Israel's Netanyahu criticises military official over Nazi claim
Israeli PM Benjamin Netanyahu has issued a stern public rebuke to the military deputy chief of staff.
Maj-Gen Yair Golan said on the eve of Thursday's annual Holocaust Day that he detected trends in Israeli society suggestive of "nauseating processes" that occurred in 1930s Nazi Germany.
Mr Netanyahu said the comments were outrageous, cheapened the Holocaust and caused harm to Israel.
Defence Minister Moshe Yaalon said he had "total confidence" in Gen Golan.
"If there's something that frightens me about Holocaust remembrance it's the recognition of the nauseating processes that occurred in Europe in general, and particularly in Germany, back then - 70, 80 and 90 years ago - and finding signs of them here among us today in 2016," the deputy chief of staff said on Wednesday.
"There is, after all, nothing easier and simpler than hating the foreigner... arousing fears and terrifying."
But Mr Netanyahu said Gen Golan's remarks were "utterly mistaken and unacceptable to me".
"The comparison drawn in the words of the deputy chief of staff regarding events which characterised Nazi Germany 80 years ago is outrageous," he said.
"They do injustice to Israeli society and cause a belittling of the Holocaust."
Correspondents say right-wing members of Mr Netanyahu's coalition have called for Gen Golan's resignation, accusing him of dishonouring the dead.
But Defence Minister Yaalon said the criticism was an attempt to cause political harm to the military.
"The attacks against [Gen Golan] and the current criticism against him are deliberate distortions of interpretation of the things he said last night," he added.
The remarks come at a time of heightened tension between Israelis and Palestinians.
A wave of stabbing, shooting and car-ramming attacks by Palestinians and Israeli Arabs over the past eight months have left 29 Israelis dead.
More than 200 Palestinians - mostly attackers, Israel says - have also been killed in that period.
There has been debate and controversy over Israelis' response to the attacks.
In March, an Israeli soldier was filmed shooting dead a wounded Palestinian. He has been charged with manslaughter.
There has been some public sympathy for the soldier but Mr Yaalon backed the military establishment in prosecuting him.
In October last year, an Eritrean immigrant was shot and beaten to death by an angry crowd after being mistaken for an Arab militant in the town of Beersheba, prompting concern about mob reactions to people thought to be suspicious.
http://www.bbc.com/news/world-middle-east-36241210
Tags
Who is online
94 visitors

There seems to be some unhappiness with Mr. Netanyahu by the Defense Department and military of Israel of the current direction of official government policy.
This is for them to figure out for themselves....
I agree. They're the experts on both sides of this one. Let them fight it out among themselves.
This was bound to happen. A lot of people in Israel don't like Netanyahu
IMHO he's an extremist as well as is the Likud party. As long as he and people such as him are in charge in Israel there will be no peace in the ME.
As long as he and people such as him are in charge in Israel there will be no peace in the ME.
You are astonishingly obsessed with Israeli politics . But the middle east is a big place . There are always different groups fighting each other ... usually it involves Sunni vs Shite . Ya want to know how to cool it off ? Stop the hidden support from Iran for some of those groups .
Western countries have determined with the Ottawa Protocol, with wording similar to that of the EU working papers on anti-Semitism, and the US Dept of State definition of anti-Semitism, that comparing Israel's policies to those of the Nazis is outright anti-Semitism. However, there are many traitorous Jews who may make the comparison, although the comparison is so blatantly false. The Jews in 1930s Germany were relatively assimilated, and did not go around stabbing and murdering gentiles, nor were they incited by their leaders and religious leaders to do so. Compare that to how the Jews have to deal with the Palestinians today. There is no reasonable comparison.
How can you criticize a country that does not imprison or even murder its citizens or officials or media (Ha'aretz) for criticizing its policies or even wrongdoings, a country surrounded and far outnumbered by despots and dictatorships and theocracies that provide no such democratic rights? As I've said on these sites a hundred times or more, criticism of Israel is not anti-Semitism, but holding Israel out to a standard not expected of any other democratic nation, holding it to a double standard - THAT is anti-Semitism.
Western countries have determined with the Ottawa Protocol, with wording similar to that of the EU working papers on anti-Semitism, and the US Dept of State definition of anti-Semitism, that comparing Israel's policies to those of the Nazis is outright anti-Semitism.
I disagree with that policy and agreement as an infringement on the freedom of speech.
Okay, so go draw some cartoon pictures of Mohammud and post them up on your nearest mosque, since you think comparing Israelis to Nazis is fair comment. Sign them and post your address on them. Then let's see what you have to say about free speech.
What would that prove? Apples and oranges. Why would I want to draw cartoons of Mohammud when (along with the fact that I can't draw worth a damn) and put them on a Masque? I wouldn't spray Swastikas on a synagogue and then leave my name and address with them. In both cases that would be defacing their private property and has nothing to do with freedom of speech. Your example makes no sense?
As for freedom of speech in general, I have it in the U.S., including to say (which I have not, an Israeli war hero general did) comparing Likud to the Nazis and not being an anti-Semite. Likud is a political party, not a religion. Israel is a country, not a synagogue. They have a governmental leader named Netanyahu, not a Pope or Ayatollah. Israel the country and government, is NOT the same as Jewishness the faith.
Here is my only problem with dropping the N word (Nazi) all the time. It diminishes the true evil of the word. And even though I have my issues with Likud and Netanyahu, they are not Nazis.
It was a war hero Israeli General who said it. And the Israeli Defense Minister defended him. If this had been said by a Palestinian or someone from ISIS that would be something else completely. But it wasn't.
There is an old saying (well, for the older ones of us it's not so old) that only Nixon could have gone to China. That's because his anti-Communist bona fides were impeccable. If LBJ or Carter had done it, it would have been screamed about by everyone on the right wing all over America. But what could they say when it was one of their own who opened the door? This is the same as that.
I stand on the statement I made above:
"The Jews in 1930s Germany were relatively assimilated, and did not go around stabbing and murdering gentiles, nor were they incited by their leaders and religious leaders to do so. Compare that to how the Jews have to deal with the Palestinians today. There is no reasonable comparison."
It was wrong for the general to have made the statement, and perhaps out of loyalty and earned respect the Minister of Defence defended him, but that did not make what he said right. So Netanyahu yelled at him. He didn't throw him off a roof or slice off his head. Get your priorities straight. Your hatred is focused on Israel's government notwithstanding the surrounding threats they have to deal with, but what have you to say about those surrounding countries where free speech isn't even a dream?
I do not like (I said nothing about hate) the current Israeli government or Likud or Netanyahu. It is my right to feel that way and to say so. I believe also that this General had every right to say what he said if it's what he believes. In fact, if anything, because of his experiences and status he has even more of a right to say so and to be taken seriously when he does. That is freedom of speech. If some or most of the nations around Israel do not have freedom of speech is completely irrelevant.
Ah yes, but it's Israel that has your unrelenting attention, isn't it.
Not at all. America has my unrelenting attention. Israel is just a side issue by comparison. They are just another country in the world and nothing special compared to the U.S. or many of our allies. They are, like from Godfather II, "Small potatoes."
That could be, they invented small tomatoes, so why not?
I like small tomatoes. Less messy, but can be a pain to stab with a fork.
Don't try to struggle with fork and knife,
just use your fingers and end the strife.
Well either way you still need to get them wet to get the salt and pepper to stick to them.
Try doing it Russian style, put some salt and pepper in your mouth and then eat the cherry tomato. You know how they drink tea with a sugar cube between their teeth? But be careful not to sneeze - the tomato can be a messy projectile.
I just pop the tomato in my mouth, get it wet and then pop it back out to salt and pepper it. Works pretty good, though my wife doesn't like it when I do it while were out at a restaurant. Come to think of it, there's a lot of things she doesn't like? Maybe it's time for a trade in?
You think what YOU do is crude. Did you ever pick up your plate and slide the food into your mouth? By the way, can you use chopsticks?
I have been known to do that, but never at a restaurant. Same reason I always get my BBQ ribs to go. Too messy. I have had so-called experts try and try and try to teach me how to use chopsticks, but no luck. Every time I think I have a hold of something, just as I get it to my mouth it goes flying! I think the Chinese invented chopsticks just to make Westerners look foolish!
After almost 10 years here I still struggle a bit with them.
I hope you also own forks, knives and spoons though?
Absolutely. Ever try to eat a beefsteak with chopsticks?