46% Of U.S. Christians See Themselves First As Christian, Rather Than As American
"......For instance, about half of Muslims said they thought of themselves first as Muslim, rather than as American. A different Pew survey found a nearly identical fraction of Christians in the United States, 46 percent, saying they thought of themselves first as Christian, rather than as American. And near-identical percentages of Muslims and Christians said there was no conflict with being devout in their own religion and part of a modern society. (Sentiments about identity were similar among native-born and foreign-born Muslims, though those born after 1990 had a somewhat larger preference for a Muslim identity.)
Jen'nan Ghazal Read, an associate professor of sociology and global health at Duke University, pointed to data from Pew and other sources showing similar rates of religious practice and beliefs among Muslims and Christians in the United States:
Other evidence lines up with what Pew found.
Selcuk R. Sirin, an associate professor of applied psychology at New York University's Steinhardt School of Culture, Education, and Human Development, found that even though 84 percent of 12-to-18-year-old Muslim Americans he studied had faced at least one act of discrimination in the previous year, most were comfortable with their "hyphenated identities" as both Muslims and Americans. "They seem to be pretty happy sitting on the hyphen," has said. "They don't feel the need to pick one over the other."
Akbar S. Ahmed, a professor of Islamic studies at American University, found similar sentiments when he did fieldwork for the book "Journey into America," which spanned 75 cities and 100 mosques.
"Muslims again and again told us that America is the best place in the world to be a Muslim," Ahmed said. "There are countless examples of Muslims who are assimilated and are completely American in every sense." He said that out of the roughly 2,000 personal interviews that comprised in his fieldwork, virtually all Muslims said that Muslims could be American.
"So it is dangerous, irresponsible and incorrect for Trump to make statements like this and demonize the entire community," Ahmed said.
Tags
Who is online
134 visitors

"Trump said that even among "second and third generation" Muslims in the United States, "there's no real assimilation."
The data and the experts agree that Trump is wrong. Substantial evidence confirms that Muslim Americans want to have an American identity and think that doing so is achievable. In fact, their preferences for self-identification mirror those of Christian Americans."
As an engineer, I've worked alongside many Muslims, Hindus and Sikhs. Never have I felt their demeanor or personality as being influenced by their religion. I honestly cannot say the same thing about the Christians I have worked with.
Wow. I've had the exact opposite experience, as an engineer.
"They seem to be pretty happy sitting on the hyphen," has said. "They don't feel the need to pick one over the other."
To me this isn't the question. The question is which one would you pick if you had to? Where are your loyalties?
For instance, just listening to how much hate comes from the Christians and how they've inserted their beliefs into our justice system and our politics I found it very concerning. I think their loyalties are to themselves first and foremost. They want to reek the benefits of this country but they don't want to afford others the same freedoms. I have no doubt that if they could invoke Christian law here in America they would without a second thought. Muslims probably feel the same way. Why aren't we "monitoring" Christians? I think we can say that factions of both Christians and Muslims have a long history of hate and violence so why do we choose to treat Christians differently? We have instances of domestic terrorism from Christians every year with respect to abortion. Why do they get a pass?
Personally I have an issue with anyone that distinguishes who they are in front of "American". In my mind (with the exception of Native American), I think we should always reference ourselves as American Muslim or American Christian or American Jew and not the other way around. It's just something that's always bothered me for some reason.
Good points PJ.
--------------
I think that the media and the internet turns everything into an urgent emergency. The thing that is changing America more than anything is the effect of social media and instantaneous communication on actual events and attitudes. We never want to realize this.
Happy Saturday John!
The internet and social media add IMMENSELY to the enjoyment and satisfaction that mass killers take from their actions. For all of us to act as if this insignificant is something I find bizarre.
-
The Orlando Mass Shooter Checked Facebook for News of His Attack As He Killed
Disturbing new evidence shows how social media is fueling gun massacres.
The massacre in Orlando stands as a grim case in many respects, not least the hateful targeting of the LGBT crowd at the Pulse nightclub, and the highest death toll from a mass shooting in modern US history. Equally dark is that the case builds on some disturbing trends related to the means and motives now seen in mass shootings. One is that the attacker struck with an assault rifle and high-capacity magazines —marking the sixth of nine mass shootings in just the past year alone to be carried out with firearms tantamount to weapons of war .
The other disturbing trend lies with how the perpetrator, Omar Mateen, used digital media. He searched online for inspiration from recent attackers before he struck. And then, as he was unleashing carnage inside the club, he sought to learn if the media was covering the killing in real time.
As Mateen shot scores of people and held others hostage, according to Johnson's letter, he searched online for 'Pulse Orlando' and 'Shooting' during the prolonged siege of the club. (Presumably he did so on a smartphone, though that isn't detailed in the letter.) Meanwhile, just weeks before the massacre, Mateen researched the couple who pledged allegiance to the Islamic State and committed the massacre in San Bernardino last Decemeber—suggesting that he wanted to follow in their footsteps.
These behaviors underscore a growing concern among leaders in the field of threat assessment that digital technology has compounded the danger of future attacks. As I reported in a Mother Jones cover story last fall, there is emerging forensic evidence showing that social media has both exacerbated a copycat effect and become a prime tool for mass shooters seeking infamy.
"In my mind (with the exception of Native American), I think we should always reference ourselves as American Muslim or American Christian or American Jew and not the other way around."
Are those our only options?!
Presumably you can refer to yourself as an American Atheist.
I prefer just "American". Atheist shouldn't even be a word, just like aleprechaunist isn't a word.
Atheist shouldn't even be a word, just like aleprechaunist isn't a word.
I agree. Using the word implies to some morons that it is a belief system, when it is not. It is the lack of a belief system, something they have trouble grasping. Still what other word can we use that they'll understand? I know there is no god, so there should be a new word to express that knowledge and truth.
That would be more convincing, if it wasn't for the evangelical atheists who spend so much time proselytizing.
I don't know of any. Atheists do not, as a rule, proselytize. I have never met an atheist who does. If they do, then they are not atheists.
Though I do admit I would like to, just to see what reaction I would get, go door to door with Dr. Richard Dawkins' book "The God Delusion" and tell people "Have you heard the good news! There is no Christ or God!! There is no second coming because there never was a first one! Let me in and I'll reveal the true word to you!"
Dawkins is a classic example of an evangelical atheist. There's no reason for him or you to convince others of your disbelief. I manage to live well without pressing my disbelief on others or mocking their faith.
Dawkins does not proselytize. He merely wrote a book. You can choose to buy it or not. He gives lecturers. You can choose to buy a ticket to one or not (I have attended one at Cal Tech a few years ago). Having read his book and attended one of his lectures I can say with complete confidence that he does not try to get people to believe what he says is the truth, he just presents the truth as he sees it and lets you decide. He does nothing whatsoever to try to convince people of the truth of what he says. He just puts it out there and, without any forceful comment and let's you decide if you feel the same way or not. That is NOT proselytizing in any manner. He also NEVER mocks other people's faith. He does not believe in that. He is far from being an Evangelical. You're going to have to come up with a real example of an atheist that proselytizes, because he ain't it.
Read his book and attend one of his lectures. Then and only then can you speak knowledgeably about him and what he says.
Using the word implies to some morons that it is a belief system, when it is not. It is the lack of a belief system
Actually it is a belief system . The only ones that lack a belief system are agnostics . The fact that you don't even perceive your beliefs even as you espouse them implies some kind of compensation mechanism .
You can say it as much a you want, but it is not a belief system, it is a knowledge. It is the opposite of a belief system, which is why so many people who think you must believe SOMETHING, pro or con, when it comes to the god myth can't grasp it. It is a lack of belief in anything. Atheists do not believe in anything.
it is a knowledge.
Actually it is a belief . Not admitting that is a delusion .
Again, you have been raised that you must believe in something. One of the somethings is that you must either believe in a god or not believe in a god. You can not grasp the idea of complete non-belief. Atheistism is a complete non-belief. It is not a belief system. It is refusing to accept that one must choose not to believe in a god. It is a non-belief, not a belief system. I don't really not believe in a god. I reject the question as an unrealistic question in the first place. There exists nothing for me not to believe in.
Yeah got it . The Higgs boson doesn't exist either ... because YOU say it doesn't .
The Higgs boson has nothing to do with this conversation. It is a derailment.
This isn't a "conversation" . It is you proclaiming your POV in spite of no proof . Here is a topic directly relevant :
That was funny and witty.
No sir Hal. It's just an opening and everyone can add their 2¢'s.
Because Christians aren't murdering people in job lots in the name of their religion?
Gunny.... Indeed. Agree 100%.
It is the duty of every Christian to be loyal to the country they live in.
No, it isn’t.
And to obey its laws as long as doing so does not conflict with obeying God's law.
Who’s god and what law ?
Still loyalty to God comes first.
?
We are all awaiting Heaven either at the resurrection or directly going at the 2nd coming.
Personally I know very few people who are waiting for either.
A nation with individual and religious liberty would never put one in a position where they
had to choose between their country and their faith.
How do you know that ?
When that literally happens, eternal life and a relationship with our savior trumps all else.
You’ve always had eternal life no matter who or what you pray to.
I am an American first and the reason is this. Our founding fathers understood that we were a nation of many people with many different beliefs and backgrounds and took that into consideration, and put that into our Constitution. There is no conflict between being an American first and your spiritual or non beliefs. When I say the pledge, I am saying it to my country, one nation, indivisible, under god... (in that order), with liberty and justice for all. So country first, for I am protected by the big 10.
Amen
I also am an American first. Even when I was a practicing Catholic or when I was a "Born again Christian" in a fundamentalist church, i was still an American first. The U.S. Constitution is my bible. My country comes first over any religion. We are a secular nation, not a Christian one or a Jewish one or a Muslim one or any kind of religious one. Being a secular nation is one of our greatest strengths and without it America as we know it would die.
My first loyalty is to my family. My second is to my nation. I don't anticipate any conflict, however.
@Cerenkov :
I noticed you always "thumbs down" my comments. Is this a Pavlovian response to seeing my avatar or do you have substantive reasons why you disagree with my comments ?
It's not automatic. It's a judgment call based on each post.
Then maybe you can tell me why my above response to XX's post was wrong or incorrect ?
Sure. I felt you were dismissive of XXJ's faith. I felt you were being purposely oblivious of his version of God and his laws. It seemed intolerant to me.
I'm not religious but I see no reason to fight ardently against what others believe in up to the point that they impose violence or control on the rest of us. And, yes, I oppose legislation that is based solely on Chrisianty, ad well.
Sure. I felt you were dismissive of XXJ's faith. I felt you were being purposely oblivious of his version of God and his laws. It seemed intolerant to me.
Okay, I can give you that.
I'm not religious but I see no reason to fight ardently against what others believe in up to the point that they impose violence or control on the rest of us. And, yes, I oppose legislation that is based solely on Chrisianty, ad well.
Thank you.
There are points of congruence between us and between the left and right. It's disappointing and dangerous that compromise is so heretical nowadays. During Reagan, Bush I, and Clinton I, the parties actually compromised. I've heard many theories about what caused the change we see now, but none of them are convincing to me.
Refreshing to see an exchange of ideas. Thanks guys!
And, yes, I oppose legislation that is based solely on Chrisianty, ad well.
Agree 100%.