Don't Teach Kids Declaration of Independence, It's Racist
Louisiana state Democrat doesn't want schoolchildren to get anywhere near the Declaration of Independence because it's racist and unfair.
State Rep. Barbara Norton opposes a new bill that would mandate schoolchildren in grades four, five and six to recite a portion of the historic document in the first class of each day. HB 1035 was presented by Republican state Rep. Valarie Hodges and did very well early on, sailing through the House Education Committee. But now the bill has stalled and is possibly dead.
Somehow it was considered controversial with some black members saying it would be better for students to recite portions of Martin Luther King Jr.'s "I Have a Dream Speech." One, Rep. Ed Price (D), wrote an amendment to the bill for students to do so. He said, “We fought a long way to get where we are today and I think Dr. King’s speech really personifies what has happened.”
But nothing compares to the assault on the Declaration of Independence made by Norton when she addressed Hodges on the state House floor last week saying:
"I'm not really sure what your intent is, but one thing that I do know is, all men are not created equal.
"When I think back in 1776, July the 4th, African-Americans were slaves. And for you to bring a bill to request that our children would recite the Declaration, I think it's a little bit unfair to us, to ask those children to recite something that's not the truth."
Hodges responded in disbelief, "You don't think that all men are created equal? You think that's not true?"
Norton continued, with little assurance that she's actually read the document:
"Let me finish… and for you to ask our children to repeat the Declaration stating that all mens [sic] are free, I think that's unfair.
"In 1776, Dr. King was not even born. African-Americans were in slavery, so since they were in slavery, in the Declaration of Independence say [sic], we were all treated eq -- we were all created equal. we were not created equal because in 1776, July the 4th, I, nor you, nor any of us were born, nor was Dr. King born, so, we were in slavery. And to have our children to repeat, to repeat again and again documents that was not even validated [sic], I don't think that that's fair because we're teaching them a lie."
Hodges responded on Facebook, saying of her fellow members, "It is disturbing to see the lack of understanding of the founding of this country and patriotism." She then added a reminder to something Dr. King said during his most famous speech:
"When the architects of our republic wrote the magnificent words of the Constitution and the Declaration of Independence, they were signing a promissory note to which every American was to fall heir. This note was a promise that all men, yes, black men as well as white men, would be guaranteed the unalienable rights of life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness."
Apparently, Norton doesn't know King's words as much as she'd like to think.
The fact that a bill could likely be dead that would give America's children a chance to recite the rights afforded to them by our Founding Fathers is a disgrace. But on this Memorial Day, remember those who still fought and died for all of our freedoms despite the dissenters and naysayers trying to tear down its foundations. http://www.truthrevolt.org/news/state-rep-dont-teach-kids-declaration-independence-its-racist
State Rep. Barbara Norton opposes a new bill that would mandate schoolchildren in grades four, five and six to recite a portion of the historic document in the first class of each day. HB 1035 was presented by Republican state Rep. Valarie Hodges and did very well early on, sailing through the House Education Committee. But now the bill has stalled and is possibly dead.
Somehow it was considered controversial with some black members saying it would be better for students to recite portions of Martin Luther King Jr.'s "I Have a Dream Speech." One, Rep. Ed Price (D), wrote an amendment to the bill for students to do so. He said, “We fought a long way to get where we are today and I think Dr. King’s speech really personifies what has happened.”
But nothing compares to the assault on the Declaration of Independence made by Norton when she addressed Hodges on the state House floor last week saying:
"I'm not really sure what your intent is, but one thing that I do know is, all men are not created equal.
"When I think back in 1776, July the 4th, African-Americans were slaves. And for you to bring a bill to request that our children would recite the Declaration, I think it's a little bit unfair to us, to ask those children to recite something that's not the truth."
Hodges responded in disbelief, "You don't think that all men are created equal? You think that's not true?"
Norton continued, with little assurance that she's actually read the document:
"Let me finish… and for you to ask our children to repeat the Declaration stating that all mens [sic] are free, I think that's unfair.
"In 1776, Dr. King was not even born. African-Americans were in slavery, so since they were in slavery, in the Declaration of Independence say [sic], we were all treated eq -- we were all created equal. we were not created equal because in 1776, July the 4th, I, nor you, nor any of us were born, nor was Dr. King born, so, we were in slavery. And to have our children to repeat, to repeat again and again documents that was not even validated [sic], I don't think that that's fair because we're teaching them a lie."
Hodges responded on Facebook, saying of her fellow members, "It is disturbing to see the lack of understanding of the founding of this country and patriotism." She then added a reminder to something Dr. King said during his most famous speech:
"When the architects of our republic wrote the magnificent words of the Constitution and the Declaration of Independence, they were signing a promissory note to which every American was to fall heir. This note was a promise that all men, yes, black men as well as white men, would be guaranteed the unalienable rights of life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness."
Apparently, Norton doesn't know King's words as much as she'd like to think.
The fact that a bill could likely be dead that would give America's children a chance to recite the rights afforded to them by our Founding Fathers is a disgrace. But on this Memorial Day, remember those who still fought and died for all of our freedoms despite the dissenters and naysayers trying to tear down its foundations. http://www.truthrevolt.org/news/state-rep-dont-teach-kids-declaration-independence-its-racist

Forgot the bit 'bout how Native Americans were "merciless Indian savages" - "He has excited domestic insurrections amongst us, and has endeavoured to bring on the inhabitants of our frontiers, the merciless Indian Savages, whose known rule of warfare, is an undistinguished destruction of all ages, sexes and conditions. "
Hmmmmm - didn't see anything 'bout blacks in there - you??? So, if it just mentions Native Americans as "merciless Indian Savages" and it doesn't mention blacks - it's no longer racist?????
The Native style and tactics of warfare was mercilessly savage, that is a historical fact. And the King did pay bounties to his Indian allies for the destruction of colonial settlements, that is also historical fact.
So the part about inciting the Indians on the frontier is particularly true. No matter their motivations. That part, in the context it was written isn't racist. It's a statement of fact.
But I agree about the lack of mention about blacks and the point you made 1st. The racism and lack of outright rejecting it was a fault of the writers and declarers.
One we paid a very dear price for later.
"When the architects of our republic wrote the magnificent words of the Constitution and the Declaration of Independence, they were signing a promissory note to which every American was to fall heir. This note was a promise that all men, yes, black men as well as white men, would be guaranteed the unalienable rights of life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness."
Actually that isn't correct. There was almost no USA, because there was an anti slavery clause in the original version of the Declaration, and slave owners wouldn't sign it, if it was in there.
Although the issue of slavery was widely debated -- both the chattel slavery of Africans in America and the civil slavery that fired patriot rhetoric -- it is conspicuously absent from the final version of the Declaration. Yet in his rough draft, Jefferson railed against King George III for creating and sustaining the slave trade, describing it as "a cruel war against human nature."
Although Jefferson's description of the slave trade was as much an indictment of the colonies as of Britain and the king, the issue that most distressed the patriots stemmed from Lord Dunmore's 1775 proclamation that offered freedom to slaves who joined the British cause: "...he is now exciting those very people to rise in arms among us, and to purchase that liberty of which he has deprived them, by murdering the people on whom he also obtruded them..."
When the document was presented to the Continental Congress on July 1, 1776, both northern and southern slaveholding delegates objected to its inclusion, and it was removed. The only remaining allusion to the original paragraph on slavery is the phrase "He has excited domestic Insurrections among us," included in a list of grievances against the king.
So really it was a promise that was unkept until civil rights.
This is not to say that I don't believe that the our Declaration shouldn't be taught. Of course it should. It is the foundations of our country and a noble attempt at something that had never been done before. In that sense we are quite unique. But it is NOT a flawless document.
I would have thought that the Declaration of Independence and the Constitution would be considered on a current rather than historical basis. Next thing, somebody is going to find fault with the Stars and Stripes and America is going to have to design a new flag - perhaps with rainbow colours to cover all aspects of American society. Although I'm in complete agreement with separation of church and state, I thought it was pretty extreme that a sculpture of the 10 Commandments had to be removed from a courthouse, but I guess there's no end. It makes life as depicted in the classic movie THX 1138 a probable destination.
By the way, when my Chinese students who are studying English are good enough, I make them read out loud Dr. King's I Have a Dream speech - eventually learning to use the kind of emotion and emphasis that Dr. King did. Actual recordings of the speech are available on the internet here. Of course they first have to know a little about the history of the various States in order to understand his meaning.
Babs sounds like an uneducated buffoon. Perpetual victimhood is no replacement for knowledge.
She reminds me of that Maxine person from Texas - both are blathering idiots.
Yeah, what about those that elected her?
While I decry the words, "the merciless Indian savages," you have to look at the context in which it was written. Personally, I'm irked that it says all MEN are created equal. What about women? Of course, at the time it was written, women couldn't own property, vote, or do anything but flutter their fans and do needlework...
I don't think we can take a lot of our own historical documents and apply today's viewpoints to them on a line by line comparison. As a whole, it was an "enlightened" document. The inalienable right to own property, the pursuit of happiness, et. al., was a really radical idea for the time. I think it should be taught in schools, but I also think it should be taught in context.
Just my thoughts...
BINGO!
Exactly the point Perrie made above.....
It took many generations to rid ourselves of the compromises made in our founding documents.
Sadly we are still working on it today.....
Everything should be taken in context. But that's not the progressive agenda. If any historical figure or event dies not completely embrace today's universal "tolerance" it is shunned.
Not by me!
I think that is too broad a brush...
And this is a great example why people are so frustrated with the political correctness in this country. What an absolutely stupid rant and position to take. I'm embarrassed for her......