It is not known for certain what, if any, procedures were undergone by Semenya, who won a silver medal at the 2012 London Olympics. Nor could it be verified, as reported in 2009 in The Daily Telegraph of Australia, that Semenya had internal testes and three times the testosterone level of a typical woman.
At this point, it does not matter. Last year, the Court of Arbitration for Sport, the Swiss-based high court for international sport, suspended track and field’s testosterone policy for two years.
Slide Show
The court said it had been “unable to conclude that hyperandrogenic female athletes may benefit from such a significant performance advantage that it is necessary to exclude them from competing in the female category.”
Did elevated testosterone provide women with a 1 percent competitive advantage? Three percent? More? Available science could not say, the court ruled. It gave the I.A.A.F. two years to try to discern that advantage. The ruling was based on the case of Dutee Chand , a sprinter from India.
The court ruling was the correct one.
As the arbitration panel noted, science has not conclusively shown that elevated testosterone provides women with more of a significant competitive edge than factors like nutrition, access to coaching and training facilities, and other genetic and biological variations.
All Olympians have some exceptional traits. That is why they are elite athletes. A level playing field for everyone remains elusive, perhaps unattainable.
Kenyan and Ethiopian marathoners live and train at altitude , naturally enhancing their oxygen-carrying capacity. And they tend to have long, thin legs that make running more energy efficient. Kevin Durant and Brittney Griner are great basketball players in part because they are nearly 7 feet tall.
Eero Mantyranta, a Finnish cross-country skier who won seven Olympic medals in the 1960s, including three golds, was found to have a genetic mutation that increased his hemoglobin level to about 50 percent higher than the average man’s.
There is “no fundamental difference” between a congenital disorder that produces high testosterone levels and a genetic mutation that produces elevated hemoglobin levels, according to a recent commentary, “The Olympic Games and Athletic Sex Assignment,” in The Journal of the American Medical Association.
Yet elevated levels of naturally occurring hemoglobin do not disqualify athletes. In any case, the Journal commentary said, “all of these biological differences are minuscule compared with the suspected use of performance-enhancing substances.”
If elevated testosterone provided an overriding competitive advantage, said Karkazis, the Stanford bioethicist, why did Chand, the Indian sprinter, not advance beyond the first round of the Olympic 100 meters?
If you believe this is jet fuel, then what’s going on?” said Karkazis, who testified on Chand’s behalf before the arbitration court.
The I.A.A.F. does not investigate further if atypically high levels of testosterone in men are determined to occur naturally, an editorial in Scientific American recently noted. It added, “Fairness and science both dictate that women should be treated exactly the same.”
There are reasonable people on both sides of the testosterone debate. And there is deep emotion, too. It is an extremely complex issue, which includes the Olympic participation of transgender athletes.
Experts do not suggest that Semenya has taken banned substances. No one serious is calling her a man. No prominent voices suggest that separate categories should not exist for women’s and men’s sports.
But many remain concerned that women’s sports will be threatened if some athletes are allowed to compete with a testosterone advantage, even if athletes are reluctant to address the testosterone issue during the Olympics.
Semenya easily advanced out of the semifinals on Thursday night; the final is Saturday. Ajee Wilson of the United States, who finished second to Semenya in their opening heat, said, “It is something that should be revisited.” But Wilson also said: “At this point, what I think doesn’t really matter. We’re all on the track. Whoever’s on there is racing.”
Dr. Eric Vilain, a medical geneticist from U.C.L.A., told my colleague Juliet Macur last year that “if we push this argument, anyone declaring a female gender can compete as a woman.”
He added, “We’re moving toward one big competition, and the very predictable result of that competition is that there will be no women winners.”
Paula Radcliffe of England, the retired world-record holder in the women’s marathon, told BBC R adio last month that it was “no longer sport” when a victory was so seemingly assured as Semenya’s appeared in Rio.
Photo
Semenya celebrated after the women’s 800 meters final at the 2009 world track and field championships. She won by more than two seconds. Credit Olivier Morin/Agence France-Presse — Getty Images Radcliffe also suggested that some unnamed countries might actively recruit hyperandrogenic athletes to win more races.
But this feared “gender apocalypse,” as Karkazis calls it, seems unlikely. We are talking about a very small number of women. And male impostors exist in myth more than reality. It appears that Semenya’s case is being used to make wider assumptions based more on supposition than evidence.
The notion that women’s sports need to be protected is paternalistic, Karkazis said, calling it “the mantle under which all kinds of discriminatory and sexist ideas enter.”
In a sport once dominated by white Europeans, said Madeleine Pape of Australia, who competed against Semenya in the 2009 world championships, women who have fought so hard for the right to compete and for sustainable financial support can feel threatened by the rising success of a faster competitor. Especially, Pape said, if that athlete is non-gender-conforming and is married to another woman, as Semenya is.
In truth, Radcliffe is more of an outlier than Semenya. Radcliffe’s marathon record of 2 hours 15 minutes 25 seconds is about 10 percent slower than the fastest men’s time of 2:02:57. Meanwhile, Semenya’s best performance at 800 meters of 1 minute 55.33 seconds, which is not the world record, is about 12 percent slower than the men’s record of 1:40.91.
Radcliffe and gold medal athletes in Rio, like the American gymnast Simone Biles and the swimmer Katie Ledecky, have been as dominant as Semenya or more dominant, but their gender has not been openly questioned, Pape said.
“When we look at it objectively, Caster Semenya is no more exceptional than they are,” Pape, who is a doctoral student in sociology at the University of Wisconsin, said in an email. “So why do we celebrate them while persecuting Semenya?”
The Journal of the American Medical Association said it was appropriate for athletes who were born with a disorder of sex development and were raised as female to be allowed to compete as women.
That sounds like the right call. Let athletes compete as who they are.
“God made me the way I am, and I accept myself,” Semenya told You, a South African magazine, in 2009. “I am who I am, and I’m proud of myself.”
It would seem unfair to tell her, Sorry, you can’t run in the Olympics because of the way you were born.
"Did elevated testosterone provide women with a 1 percent competitive advantage? Three percent? More? Available science could not say, the court ruled.
...In truth, Radcliffe (marathoner Paula Radcliffe) is more of an outlier than Semenya. Radcliffe’s marathon record of 2 hours 15 minutes 25 seconds is about 10 percent slower than the fastest men’s time of 2:02:57. Meanwhile, Semenya’s best performance at 800 meters of 1 minute 55.33 seconds, which is not the world record, is about 12 percent slower than the men’s record of 1:40.91.
Radcliffe and gold medal athletes in Rio, like the American gymnast Simone Biles and the swimmer Katie Ledecky, have been as dominant as Semenya or more dominant, but their gender has not been openly questioned, Pape said.
“When we look at it objectively, Caster Semenya is no more exceptional than they are,” Pape, who is a doctoral student in sociology at the University of Wisconsin, said in an email. “So why do we celebrate them while persecuting Semenya?”"
I think the conservatives complaints about this issue are very much in line with their complaints about "political correctness" . To them Semenya is the beneficiary of p.c.
I think it is prejudice to worry about Semenya being a man or a woman. I think when they have a race, anyone man or woman should be able to run in that race, then everyone will be given equal opportunity to see who the fastest runner without all this prejudice floating around.
They should be able to just say they identify as a female if there is a question about their gender and that should take care of it.
There is nothing politically correct about medical science.
Why are you folks using science now? I thought we settled that argument awhile back. A person should be able to choose the gender they want to be just by identifying with it according to many of you. That's what most of you have been arguing for some time now. Why are we going back to that old school right wing idea that a person is actually a male, female or something in between based on science?
Your needling isn't going unnoticed. I'm curious though, since you obviously have an opinion, in your perfect world which restroom should this runner use?
That should be decided with a coin toss, if the urge isn't imminent, don't you think? Otherwise the bathroom which is the closest.
So a hermaphrodite is required to disclose to the world their physical abnormality so that the world will understand that they have a special right to use whichever restroom they desire?
Is that what you're saying? I didn't say that. Don't you think everyone should be able to use whichever bathroom they choose to use and sue if confronted for discrimination?
Your sarcasm is outing you. Now you've painted yourself into a corner with it.
Your needling isn't going unnoticed.
I got to agree with that. This topic isn't about transgender, it is about a naturally occurring condition.
Your sarcasm is outing you. Now you've painted yourself into a corner with it.
Oh yea. Will you move over so I can see it?
Let's take a look at it from a scientific point of view and then a political point of view.
Politically transgenders and the many expansions on that condition do not require a science in order to choose their gender, only the science of psychology which is very flawed to say the least.
Politically those suffering from hyperandrogenism should have the same rights as transgenders, don't you think? Actually I think a little more, but that's just me. It would be discriminatory to act otherwise.
If she feels her testosterone level is up a little, it shouldn't be anyone's decision but her own to decide whether she should participate in the Olympics. After all they know her condition, it's no secret.
Are we going to use science to make our decisions about something or are we going to ignore science in some of these decisions because it's old school and doesn't fit the political environment of the day?
Personally, I think she should be able to race. When you have good genetics, training and a little extra testosterone, but are more woman than man, the others will have to realize they just won't be winning any races until you retire.
You know which famous movie actress was born with both male and female genitalia? Jamie Lee Curtis. Her parents had to choose which she would be. She had more complete parts as a woman, than as a man, and it was easier to fix her as a woman. Of course this was in the 1950-1960s.
It does happen to people. Jamie Lee has always been a very special lady to me, and is one hell of an actress-- besides being beautiful!