╌>

A Debate Disaster Waiting to Happen

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  bob-nelson  •  10 years ago  •  56 comments

A Debate Disaster Waiting to Happen


 


Matt Lauer moderated the presidential forum on Wednesday. Credit Doug Mills/The New York Times

There was not much of a contest in  Wednesday night’s forum  with Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump. Mrs. Clinton answered the questions of the moderator, Matt Lauer, in coherent sentences, often with specific details. Mr. Trump alternated between rambling statements and grandiose boasts when he wasn’t lying.

Mr. Lauer largely neglected to ask penetrating questions, call out falsehoods or insist on answers when it was obvious that Mr. Trump’s responses had drifted off.

If the moderators of the coming debates do not figure out a better way to get the candidates to speak accurately about their records and policies — especially Mr. Trump, who seems to feel he can skate by unchallenged with his own version of reality while Mrs. Clinton is grilled and entangled in the fine points of domestic and foreign policy — then they will have done the country a grave disservice.

Whether or not one agrees with her positions, Mrs. Clinton, formerly secretary of state and once a member of the Senate Armed Services Committee, showed a firm understanding of the complex issues facing the country. Mr. Trump reveled in his ignorance about global affairs and his belief that leading the world’s most powerful nation is no harder than running his business empire, which has included  at least four bankruptcies .

Mr. Lauer seemed most energized interrogating Mrs. Clinton about her use of a personal email server while secretary of state. Focusing on it meant that other critical issues — like America’s role in Afghanistan and its ties with China — went unaddressed. He was harder on Mrs. Clinton than on Mr. Trump, reflecting a tendency among some journalists to let Mr. Trump’s deceptions go unchallenged. That certainly was the case when he let Mr. Trump attack Mrs. Clinton for voting for the Iraq war and  going into Libya  when  Mr. Trump had supported  those actions.

Disputing outright lies may actually be one of the easier challenges for a moderator. The harder task is to pierce fantasies and gibberish. That requires preparation and persistence.

Mr. Trump was asked to explain his qualifications to lead the armed forces. “I have great  judgment, ” was his response. Fortunately, despite the lack of a follow-up question to that non-answer, Mr. Trump was perfectly able to display his abysmal judgment.

He repeated his view that President Vladimir Putin of Russia, who invaded Ukraine and annexed Crimea, is a better leader than President Obama. He denigrated America’s generals as having been “reduced to rubble.” He talked in circles about defeating the Islamic State, boasting of a secret plan that he would not share.

Mr. Trump reinforced his reputation for misogyny by defending his tweet from 2013 suggesting that sexual assaults were to be expected if women serve in the military. And, prompted by an audience question, he adjusted his immigration policy on the fly, suggesting that immigrants who join the military could avoid deportation.

Lucky for him, no one bothered to ask why he should be allowed to be commander in chief when he spent so much time attacking the parents of a Muslim Army captain killed in Iraq. Earlier in the day, Mr. Trump called for a huge expansion of the military that experts said would cost an extra  $150 billion  over a decade. He gave no hint where that money would come from.

At one point, Mrs. Clinton, trying to assure the audience that she would use military force judiciously, said, “We are not putting ground troops into Iraq ever again, and we’re not putting ground troops into Syria.” This left unanswered the question of whether she had made a promise she can’t keep, particularly since there are some Special Operations forces in both battlefields now.

There will be many issues to explore at the three presidential debates. For the sake of the nation, the moderators need to be fully prepared to challenge the candidates, so voters can have a clear picture of how they will lead.

-----------------------------

Editorial by THE EDITORIAL BOARD , New York Times

-----------------------------------

RED RULES apply:
Be polite .
No insults whatsoever.
No insults to particular people, to groups of people, to ideas, ...
None!

 


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    10 years ago

RED RULES apply:
Be polite. No insults whatsoever. No insults to particular people, to groups of people, to ideas, ... None!

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     10 years ago

I watched the interviews done by Lauer. IMO, he was inept.  I hope that the moderators of the 3 debates don't follow Lauer's path.

Sadly, I watched Chris Wallace explain that he would rather let Trump and Clinton make their points without intervening. IMO, that is going to lead to what we saw with Lauer.

I am for the moderators to challenge either Trump or Clinton when they are avoiding the question or spewing BS.

 

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Kavika   10 years ago

"Journalism" today doesn't seem to mean anything. Lobbing softballs and not getting in the way of the line drive coming back.

 

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy  replied to  Kavika   10 years ago

I am for the moderators to challenge either Trump or Clinton when they are avoiding the question or spewing BS.

That's not their job, its their job to ask tough, but fair questions, and enforce the rules. It's the job of the candidates to defend their own positions and expose the weakness of the other candidate's position. Otherwise, the moderator becomes just another participant and has every incentive to steal the show to burnish their own reputation.  

Wallace's position, which has been the accepted position of moderators since we began holding debates, is the only way to moderate with actual journalistic standards, where the journalists report the story, they don't become the story themselves.  It's tough enough for a moderator to avoid bias in deciding which questions to ask, give him or her the power to selectively intervene to insert the moderator's own  preferred narrative of a story and you have a recipe for total chaos as well as blatant unfairness. 

Advocacy journalism from a moderator (in which the moderator selectively decides which candidate's positions or statements to criticize) would be an absolute disaster. One of the CNBC anchors tried to do it during a Republican debate and everyone agreed it was a train wreck. 

Believe me, the message has been sent by the mainstream media  to future moderators. Don't ask Clinton tough questions about her lengthy record and aggressively attack Trump or you will be attacked by the mainstream outlets. That's all the brouhha about Lauer is about, working the refs of the real debates to ensure they know what will happen if they don't do their best to bring down Trump.  

 

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.  replied to  Sean Treacy   10 years ago

That's not their job, its their job to ask tough, but fair questions, and enforce the rules. It's the job of the candidates to defend their own positions and expose the weakness of the other candidate's position. Otherwise, the moderator becomes just another participant and has every incentive to steal the show to burnish their own reputation.  

Sean,

Your comment seems to be a bit at odds with itself. If you are asking tough questions, and you get an odd answer, the follow up question is required. 

May I point you to my personal hero, Edward R. Morrow. If he never challenged McCarthy's answers, he would have never exposed his weakness. Until then, McCarthy was a bully, and used to going unchallenged. Morrow had the integrity, to do his job. Mind you... it could have not gone well for Morrow, but that didn't dissuade him from his duty. And that is what made him a true journalist. 

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty  replied to  Perrie Halpern R.A.   10 years ago

"McCarthy was a bully"  is that an insult? 

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Dean Moriarty   10 years ago

I'm running an experiment, here, Dean. I want to see how members behave when all they are required to do is "be polite". Will they therefore try to derail, since that's not against today's Red Rules?

Some will.......

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy  replied to  Perrie Halpern R.A.   10 years ago

f you are asking tough questions, and you get an odd answer, the follow up question is required. 

No, it's not at all. The moderator asks the question and allows the candidate to debate to debate the question. It's the opposing candidates job, not the moderator's, to expose any weakness in the response. You are basically asking the moderator to step into the debate in the place of the candidate and serve as a participant rather than a referee.

It's like giving the referee of a boxing match the power to punch a boxer if he clinches his opponent too long. If a candidate can't expose a weak answer, they don't belong on the stage to begin with.

 If he never challenged McCarthy's answers, he would have never exposed his weaknes

Murrow was not moderating a debate with McCarthy as a participant when he challenged him. Moderating a debate is not the same thing as investigative journalism. There is certainly a time and place for aggressive journalism,  but a debate is not that time. The moderator has to be neutral or it becomes a farce. 

 
 
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   Spikegary    10 years ago

It's funny that Mrs. Clinton had an earpiece in for the interview, almost so that someone could feed her answers to the questions to try to make her look 'Presidential'.  Also, it's been reported that Lauer is a heavy hitter in contributing to the Clintons.  I wonder if that could be one of the reasons he went 'soft' on Mrs. Clinton?

Neither candidate of the 2 parties is thrilling me in any way shape or form, but the press is in the bag for Mrs. Clinton.  Anyone that can't see that is lying or a fool.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell  replied to  Spikegary   10 years ago

It's funny that Mrs. Clinton had an earpiece in for the interview, almost so that someone could feed her answers to the questions to try to make her look 'Presidential'.  Also, it's been reported that Lauer is a heavy hitter in contributing to the Clintons.  I wonder if that could be one of the reasons he went 'soft' on Mrs. Clinton?

This entire paragraph is at odds with reality. 

 
 
 
ArkansasHermit
Freshman Silent
link   ArkansasHermit  replied to  Spikegary   10 years ago

It's funny that Mrs. Clinton had an earpiece in for the interview, almost so that someone could feed her answers to the questions to try to make her look 'Presidential'

Anyone that can't see that is lying or a fool

Since this statement has been well and thoroughly debunked, I assume anyone still pushing it as a fact would either be ly.......... or a f.....

Fear Piece
A photograph purportedly showing Hillary Clinton wearing a 'secret earpiece' during NBC's 'Commander-In-Chief' candidate forum reveals nothing unusual.

Claim: Hillary Clinton wore a 'secret earpiece' at NBC's Commander-In-Chief forum.

256

 

 

 

Although this photograph was frequently shared as a "high-res" image showing Clinton wearing an earpiece, it's actually a cropped version of an image taken by news photographer Brendan Smialowski.

Smialowski's image has been cropped to show only Clinton's face (and then blown up back to size), revealing what looks like a small light inside Clinton's ear. However, this "object" can't be seen in other photographs of the candidate from the same event.

The "earpiece" photograph most likely captured a light source temporarily reflecting on Clinton's ear.

proof ear

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior  replied to  ArkansasHermit   10 years ago

Very old picture - not conducive to your "logic".

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  ArkansasHermit   10 years ago

... would either be ly.......... or a f.....

You're skirting the Red Rule. Next time it will be deleted. Perrie allows skirting. I do not.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior  replied to  Bob Nelson   10 years ago

Nice try, but you don't have the "power" to delete.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  1stwarrior   10 years ago

An author / seeder's decision is absolute when there are Red Rules. 

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    10 years ago

Anyone that can't see that is lying or a fool.

This is an insult, a violation of Red Rules. One warning before deletion. This sentence was unnecessary, as well. If you had just posted the preceding sentence... no problem.

 
 
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   Spikegary  replied to  Bob Nelson   10 years ago

Well, in your judgment it seems, though it was not directed at any particular individual.  It was a statement of belief.  You can choose to see it as an insult or choose to see it as it was intended.

I note that you didn't see John's comment as an insult.  It added nothing to the discussion.

 

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Spikegary   10 years ago

RED RULES apply:
... No insults to ... ideas...

Is that not clear?

As for John's post... There's nothing in the Red Rules -- this time -- about anything other than "BE POLITE". I'm running an experiment to see how people behave when given a bit of latitude.

 
 
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   Spikegary  replied to  Bob Nelson   10 years ago

As I said, It was not intended as an insult, but if it makes you feel better, an admin can remove.  But again, you should also castigate John for his comments, then everyone will see that you are capable of being an honest broker.

Edit-Since the seeder/author modified his answer after I responded to it, I'm posting hits Edit:

So, you choose who you allow latitude on violating your redbox rules.  Okay, got it, Bob.  I fully understand.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Spikegary   10 years ago

John insulted no one. You called everyone who does not agree with you a "fool".

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    10 years ago

Interesting article, Bob.  Thanks for posting it!

I get the feeling these days that journalists are afraid of Mr. Trump-- or it is being afraid of Mr. Ailes who supports him?  I wish that journalists would ask more pointed questions, and not let the candidates get away with vague answers-- it leaves us, as viewers, scrambling to connect the dots.  I found Mr. Lauer's interview to be baffling.  And his lack of hard questions for the vague Mr. Trump unsettling.

To Mr. Trump:  Are you going to release your tax returns?  No.  Why not?  

To Mr. Trump:  Are you sick?  No.  How can you prove that your health is good, and your strange skin color is the result of a bad spray tan job?  How can a man of your means allow yourself to be spray tanned at a discount store?

To Mrs. Clinton:  Are you really sick?  No.  How can your prove that your health is good, (as of today)?

As far as debate moderating, I've never participated in debates, so, despite having watched them a lot, I don't know what a debate moderator is supposed to do besides being fair and balanced.  According to Wikipedia, my easy access reference:

A discussion moderator or debate moderator is a person whose role is to act as a neutral participant in a debate or discussion, holds participants to time limits and trying to keep them from straying off the topic of the questions being raised in thedebate.

Mr. Trump seems to be completely adept at going off topic, and into a bellicose rant.  I wouldn't want to have to try to keep him on topic and on time.  I mean, further clarification of his rantings would put him over the time limit, which may be the purpose of the rant...  Say a lot while saying nothing.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Dowser   10 years ago

What kills me is that the candidates' previous statements are all over the Interwebs. If the "journalist" makes the effort, s/he can be ready to follow up on just about any subject. Index cards!

 

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser  replied to  Bob Nelson   10 years ago

Their job is to initiate higher ratings, not really "DO" anything.  We've lost out on fair and balanced reporting, true investigative journalism, in the pursuit of the $$.  I think, any way.

Where are our William Shirers, Edward Murrows, and Walter Cronkites?  Or Huntleys and Brinkleys?  They've all fallen by the wayside for those who scream and shriek and give air time to fantasies...  Are our lives so horrible that we can't bear to face the truth?  I want some truth in my reporting, unbiased facts.  Not going to find it today, for sure!

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Dowser   10 years ago

We've lost out on fair and balanced reporting, true investigative journalism, in the pursuit of the $$.

Isn't there a niche for a serious television journalist? Just one?

It doesn't seem so. I can think of a bunch of toadies, but not a single real journalist.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser  replied to  Bob Nelson   10 years ago

I agree.  I'm tired of searching high and low for real investigative journalism.  None of the news sources seem to be able to report the plain, unvarnished truth.  

It's frightening.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Dowser   10 years ago

It's frightening.

Everyone agrees that a free press is essential for democracy. But "free" isn't enough. "Effective" is just as necessary. 

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser  replied to  Bob Nelson   10 years ago

I'm feeling that Goebbels is at the head of our news services...  I just want the truth.  Not lies and innuendo, just facts.  Someone pin them down!  Refuse to allow vague answers and promises!  

Yeah, like that's going to happen...  winking

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Dowser   10 years ago

The Big Lie existed before Göbbels. What changed with him, and has accelerated constantly ever since, are the means of communication. Göbbels had Leni Reifenstal with her targeted films, but nowadays we have Roger Ailes and his offspring. Fox is vastly more sophisticated... and vastly more effective. 

But... Let's be honest. Fox couldn't be so successful if they didn't have a public avid for "the right news". The public is the real culprit. Wanting to hear only "what is agreeable" is fine for children; voters should do better. 

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser  replied to  Bob Nelson   10 years ago

I can only agree!  But, it's human nature not to want to have to "think"...  Thinking leads to introspection and that's a lot of work.  If we can be spoon fed, then we're a lot happier...  winking

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Dowser   10 years ago

* * *   s i g h   * * *

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell  replied to  Bob Nelson   10 years ago

These days, even journalists want to establish a personal brand and promote themselves. On tv this is very apparent and it is even kind of apparent online as well. 

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

These days, even journalists want to establish a personal brand and promote themselves. 

Good point. This would be okay if their stepping stone was "quality journalism", but it often appears that "outrageous" is preferred. 

 
 

Who is online






145 visitors