╌>

Rape victim could be punished under Brigham Young University’s ‘honor code’

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  community  •  10 years ago  •  21 comments

Rape victim could be punished under Brigham Young University’s ‘honor code’

Students protest over case of sophomore Madi Barney, who publicly revealed she was raped and then punished for violating the mormon school’s bylaws.


Brigham Young University sexual assault Students rallied outside Brigham Young University on Wednesday to protest the school’s treatment of sexual assault victims, calling for revisions to the Mormon university’s “honor code”, religious bylaws through which rape victims can be punished for having consumed alcohol or had a member of the opposite sex in a bedroom.

The protest follows outrage over the rape case of sophomore Madi Barney, 19, who reported to Provo, Utah , police that she was raped in her off-campus apartment during a date.

According to police documents viewed by the Salt Lake Tribune, Barney claims the perpetrator, 39-year-old Nasiru Seidu, lied about his age, name, and marital status, and that he raped her while she cried out and screamed ‘no’. The Tribune said the police confirmed those details during a staged phone call between Barney and Seidu after she filed the report.

A Utah County sheriff’s deputy, who was friends with the accused, then sent Barney’s police case file to BYU and, two months after her attack, she was summoned to the honor code office for a disciplinary hearing.

“We have received information that you have been a victim of behavior that is addressed in the university Sexual Misconduct Policy,” a BYU official wrote to her in December, according to the Salt Lake Tribune . “We have also received information that you have engaged in behavior that violates the BYU Honor Code. I would like to meet with you and provide you with the information that we have received and give you an opportunity to respond.”

Barney went public with her case last week, and a petition she drafted demanding BYU grant victims of sexual assault immunity from honor code punishments has since garnered over 90,000 signatures.

Citing safety concerns, Barney’s supporters said she could not attend Wednesday’s protest, but they delivered the petition on her behalf to a representative of BYU president Kevin Worthen. They wore teal armbands, a symbol of solidarity with assault victims, and carried placards that read, “Protect victims, don’t shame them.”

A fellow rape survivor, Brooke Swallow, said, “Dissension is a Mormon value. We need dissension and dissidents in this culture so we can effect change.”

Under the counsel of her attorney, Barney declined to participate in the school hearing, claiming it would complicate her legal case. The university has since blocked her from registering for new classes, she told the Salt Lake Tribune. And when she tried to retroactively withdraw from two courses she struggled in due to frequent court appearances and other aspects of the investigation, Barney’s request was denied because, according to her account, administrators said they “can’t prove the rape occurred”. Barney did not respond to a message from the Guardian seeking comment.

She has filed an official complaint to US Department of Education, according to the Tribune, saying BYU denied her services that under federal law should be available to sexual assault victims in accordance with Title IX, the gender equity rule that requires schools to address reports of sexual assault and harassment. The university claimed to be meeting Title IX compliance standards when it began investigating Barney’s case.


In a Facebook post announcing Wednesday’s protest, Barney noted that by reporting sex crimes, victims like her expose themselves to potential probation, suspension or even expulsion. “Nothing a survivor does makes rape or any sexual assault OK,” she wrote. “By investigating victims for violations of the honor code, BYU is revictimizing those who come forward and blaming them for what happened.”

The Department of Education warned universities in a 2011 letter about the “chilling effect” that disciplinary policies may have “on victims’ or other students’ reporting of sexual violence offenses”.

“Schools should be aware that victims or third parties may be deterred from reporting incidents if alcohol, drugs, or other violations of school or campus rules were involved.”

In response to the uproar Barney’s case has inspired, Worthen issued a statement on Monday promising to “study” the relationship between its Title IX office and honor code office.

“Sometimes in the course of an investigation, facts come to light that a victim has engaged in prior Honor Code violations. The university recognizes the inherent tension, in some circumstances, in these two important parts of BYU’s efforts to create and maintain an atmosphere consistent with the ideals and principles of the Church,” the statement read. “In all Honor Code proceedings, the university strives for fairness, sensitivity and compassion, taking into account all mitigating facts and circumstances.”

The school’s announcement did not impress Kelsey Bourgeois, an organizer from the petition network Care2 and a former BYU student. She told the Guardian, “It seems more like they are trying to get this bad press to go away versus really committing to making a change.

“Just saying they’re going to ‘study it’ isn’t really enough.”

http://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2016/apr/20/brigham-young-sexual-assault-victims-protests-honor-code?utm_source=esp&utm_medium=Email&utm_campaign=GU+Today+USA+-+Version+CB+header&utm_term=168346&subid=14230036&CMP=ema_565



Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    10 years ago

So it's HER fault that she was raped? SHE is the one getting punished? Where the fuck is Brigham Young located? Saudi Arabia?

This is raping her again and making sure other girls who are raped and attending the school, even in their own apartments, will be punished because they "let themselves" get raped! I guess the school expects them to just lay back and take it and then keep their mouth shut about the crime! Are they living in the 18th century?

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  Randy   10 years ago

There is one hell of a lot more to this story that any news article is going to reveal. So it is difficult to really respond here.

They proved the rape took place and that it actually was a rape through a recorded phone conversation between the victim and perpetrator AFTER it took place? you mean she made contact with her rapist after she was raped in her bedroom. And, it was conversation civil enough for the alleged attacker to actually respond and discuss what transpired. (alleged is used in a legal sense here, not a personal opinion sense on veracity) There's a whole ton more to the story there than meets the eye.

So obviously she didn't feel threatened in any way. So it wasn't a typical rape. (which is about power and control)

Personally No woman should be forced to endure the sexual advances of anyone when she doesn't want such advances and there is no "No mean Yes" which I adamantly believe. A woman says no at any point in the coital act you stop and check the room temp so to speak. (in a real criminal rape, saying no is irrelevant)

That being said. I also believe that a woman has a responsibility for her own security. She has to be aware of her surroundings and acquaintances and do her best not to place herself in situations which could result in unwanted things happening. It's called being self aware.

This was not a rape in the commonly understood sense of a violent power/control crime. This was a rape of absence or withdrawal of implied consent. It's the only way it can be looked at given the paucity of evidence.

But for the grace of god go I. In my youth there were any number of occasions where I could have been the subject of a rape complaint like this. I was never accused of such cause the approach was consensual and the end result was not what the lady in question truly wanted, but she accepted (besides she never said no or gave any indication she wasn't accepting of what was occurring).

I guess I was lucky.

But what the School is doing is atrocious. They have no more right to power/control over what she does or who she does it with in her bedroom than I do. This is why I hate organized religion, the dogmas of such say that you have to allow such judgmental acts in the name of god. and they call it having "Honor" Seems to me they have a warped sense of "Honor"

The Honor I feel and understand the most is a heartfelt giving of personal individual respect one to another whether public or private.

The Honor they are claiming is a taking, it is demanding that which isn't earned.

And that isn't honest in my book. and brings dishonor to those who demand such.

But to use it to deliberately take action against someone who has done nothing wrong? punish them?

The dishonor is squarely on them.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy  replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago

The dishonor is squarely on them.

Even an atheist like me can say Amen to that.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    10 years ago

She violated the school's" Honor Code" by having a male in her off campus apartment, who happened to rape her, and she will be punished by being kicked out of school. Where the hell is the "Honor" in that?

 
 
 
jennilee
Freshman Silent
link   jennilee    10 years ago

I am in no way blaming the victim, her rapist should be prosecuted when the rape is proven.  But on the other side, the honor code is in place as a way to maybe prevent a women from getting herself in this situation.  Too many times women consume too much alcohol and make a bad decision.  We have all woken in the morning and thought "what the hell was I thinking?"  The days of chaperones and more discrete behavior are gone.  We have not made ourselves safer.  The school may, by implementing and enforcing the honor code, be trying to save a young women from making a decision that ends in rape, or worse.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  jennilee   10 years ago

I wholeheartedly agree with everything you state here.

And YES, it could be the schools attempt to make their younger female students aware of what could happen and to take appropriate actions to lessen the dangers.

The thing is, taking actions against her afterwards is wrong. It is imposing a moral standard based upon a religious dogma that has no place in getting an education. Yes I can see the schools dilemma at creating standards of safety that serve the needs of both sides. Yet, do not cross into the realms of personal privacy or controlling the lives of it's students.

That would be placing religion over teaching.

So one has to ask, what is the school trying to accomplish?

Many of us have had the experience of OOPS! when we wake up the next morning with someone draped over us wondering what in the hell we did last night. (not remembering a thing)

WE all do stupid shit at times with the opposite sex, most of the time it is called a life's lesson or a learning experience. (or a marriage license and parenting classes)

Occasionally, it is deemed to be something you need to answer for. (having sex without your partners permission is one such thing)

The issue here though is the schools actions, which are totally way beyond setting up standards of behavior.

 
 
 
jennilee
Freshman Silent
link   jennilee  replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago

I understand your point, and it is a good one. The only thing is, this IS a religious institution. The women know the rule going in. They are only pushing their religion on those who made a choice to be there.  Harsh consequences,  but it may save another young girls life,  who may now abide by the honor code because of the consequences,  both froth school and personally.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy  replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago

The thing is, taking actions against her afterwards is wrong. It is imposing a moral standard based upon a religious dogma that has no place in getting an education. Yes I can see the schools dilemma at creating standards of safety that serve the needs of both sides. Yet, do not cross into the realms of personal privacy or controlling the lives of it's students.

Exactly. Religious school or not she was in her own private apartment off campus. It's not like she sneaked someone into her women's dorm room. Besides she was RAPED. It's not like she invited a man up to HER apartment for consensual sex. The list of the school's so called Honor Code should be a guide. Not a set of laws that punish someone who has already been through a terrible experience. The school is clearly going way beyond proper boundaries in this case. What the are doing to her is the very opposite of being Honorable. As I said before, this is not Saudi Arabia.

Plus it will make other victims of rape afraid to report the crime for fear of being kicked out of school. This is the school saying if you are the victim of a rape, it is your fault and shut up about it or we'll banish and shame you.

Also incidents like this make the religion in question look "cult-ish" rather then a loving, forgiving, Christian institution.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    10 years ago

Once again, religion poisons everything.

 
 
 
jennilee
Freshman Silent
link   jennilee  replied to  Hal A. Lujah   10 years ago

Did religion rape this woman? Did religion tell her to bring an unknown man back to her apartment?  Did religion tell her to do whatever she wants and damn the consequences?  

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah  replied to  jennilee   10 years ago

No, it rejected her for being a human.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy  replied to  jennilee   10 years ago

No, but the religion has no right to punish her for being raped which is what they are doing. There is no honor in what they are doing to her. All they are doing is driving other rape victim underground and refusing to report the crime out of fear of banishment and shaming from what is supposed to be a loving, forgiving, Christian church. They are acting more like a ridged cult then a Christian church. They are acting like they are under Saudi law. The "dishonor" for "allowing" herself to be raped is being put on her. They are punishing the victim.

If they truly were a loving Christian church they would take her in their loving arms and comfort her and help get past what happened to her. They would be supportive, not judgemental. They would not blame her by punishing her, by shaming her like this is still the 18th century. The Christ they say they worship would turn his back on them for what they are doing to her. There is no honor in their code if this is a result of it.

 
 
 
jennilee
Freshman Silent
link   jennilee  replied to  Randy   10 years ago

Taking an unknown man to your apartment is dangerous behavior.  Do you have any idea how many women are raped, tortured, murdered by men they just met? The stats are scary and horrifying.   The school is enforcing a code that they hope will prevent this.  As I said, the man must be prosecuted and punished.  But in this case, maybe the woman has to learn to respect herself and take measures to prevent this from happening again.  If the school explains that they have these codes in place to help women make better decisions,  at a time in their life when good decisions don't come easy, they may save a life.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy  replied to  jennilee   10 years ago

But they are not saving lives! They are punishing a victim! She made a mistake, but she does not deserve to be punished by her religion for it! She should be being comforted by them for what happened. Helped. Counseled. Cared for. That's what real religions do.

Religions are supposed to help people. It did not happen on campus in a dorm. It was in her private apartment where she can do as she pleases because she is a free American. They were not involved in any manner whatsoever. Yet they feel that because she "allowed" herself to be raped she has some how "dishonored" their school and church and religion by being a victim of a crime. They are punishing her for being a victim. For dishonoring them. That is NOT Christian! That is cult-ish. They do not have the right to punish her for something that did not involve their "religion" or school in any manner. They are raping her all over again. The dishonor is theirs in this case, but the are trying to dishonor her. They should be ashamed of themselves for what they are doing to her.

 
 
 
jennilee
Freshman Silent
link   jennilee  replied to  Randy   10 years ago

From what I read, and I may have missed something,  the school has tried to meet with her to discuss this and she, on advice from a lawyer, has refused to meet them. If I am wrong on this, I apologize,  but I still do not change my opinion of the situation. 

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy  replied to  jennilee   10 years ago

Neither do I. They should be standing by her side in love and not punishing her for something that was not her fault. Inviting someone to your apartment is not an invitation for sex, or in this case rape and unless someone changed the dictionary on me no still means no. SHE IS THE VICTIM HERE. NOT BRIGHAM YOUNG! Yet they are acting like her "allowing" herself to be raped somehow dishonors THEM! Is this the 18th century when women were not much ore then chattel in some churches or is this the 21st century when we know women are the victims of rape and not inviters of it. NO MEANS NO!

Her lawyer told her to decline to be in a hearing at the school to decide if they were going to punish her because it might mess up her criminal case against the rapist, which is far more important. Well there should have never even been a hearing. In a real church there would be open arms of love and comfort. Not banishment and shaming.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell    10 years ago

I wonder how old she thought the 39 year old man was. Must be a baby face.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    10 years ago

I have what many might consider a stupid question, or at best an inappropriate one. Did he force himself into her bedroom or did she invite him in?

I'll balance that with stating my admiration of the late Canadian Prime Minister Pierre Elliott Trudeau, the father of the present Prime Minister, who stated as government policy: "The state has no business in the bedrooms of the nation." IMO neither do university administrations.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy  replied to  Buzz of the Orient   10 years ago

It doesn't say if the rape took place in a bedroom. Just that it took place in her off campus apartment. I could see BYU being so upset if she had sneaked him into the women's dorm or something. But this was her apartment and inviting someone to your apartment is not an invitation for sex.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient  replied to  Randy   10 years ago

Agreed - the article DID say "off-campus apartment", not "bedroom". The BYU policy speaks of "bedroom" rather than apartment. I, too, see nothing wrong with entertaining a friend in one's apartment if the room used is not the bedroom, nor should BYU. Entertaining in the bedroom might well be considered an invitation to use the bed. I guess there could be a problem of misinterpretation if it is what in Toronto we called a "studio apartment" which would be one room with a kitchenette and bathroom.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy  replied to  Buzz of the Orient   10 years ago

Besides BYU would have never known of the rape and taken action against her except:

A Utah County sheriff’s deputy, who was friends with the accused, then sent Barney’s police case file to BYU and, two months after her attack, she was summoned to the honor code office for a disciplinary hearing.

A friend of the accused. A sworn officer of the law. What he did MUST be illegal! Trying to get her screwed by the University. Disgusting!

 
 

Who is online



97 visitors