Hillary Clinton Isn’t Lying, The Fact-Checkers Are
http://thedailybanter.com/2016/08/hillary-clinton-isnt-lying-the-fact-checkers-are/
Hillary Clinton Isn’t Lying, The Fact-Checkers Are
At a press conference following her speech at the NABJ convention today, Hillary Clinton "clarified" a remark that the media insists was a horrible gaffe, that FBI Director James Comey said she told the truth about her emails:
As Donald Trump‘s terrible week winds to a close, the mainstream media has picked up a counter-narrative that says Trump did Hillary Clinton a yuge favor by overshadowing the “gaffe” she committed last weekend when she told Fox News’ Chris Wallace that FBI DirectorJames Comey backed up her version of the “Emailgate” story. Armed with a quartet of fictional marionette heads , Republicans fashioned the narrative into a talking point that even pro-Hillary media yappers didn’t bother to refute. The “fact-checkers” have spoken.
Except they’re wrong, every one of them, and they’re all, to some degree, lying in order to support their wrong conclusion. Mostly, they are committing a lie of omission, and so, for our more impatient readers, I will cut to the chase, on the condition that anyone who wants to argue the point with me on Twitter must read the whole thing first. The thing they are all leaving out of their various and sundry fact-checking exercises is this key exchange from FBI Director James Comey’s testimony before Congress:
“That would be a reasonable inference.”
All of the “Big Three” fact-checkers acknowledged the substance of the exchange to some degree, but either downplayed or outright lid about it. Politifact said Comey called the markings “insufficient,” when what he actually did was reply “no” when asked if any of the emails were “properly marked” as classified.
FactCheckDotOrg said Comey told that hearing that those emails “could have been missed by Clinton” when what he actually said was that a person who’s an “expert at what’s classified and what’s not classified” would reasonably infer “that those three documents were not classified.”
The Washington Post ‘s fact-checker, the oft-quoted Glenn Kessler, made zero mention of the exchange, instead relying on this earlier exchange that Comey himself later contradicted:
The remark about Hillary Clinton’s lack of “sophistication” about classification got a lot of play in the media, but the fact is that he said just a few minutes later that an “expert at what’s classified and what’s not classified” would reasonably conclude the same thing that Hillary concluded.
So, the fact is that there were exactly zero emails sent or received by Hillary Clinton that were properly marked as classified. This is not some technicality, they were supposed to have big block letters at the top of every page, and they did not.
Now, it is fair for Hillary Clinton’s critics and opponents to point out that this explanation relies heavily on the question of what the definition of “classified” is, but for purposes of a “fact check,” matters of opinion are not supposed to enter into the equation. In order to evaluate Hillary’s truthfulness in a fair manner, it is necessary to evaluate what she said, what she meant when she said it, and what she believed when she said it. There’s a very good reason Comey wouldn’t say Hillary “lied” to the public, and told Congress that “I really don’t want to get in the business of trying to parse and judge her public statements,” because you have to ignore important context in order to conclude that this exchange proves that Hillary “lied”:
Gowdy: “Secretary Clinton said there was nothing marked classified on her emails either sent or received. Was that true?”
Comey: “That’s not true.”
Gowdy: “Secretary Clinton said, ‘I did not email any classified material to anyone on my email. There is no classified material.’ Was that true?”
Comey: “There was classified material emailed.”
That clip was mentioned in all three “Fact Checks,” but all three omitted the “portion markings” part of the exchange from their transcripts. Comey was referring to the classification of the subject matter, not the documents themselves, and mentioning that inconvenient fact would mean having to explain that when Hillary Clinton said she had never sent or received any material marked classified, she had every reason to believe she was telling the truth, because she was. None of them were properly marked.
All the rest of it, while legitimate to discuss as a philosophical matter, is irrelevant to a fact-checking exercise, because there are vast differences of opinion about the material that wasn’t marked classified, but which people alternately assert should and should not have been. The only factually verifiable claim at issue is whether any of it was marked , and none of it was.
On Friday afternoon, Hillary addressed the “controversy,” and given the week’s political currents, was wise not to make a federal case over it. Here's her full answer, much of which references the facts I've laid out here:
Tags
Who is online
164 visitors

Hillary should probably just give up and throw herself on the mercy of whatever god is in charge of this stuff. She's never going to win with the media, who are the gatekeepers of how this issue is framed to the public.
I have watched numerous pundits discuss this, even in the past few days, and most of them don't know what the hell they are talking about.
The FACT is that out of 30,000 e-mails examined by the FBI , NONE of them were marked "classified". NONE.
Yet, because the FBI head rather imprecisely answered a question from one of the Republican congressmen, the media keeps repeating the mistake of saying that Clinton sent or received emails "marked classified" . She did not, and Comey admitted that later in the hearing.
They were marked classified. Sorry, but that is not in dispute except among the uneducated.
How fucking dumb do you have to be to be secretary of state and not realize that the informationin in emails should be classified? It's not like they were swapping recipes or sharing pinterest pages. Really, if you don't understand that the enails may contain sensitive information whether or not they are marked classified, then you just don't understand your job description. And i am sick to death of liberals spinning this to make her look like she did nothimg wrong.
Dumb or evil? Which one is she? I assume both given the evidence of her gross negligence.
This is the work product of an author who is either being paid to lie or has lost all touch with reality. Any person whose paid the least bit of attention to what Comey said knows she is continuing to lie.
This is a great example of how Clinton spins her ignorant defenders. She claims Comey said she was "truthful." That is in fact true as far as anyone knows, in regards to what she told the FBI during their sit down interview. So she takes Comey's statement about her private interview with the FBI and turns that into "Comey agrees that everything I said to the PUBLIC was true."
That's an obvious falsehood, as anyone whose looked at Comey's statement and testimony understand. In fact, Comey confirmed that Clinton lied multiple times and that all of her public talking points from the last year were complete bullshit. His testimony is one long debunking of the numerous lies she told about all aspects of this.
It's a simple misdirection, in which she uses Comey's statement about her PRIVATE interview to describe his suppose opinion about her PUBLIC statements. It the sort of sleazeball tactic an unethical used car salesman might use in which he swaps reviews from different makes of cars to mislead a buyer. She's banking on her followers ignorance and their refusal to actually look into what Comey said. Obviously, it works for a sizable portion of population.
The other tactic is too simply ignore the blizzard of lies she told and focus on one debatable point to exonerate her. Notice how when critics talk about she lied, John is reduced to arguing the legally irrelevant point about whether they were "marked classified" or had "classified markings". It doesn't matter legally and Comey said any reasonable person would have understood they were handling classified information.
So John wants to simply ignore all of the many, many lies Comey exposed and focus only on irrelevant distinction between marked classified and classified markings and then claim that means she didn't lie. Which again, is total bullshit to anyone who knows paid any attention to the Comey's statement.
As the Washington Post demonstrates, she's even lying about what Comey said. She's lied about everything from day one, and the markings distincton is only one subset of one of her many proven lies.
Very well said. The shills lying to defend her are getting more desperate. Or more ignorant.
They were marked classified. Sorry, but that is not in dispute except among the uneducated.
This is why it matters whether or not they were marked classified. We have ignorant comments like the above on the loose. Comey was very unfair to Clinton by telling the people that there were emails marked classified in the 30,000. It was unfair to use THREE as representative of 30,000, and it was unfair because even the THREE were not marked "classified". This is not even in dispute any more, and yet the tool Cerenkov exposes the damage to the truth that can be caused by unbridled ignorance.
There were 110 emails that Comey infers were "born classified", according to other agencies than the state dept. Obviously the state dept officials that dealt with Clinton did not consider them classified AT THE TIME. It is a mitigating factor. THAT is why the markings matter.
They were marked, you idiot. Portion marking counts. She's a liar and a criminal. And you are her mouthpiece.
3 out of 30,000 had a "c" in the margin.
THREE OUT OF THIRTY THOUSAND
and in the hearing it was determined that they were improperly marked. Comey acknowledged that they were not sufficiently marked.
Einstein, why were none of the 30,000 marked classified?
As for deleted emails, Comey said the FBI recovered thousands of them. Guess what? NONE of them were marked classified either.
I would ask you to stop vomiting ignorance on this forum but I know that is a hopeless cause.
So you finally admit that some of the emails were marked? That's a big breakthrough for a denier like yourself. Now, try to confront the issue that information is born classified. You can do it!
She's a liar, and the FBI confirmed it.
You are completely incompetent.
And you resort to ad hominem attacks again... You've got nothing.
I win, Francis.
Here ya go John - 23,035 messages, during HER FIRST YEAR AS DOS, were marked Classified.
https://wikileaks.org/plusd/?qproject[]=cg&q=&qfdestination=Secretary+of+State&qfoclass=CONFIDENTIAL&qtfrom=2009-01-10&qsort=tdesc#result
Kinda a bit over 3, eh?
Lord only knows what it is you think you are trying to prove.
Everyone knows the Secretary Of State gets classified communications. What you are showing are neither e-mails nor came in through her private server.
John, I thought you had already reached the pinnacle of delusion, but I was wrong. At this point, I don't know how much longer you can have a way back to reality without being lost forever.
One thing you may consider is none of them were marked "Classified" anyway. That's why she used that word. That way she could deceive people and at the same time not lie. They were different levels of "Secret".
Yuri Bezmenov said they would become so brainwashed, you could carry them to the Gulag and they would deny they ever existed.
By the way I listened to Hillary being questioned by Congress, Comey's decision to not charge her, Comey being questioned by Congress and Hillary's interview with Chris Matthews.
One thing you may consider is none of them were marked "Classified" anyway. That's why she used that word. That way she could deceive people and at the same time not lie. They were different levels of "Secret".
Six , FBI Director Comey acknowledged that none of them were marked classified.
Hillary Clinton received most of these emails from other people , who did not believe them to be "classified" either.