on the GOP right wing. In fact I would venture to say most of them are. Survival of the fittest, PERIOD. That Florida congressman (I forget his name) was right. The GOP Health Care Plan is...DIE.
"Social Darwinists" on the GOP right wing.
I think many of these cnsider themselves to be Conservative Republicans, but some are "Libertarians". They are about as opposite to Socialism as you can get.
If you lived on a raod and wanted it paved, under them the government wouldn't do it. Rather, everyone living on along that stretch of raod woud have to do-- agree to doing it, collect money from indivduals, decide on a private contractor & get it paved.
I think ultimately Libertarians would want to print their own money, have privately hired militias protect the country, etc.
And you haven't a clue what Libertarianism actually is. You know what whackos claim it to be which is worse than nothing.
I suggest you take off the blinders and go learn something about it.
Or in the alternative keep right on demonstrating how clueless you actually are.
I suggest you take off the blinders and go learn something about it.
Actually, I was a Libertarian-- for about a year. I read a lot about, and discussed a lot with other Libertarians (We had a Libertarian Club which met regularly).
But one of the things I learned was that all Libertarians don't necessarily have the same view on all aspects of it. (Probably true with most political philosophies, actually).
Very good, You are almost there to understanding, but you still haven't overcome the one thing that hold most back.
True Libertarianism isn't a political philosophy.
It's a way of life.
If you lived on a raod and wanted it paved, under them the government wouldn't do it. Rather, everyone living on along that stretch of raod woud have to do-- agree to doing it, collect money from indivduals, decide on a private contractor & get it paved.
I'd rather pay my taxes and have the government pave the road. Less hassle. First of all you have to get all of the people along the road to agree it should be paved. Some people are going to have different lengths of road frontage so you have to decide who pays more and who pays less depending on how much frontage the have, etc. Then the contractor is bound to be the uncle or brother-in-law of someone who lives on the road and will do an extra nice job in front of certain residences and worse in front of homes the guy doesn't like. Way, way, way to much hassle and too many ways for it to end up fucked up...bad.
So would I....
Paying your taxes is as libertarian as it gets.
And just as obviously, you are going to criticize what you do not know.
Too bad.
I am seriously beginning to wonder if you do since you change all of the time. You have no consistence.
I don't change, What your real issue is?
I don't fit into your preconceived notion of what a Libertarian should be.
Very few of us do.
There are liberals, conservatives, religionists of all stripe, atheists, Republicans, Democrats pretty much any political denomination you can come up with.
And they are Libertarian to the core.
Your preconceptions of Libertarians that they are something to revile are what hold you back from seeing the truth.
Your preconceptions of Libertarians that they are something to revile are what hold you back from seeing the truth
I don't have any and that statement is just bullshit.
You don't fit into anyone's political or lifestyle concept of anything or anyone because you constantly change your positions and then accuse others of not understanding you when the point it out to you. It's not possible to understand you because you purposely have decided you don't want anyone to because it more fun to you to constantly accuse others of not understanding you. You're game playing.
You have a bizarre need to be seen as some sort of mystery person, but you're just jerking others around, either for fun or because you can't help yourself.
Yep, Insults go a long way to proving your contentions.
Typical when you can't or won't accept people for what they are. When you have to pigeon hole them into your own little preconceptions.
And we come to it finally, when you can't understand, you insult and disparage.
Why, cause it is easier to insult and disparage rather than gain a greater understanding.
The ends justify the means, ie take the easy way out.
Oh one little thing you forgot to mention whan you were claiming that Einstein left Germany because he was a socialist. He never revealed what his personal ideas were on the state of man in society until 1948 when he wrote his first piece for a fledgling magazine. It's available online if anyone want to read it. And he wholeheartedly rejected the commonly accepted socialist/communist paradigm. I actually read it.
But that was 1948. In the late 30's when he left Germany and became a US citizen, it was because he was Jewish. If I remember correctly a lot of people were leaving Germany for that very reason in the 30's.
Your liberal college professors propaganda paper you cited, written in 2011, failed to mention that little fact.
Your quest to trash anything that disagrees with your little liberal/socialist paradigm. Has fallen flat on it's face.
You have a very nice rest of the day.
Sure. Whatever you say. I believe you. Of course I have never even mentioned Einstein's name at all in any post on any subject in the history this site. Or cited an paper by any college professor at all. But if it's in your mind that I did, well then it must be true, to you any way.
You know there have a few times in darker times in my past when I have run across people like you. Unfortunately I was usually in a position at the time where I couldn't get very far away from them (for reasons I'd rather not go into), but I discovered that it's best to just keep agreeing with whatever they say. No matter how bizarre or strange or disconnected from what you say or reality and that eventually they'll wander away, usually mumbling to themselves. Until they corner someone else to "talk" to.
Have a normal day.
Ok, here is the link to the posting of the Kline propaganda article
Which you used to support the ideal that the Nazi's are not socialists, Kline purports that the Nazi's were not socialists cause they were sending them off to the gas chambers just like the jews and makes the argument that Einstein left Germany cause he was a socialist.
You posted it in defense of your proposition which was the same as his.
In that article he linked to the Article Einstein actually wrote in 1948 which was published by the magazine in 1949.
You made the same argument he did in defense of your position (which is completely false cause it is based upon a false premise Einstein left cause he was a Jew long before he ever stated his positions on the condition of man)
Doesn't matter if you typed the actual words, (you didn't) but you used his which did. Hence making them yours.
You don't get to make an argument, then claim you never did. And, if you use someone else's argument as an evidentiary simile to back up yours, his words become yours.
So your right you never typed his name on the site, but you made the argument anyway.
And it is absolutely false.
I will have a very pleasant day, thank you.
I agree with you completely. With whatever you say.
There are not, and never have been, a significant numner of "social darwinsts" on the right wing of American politics. Not that liberals actually seem to,care about academic research or history, but the favorable mentions of Darwinism were almost exclusively from progressives. Sterilize the infirm, the blacks etc...
Read the liberal heroine margert sanger if you want to see actual darwinst policies championed. Keeping all the non WASPS from reproducing was the goal of progressives through much of the 20th century.
If socialism means nationalizing all corporations and institutions
Socialism & Communism are based on the ideas of Marx (amongst others). And over time, not surprisingly, different people interpreted his teachings differently, or in some cases modified that to fit their particular situation.
IMO all philosophies that are based on the teachings of Marx are Socialist-- everything from the Stalinist form of Communism to some very moderate, democratic forms of Socialism.
Communism is only one type of Marxism/Socialism. And of course there are also other forms of Socialism that are not Communism.
While Communism and Capitalism are incompatible (Unless live in China
, Socialism & Capitalism can be compatible & can co-exist in the same society. One example of the is the U.S. We have aspects of both. (Social Security is basically a Socialist idea-- although most Americans accept it, and that even includes many Republicans."Free enterprise", being able to start your own business is Capitalism).
Socialism means nationalizing all corporations & institutions? Depends. Its true with one form of Socialism-- i.e. Communism. But with other forms there may be a little or a lot of nationalization. (In the U.S. I believe the Post Office is nationalized (or is it now private, I forgot). The Treasury Dept, and printing of money has been nationalized. Defense of our country (the military) has been nationalized.
According to "Actual" Socialists
If you have two groups of Socialists who interpret marx's teachings differently-- which one are the "actual" Socialists? And which group tends to decide it?
Its similar to religions-- which groups of Christians are "actual" Christians-- Baptists? Catholics? Evangelicals? Mormons? Unitarian-Universalists? Quakers?