╌>

West Point Says Black Cadets Who Posed with Raised Fists Ddidn't Break the Rules

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  robert-in-ohio  •  10 years ago  •  32 comments

West Point Says Black Cadets Who Posed with Raised Fists Ddidn't Break the Rules

West Point officials said Tuesday that a group of black cadets at the center of a national controversy over a photo in which they posed with raised fists did not violate academy rules on student conduct.

Social media had erupted over the photo of the 16 women, which evoked black power salutes of the 1960s.

 

The cadets, members of the class of 2016, had worn formal gray uniforms, some holding sabers, to pose in an "Old Corps" photo -- a tradition at West Point for generations. But each woman held a fist in the air, a sign some people took for political support of the Black Lives Matter movement. Military rules bar cadets from taking part in politics aside from voting.

In an investigation , which began two days after the photo was taken on April 26, officials found that the students were not making a statement on anything other than “unity” and “pride.” Officials said the picture was one of three “taken in the spur of the moment," including both "serious" and "silly" poses.

Though the fists could be seen as political, the students were exonerated because that wasn't their intention, the investigation found. The inquiry quoted an initial email from one of the women to a fellow cadet in which she asked him to take photos in order to "showcase the awesome black women in our class."

In a letter to students, academy Supt. Lt. Gen. Robert L. Caslen Jr. lamented the photo causing "division" instead of "shared unity," but pointed out that it was not the first time students had used the raised fists symbol. For example, he and other cadets raised their fists to support their football team in December at the Army-Navy game, he said.

Yet “as members of the Profession of Arms, we are held to a high standard, where our actions are constantly observed and scrutinized in the public domain,” he later added.“We all must understand that a symbol or gesture that one group of people may find harmless may offend others. As Army officers, we are not afforded the luxury of a lack of awareness of how we are perceived.”

The investigation said the women, who are scheduled to graduate May 21, would not be barred from the ceremony. Still, they will first have to attend a class to learn about their "intent versus the impact of the photo," Caslen wrote.

 


West Point

 



Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    10 years ago

This story caught my eye and my attention.

I firmly support the right of free expression of ideas but wonder if the reaction "they broke no rules" would have been the same if a group of white cadets demonstrated in a like manner proclaiming white power and solidarity?

But I guess that as long as they attend the class on intent versus impact that all is well.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1  replied to  Robert in Ohio   10 years ago

DoD Directive 1325.6 says it is DoD policy to preserve military members' "right of expression … to the maximum extent possible, consistent with good order and discipline and the national security." Then it puts limits on that right. Members of the military may attend demonstrations. But only in the United States. Only off base. Only off duty. And only out of uniform. Free speech may be forbidden if it "constitute[s] a breach of law and order." It is also forbidden "when violence is likely to result." Peaceful demonstrations are not a problem. Violent ones are. Members who do not want to risk court-martial, should stay away from demonstrations they think are likely to become violent.

Based on this directive, I would say the cadets are in violation of Article 92 of the UCMJ.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio  replied to  FLYNAVY1   10 years ago

FLY

There are those that would argue that there was no demonstration and therefore no violation of Article 92 (as a Retired 1SG USA I would be one of them), though that is not the point

( 1) Violation of or failure to obey a lawful general order or regulation.

  • (a) General orders or regulations are those orders or regulations generally applicable to an armed force which are properly published by the President or the Secretary of Defense, of Transportation, or of a military department, and those orders or regulations generally applicable to the command of the officer issuing them throughout the command or a particular subdivision thereof which are issued by:

    • (i) an officer having general court-martial jurisdiction;

      (ii) a general or flag officer in command; or

      (iii) a commander superior to (i) or (ii).

    (b) A general order or regulation issued by a commander with authority under Article 92(1) retains its character as a general order or regulation when another officer takes command, until it expires by its own terms or is rescinded by separate action, even if it is issued by an officer who is a general or flag officer in command and command is assumed by another officer who is not a general or flag officer .

    (c) A general order or regulation is lawful unless it is contrary to the Constitution, the laws of the United States , or lawful superior orders or for some other reason is beyond the authority of the official issuing it. See the discussion of lawfulness in paragraph 14c(2)(a) .

    (d) Knowledge. Knowledge of a general order or regulation need not be alleged or proved, as knowledge is not an element of this offense and a lack of knowledge does not constitute a defense.

    (e) Enforceability. Not all provisions in general orders or regulations can be enforced under Article 92(1). Regulations which only supply general guide-lines or advice for conducting military functions may not be enforceable under Article 92(1).

(2) Violation of or failure to obey other lawful order.

  • (a) Scope. Article 92(2) includes all other lawful orders which may be issued by a member of the armed forces, violations of which are not chargeable under Article 90 , 91 , or 92(1). It includes the violation of written regulations which are not general regulations. See also subparagraph (1)(e) above as applicable.

    (b) Knowledge. In order to be guilty of this offense, a person must have had actual knowledge of the order or regulation. Knowledge of the order may be proved by circumstantial evidence

The double standard and reaction to a cadet display of "white power and unity" is the point

This photo will be viewed by promotion boards and selection panels for years to come and the intent will be judged each time.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell  replied to  Robert in Ohio   10 years ago

wonder if the reaction "they broke no rules" would have been the same if a group of white cadets demonstrated in a like manner proclaiming white power and solidarity?

 

Is there any evidence that the gesture meant "black power", other than that they are black?

They must have told someone.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

John

The sad thing about your comment is that you think you have posed a serious question.

What else do you propose that it might mean?

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell  replied to  Robert in Ohio   10 years ago

"In a letter to students, academy Supt. Lt. Gen. Robert L. Caslen Jr. lamented the photo causing "division" instead of "shared unity," but pointed out that it was not the first time students had used the raised fists symbol. For example, he and other cadets raised their fists to support their football team in December at the Army-Navy game, he said."

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

Maybe they were signaling black power, maybe they weren't. Where is the proof? Or do you want to punish people without proof? 

 

 

th?id=OIP.M2978fc77bc5a06c1273590dc5546f2a6o0&pid=15.1

 

51714772-striking-building-workers-raise-their-fists-gettyimages.jpg?v=1&c=IWSAsset&k=2&d=AMM7PG28rc%2bWBnlHvr4Iic2AJlleNCoT8um6%2b5y3wIbN50HGNSSaOT79HGNAtg1L

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

To me the raised fist means power to the people. It's also a sign of victory. I see nothing wrong with the picture and I don't believe it does anything to discredit West Point, the U.S. Army or the USA.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  Randy   10 years ago

White West Point Cadets giving a "Black Power" salute? Should they be disciplined? Or does it only disrupt the UCMJ if you're Black?

And in uniform too!!!! My, how disgraceful!/s

256

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell  replied to  Randy   10 years ago

lol.

It had to be a white power salute, no?

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

That's what happens when you open the door to race power salutes!/s

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

It had to be a white power salute, no?

Maybe it's both? I mean they are wearing black gloves! LOL!!!!!

Obviously these young White Cadets are not being "consistent with good order and discipline"

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

And he is posturing politically despite knowing full well what was being expressed by the group.

 

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    10 years ago

I' guessing that this won't be the end of it Robert.  As you say, a double standard could every easily exist, and per the regulation I posted,  this activity ( by my interpretation) would be contrary to being...

"consistent with good order and discipline". 

The command has opened the door to allowing a "White Power" photo, and they would be powerless to do anything about it.  How the hell could that be consistent with good order and discipline.  The commandant's decision needs to be reviewed and reversed by the chain of command in this case.  Plus these young cadets should know better.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio  replied to  FLYNAVY1   10 years ago

FLY

The command has opened the door to allowing a "White Power" photo, and they would be powerless to do anything about it.

As always, my friend, you hit the nail directly on the head.

The point you make is the exact reason I posted the article.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  FLYNAVY1   10 years ago

The command has opened the door to allowing a "White Power" photo, and they would be powerless to do anything about it.

I couldn't disagree more. This was an expression of happiness and unity and the joy of graduating, not of Black Power. It does not open the door to an expression of White Power in any manner.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio  replied to  Randy   10 years ago

Randy

This was an expression of happiness and unity and the joy of graduating, not of Black Power.

To believe that is to be naïve or stupid - you are neither, that makes it political posturing.

 
 
 
PJ
Masters Silent
link   PJ    10 years ago

The raised fist means different things to different people and it has a variety of meanings depending on the situation.  The black community has always been very clear what it means to them when they raise their fist.  I will be waiting to see what the next headline will be because we know there will be another group that will respond with their own "pose".   The door has been opened and a precedence has been set. 

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio  replied to  PJ   10 years ago

The door has been opened and a precedence has been set. 

Indeed

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    10 years ago

 I’m sure that if a picture emerged of sixteen white male cadets with arms upraised, the Post editorial board would just claim they’re “pointing to the sky.”  Wearing the uniform of your country is a privilege and a sacred trust. It is not a cadet’s platform for attention-seeking and statement-making. The Army should investigate and respond according to the law and the evidence — and not according to the latest trends in liberal intellectual fashion. If the cadets were intending to make a politically-charged statement, then they must be punished in the same manner as any other cadet. If not, then they should be sharply warned to use good judgment and common sense in the messages they broadcast to the world.

Read more at:

 
 
 
PJ
Masters Silent
link   PJ  replied to  Sean Treacy   10 years ago

Wearing the uniform of your country is a privilege and a sacred trust. It is not a cadet’s platform for attention-seeking and statement-making.

I agree wholeheartedly. 

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell    10 years ago

Is there any actual evidence that they meant it as "black power", or is that just the assumption?

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

It's an assumption that, since these cadets are Black, it must be some sort of Black power thing. When White cadets do it, it's just good, clean, enthusiastic fun!

When I raise my right fist it's on the rare occasion a Detroit Lion scores a touchdown!

 
 
 
Sister Mary Agnes Ample Bottom
Professor Participates
link   Sister Mary Agnes Ample Bottom  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

Is there any actual evidence that they meant it as "black power", or is that just the assumption?

Do you mean besides the fact that the participants were all black, and they used the forward-facing fist that is a known Black Panther symbol?  The reason it is a known BPP trademark, is because of this poster that was widely distributed around the time of the group's formation:

256

 

256

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

256

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

The fist is forward-facing because it depicts how the hand would be positioned if it were holding a gun in the air.  The symbolism is obvious.

I really recommend taking a peek at what the Southern Poverty Law Center has to say about the New Black Panther Party and their mission.  They quote public statements made by the group's leaders.

"Our lessons talk about the bloodsuckers of the poor… . It's that old no-good Jew, that old imposter Jew, that old hooked-nose, bagel-eating, lox-eating, Johnny-come-lately, perpetrating-a-fraud, just-crawled-out-of-the-caves-and-hills-of-Europe, so-called damn Jew … and I feel everything I'm saying up here is kosher."
— Khalid Abdul Muhammad, one of the party's future leaders, Baltimore, Md., Feb. 19, 1994

"Kill every goddamn Zionist in Israel! Goddamn little babies, goddamn old ladies! Blow up Zionist supermarkets!"
—Malik Zulu Shabazz, the party's national chairman, protesting at B'nai B'rith International headquarters in Washington, D.C., April 20, 2002   

"I hate white people. All of them. Every last iota of a cracker, I hate it. We didn't come out here to play today. There's too much serious business going on in the black community to be out here sliding through South Street with white, dirty, cracker whore bitches on our arms, and we call ourselves black men. … What the hell is wrong with you black man? You at a doomsday with a white girl on your damn arm. We keep begging white people for freedom! No wonder we not free! Your enemy cannot make you free, fool! You want freedom? You going to have to kill some crackers! You going to have to kill some of their babies!"
— King Samir Shabazz, head of the party's Philadelphia chapter, in a National Geographic documentary, January 2009 

Even one of the group's founding members, Bobby Seale, called the new generation of Black Panthers "a black racist hate group."

Bottom line:  It is how the fist can be (and has been) interpreted that makes it inappropriate for the graduates to display and distribute in such a public manner.  Do you think that the men and women who might serve under the command of one of these women will be able to maintain unconditional respect and confidence in a superior officer that has exhibited solidarity with an indisputably violent and racist organization?  Confidence in a military superior is a key element to survival, especially in combat.  

Just to re-state, regardless of the meaning behind the action in the photograph, it's how the action is perceived by others that can have a negative impact on traditional military interaction.  It might be interesting to learn the promotion history of these women in 10 years. 

Source

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell  replied to  Sister Mary Agnes Ample Bottom   10 years ago

I think it's possible that these 15 young black female US Military Academy cadets are secret Black Panthers, but not likely.

If people want to ruminate on it, fine, but they should not be punished without further evidence. That would have been unjust.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     10 years ago

The grad's were celebrating their coming graduation from West Point. I don't see anything that wrong with the photo.

West Point has had it share of real scandals. More time spent correcting those scandals would be more useful then this make believe controversy.

 

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  Kavika   10 years ago

If I had attended and graduated from the U.S. Air Force Academy, you can be certain my parents would have a picture of me with my right fist high in the air in celebration! And most of the other grads too.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell  replied to  Kavika   10 years ago

One more raised fist -

512

 

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

And Another.....

And another.....

And another.....

What difference does it make?

 

256

256

256

 

256

256

256

256

 

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago

Exactly!!!

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Robert in Ohio    10 years ago

I thank everyone for participating in this discussion, for the most part with civility and restraint.

Many have attempted to explain away the students' "intent" as celebrating the football team, joy at their impending graduation, a simple expression of solidarity, saying hello or whatever.

I (and a few others) have countered with what seems obvious to me and most of the country that similar to the raised black fists of Tommie Smith and John Carlos in 1968 the pose was meant to express black unity black power if you will.

I would like to reiterate that I think free expression of this type is a very good thing and see nothing wrong with it.  I would also note that as a long serving member of the U.S. Army, I think such a demonstration while in uniform is inappropriate.

The point of posting the article was to get to a point that FLY made first that sooner or later there is going to be a picture or a pose if you will expressing "white unity" or white power if you will and I just wonder if there will be a similar acceptance to the "intent" of that group.

Again thanks to one and all that have participated on my article.

 
 

Who is online



95 visitors