╌>

CDC Prescription Guidelines Will Leave More Patients in Pain and Drive More Addicts to Heroin

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  dean-moriarty  •  10 years ago  •  9 comments

CDC Prescription Guidelines Will Leave More Patients in Pain and Drive More Addicts to Heroin

http://reason.com/blog/2016/03/16/cdc-prescription-guidelines-will-leave-m

CDC Prescription Guidelines Will Leave More Patients in Pain and Drive More Addicts to Heroin


CDC CDC Yesterday the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC)  released prescription guidelines for family doctors aimed at reducing nonmedical use of opioid painkillers and the harm associated with it. The  guidelines , which are officially nonbinding but can be expected to affect regulators' judgments, malpractice liability, and insurance coverage decisions, include some sensible precautions, such as warning patients against mixing opioids with other depressants, avoiding dual prescriptions of opioids and benzodiazepines when feasible, and providing naloxone, an opioid antagonist that reverses the effects of an overdose, to patients taking large amounts of painkillers. But the overall message sent by the guidelines and several of the CDC's specific recommendations inevitably will impede access to narcotic painkillers by legitimate patients who would benefit from them.

The CDC urges doctors treating acute and chronic pain (except in cancer patients or people near death) to view opioids as a last resort. They are supposed to first try nonpharmacological treatments and nonopioid painkillers such as ibuprofen and acetaminophen. That's fine if the other approaches work as well. But doctors who internalize the CDC's overwrought concerns about addiction and overdose (more on those in a minute) will be inclined to avoid opioids even when the alternatives are only half as effective, leaving patients to suffer unnecessary pain. 

The CDC wants doctors who are already inclined to treat patients complaining of pain with suspicion to be even more leery. It recommends interrogation and urine testing aimed at discovering illicit drug use, ostensibly to inform clinical decisions. It does not explicitly say that someone who, say, admits consuming cannabis or tests positive for it should be denied the drugs he needs to control his pain, but you can be sure that will be the result in some cases.

"Clinicians should prescribe the lowest effective dose of immediate-release opioids and should prescribe no greater quantity than needed for the expected duration of pain severe enough to require opioids," the CDC says. "Three days or less will often be sufficient; more than seven days will rarely be needed." Since pain cannot be objectively verified, what counts as an "effective dose" or a "needed" quantity depends not only on the patient's report but on the doctor's willingness to believe it. The CDC is encouraging doctors to be more skeptical of patients' reports and to substitute their judgments for those of the people who are actually experiencing the pain. That tendency, combined with the arbitrary limits on pill counts, will mean more needless suffering.

"While we are largely supportive of the guidelines,"  says  the American Medical Association, "we remain concerned about the evidence base informing some of the recommendations, conflicts with existing state laws and product labeling, and possible unintended consequences associated with implementation, which includes access and insurance coverage limitations for non-pharmacologic treatments, especially comprehensive care, and the potential effects of strict dosage and duration limits on patient care." The consequences for patient care may be unintended, but they are entirely predictable.

"If [the CDC guidelines] produce unintended consequences," the AMA adds, "we will need to mitigate them." That will not be easy now that the pendulum is swinging toward drug control and away from pain control. "These [guidelines] will not be seen as voluntary,"  notes  Myra Christopher, director of the Pain Action Alliance to Implement a National Strategy. "These will become the definition of the standard of care, because of the clout of the Centers for Disease Control."

The official justification for exercising that clout is the need to curtail the "epidemic of prescription opioid misuse and overdose," which according to the CDC killed more than 165,000 Americans between 1999 and 2014—around 10,000 a year on average. That sounds like a lot, but it's a tiny percentage of the people who received opioid prescriptions during that period. The CDC  says  "health care providers wrote 259 million prescriptions for painkillers in 2012, enough for every American adult to have a bottle of pills." On the face of it, 10,000 or so deaths out of 259 million prescriptions—one for every 26,000—do not amount to a very big risk.

The same goes for addiction. According to the  National Survey on Drug Use and Health  (NSDUH), a bottle of opioids for every American adult resulted in about 2 million cases of "abuse or dependence" in 2014, or one for every 130 prescriptions. The rarity of abuse or addiction should come as no surprise to the vast majority of Americans who have taken Vicodin or Percocet for pain. Maybe you enjoyed the buzz, but odds are you did not continue taking painkillers every day once your pain was gone. The truth is that using such drugs regularly for their psychoactive effects appeals to only a small minority of people, which is one reason heroin has never been very popular even among illegal drug users. "We lose sight of the fact that the prescription opioids are just as addictive as heroin,"  says  CDC Director Thomas Frieden. In other words, not very.  

The risk of addiction for pain patients is even smaller than these numbers suggest, because most nonmedical opioid users do not start as pain patients. According to  NSDUH , only a quarter of people who take opioids for nonmedical purposes get them by obtaining a doctor's prescription. Most (66 percent) get them from a friend or relative, usually for free by asking, sometimes surreptitiously and sometimes in exchange for money. Another 5 percent buy opioids from a dealer or other stranger. Theft, fake prescriptions, the Internet, and "other" account for the rest. Hence the sequence that many people imagine—a patient takes opioids for pain, gets hooked, and eventually dies of an overdose—is far from typical of opioid-related deaths.

Opioid-related deaths are rare even for patients who take narcotics every day for years. The CDC cites "a recent study of patients aged 15–64 years receiving opioids for chronic noncancer pain" who were followed for up to 13 years. The researchers found that "one in 550 patients died from opioid-related overdose," which is a risk of less than 0.2 percent. Furthermore, that risk is not random, since deaths attributed to opioids  generally involve  combinations of two or more drugs. 

Discouraging such dangerous mixtures, combined with wider availability of naloxone, would help reduce the number of deaths involving prescription opioids and heroin, which hit a  record high  of 29,467 in 2014. Cracking down on painkillers, by contrast, will only drive more prescription opioid users to heroin, which exposes them to  more danger . "In the case of heroin,"  observes  Norah Volkow, director of the National Institute on Drug Abuse, "this danger [of poisoning] is compounded by the lack of control over the purity of the drug injected and its possible contamination with other drugs (such as fentanyl, a very potent prescription opioid that is also abused by itself). All of these factors increase the risk for overdosing, since the user can never be sure of the amount of the active drug (or drugs) being taken."

As a strategy for reducing opioid-related harm, shrinking the supply by making prescriptions less generous and harder to get sacrifices the lives of current users to protect future users. As is generally the case with drug prohibition, the beneficiaries of this paternalism are not the people who bear the cost. The same is true of legitimate pain patients who will suffer as a result of the government's attempt to prevent others from becoming addicted. Regardless of whether they "work" from a prohibitionist perspective, such tradeoffs are inherently unethical.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   seeder  Dean Moriarty    10 years ago

Once again we see government taking a bad situation and making it worse. 

 
 
 
Tex Stankley
Freshman Silent
link   Tex Stankley  replied to  Dean Moriarty   10 years ago

It is what governments do.   256

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    10 years ago

Dean, I read a comment somewhere that you made about your back and the pain you are suffering.  I just want to tell you how very sorry I am that you are going through this.  I understand, I'm in the same boat.  I wish only the best for you and hope that you can get some relief, soon.  You are in my thoughts and prayers.

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   seeder  Dean Moriarty  replied to  Dowser   10 years ago

Same to you Dowser thanks. 

 
 
 
Tex Stankley
Freshman Silent
link   Tex Stankley    10 years ago

I'm in the same sinking pirogue of pain as well.   The DEA nabbed my chronic pain Doc a few years back.  Since then, at least in the states wherein I dwell, apparently, I am shyte outa luck.   As are all the rest of the walking wounded. 

It is little more than a modern witch hunt which will do little other than help produce more of the black market.  

 

 

 
 
 
PJ
Masters Silent
link   PJ    10 years ago

This is one of those situations where the damage is too far along to walk back.  I understand what they are attempting to do but it will probably result in more people using substitutes in order to manage pain or addictions.  They are only going to curb a small percentage with these new recommendations.  Even so, should we criticize and tell them to do nothing because we don't think it will have the outcomes we want immediately?  There has to be a starting point.    

 

 
 
 
Tex Stankley
Freshman Silent
link   Tex Stankley  replied to  PJ   10 years ago

Beginning at a cruel and totalitarian point doesn't seem all that wise to me. 

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    10 years ago

In this day and age, this is so easy to control without going through these draconian measures. All controlled substances are written on scripts that have a code on them. 

There are a lot of people in chronic pain and the CDC seems very good on telling us how we should feel. Thake this article:

On September 30th The Opiate Addiction Life Saving Herb Kratom Will Be Classified By The DEA As A Schedule 1 Drug

This is about a leaf that has benefits in both pain management, getting off opioids, and even mood stabilization, yet the CDC now wants to ban it in the US. 

I bet these rules don't apply to them.. only us regular folks. 

 
 

Who is online







128 visitors