╌>

Dershowitz - Did FBI director Comey exceed his authority?

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  looser-too  •  10 years ago  •  32 comments

Dershowitz - Did FBI director Comey exceed his authority?

Did FBI director Comey exceed his authority?





 




FBI Director James Comey's statement recommending against prosecuting Hillary Clinton was unusual in several respects. First, it is not generally regarded as the job of the FBI to make judgment calls about whether or not to prosecute. Those judgment calls are supposed to be made by prosecutors. The job of the FBI is to investigate the facts and lay them out as objectively and completely as possible so that prosecutors can exercise their discretion and judgment.

Although technically the attorney general in this case could exercise independent judgment, she is unlikely to do so, having already said she would defer to the FBI's recommendation. So in this instance the FBI found the facts, applied the law and exercised prosecutorial discretion. A strange role for an investigative agency!

Second, it is unusual for an FBI director to express opinions such as the kind that Comey made in his statement. He said that Clinton had been "extremely careless" in her handling of sensitive material. That is not a legal concept, but to lay people it could sound very much like "gross negligence," which is one of the statutory criteria for bringing a prosecution.

Normally when a prosecutor declines prosecution, all that is said is that there will be no indictment. It is rare, though not unprecedented, for a prosecutor to then go on to excoriate the object of the investigation. The question should be asked: Is that a proper role for the director of the FBI?

Third, Comey used an unusual verbal formulation in discussing classified information. This is what he said:

"Only a small number of the emails containing classified information bore markings indicating the presence of classified information."

He did not explain what he meant by the words "bore markings." Does this mean that they were stamped "classified"? Or does it mean that there were indications within the text of the emails that would show that it was in fact classified? The confusion was exacerbated by Comey's next sentence in which he said the following:

"But even if information is not marked 'classified' in an email, participants who know or should know that the subject is classified are obligated to protect it."

Comey's use of the words "marked classified" seems to suggest that there is a distinction between emails that were marked "classified" and emails that "bore markings indicating the presence of classified information."

This use of different verbal formulations suggests that none of the emails were actually marked "classified." I may be wrong in that surmise, but it is certainly suggested by how Comey used these different formulations.

Fourth, Comey went out of his way to say that even if there is no basis for criminal prosecution, there might be other sanctions that could be applied to all those who participated in email exchanges that contained classified material.

This statement suggests that several of Clinton’s most important aides may eventually be denied security clearance, which would prevent them from serving in sensitive positions in the government. The decision whether to grant or deny security clearance should be made at the relevant time, by the relevant authorities, not by the FBI in anticipation of future possibilities.

Putting aside these unusual aspects of the Comey statement, he was certainly correct in his ultimate recommendation. The evidence in this case, as he described it, would not have justified a criminal prosecution.

There is simply no precedent for indicting a former secretary of State for carelessness, even extreme carelessness. This is especially true when the former secretary is about to become her party's nominee for president. Directors of the FBI should not be influencing the outcome of presidential elections unless there is a clear and unequivocal violation of the law.

In general, the principal of "lenity" — which requires doubts to be resolved in close cases against prosecution — applies even more strictly when the decision to indict would effectively deny the public the right to exercise its judgment about who should be the president.

So the bottom line is that Clinton will not be indicted, but the director of the FBI has issued a statement that may have a considerable impact on the upcoming election. This raises fundamental structural questions about the role of the FBI in investigating political figures.

Comey is an honorable man, an excellent lawyer and an experienced prosecutor. We must never forget that the building in which Comey works bears the name of one of his predecessors, J. Edgar Hoover. We must all ask ourselves the question whether we would trust another Hoover to make the kinds of decisions that Comey has made in this case.

If the answer to that question is "no," then we must consider structural changes that would prevent a future J. Edgar Hoover from exercising the kind of power exercised by James Comey in this case.

Dershowitz is professor emeritus at Harvard University and author of "Taking the Stand: My Life in the Law."

http://thehill.com/blogs/pundits-blog/presidential-campaign/286614-did-fbi-director-comey-exceed-his-authority#.V3z3BaWwA7h.twitter

 





Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    10 years ago

Like it or not, Alan Dershowitz is one of the most well known legal experts in America.

Today we are hearing a lot of whiny complaint from the right. But what justifiable complaint may Democrats and Clinton supporters have.

One that Dershowitz hints at -  how many emails were marked "classified"?   The conservatives are making a big deal today out of the fact that Comey said that a "small number" were marked classified, supposedly proving Clinton lied when she said she never sent or received emails "marked classified".  But listening to Dershowitz , he seems to have concluded that Comey was very hazy about this. And I have seen somethings on twitter that suggest that none of the emails were marked classified

 

NYTimes today: Two emails received by Clinton were *marked* classified at time.

 

and 27 others follow

State Dept spox Kirby just now says two emails that Comey said were 'marked classified' were wrongly marked, and were not classified.

 

Maybe one of the Democratic congressmen at the hearing tomorrow will ask Comey what the number of emails "marked classified" really is.  If it is zero, that IS a big deal.

 

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

"Comey had said in his statement : “Only a very small number of the e-mails containing classified information bore markings indicating the presence of classified information.” The New York Times nailed down that “very small number” to two:

While [Comey] did not identify any, he was evidently referring to two emails that one of Mrs. Clinton’s close aides, Monica R. Hanley, sent to prepare her for telephone calls with foreign leaders, according to a State Department official familiar with the matter, who spoke on condition of anonymity to discuss classified information. One email, dated Aug. 2, 2012, noted that Kofi Annan, the former secretary general of the United Nations, was stepping down as special envoy trying to mediate the war in Syria. A second one, sent in April 2012, discussed Mrs. Clinton’s call to the newly inaugurated president of Malawi.

So it appears that the only two emails that were “ marked” classified (or to be more precise “bore markings indicating the presence of classified information”) in Hillary’s tens of thousands of emails were erroneously marked as such."

 

 

If it is true that only two of the emails were "marked" classified, and now even that is in dispute, one cannot say that Hillary Clinton lied when she said she never sent or received anything marked classified.

Yet, the conservative media is running wild saying just that.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

It's true that committing only two murders, for example, is less evil than committing a dozen murders. It's stil evil though. Nice spin.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell  replied to  Cerenkov   10 years ago

I would like to see the content of these "Top Secret" emails. Reports during the investigation were that they were mostly already published information about drone strikes. This is a lot of bullshit.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

Your opinion about whether information should be classified is irrelevant. That is stressed multiple times during classified matter control training.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    10 years ago

I felt that Mr. Comey was making a political statement, and that's not his job.  His statement was unprofessional, at best, and I believe, in time, he will be censured for it.  It make take a while for the dust to settle, but it is not his job to make sweeping judgements-- but to investigate and represent the facts.  Period.

But, of course, that's just my opinion.  That, and $5 will get you a cup of coffee, maybe.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell  replied to  Dowser   10 years ago

It is a well thought and good opinion Dowser.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

Thanks.  I thought that some of his remarks were inappropriate, and more suited to an editorial.  He needed to stick to the facts of the investigation-- not editorialize.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov  replied to  Dowser   10 years ago

And any action will be conveniently deferred until after the "election".

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser  replied to  Cerenkov   10 years ago

What kind of action are you speaking of?  Action against Ms. Clinton, or action against Mr. Comey?  Whichever, you're probably right!

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient  replied to  Dowser   10 years ago

"That, and $5 will get you a cup of coffee, maybe."

Hah! I miss the days when the expression and the quoted price was: "That and a dime will get you a cup of coffee."

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser  replied to  Buzz of the Orient   10 years ago

I was going to say that, but realized that nowhere can we get a cup of coffee for $.10...  Or even $.25...  Sad times!

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    10 years ago

"Comey's use of the words "marked classified" seems to suggest that there is a distinction between emails that were marked "classified" and emails that "bore markings indicating the presence of classified information.""

No, there is no difference. This is the language used for marking classified material. 

"This use of different verbal formulations suggests that none of the emails were actually marked "classified." I may be wrong in that surmise, but it is certainly suggested by how Comey used these different formulations."

You are wrong. He clearly indicated that some of the emails were marked. 

It seems clear that the author has little or no experience with controlling classified matter. His conclusions are thus greatly suspect.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    10 years ago

Dershowitz may be a well respected attorney but his comments add nothing useful to the conversation. Comey did not exceed his authority at all. The FBI conducts an investigation and then makes a recommendation to the prosecutor just like police in state investigations make recommendations to District Attorneys (DAs). The Prosecutors decide whether to prosecute based on whether they think they can get a conviction. The police or FBI recommendation is usually part of an internal process. In this case, however, the Attorney General Lynch decided to publically state that she would rely on the recommendation of the FBI. So it's Lynch that's acting unusually. Basically, Lynch (a Democrat) dumped the responsibility for this matter entirely on Comey (a Republican).

Comey has a weak high profile case and, if he brings charges that can't hold up in court, he runs a huge risk of literally changing the course of history and damaging his reputation. He wisely chose to make his recommendation public in keeping with Lynch's public statement that she would rely on Comey's recommendation. He said he did not recommend charges and outlined why. He didn't go into detail so there are some unanswered questions. However, the actual decision to prosecute rests on the Attorney General so maybe she should be answering the legal questions rather than Comey since he's not the prosecutor.

Comey doesn't have to explain whether emails were properly marked classified because that's up to the marking agency. If it was marked classified, improperly or not, then Hillary shouldn't have been sending it over an unsecured system. In any event, he has already explained that the small amount of information marked classified relative to the total number of emails was a factor in deciding not to recommend prosecution. Of course, there's the matter of the 30,000 emails that Hillary deleted as personal. We only have the word of a liar that those emails did not contain classified information.

As for the rest of what Comey said, it was brilliant. He briefly stated why he thought there was insufficient evidence to make a criminal case stick and then publically reported some of what he uncovered in the investigation so that both sides can make of it what they will in the court of public opinion. He split the baby. He answered no questions for reporters and has reserved any answers for Congress where no one can question his propriety in providing answers in response to a Congressional inquiry. Republicans are unlikely to go after him because he can easily defend his position. Running all state department correspondence through a private email account and private server is so stupid and reckless that Democrats would be ill-advised to press Comey in public about how much at risk Hillary placed national security -- trying to keep her correspondence secret from the government with no regard as to how accessible the correspondence would be to hackers. I look forward to the Congressional hearing because, if Republicans have any sense, they'll use this as an opportunity to get as much of Hillary's unbelievable stupidity on record as possible.

 

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell  replied to  1ofmany   10 years ago

I'd like it to come out just what these 110 classified emails were about. Something tells me they are not going to be considered earthshaking secrets.

We also have to remember something no one is talking about. All of the people Clinton sent these emails to or received them from had clearance to view the material. She wasn't selling state secrets.

I don't think there is any chance that Clinton would be convicted, simply because there was so much controversy as to whether she should have been indicted in the first place.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

I'd like it to come out just what these 110 classified emails were about. Something tells me they are not going to be considered earthshaking secrets.

We also have to remember something no one is talking about. All of the people Clinton sent these emails to or received them from had clearance to view the material. She wasn't selling state secrets.

The whole point of classified information is to avoid making it public. And the fact that the recipient of these "known" emails had a clearance does not stop her unsecured system from being hacked, especially while traveling abroad. She was more concerned with keeping things secret from her own government than avoiding hacking by foreign governments. She is an idiot and should not be trusted with sensitive information even in a low level position, let alone as president.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell  replied to  1ofmany   10 years ago

Clearly it was a bad idea, at the least, to do what she did. But it was not a secret to the people she worked with, and there doesnt seem to have been any intention to conceal the existence of her private e-mail. This is an administrative matter, as Comey basically said. And of course people are free to criticize her on a political basis.

This is not some big spy scandal, which is what the haters want it to be. I don't think there is any chance this issue will decide the election. Trump is a clown of the highest order and his phenomenal lack of qualifications to be president will "trump" this issue.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

Clearly it was a bad idea, at the least, to do what she did. But it was not a secret to the people she worked with, and there doesnt seem to have been any intention to conceal the existence of her private e-mail. This is an administrative matter, as Comey basically said. And of course people are free to criticize her on a political basis.

According to the state department OIG report, there is no evidence of Hillary ever making anyone aware of her private email account or server and certainly she did not make anyone aware that she was using her own system exclusively. State department officials said that, if she had requested to use such a system, they would have disapproved it. Her shenanigan was not a crime but it would get anybody else fired. Hillary can say I don't work there anymore so what ya gonna do about it . . . (sticks tongue out) and cackles.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    10 years ago

I thought this was a defense of Hillary Clinton given how you hyped it. Instead, its a political argument about the role of the FBI and is filled with uninformed guesses. It's just a simple political piece, based on his guesses and doesn't even bother with any legal argument.  

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell  replied to  Sean Treacy   10 years ago

Sean, I have posted a half dozen legal arguments against indictment here, as you know. Dershowitz is telling the simple truth. It is too late to indict the presidential candidate. The same thing would be the case if it was a Republican.

 
 

Who is online