╌>

ChristianMingle Forced to Admit There Are Gay Christians Looking for Love

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  bobby-nguyen  •  10 years ago  •  103 comments

ChristianMingle Forced to Admit There Are Gay Christians Looking for Love

384



 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Nearly three years after two gay men filed a class-action lawsuit against Christian dating website ChristianMingle.com, the Los Angeles-based company has agreed to let its members seek out same-sex partners, reports  The Wall Street Journal . 

Although a California judge determined the site’s straight-only formatting violated the state’s  Unruh Civil Rights Act , which prohibits discrimination based on sexual orientation, the company behind ChristianMingle did not admit any wrongdoing. 

The  judgement, finalized Monday  by Judge Jane L. Johnson of the Superior Court of California in Los Angeles County, ordered Spark Networks to do away with settings on all its sites that only allow users to select “man seeking woman” or vice versa. 

Spark Networks is the  parent company  of more than a dozen other dating sites that match people based on faith practices, age, or race, including CatholicMingle.com, LDSSingles.com, BlackSingles.com, and SilverSingles.com. The company first entered the online dating business with Jewish dating site JDate.com, though that property was not impacted by the judge’s order. A spokesperson for Spark Networks told the  Wall Street Journal  that the company was “pleased to resolve this litigation.” 

For the next two years, “Spark will ensure that the ‘man seeking woman’ and ‘woman seeking man’ options on the gateway/home pages of the Mingle sites ask only whether the user is a ‘man’ or a ‘woman,’” reads the judgment. The company was further ordered not to change the match prompts to “man seeking woman” at any time in the future, unless it also “provides similar prompts which allow individuals seeking a same sex match to enter and use the sites without having to state that they are seeking a match with someone of the opposite sex.”

“As long as Spark operates the Mingle Sites, users will continue to have the ability to search for potential same sex matches using the sites’ text searching and profile building functions,” summarizes the order. The company has 24 months from the date of Monday’s order to bring all its sites into compliance. 

The judge also ordered Spark to pay $9,000 to each of the two plaintiffs who brought the suit, in addition to covering the full $450,000 in attorneys fees incurred by the gay men. 

Vineet Dubey, one of the attorneys for the two named plaintiffs, expressed gratitude for the case’s resolution. “I am gratified that we were able to work with Spark to help ensure that people can fully participate in all the diverse market places that make our country so special, regardless of their sexual orientation,” Dubey said in a statement.

While ChristianMingle’s home page currently asks only for the member’s binary gender (male or female), a search of the site’s “help” page at press time for the words “ gay ,” “ same-sex ,” “ lesbian ,” or “ bisexual ” all returned no results. 

Although some sects of Christianity  maintain strong anti-LGBT doctrine , many Christian faith communities welcome LGBT people, and there’s  no shortage of high-profile Christians  who are also LGBT.

Grammy-nominated singer-songwriter  Mary Lambert has made no secret  of her religious upbringing, and her emotional work often explores her journey back to her faith as an out lesbian. Similarly,  Matthew Vines  is making waves in the evangelical Christian community with “ The Reformation Project, ” a campaign that bills itself as “a Bible-based, Gospel-centered approach to LGBT inclusion.” Vines, who is himself a gay Christian, rose to prominence in 2012 when a video of him outlining a scriptural defense of monogamous, Christ-centered same-sex relationships titled “The Gay Debate: The Bible and Homosexuality” went viral. Last year,  he published   God and the Gay Christian: The Biblical Case in Support of Same-Sex Relationships.

And while  anti-LGBT politicians  and pundits often use  so-called religious freedom  as a  sword to strike down  LGBT-inclusive policies ,  Georgia’s Republican Gov. Nathan Deal earlier this year vetoed  a sweeping “religious freedom” bill that  opponents said  would act as a “license to discriminate” against LGBT people,  saying it did not reflect his Christian values . 

http://www.advocate.com/religion/2016/7/02/christianmingle-forced-admit-there-are-gay-christians-looking-love




Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     10 years ago

''I don't think Jesus had many blind dates.''

LOL, probably not.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    10 years ago

He had a few but he healed them.

LOL

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    10 years ago

From the article:

The judge also ordered Spark to pay $9,000 to each of the two plaintiffs who brought the suit, in addition to covering the full $450,000 in attorneys fees incurred by the gay men.

Ouch!!!  Meanwhile the attorney who gets the plaintiff who was injured in the car accident by a reckless driver $100,000 and the attorney gets $33,000 of that.

I bet the judge gets something in this case, like under the bench.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell    10 years ago

If one went by the Newstalker response, they might think that what the Bible says about gays and transgender was not only the most important issue in the world, but practically the only issue in the world.

What has happened to this site?

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

Issue #2

Let's all talk about how bad Muslims are.

NT in a nutshell.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

Why don't you stay on topic? Next off topic comment will be deleted.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna  replied to  Perrie Halpern R.A.   10 years ago

link   07/04/16 12:30:47PM  @Perrie-Halpern :

Why don't you stay on topic? Next off topic comment will be deleted.

Good idea!

But I wonder-- what do you think was John's purpose in saying that?

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    10 years ago

The question has arisen as to why the abomination of homosexuality should stand above 613 other sins and why pick and choose among them.

Nobody has brought up Sodom and Gomorrah so I will. In the biblical story, these two cities practiced all manor of immorality but chief among them was homosexuality. As the story goes, two angels came to visit Lot in his home. Apparently, they were so good-looking and the men townsmen so perverted that all the men of the town descended on Lot's home demanding that he bring the angels out so they could be gang-raped. Lot offered his virgin daughters instead but the townsmen demanded the angels. (The daughters must have been able to shatter a mirror just by looking at it if he couldn't give them away). Anyway, the angels escaped and God destroyed both cities because they were beyond redemption. That story was known to Jesus and everyone else as an example of the special place that this particular abomination holds in God's eyes. The homosexual practice of sodomy is named for Sodom, the city God destroyed. If God singled out this particular abomination as a primary reason for destroying two cities, then Christians can single it out as a particularly loathsome practice. 

Now I'm aware that some will say the cities were destroyed for inhospitablity to strangers (and gang rape is pretty inhospitable) or that it's really about immorality in general not just homosexuality but it's been pretty clear to everyone for millenia that this story is about obliterating the practice of homosexuality.

 
 
 
PJ
Masters Silent
link   PJ  replied to  1ofmany   10 years ago

Well......where to begin.  I'm not sure I understand why you would automatically assume it was the fault of the angels for being attractive and the fault of the daughter for being what you assumed was ugly and therefore their fault in creating this mess because they weren't pretty enough to be selected for rape.  

Sometimes less explanation is best.

Maybe this God of yours was upset with both the rapists for wanting to commit rape and the father for offering up his daughters instead of protecting them.  Maybe it had nothing to do with the pretty angels.....  just another perspective to a twisted story of values and morals.

I don't have to agree with your position but I understand that it is part of the fabric of your character and who you are and it's not up to me to change your mind but to accept you for you.  

Happy 4th 

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany  replied to  PJ   10 years ago

PJ -- I didn't write the Bible or blame anybody. All I did was recite the story (except the part about ugly daughters) and the story makes an issue of homosexuality. But you guys are free to ignore the Bible or pretend it condones something God rebukes or do whatever your hearts desire -- personal choice.

Enjoy the 4th

 
 
 
PJ
Masters Silent
link   PJ  replied to  1ofmany   10 years ago

I'm not ignoring the bible and I don't dispute what is written in the bible and to be honest I don't dispute what you think the messages are.  I'm simply saying that the bible is nothing more than a book of stories put together for the purpose of scaring people to act and behave a certain way.  

To me, the bible is a "greatest hits" book and nothing more.  It's like the very first motivational reference guide.  Like a shake n bake eight ball fortune teller.  The answers are all geared towards domination and control.....don't think outside of the box or for yourself otherwise you're going to hell.   Don't question what we tell you to do, just do it or else......  The bible like all religion takes away individual thought and choice.  I get that some people can't think for themselves.  They must follow a script or otherwise they are lost.  Just don't expect those of us who have embraced "free will" and feel confident enough to know exactly what is right and what is wrong to go along with it.  Rape is wrong for any reason.  If a group of people come to my house and demand that I hand over someone because they're pretty and the mob wants to rape them I'm not going to appease them by trying a bait and switch and offer my children.  I'm going to go get my gun and exercise my 2nd amendment right.   

What you and others are suggesting is that we ignore what is right and wrong because the bible told us so.  Isn't that the same thing as "the devil made me do it"?  just saying......  

I'm glad it works for you though. 

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany  replied to  PJ   10 years ago

What you and others are suggesting is that we ignore what is right and wrong because the bible told us so.  Isn't that the same thing as "the devil made me do it"?  just saying......  

I'm glad it works for you though. 

I'm not suggesting that you do anything at all. I was just commenting on what the Bible says. You should always do what you think is right but recognize that what's right to you may be wrong to me. 

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah  replied to  1ofmany   10 years ago

The bible is not some divinely inspired infallible wisdom, it is just some stuff written by men.  It's time to stop pretending that it is anything more than that.  The story of Jesus and the prostitute has been proven to not even be part of the original canon of scripture, but you all keep pretending it is  by endlessly referencing it as a prime example of "Jesus's teachings". There is no bottom to the blind stupidity of Christianity.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    10 years ago

Did Spark Networks or many of the other companies get a chance to rectify the way they had their website set up?

Yes, a "Contact" option on their website and an email from the plaintiff I assume the courts verified were sent.  We don't know, other than the plaintiff' saying he did these things and we can only assume there is verification he actually did.

We don't hear the whole story, only what the media presents to us.  We have to research and most of the time are unable to actually find anything more than what is presented to us.

These attorney's and people are like ambulance chasers.  They go in restaurants and other businesses, take photos for any discrepancy they can find.  Do they go to the business to rectify the problem before going to the ambulance chasers?  One wonders, but in too many cases they don't.  The offenders who may not even know they are offenders receive notice they have a lawsuit against them when the plaintiff has only spoken to an employee of the business.  What happens then?  They are served with a lawsuit.

Spark Networks can handle the cost of the settlement in this lawsuit, but many businesses can not while these ambulance chasers and their attorneys are nothing more than extortionist in quite a few cases.

So the plaintiff Aaron Werner found out Christianmingle.com didn't offer a choice for same sex contacts, he contacted them through their "Contact" option.  He didn't receive a response, so he sent them an email and received no response.  I would say they need to take either of these options more seriously, but you would think he would have needed to send them a certified letter or something that could actually be counted on to get to the proper person within the company to guarantee a response or show a determination to actually deal with the problem.

I say most of these types of lawsuits are more about money than actually helping people.  When plaintiffs receive 3.8% of the $468,000 giving each of the two plaintiff less than 2% each in what could have been dealt with at a considerable lower price tag, it's obvious in such a case as this.

Links:

Spark complaint summary

Spark settlement summary

Case Timeline

Suits by disable raise questions on litigation Law

A Senate bill was supposed to reduce inappropriate claims under the Americans With Disabilities Act, but some small businesses faced with litigation say reforms are needed.

It didn't take long to figure out why a man in a wheelchair had been snapping photographs of the aisles, counters, shelves and bathrooms inside eateries and watering holes in a fashionable eastern Long Beach enclave.

On June 30, Powell's Sweet Shoppe; Open Sesame, a Lebanese restaurant; and Panama Joe's Grill & Cantina were served with lawsuits on behalf of Eric Moran alleging that they were in violation of the Americans With Disabilities Act. The violations, each of which could cost a minimum $4,000 in damages, ranged from lacking a restroom grab bar to a restaurant chair out in an aisle.

About a week later, each received an identical letter from Moran's Los Angeles attorneys, Miguel Custodio Jr. and Vineet Dubey, seeking an out-of-court settlement of $9,000. "We have photographic evidence of these violations," the letter said. "We will prevail if this case goes to trial."

Moran has filed at least 27 such lawsuits since June. Hundreds more have been filed by a relatively small number of attorneys throughout California.

You'll notice Miguel Custodio Jr. and Vineet Dubey are the same attorneys in the Spark Networks vs Aaron Werner.  Wonder how many more of the 27 lawsuits by Moran were handled by this law firm?

It's not a surprise the firm refuses to discuss individual cases.  I can understand for privacy reasons they wouldn't want to discuss intimate details, but I bet they have many people like Warner and Moran seeking their services and immediate lawsuits are the first and only option they offer when they make that kind of money for what appears to me to be an open and close case in spite of Judge Jane L. Johnson saying this was a complex case.  With a law on the books which appears to clearly lean toward the plaintiff, I can't understand how it is so complex. Maybe she should retire like she said she was going to do even though she would hold the bench until 2021 if she didn't.

While some will applaud law firms like this and in a lot of cases it is deserved  Hitting them in the pocketbook will make them think twice, but an email, contact option and $468,000 later. 

 
 

Who is online