If Trump is nominated, the GOP must keep him out of the White House
Donald Trump’s damage to the Republican Party, although already extensive, has barely begun. Republican quislings will multiply, slinking into support of the most anti-conservative presidential aspirant in their party’s history. These collaborationists will render themselves ineligible to participate in the party’s reconstruction.
Ted Cruz’s announcement of his preferred running mate has enhanced the nomination process by giving voters pertinent information. They already know the only important thing about Trump’s choice: His running mate will be unqualified for high office because he or she will think Trump is qualified.
Hillary Clinton’s optimal running mate might be Sen. Sherrod Brown of Ohio , a pro-labor populist whose selection would be balm for the bruised feelings of Bernie Sanders’s legions. Running mates rarely matter as electoral factors: In 2000, Al Gore got 43.2 percent of the North Carolina vote. In 2004, John Kerry, trying to improve upon Gore’s total there, ran with North Carolina Sen. John Edwards but received 43.6 percent . If, however, Brown were to help deliver Ohio for Clinton, the Republican path to 270 electoral votes would be narrower than a needle’s eye.
Republican voters, particularly in Indiana and California, can, by supporting Cruz, make the Republican convention a deliberative body rather than one that merely ratifies decisions made elsewhere, some of them six months earlier. A convention’s sovereign duty is to choose a plausible nominee who has a reasonable chance to win, not to passively affirm the will of a mere plurality of voters recorded episodically in a protracted process.
Trump would be the most unpopular nominee ever, unable to even come close to Mitt Romney’s insufficient support among women, minorities and young people. In losing disastrously, Trump probably would create down-ballot carnage sufficient to end even Republican control of the House. Ticket splitting is becoming rare in polarized America: In 2012, only 5.7 percent of voters supported a presidential candidate and a congressional candidate of opposite parties.
At least half a dozen Republican senators seeking reelection and Senate aspirants can hope to win if the person at the top of the Republican ticket loses their state by, say, only four points, but not if he loses by 10. A Democratic Senate probably would guarantee a Supreme Court with a liberal cast for a generation. If Clinton is inaugurated next Jan. 20, Merrick Garland probably will already be on the court — confirmed in a lame-duck Senate session — and Justices Ruth Bader Ginsburg, Anthony M. Kennedy and Stephen G. Breyer will be 83, 80 and 78, respectively.
The minority of people who pay close attention to politics includes those who define an ideal political outcome and pursue it, and those who focus on the worst possible outcome and strive to avoid it. The former experience the excitements of utopianism, the latter settle for prudence’s mild pleasure of avoiding disappointed dreams. Both sensibilities have their uses, but this is a time for prudence, which demands the prevention of a Trump presidency.
Were he to be nominated, conservatives would have two tasks. One would be to help him lose 50 states — condign punishment for his comprehensive disdain for conservative essentials, including the manners and grace that should lubricate the nation’s civic life. Second, conservatives can try to save from the anti-Trump undertow as many senators, representatives, governors and state legislators as possible.
It was 32 years after Jimmy Carter won 50.1 percent in 1976 that a Democrat won half the popular vote. Barack Obama won only 52.9 percent and then 51.1 percent , but only three Democrats — Andrew Jackson (twice), Franklin Roosevelt (four times) and Lyndon Johnson — have won more than 53 percent. Trump probably would make Clinton the fourth, and he would be a tonic for her party, undoing the extraordinary damage (13 Senate seats, 69 House seats, 11 governorships, 913 state legislative seats) Obama has done.
If Trump is nominated, Republicans working to purge him and his manner from public life will reap the considerable satisfaction of preserving the identity of their 162-year-old party while working to see that they forgo only four years of the enjoyment of executive power. Six times since 1945 a party has tried, and five times failed, to secure a third consecutive presidential term. The one success — the Republicans’ 1988 election of George H.W. Bush — produced a one-term president. If Clinton gives her party its first 12 consecutive White House years since 1945, Republicans can help Nebraska Sen. Ben Sasse, or someone else who has honorably recoiled from Trump, confine her to a single term.

Personally I believe that George Will is being optimistic about Hillary Clinton being only a one term President. I believe the anger and resentment that Donald Trump's run for the White House will extend out at least one more election cycle. If Ted Cruz is somehow the nominee, then I can't see the GOP staying together at all and it may be several Presidential election cycles before the rift can be repaired of before one of the two new parties created gains enough strength to make a serious run at the Presidency.
I agree. Republicans created the mess they are in, and it's not going away in a single presidential election cycle. Trump supporters aren't going to suddenly become rational any more than Trump is going to suddenly become presidential - particularly if the obstructionist 'policy of no' is extended into another Democratic presidential term.
Trump has exposed an underlying feeling among many of the party. Right or wrong (wrong IMO) and it is not going to go away. There is a fracture in the party and Cruz is adding to it as well.
Trump is Trump, what he says means little, since he has no policies that are even rational. Will people vote for him, yes they will because he is appealing to their sense of we are being screwed, whether that be financially, racially or any other way.
It is what it is, hopefully he will lose the general election. If not, they we are in for a hell of a bumpy ride.
I think that George Will doesn't get what's going on in this country.
Trump, (and Bernie to some extent), are the anti establishment nominees. That is their appeal. Also not represented in the article, are the closest Trump voters. I am shocked by the number of people I am friends with, that I consider totally rational, who are voting for Trump, because they hate both Hillary and Cruz.
So I think the election will do two things. If Trump wins, the GOP is dead in the water. If Hillary wins, the GOP will stay intact, but I think she will get 2 terms, because Bill will be involved, and a lot of people who hate her, still love Bill.
If this demonstrates anything to this country, is that we need a third party. We are the only 2 party democracy in the world and 2 is not a choice anymore. Both parties are way too polarized to represent the body of the US.
I can wrap up Will's and the GOP's issues with just one thing he said. By lamenting about Merrick Garland getting into SCOTUS, he has demonstrated that a moderate is still too left, for the right. If they want to be the party of the people, they better realize that they are not in sync with the people.
I am shocked by the number of people I am friends with, that I consider totally rational, who are voting for Trump, because they hate both Hillary and Cruz.
No rational person would even consider voting for Donald Trump, unless they are of low character themselves. From what I have seen Trump is easily the most disreputable person to ever seek the presidency as a major party candidate, in our lifetimes for sure, and maybe ever. He meets all nine criteria for narcissism. The presence of one or two is sufficient for the diagnosis. His personal business dealings are rife with corruption. He lies the way regular people draw breath. He has conned regular people out of millions of dollars via his various business and franchising scams.
He is extremely ignorant of national and international issue after issue.
The list of people who endorse his candidacy is filled with extremist politiciuans and D list celebrities from his reality TV show.
I don't doubt you have friends that will vote for Trump (I have a few relatives that say they will vote for him) , but they are not being rational. Far from it. No one being rational would vote for the worst candidate in the nation's history.
The country needs to stop playing games with this thing.
I don't doubt you have friends that will vote for Trump (I have a few relatives that say they will vote for him) , but they are not being rational.
I think they feel that things couldn't be any worse than they are now, and Hillary is just so unappealing to them. I wouldn't call them irrational, after having an in depth convo with them, but I don't agree with them either.
I think they feel that things couldn't be any worse than they are now,
When you say that you are saying that they would vote for the most unqualified person that we have EVER seen run for president, both in terms of character and knowledge of issues, because "things couldn't be any worse than they are now".
What does that say about Americans? It's not good, I know that.
Donald Trump is promising people how great things will be when he gets in. He's going to have the best people and things are going to be great....bla bla bla. This is exactly what he told the people he scammed out of 35,000 dollars with his phony real estate university. There are videos for people to watch. Trump is a severe narcissist who does not think twice about lying to people, do "you" really think he cares about the people? There is absolutely no evidence of it.
John,
You are asking me these questions as if I was voting for Trump. I am not. But I keep an open mind and I hear what people have to say. I might not agree with them, but if you are trying to figure out why he is so popular, I am trying to explain that.
Perrie, people who support Trump are doing a great disservice to this country. He is the most unqualified person ever to run for the office. There IS NO good explanation for why people vote for him.
There IS NO good explanation for why people vote for him.
That is an emotional rather than a rational analysis, and exemplifies why the pundits and so-called experts were blind-sided by both Bernie and Donald's rise.
If Charles Manson ran for president, and he got a lot of votes from disgruntled people, would you say they had a good reason to vote for him?
Donald Trump stands on the stage today and he bellows out to his audience "WE ARE NOT GOING TO BE BUFFALOED BY LIES !"
This from the man who is easily the biggest liar to ever run for the office.
What is rational about any of this?
I'm NOT sayin' that voting for Donald is right, I am saying that your analysis of WHY people are voting for him is an emotional, rather than rational, analysis. You ask why people are voting for the rump and folks are trying to explain it to ya, but you are so emotionally involved that you can't throw way your own blinders and see the truth right in front of you.
And THAT is exactly one of the biggest reasons why he is winning, because folks are sick to death of the same-ol'-same-ol' being tossed their direction like starving begging dogs. They are so goddamn sick of it that they are ready to commit political suicide rather than live with the status quo anymore. If politicians and pundits don't get that within the next couple of election cycles they will most likely ALL be without a job.
They are so goddamn sick of it that they are ready to commit political suicide rather than live with the status quo anymore.
And I am emotional? ok.
I will give people the slight benefit of the doubt and assume that many of the people supporting Trump have not read any long form exposes of him, or seen any of the documentary video about him. Of course there is a good chance that they will do neither before they go to the voting booth in the fall also.
Fact checkers ROUTINELY determine that Trump statements are false, often 'pants on fire' or '4 pinocchios'. One fact checker determined that only 2 of 75 Trump statements qualified as completely true. Politico had a reporter go through a weeks worth of trump speeches a couple months ago. What was determined was that Trump lied constantly through all of the speeches. Most of the time that he wasn't lying he was talking about his family (which he does at every speech) or some of his business achievements.
The time is going to come when Trump supporters are going to receive tremendous criticism on a widespread basis.
The time is going to come when Trump supporters are going to receive tremendous criticism on a widespread basis.
Agreed. For good or ill, it may very well spell doom for the Republican Party.
They are so goddamn sick of it that they are ready to commit political suicide rather than live with the status quo anymore.
And I am emotional? ok.
Yes. No more or less so, than the rump supporters we are talking about.
Most of the time that he wasn't lying he was talking about his family
Yes. And I can just about guarantee ya that most average Americans feel that they are all a bunch of liars, and can go all over the internet to fact-check and find lies on all the candidates. And yes as bad as rump is, Clinton is a full-fledged liar herself and everyone knows it. Doesn't matter if you or I feel differently, because THAT IS how the average American voter feels. They don't trust any politicians to tell the truth at all.
Your a savvy political guy John, and smart to boot. Why is it so hard to see how disenfranchised voters are? They see the establishment as having stolen their government from them, and they view people like Bernie and Donald as possible reformers (regardless of the ridiculousness). Even if it places the country in a tight spot, it might be perceived as what is required to get DC's intentions back where they belong.
I have never seen anything that persuades me that Hillary Clinton is the scale of liar, scoundrel, or crook, or , frankly, asshole, that Trump is. Hillary Clinton has been attacked by well financed political enemies for over 20 years. These are people with expertise at smearing people. I don't think Clinton is "innocent" , I think she has used her influence to gain financial success and power and most likely crossed lines to do some of it. But I don't believe this is at all unusual in high level politics.
We all watched many people on the right proclaim that Clinton let the 4 people in Benghazi die , and she lied about the video. This is actually one of the major allegations about her character, and the allegation is very shaky. Clinton spoke DIRECTLY about every aspect of this at the hearing last fall, and none of the Republicans on the committee could get the best of her on it. To this day, there is a good possibility that the video was part of the motivation for the attack. The right says the video had nothing to do with it. That is not what first person accounts showed.
So if they are wrong about Clinton on that, what else are they wrong about? Some of the authors that have written about the Clintons have been discredited. One of them, Ed Klein , who has written two or three widely excoriated books about Hillary and Bill Clinton met with Donald Trump for lunch today. If so, is Trump planning to use Klein's lies in his campaign against Clinton? Going by Trump's past, that is most likely.
I have never seen anything that persuades me that Hillary Clinton is the scale of liar, scoundrel, or crook, or , frankly, asshole, that Trump is.
Nor have I.
Which is the lesser of two evils, and the sad-assed reason I'll most likely be voting for Clinton myself come November.
I think she has used her influence to gain financial success and power and most likely crossed lines to do some of it. But I don't believe this is at all unusual in high level politics.
I agree; as well, that is also the rub of the situation.
Americans will be forced to reevaluate ourselves and our political process, as they are both desperately wanting.
Even if it places the country in a tight spot, it might be perceived as what is required to get DC's intentions back where they belong.
Sorry, imo, if electing the biggest liar and the most personally corrupt candidate in history is what is required, then the country is fucked.
if electing the biggest liar and the most personally corrupt candidate in history is what is required, then the country is fucked.
Yup.
That should be fucked beyond repair, if we elect Trump. Electing a person like Trump would not solve any of our country's problems, but rather would be the beginning of the end of it.
Hillary is just so unappealing to them.
Unappealing yes, but not sly and a little insane as Trump is. Many people may not like her for various reasons, though I am one who does like her, but they have to ask themselves who would they rather have as the Commander in Chief of the most powerful military in the world, including the nuclear launch codes. Her or someone as egotistical, hyper-sensitive and prone to rash action as Trump. Given the right provocation and a President has to deal with hundreds of them a year, those might not be just angry tweets he's sending out in the middle of the night.
You're right good point we know Hillary is a war hawk and Trump was against the wars.
While "we the people" are at it we should try very hard to keep Hillary, Cruz and Bernie out of the White House as well.
I concede that trims the possible pool, but none them especially Trump would be good for this country.
Bernie is the only one I would call a candidate with a character to admire - I disagree with most of his positions, but enjoy his honesty and stance on issues over the years.
Cruz is a nut case plain and simple.
And Hillary well I (and I do not feel alone) simply do not trust her
So there we are - it is going to be an interesting election process this year.
The lesser of several evils...
Bernie is the only one I would call a candidate with a character to admire - I disagree with most of his positions, but enjoy his honesty and stance on issues over the years.
Well said.
So you're going to hold your nose as you vote....? I think you are going to be in very good company Robert.
Perry is right. It is time for a 3rd party made up of left/right moderates to form. The 30% from the far left/right are sucking all the air out of the room. Unfortunately they are not the types that will take "Shut up and sit down!"
It is why I have openly said I would vote for him, (Bernie) I mean if you really want to get this government moving again, Bernie is your candidate.
Hillary will never garner enough support from the people to completely shift the government as far left as Obama had in '08. She will never gain the house.. Highly doubtful if she will pull the Senate back into Leftist control also. (but there is that possibility that the people can shut off their brains for that to actually happen. But I don't think so.
Recent history says otherwise.
Cruz? he's no Reagan, he does represent the religious element in society that actually doesn't care which side they get political power from, just that they get it. Reagan invited them into the party after they were outside politics for a decade after the Democrats kicked them out of their party. (Reagan's ideal of an all inclusive republican party, a touch to his democrat roots) Cruz should never hold a senior level position anywhere in our government. WE do not need an America ran like a religious sect.
Trump, probably going to be president, if only cause the other candidates wish so badly to hand it to him. They are assuming that all the brash idiocy he is spewing is because he is a brainless troglodyte. They can't be more wrong.
He has run a masterful campaign up to this point specifically targeting the liberal weakness and exploiting it where ever he can and the rank and file liberals are giving him exactly what he wants. No reason to think that the party leaders won't either.
He is not republican, he is not mainstream, he is not anything connected to this current government. and his greatest gift is getting people to give him what he wants from them. He wants to be the most powerful man on the planet, and everyone is working hard at giving it to him.
Trump is going to win this thing despite everyone angst, the party will get behind him but he won't be a shill for the party.
And the rest of government will have to learn to work with him, if we want to get anything done.
It is not too late to stop Trump, But people need to actually stop giving him what he wants.
Until then there is no point in discussing it.
Moderates , and "third partiers" , are great at saying "a pox on both their houses" , and claiming that both parties are equally at fault , and all the candidates are equally bad and unworthy, and so "it doesn't matter" who we vote for.
This sort of nonsense is very harmful to the country.
We have a two party political system, and until that changes we have to choose between the lesser of two evils.
How does saying that Bernie is an honest guy like saying a Pox on both their houses?
It doesn't.
The fact is that both parties are owned and we are stuck only with two viable parties.
So yes, the choice is voting for who YOU believe is the lesser of two evils, (which sucks) and end up with the same old, same old OR voting for some no go third party OR not voting at all.
Not what I call satisfying.
How does saying that Bernie is an honest guy like saying a Pox on both their houses?
My comment directly above was not necessarily in response to you dear. It was to the seed in general.
I love Bernie. I rally do. However he is selling pie in the sky and always has. That's great if you are representing Vermont, but not so much if you are trying to get that pie past the Congress. His great revolution is not happening and if a miracle occurs and he is the Democratic nominee he'll likely win, but he will be going into office already crippled. Just like Trump could not effectively govern with only angry white men as his base, Bernie can not effectively govern with the majority of his base being young idealists. If it's a Sanders v Trump General election Sanders may well win. But I predict most people will just stay home.
Change doesn't begin without a serious and honest initiative, and that's what Bernie is. Of course he couldn't do everything on his wish list, but in 2008 Obama had a wish list that made Bernie's look reasonable.
Funniest line from Bill Maher last week :
So yes, the choice is voting for who YOU believe is the lesser of two evils, (which sucks) and end up with the same old, same old OR voting for some no go third party OR not voting at all.
Then form a viable third party or quit voting.
Moderates , and "third partiers" , are great at saying "a pox on both their houses" , and claiming that both parties are equally at fault , and all the candidates are equally bad and unworthy, and so "it doesn't matter" who we vote for.
This sort of nonsense is very harmful to the country.
Agreed. The idea that there is a moral equivalency between the two parties is absurd. They are not equally at fault. I think far too many people have forgotten where we were 8 years ago and where we are now. We are doing better then any other country in the world. We are the best country in the world, but many don't feel it because of the constant GOP drumbeat that the country is doing worse off all of the time when the truth is just the opposite. The perennial question is "Are you better off to you were 8 years ago" and yes we are. We are a LOT better off then we were 8 years ago.
The "pox" is strictly on the GOP and if the third partiers can't see it, then they are falling for the GOP con job.
If it's Clinton v Trump in November, I'll vote for Clinton. If it's Sanders v Trump in November I'll be voting against Trump.