The Confederate Flag and Avatars on News Talkers
A question for the site
In light of recent events and decisions
Is it appropriate that images of the Confederate Flag and the Confederate Battle Flag no longer be used as or as part of avatars?
"Discussion Rules
Present Your Position on the Question
Everyone is entitled to their own view on the matter, do not belittle or attack the position of others
Robert in Ohio"

For myself, I agree with the decisions in South Carolina to remove the flag from the state house, in Virginia to remove the image from the license plate and by WalMart to stop selling merchandise with the image
That being said, I would never use the image in an avatar, but as to a site wide decision that is up to the membership
I look forward to your opinions please observe the discussion rules
"Discussion Rules
Present Your Position on the Question
Everyone is entitled to their own view on the matter, do not belittle or attack the position of others
Robert in Ohio"
It's my heritage regardless of the hysteria circulating now.
As I have stated a few times now, no one was bothered by demonstrators in California flying the flag of Hamas, and some were carrying symbols of ISIS. I mentioned both here and was told it was freedom of speech.
Muslims live in this country and proudly display flags and symbols of their home and religion, and we're being told to forget 9/11.
I don't use any symbol of the Confederacy as my avatar; but if I chose to do so and was told it was banned from the site, I would leave NT. The next move might be telling me the Jewish Star of David is forbidden here as an avatar because Israel keeps all the Palestinians in a state of slavery.. and that has definitely been said here.
I would still believe that it is still up to the individual member to make use of the confederate flag or any icon they choose to represent themselves in the way of an avatar.
That being said, the user would leave little in the way of imagination as to their approving mindset supporting white supremacy, or at the very least, the users ignorance of a sad part of our history.
scremminmimi
Thanks for sharing your perspective
FLY
Good points
Thanks for the feedback and the perspective.
Cerenkov
Are you saying you are unsure or that you see a slippery slope ahead?
Sounding more like you are a "No" to the question
Thanks for the perspective
Nah..... it wouldn't be that.
NO!
Not clear?
NO!
Slippery slope indeed!
The argument in sum here on the forum is one of people not knowing what REAL racism actually is.
I mean the racism in this country is so bad that millions of people are leaving the country to escape it right? If they don't, they will wind up dead right?
Some people want to call it a symbol of racism equivalent to the NAZI flag, or the swastika. but the swastika if I remember correctly was a symbol of life used around the world before it was usurped by the NAZI's The Nazi's were actually using it as a symbol of life also, in their twisted evil way.
Do not lose sight that racism and bigotry is a choice. An individual choice. And is only truly represented by the content of the character that makes that choice.
No flag can carry that content, it can only be carried by man.
So the answer is no, and should be no for any honest man.
Just for jollies-- I've worked very hard to make an array of avatars if you want one pre-made and ready to go!
Avatar blog
I wouldn't chose one, personally, even if it is a part of my heritage. I had family on both sides of that conflict. I just wouldn't want to make anyone else uncomfortable. Which is why I don't fly it at my house, either.
So, I don't want the site to "forbid" use of it, but I do think it sends a message to people-- and each message is individual.
Personally there are and have been avatars on NT's I don't like, but I believe it's an individual's responsibility to portray themselves as they'd like to be perceived.
I just use a photo, like it or not, it's me and individual opinions of me would be gleaned from my responses and not an avatar.
That being said, the user would leave little in the way of imagination as to their approving mindset supporting white supremacy
That is what it means to you, FLY.
I don't know how many different ways I can say it doesn't mean that to everyone.
If someone wants to use the confederate flag as an avatar, I really hope that they do. The same way that I feel it would be ok for nazis to wear their old uniforms, because it would disallow them from hiding behind civilian clothing.
Feronia
Thanks for sharing your perspective on the question
I know that Mimi....
Since this thing has come to the forefront, I took some time to really think about my position on the matter for a couple of days. Believe it or not, one of your comments was one of two that gave me real pause to stop, think, and evaluate the issue. I can honestly say I worked hard to understand what you, and Bruce and others think and feel about this thing. Unfortunately I can't see it being possible to separate out one's historical pride, without ignoring what the civil war was all about. I can't support that.
Besides my hometown was burned to the ground by them Missouri Bushwhackers lead by Bill Quantrill in 1863.
scremminmimi
Point taken
Nowhere Man
Thanks for a very clear and definitive position on the issue
Appreciate the feedback
Dowser
Well said thanks for the perspective and feedback on the question.
Lynne
A good approach to how we present ourselves
Thanks for sharing that perspective
Raven Wing
It would be a huge deal to a lot of us if you ever even considered leaving NT so put that thought out of your mine (far out of your mind)
Thanks for the perspective and feedback on the question
p.s. I think you avatar is great!
Larry
Appreciate the feedback and your perspective
Using your analogy, is a person that uses the confederate flag a racist any more than someone who use the U.S. flag is a patriot? Perhaps some people would use the confederate flag or a Nazi symbol merely to irritate and elicit reactions from others when it has nothing to do with their actual views?
The only reason I can think why someone would use the confederate flag isas provocation. Specifically it has become a racial provocation, though it is very well used to merely get a rise outta folks. Is the flyer of the confederate flag more racists? No, not necessarily so, though they obviously don't mind being thought of that way; so, it does make one wonder...
Maybe making you wonder is all they want to do.
Comment removed for COC "inflamatory" at seeders request "96WS6"
I look at it as a symbol that once represented the heritage of the Old South, even though I personally abhor that heritage. Still, how ever I feel about that heritage doesn't matter. It is a symbol that has been adopted by White Supremacist groups as theirs. They have dirtied it much further then anyone could who merely objects to it because it represents the old slave South. They have turned it into a symbol of fear, terrorism, hate and racism among other feelings. When most people look at it today, that is all they see. The hate and bigotry of White Supremacists. I know that when I look at it, that's all I see. Hate and bigotry toward Blacks, Jews, Catholics, Hispanics, etc. Toward anyone who is not a believer in White, Anglo-saxon, Protestant Christian Power. Toward anyone who is not exactly the way they are and the way the see themselves, as a Master Race. As inherently superior to everyone else of every other race and religious order. When I look at it I see the Klan. Now if someone wants to be angry about the reputation that flag has today, they are the ones to be pissed at, the White Supremacists and no one else. It is no longer a symbol of Southern Pride. It is a symbol of hate, thanks to them.
Love you, bf!
Yay, NewsTalkers!
T G D
The symbol obviously has a lot of meaning to you
Thanks for sharing
That is a good argument against the takeover of the word "gay" by the homosexual community ...
Petey
Try to stay on the topic of the Confederate flags
Perhaps you have an idea there for article of your own
Momma taught me to tell the truth
Even many in the South did not support Quantrill. He used the war as an excuse to be a glorified outlaw with no boundaries and no law to stop him. Complete mongrel.
@ Randy:
It's true that the Confederate flag has been "taken over" by white supremacists for some very ugly things.
They also took over the cross, a religious symbol for every Christian religion. Yet no one has advocated doing away with the cross, and it swings from the necks of Popes, children, and every religious church-goer of every Christian religion in the world. It stands on almost every grave site around the world save for Muslim and a few other religions, whether the dead was religious or not.
The burning cross strikes fear in the heart of blacks far more effectively than the sight of a Confederate flag.
Where is the campaign to remove the cross from the sight and history of America?
The taking away of the cross is a false equivalency because they burn it as a show of intimidation. A burning cross is just as much of a show of White Supremacy and hate, but I have never seen a Christian church burning a cross. The two simply are not the same thing.
Present Your Position on the Question
Everyone is entitled to their own view on thematter, do not belittle or attack the position of others
Here is my position. I don't care what you think of the avatar, or of me. I'm not here to please anyone.
(And if you're trying to run the article on RBR, you need to read the requirements. RBR HAS to be in the Title.)
I have never seen a Confederate War history group use the flag to threaten blacks ...
I never have. How many crosses have they burnt. Do you have pictures of them actually burning a cross, say on someones yard or at some sort of ceremony or as a show of intimidation?
Hardly the same thing, now is it? Notice that the flame is near the cross, but it is not a burning cross
As well as a pedophile.
I find your avatar offensive as Charlie Chaplin was an alleged communist and communism killed 100 Million people.
Fixed that or you.
It wasn't that hard to present your position without being crude.
Thank you for the feedback and the perspective
John
The question was concerning avatars and NT?
DO you have a position on that question?
I know it is difficult for some but the topic was quite narrow it is about the confederate flag and NT avatars.
Feel free to present opinions on that topic but kindly refrain from going off on tangents or down other rabbit holes
Thanks
I don't care if anyone wants to have it on their home page or use it as their avatar. I will just think of them as I have already said in previous posts how I think of that flag.
Then why do you bother to offer ignominious commentary?
If people cannot agree on whether or not it represents white supremacy
It represents White Supremacy. There, I've agreed.
Snort.
That goes without saying. You never have any useful thoughts when you spout your ignorance.
Not every person who has a Confederate flag uses it to harass, intimidate, and frighten blacks, either, Randy.
You just destroyed your own argument.
And the cross was used for centuries as a tool of terror and intimidation against entire nations of populations. It should have been outlawed when Rome fell!
Avatars are a form of personal expression, completely different from the "should the State be sponsoring something?" debate, and as such members should be allowed a broad range of freedom in their choice of theimages they chose to be associated with as long as it doesn't reach the level of obscenity as judge bythisforumsstandards. ie: (I know it when I see it)
If a member wants to be identified with the Nazi swastika, the Confederate battle flag or some image associated with the Westboro Baptist church then I say fine, @ least I have an early warning of where their thoughts are coming from.
Personally I don't buy the "it's a heritage thing". How could IsinceI was born andgrew up inTexas, where there have been 6Flags flying over us through the years. You wont see a bunch of folk getting their panties in a wadwhen people rightly point out that their wish to fly the French or Spanish flags over the Texas State house because "it's our heritage"would just be astupid stand to take.
Personal use fine, State sponsored use, Not fine.
I guess the flag over the Confederate War cemetery wouldn't be state sponsored ?
Is there such a thing Petey?
I thought our National Military cemeteries officially only used American flags. Are there other flags used by family members on a given grave site, or something like that?
Max Henry
No personal attacks please
A H
Thanks for sharing your perspective on the tough issue.
Petey
In my view, it would depend on who owns and maintains the cemetery
The state or a private group
Robert G
No one is imposing anything on anyone
It was merely a question, to allow for the exchange of opinions on the issue.
If you are insulted by the question, I invite you to ignore it
As it is, despite the bluster you did not answer the question YES or NO.
Before it was co-opted by southern state governments, the flag was a symbol, not of sanctioned racism, but of rebellion, of the kind practiced by teenagers. It's use as a symbol, today, is reactionary and backward, appropriate forold-fogies, who were those teen-aged rebels of yore.
rimbauda
Interesting perspective on the issue - thank you for sharing it with us.
RG, SMAAB RW JR BF (and everyone else)
Let's all focus on the topic and not on commenting on other members please
Perhaps it has become a symbol of free speech for some, provoking conversation and debate; yet, it's primary provocationhas becomeracial in it's premise and acceptance. So yes provocative speech is necessary at times, though in this case the only freedom of speech it seems to provoke and preside over,is a reminder of the racism that still exists, just like it did when that flag was first raised.The free speech that flag represents in any practical manner, is the freedom to be celebrate racism.
YES!!!
Well, Ok--- I realize that there are some non Francophones in the crowd. So, here it is in English:
I believe that at one time "Haut Les Mains" ("Hands Up") was also the official theme song of
Club Mditerrane (link ) in the Americas:
And probably a Socialist Muslim Kenyan as well!
It seems to me this 'knee jerk' reaction beingenactedall overthecountry by taking down the rebel flag, is kind of forgetting about the mostpreciousof our Constitutional Rights. I doubt that I need tell you what it is.
Actually, I kinda like the fact that some people like to identify themselves as Redneck, rebel bigots by displaying the symbol of treason and bigotry used by the Confederate Rebels when they attempted to divide this nation so they could continue to enslave human beings.
I swear to God people come on here and they just babble. Well, let's not over-generalize. At least there are some people here (for example, people such as yourself) who would never engage in that sort of behaviour!
Ya know Robert, I agree with that.Imo there aretwo reasons to not ban the use of the Confederate flag here on NTers. First,a person should be free touse whatever avatar they want that doesn'tviolate Ning's ToS, whether I am offended by it or not; and, second, because I personally want to know who here doesn't mind being thought of as racists.
This article raises the question as to our communities thoughts on banning the Confederate flag. Our expressions in our comments are freely given, and as a community we delve into what we do and do not want. It's up to us. I hope that we don not vote to ban the flag: I would not agree with that. Otoh, what if the community decides to go ahead and ban that flag? Would it be a violation of the communities freedom to disallowdeciding such a thing?
Larry
Thanks for that feedback and perspective.
Your points are solid and hard to argue with - as to banning the symbol or not, I figure that we shouldn't and likely won't even vote on it.
The question came to mind because we, as a community/site voted on whether to an certain words being used a while back as I recall and I thought this was similar.
Thanks for the great feedbacl
Fairly irrelevantto the topic don't you think
R G
Then why not leave out all the bullcrap and answer the question
Jerry
So that perspective makes you a NO on the question I guess.
A lot of people like labels for people and groups
Keep you eye on the topic please
Talk about the topic and not about other members if you please
Well, obviously today different people have different perceptions of what it symbolizes.
However, the "symbolizing our heritage" has another element to it-- one you just alluded to. One which many of you Yankees might not be aware of-- specifically the rebellion aspect. (Certainly the Boston Tea Party, the one in colonial times, was an act of outright rebellion! And, BTW, had nothing to do with racism-- if anything it was about increasing human rights!).
Historically, some supporters of the flag were outright racists, others not so much. The whole idea of the Confederacy was..rebellion. Against the Union (rule by an overly powerful government). There's a history behind it.
When the U.S. was still British Colonies, like most colonies we were subject to oppressive rules and restrictions of our colonial rulers (Britain). At first while some people wanted total independence from Britain, others wanted merely to have more self rule. To be able to have some say in the laws and government. For some, they merely wanted to have the power of "nullification"-- veto of some of the more egregious British colonial laws.
Slavery and accompanying racism was a specific issue. However, there was a key general issue as well. Generally, historically, advocates of state's rights were rebels. The American colonialists were afraid of strong central government rule (by the British King) so they wanted a USA where more states' power would serve as a check and balance against an overly strong oppressive central government.
I'm lazy to google it, (plus I am probably guilty of having all of the horrendous personality defects that XXJohnRussell11.5 keeps accusing me of when he realizes he is losing the arguments and hopes to derail the discussion by his patently silly personal attacks). But if anyone wants to know more about state's rights*, you can google topics such as the doctrines of "Nullification" and "Interposition ".
________________________________________________
*Of course its highly doubtful that most people here will want to know more. About that or indeed anything at all. Given the current predominant "know it all" zeitgeist on NT.
Well, at least you're not overly opinionated, self-righteous, or condescending about your views!
And why not? If they stopped doing that, they might have to drop their know it all attitude-- and who wants to do that???
And now back to the topic okay
Please discuss the topic and not each other
(?!) Why would it make me a 'NO'?
Actually it makes me YES! Asmuchas dislike people displaying arrogance and belligerence, I realize they have a constitutional right do to do so.
Your question is a littleambiguous in that you a sk, " Is it appropriate.....? ", IMO, although it often may inappropriate to use controversial or insulting avatars, the 1st amendment grants us the right to use them.
However, this being a privately owned site the ownership does has the right to set limits. And IMO avatars such as these should be considered beyond the limit:
As much as I try to be the most opinionated on the site, there are others that outdo me. Condescending? Yeah I suppose, can't help it, myself righteousness gets the better of me..
But enough of this, RIO gets upset when we go off topic.
So, is a rebel flag avatar appropriate or not Krish?
Jerry
All of the emblems you offer here are based on hate of one kind or another which applies to the confederate flag as well in the minds of most, so why is it not beyond the limit as well.
I agree with you on the constitutional right of expression, but if the ones you show are inappropriate the confederate flag would be as well.
Removing the flag as an official, state, government-sanctioned flag is much different than banning it: doing so restores it as a symbol of rebellion and displaying it as an act of free speech.
Not every person who has a Confederate flag uses it to harass, intimidate, and frighten blacks, either, Randy.
But that is the effect it has. When I see it, I see Klan. Oh and you saying that I've destroyed my own argument and me actually destroying my own argument are not the same things. Just so you know.
And the cross was used for centuries as a tool of terror and intimidation against entire nations of populations. It should have been outlawed when Rome fell!
You may be right. So start a movement to get the cross banned. Good luck.
Here's something else US blacks are afraid of :
But here's what they should be afraid of :
RE the song "Sweet Home Alabama". Alabama just decided to remove the Confederate Battle Flag from all of their public grounds too, including at the capitol also.
In fact it's become something of a Tsunami. Every state government that has it anywhere on their properties are having them removed and states that have it in their state flags are having their flags redesigned to have it removed.
Next they are gonna delete that song from rock n' roll history ...
and I disagree.
And I disagree.
Rimbauda
Absolutely agree - excellent point.
Bruce,
Your comment about the RBR's is wrong. They are supposed to always be in the first comment, since the first comment can't be changed after 15 min. while your article can be changed always.
I reposted the article with just the link on the front page as a reminder.
If I'm not at all interested in the topic I don't. (Of course in that case i don't even look at the seed at all).
If I'm interested in the topic I almost always do. In fact sometimes I even follow links from that article to find other articles which I then read!
On rare occasions I am not really interested in the topic, but I do comment without having read the original. But then I have other motivations in the discussion.
Being a somewhat mischievous type, sometimes I read the article for a different reason. People post lies (false information) surprisingly frequently on the 'net. So occasionally when something about the seed or discussion comments doesn't "pass the smell test"--- I read the original article and find a sentence or three (a factual sentence) that directly contradicts what the seeder or commenter has said! (And of course I post that in the discussion...heh
).
But my long experience online has been that most of the time most people don't even't bother to skim the origianl article. It took me quite a while to finally figure out why that is so...
Well, we do have freedom of speech. And IMO, that includes the right to not speak!
So-- I'm not going to say....
I think many people were surprised at the number of political leaders who called for removal of Confederate flags in their state. And perhaps most surprising of all, many of them were Republicans--- and conservative Republicans! In fact, some were Southerners!
I think that this is due in part to the fact that many people don't really understand politics. Many hate conservatives, but they actually have misconceptions about them.
Is this racist?
Krishna
That's the whole point of the controversy - it depends on who you ask
Krishna
We all want to believe that they are sincere, but there is also a little political expediency in the statements and position of some I fear.
An understatement RIO. As a result of theCharleston shooting, the Rebel flag is a political hot potato. With the 2016 elections just around the corner, it's a political necessity to be on the right side of public opinion.
Jerry
The sad part of that truth (and what you say is the truth) is that people on both sides of the aisle have taken strong positions on the issue based solely on political expediency years of either opposite views or simply indifference.
jennilee
Yes that is correct.