Colorado Court: Workers Can Be Fired for Using Marijuana Off-Duty
Employers' zero-tolerance drug policies trump Colorado's medical marijuana laws, the Colorado Supreme Court ruled Monday.
In a 6-0 decision, the high court affirmed lower court rulings that businesses can fire employees for the use of medical marijuana even if it's off-duty.
With the ruling, which was a blow to some medical marijuana patients and a sigh of relief to employers, Colorado became the first state to provide guidance on a gray area of the law.
The decision came nine months after the state's highest court heard oral arguments in Brandon Coats' case against Dish Network. Coats became quadriplegic in a car accident and used marijuana to control leg spasms. He had a medical marijuana card and consumed pot off-duty. He was fired in 2010 after failing a random drug test.
When the case went to the state Supreme Court , legal observers said the case could have significant implications for employers across Colorado. They noted that the ruling also could be precedent-setting as Colorado and other states wrangle with adapting laws to a nascent industry that is illegal under federal law.
At the crux of the issue was whether the use of medical marijuana which is in compliance with Colorado's Medical Marijuana Amendment was "lawful" under the state's Lawful Off-Duty Activities Statute.
That term, the justices said, refers to activities lawful under both state and federal
law.
"Therefore, employees who engage in an activity, such as medical marijuana use, that is permitted by state law but unlawful under federal law are not protected by the statute," Justice Allison H. Eid wrote in the opinion .
Current Colorado law allows employers to set their own policies on drug use.
Coats' attorney Michael Evans, of Centennial-based The Evans Group, called the decision "devastating."
He said he does not plan to take the case to the U.S. Supreme Court.
http://www.denverpost.com/news/ci_28315256/colorado-supreme-court-affirms-lower-court-rulings-medical

An unexpected decision (at least for me), but solidly based on current statutes in Colorado
No problem if you get yourself stinking drunk and beat up your wife every night - can't get fired for that, eh? What a country.
Hal
That is certainly your choice to make.
The point is the divergence of state and federal law and the rights of the employer to have a drug free workplace policy
Boycotting Dish Network probably won't have much effect on that part of the problem
Buzz
Coming to work under the influence of alcohol (a measurable amount in your blood) is also a termination generating offense in a company with a zero tolerance drug free workplace policy.
Domestic violence and this matter are truly apples and oranges.
jwc
But the termination in that case would be for the fact that you were in jail and unable to work (job abandonment) and would have nothing really to do with the fact that you were drunk
A tough call. And I believe research has proven that pot stays in you system much longer than previously thought...?
Krish
I think you are right about that
I used to have get drug tested at work, regularly, because I take pain medication every night. The funny thing is that I also have to get drug tested at the doctor's office, to make sure I'm taking my meds, and not selling them.
A LOT of places have a zero tolerance policy. I have found that if you take your meds with you, and leave the phone number of your pharmacy, that they can call and verify your prescription. I would assume it's the same in CO.
Ahhhh. Here in KY, I thought there WERE legal prescriptions, for cancer patients, et. al.
I thought pot smokers didn't work?
Didn't work that way with me. From the time I was in the Air Force for the next 20 or more years I'd usually full up my pipe or bong with some of natures own AFTER WORK and when I was at work I busted my ass. When I was working for a drug company (of all places) for 10 years, when I got off the factory line and back on computers I used to work 6 day weeks on a regular basis and 7 days a lot of the time. When I worked on a weekend I'd be working in the computer room like after a bad electrical storm for 24 to 36 hours sometimes, Plus I went to the office after Christmas presents were opened on Christmas just to get few ends cleaned up. I didn't take a vacation or any real time off for almost 3 years, then my boss noticed and ordered me to take a two week vacation. Still in the Air Force and at the drug company, I always managed to smoke some good shit after work. Of course all of that working without time off cost me 2 marriages, but that's the price.
I know that back in the 1980s, urine testing could identify marijuana use after 30 days. I don't know about modern systems.
al
The court seems to disagree with your view and for now that is the law in Colorado
I get your point though
Thanks for the feedback
FLY
I am not sure about current testing levels and sensitivity either
You could see this one coming. With the number of contradicting laws in existence, confusion will remain the byword of the day regarding this situation.
Have to agree with Cerenkov on this one. The law should be changed, or we should have never gone down this path to start with.
Dean
You were close to making a good point until your predictable veer towards race
Better luck next time
CErekov
Good point, but until then .....
And the underlying issue of the employers right to a drug free workplace needs to be more clearly decided.
Alcohol is legal, but being under the influence is a sure route to termination in most companies, why should marijuana even if legal be treated differently
Dowser
I worked in the same environment for the government and in the private sector.
The problem is that the prescription is legal in Colorado and the employer's rightto a drug free workplace is a federal law, and in the federal realm the pot is still illegal.
And it is a given that Ron Paul is an authority on the subject, right?
Well, I can see that point, for sure. However, as soon as my meds wear completely off-- about 9 am, I'm in pain. I can deal with it when I'm up and about, but trying to sleep is the pits.
I can only agree! If smoking pot relieves symptoms of cancer treatments, then why deny it to someone who is working? They may not be able to work without it. Seems unfair to me.
You can smoke a joint and have a urine test come back positive a week later. You can be a heroin addict, but stop for a couple of days and it won't show up on a urine test. Pot smokers may need to switch to heroin if they wanna keep their jobs!
;^)
Hey Larry,
Moral of this story, don't take a job in Colorado. You'd be fired, LOL!
No worries, though Colorado is a beautiful state, I don't have any plans to relocate any time soon.
Same thing can be said about meth, crack, prescription pills...all much more destructive not to mention addictive; yet, do not stay in a person's system as long. So someone with a perfect driving record, can be fired from their job as a bus driver for smoking a joint the week before, while a meth freak merely needs to not do drugs for a couple days, and they may be allowed to cart kids allover the country side because their piss test was negative.
So True! And this is why the law is so stupid.
Well, now that I know you won't be moving to Colorado, I feel much better now. BTW, don't give up the beer either!
Oh trust me, if beer ever got outlawed, I'd be moving to Canada tomorrow!
:~)
He gives his opinion as to why it was passed, that does not make him an expert any more than your opinion or my opinion on an issue makes either of us an expert.
He is simply a man with an opinion on the issue
A related article that you all might find interesting
This is a huge issue right now, in KY, for sure. We seem to have the perfect climate to grow hemp, even that which is used for rope, but the state legislature is not allowing it to be grown.
Dowser
Whether one supports legalization or not, logic and reason seem to dictate that the rules need to be the same at the state and federal level (one way or the other)
Larry
We tried that once, it didn't last
We tried it with pot too and it failed miserably and lasted far too long.
The current situation would indicate that the jury *pun intended" is still out on that one
30 days!!! I never would have guessed. hmm... learn something new every day!