╌>

The News Media’s Miscalculation on Hillary’s Health

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  sixpick  •  10 years ago  •  31 comments

The News Media’s Miscalculation on Hillary’s Health

by Sharyl Attkisson September 11, 2016

 

The following is a news media analysis and commentary.

I watched the video of Hillary Clinton as she faltered, slumped and then apparently got dragged into her van, and I felt awful. Public officials put themselves in the public eye, but to have every step and misstep analyzed the way we do today seems to be a no-win situation. I wouldn’t want someone videotaping me when I had a migraine headache or–as I did several times in my 20’s working in Florida–became faint and dehydrated. I join with many Americans who wish Clinton the best, and a speedy recovery from what her doctors say is a case of pneumonia and dehydration.

Clinton being helped prior to slumping and being pulled into her van. Courtesy: Zdenek Gazda on Twitter

Clinton being helped prior to slumping and being pulled into her van. Courtesy: Zdenek Gazda on Twitter

But the incident raises questions about the news media’s coverage surrounding Clinton’s health. Rather than reporting the facts, many in the media have taken it upon themselves to shout down the questions and to controversialize those asking them. On August 21, 2016, after Trump adviser Rudolph Giuliani suggested people research Clinton’s medical state on Google, a New York Times tech columnist retorted in a tweet:


“Google should fix this. It shouldn’t give quarter to conspiracy theorists.” Tweet by Farhad Manjoo of the New York Times, 8/21/2016 .


In other words, the columnist was advocating that a conspiracy be committed to stop people from researching Clinton’s health, which he labeled a conspiracy. Many others in the media also chimed in using the “conspiracy theory” moniker. It’s designed to convince the public to tune out the discussion, in much the same way as other common astroturf terms such as “debunked,” “bonkers,” “tin-foil hat,” “shoddy,” “discredited,” “quack,” “bogus,” “denier,” and “crank.”

Left-wing apparatus Vox chimed in with an article titled: “The bonkers conspiracy theory about Hillary Clinton’s health.” The pro-Hillary Clinton smear machine, Media Matters, chided  NBC News for “mainstreaming conspiracy theories about Hillary Clinton’s health.” Vice picked up the theme writing, “How conspiracy theories about Hillary Clinton’s health went mainstream.” CNN published an article “Debunking conspiracy theories” about her health. CNN media critic Brian Stelter urged the media: “Do Not Give Oxygen To ‘Conspiracy Theories’ That Hillary Clinton Is ‘Secretly Ill’.”  HuffPost wrote, “Let’s call the conspiracy theories about Clinton’s health what they are…” ThinkProgress  joined in with, “Trump campaign embraces conspiracy theory…” From MSNBC : “Trump, allies push conspiracy theory about Clinton’s health.” NPR : “Trump adds fuel to conspiracy theory about Clinton’s health.” You get the idea. Everybody’s on the same page.

In fact, questions about Clinton’s health, whether grounded or far-fetched, had little to do with supposed conspiracies.

Today, a Washington Post reporter acknowledged that he, too, had recently argued the discussion was “the stuff of conspiracy theorists.” But now, in the face of the obvious, he agrees there are legitimate concerns.


Coughing, I wrote, is simply not evidence enough of any sort of major illness that Clinton is assumed to be hiding. Neither, of course, is feeling “overheated.” But those two things happening within six days of each other to a candidate who is 68 years old makes talk of Clinton’s health no longer just the stuff of conspiracy theorists.– Washington Post reporter Chris Cillizza


In other words, all this was “the stuff of conspiracy theorists” until the reporters who appear to have been proven wrong, decided it was not. It’s almost as if we in the media take an editorial position with no factual basis, dare critics to prove us wrong, and then when events do, we modify our stance.

That’s not what the news is supposed to do. Reporters are, ideally, supposed to bring facts to light. If we relegate our role to one of spinning and trying to convince the public of our position; then end up bringing up the rear after-the-fact, what good are we?

Pneumonia is a serious disease. According to the Centers for Disease Control , each year about 50-thousand people in the U.S. die of pneumonia. While successful pneumonia treatment often leads to full recovery, it can have longer term consequences: “worsened exercise ability, cardiovascular disease, cognitive decline, and quality of life for months or years.” How much does it matter? Perhaps not much. After all, any of us could drop dead tomorrow. It will be up to Americans to decide whether this is an issue that matters to their vote. It’s up to the news media to try to get at the facts rather than advance either candidate’s narratives.

~~Link~~



Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  sixpick    10 years ago

If all journalist were like Sharyl Attkisson, the country would be a much better place.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    10 years ago
The coughing was an indication of pneumonia, an attempt to clear the buildup of congestion. The worry here is that complete rest is needed to successfully treat pneumonia, if that is what her illness is. How can she at this point of the campaign rest in the required manner, and if she does not rest then surely there is a concern that ignoring the needed treatment can mean progression of the disease and death. It is a real dilemma.
 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell    10 years ago

If all journalist were like Sharyl Attkisson, the country would be a much better place

 

This article is simply ridiculous. This is Attkisson's argument. People should have listened to Rudy Giuliani and others when they peddled fraudulent material about Clinton's health, because it turns out they were right anyway.

Well, you can't be right IN ANY WAY when you promote fraudulent evidence. Some part of your claim may turn out to be true, but it isn't because of anything you did. Giuliani was pointing to fraudulent evidence in "You Tube videos", because that is all there was. Or to put it another way, Hillary Clinton developed pneumonia after Giuliani made his comments, not before, and the You Tube videos don't show her with pneumonia. Many of them claimed she had brain damage and seizures. 

People like Attkisson depend on her audience being stupid. She could not survive as a "journalist" if they weren't. 

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

"This article is simply ridiculous. This is Attkisson's argument. People should have listened to Rudy Giuliani and others when they peddled fraudulent material about Clinton's health, because it turns out they were right anyway."

 

Actually the article is more about pointing out that liberals will try to stifle the conversation on any subject they don't want discussed, (even one as rudimentary as a presidential candidates health) and the tactics they use. (oh it is a crazy conspiracy theory, you are bat shit crazy to be concerned, or even en-quire about the health of someone running for president!  Stop asking about it or you will be labeled a crackpot, conspiracy theorist, womanizer, and every other shitty thing we can think of!)

Not surprised it went right over your head.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  sixpick    10 years ago

People like Attkisson depend on her audience being stupid. She could not survive as a "journalist" if they weren't.

I don't think so John.  She started off with "I join with many Americans who wish Clinton the best, and a speedy recovery from what her doctors say is a case of pneumonia and dehydration".  Then she went on to tell the truth about all the MSM going to bat for her and calling anyone who questioned her good health as being a conspiracy nut, so to speak.

“Google should fix this. It shouldn’t give quarter to conspiracy theorists.” Tweet by Farhad Manjoo of the New York Times, 8/21/2016.

I think it should be normal to people to question her health due to all the incidents she has had recently, but the MSM, who we know are totally promoting Hillary, wanted to stomp anyone who questioned her health out as being a conspiracy nut.

As it turns out she does have a bad health condition that 50 thousand people die from each year in the USA.  That's where the miscalculation is concerning the MSM.

Let's hope she gets better soon.  I really would like her to continue being the candidate, wouldn't you?

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell  replied to  sixpick   10 years ago

If Hillary Clinton just developed pneumonia, without all the 'conspiracy' theories of the past couple months having been in the news, it would have been a news story about the campaign, rather than becoming a national hysteria.

You cannot remove concerns about her health now from the fraudulent , doctored information of the past weeks. The insidiousness of the spread of the false information has served to heighten the "importance" of the current development.

We KNOW that you have no problem with spreading false information. You have been doing it for years. 

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

No one knows what's going on with her. Her campaign's gone through about 8 stories since her collapse and settled on pneumonia. After having her hug a little girl in a photo op, of course. 

As Ed Morriseey says:  "The collapse forced their hand, but even in the immediate aftermath of the news reports about her fainting spell, they tried to pass it off as “overheating” … on a 79-degree day. And now she’s canceling events in California today and tomorrow only because the secret’s out.

Team Hillary won’t tell the truth until all of the lies stop working. That, even more than Hillary’s health, is a big lesson for voters in 2016. This parade of obfuscations has begun to resemble Soviet prevarications about the health of Politburo members back in the 1980s."

 

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

John can always justify a Clinton lie. It's never her fault that she lied. Those bad republicans force her to lie and poor Hillary is powerless to tell the truth.

And then he wonders why no one trusts her. 

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell  replied to  Sean Treacy   10 years ago

What lie Sean? Attempting to "power through" an illness in order to maintain a campaign schedule is not lying. 

If there had not been weeks if not months of irresponsible and largely FRAUDULENT speculation about her health ("brain damage") this current development would be seen as an interesting sidebar to the campaign instead of the national emergency it is now portrayed as.

Use your head.  

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

The cough is just pollen

Then it was just heat exhaustion on a 79 degree day.

Then she "feels great" and exposes a little girl to pneumonia by publicly using her as a prop in a photo op to demonstrate how healthy she was. Is it appropriate for someone with a communicable disease like pneumonia to set up a phot op to hug a little girl? 

A couple hours after telling the country she was fine, Whoops, I've had pneumonia. 

The most charitable reading of this timeline is that her campaign — presumably with the blessing and perhaps insistence of the candidate — fully intended to keep her illness a secret from the public. Let's be clear about what this means: Her campaign intended to lie. Even though doing so would require her to keep up a public schedule that might well make her condition worse and require ever-more elaborate forms of concealment. Because, of course, to curtail her schedule would raise questions that might reveal the truth.

So even after she collapsed, the campaign decided the ruse would continue. It arranged for the candidate to make her curbside declaration of wellness, even bringing on the girl to give her a "spontaneous" hug. (Clinton's protection detail would never have permitted a genuinely spontaneous embrace on the street, even by a child.)..

So the campaign chose to lie. The potential reward was considerable: namely, an absence of politically damaging news stories about Clinton's medical condition. But the risk was enormous — and it's blown up in their faces. Because now the story isn't just that Clinton is ill. It's that, once again, she's untrustworthy — and this time about her own health.

That's why the announcement that she has pneumonia will only fuel more speculation about Clinton's physical condition, with potentially no end in sight. The world saw her collapse, and 90 minutes later, the candidate looked America in the eye and proclaimed that she was feeling great. Except now we know that she wasn't...

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell  replied to  Sean Treacy   10 years ago

Damon Linker is hardly an objective commentator.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

I agree he's biased, he hates Trump. You realize in the article you posted he's taking a very anti-Trump position, right? Here's him being about as explicitly as anti-Trump as one can be: 

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell  replied to  Sean Treacy   10 years ago

Seems like he changed his mind. 

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

I think you read the entire article you posted, not just the first few sentences. 

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

"If Hillary Clinton just developed pneumonia, without all the 'conspiracy' theories of the past couple months having been in the news, it would have been a news story about the campaign, rather than becoming a national hysteria."

 

You are the only one hysterical over it.  Face it, if she wasn't so secretive and if they addressed it right away instead of waiting to concur their "story".  We wouldn't be having this conversation.   She has made her own bed. 

 
 
 
PJ
Masters Silent
link   PJ    10 years ago

The problem these days with reporting is that much of it is speculation.  There doesn't seem to be any real journalism anymore just soundbites and gotcha phrases and headlines.  

It's clear they have joined in the mission to divide Americans.  

 

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy  replied to  PJ   10 years ago

When the Clinton team lies about her health and hides from the press, what else are they supposed to do? 

 
 
 
PJ
Masters Silent
link   PJ  replied to  Sean Treacy   10 years ago

Well Sean.....Hilary's doctor has actually released medical information about her health so I'd say that maybe the media should take that into consideration when they are "speculating".  Trump's doctor has provided absolutely no documentation about Trump's health.  

I'm not saying that Hilary's campaign hasn't tried to downplay things and when I view yesterday's video it's clear to me that she is not feeling well and is on the verge of collapse requiring assistance to get into the vehicle.  That's reality, that to me is indisputable but to speculate that she's dying and she has some serious health condition when they just don't know that is simply bad form and irresponsible.  Come on Sean - be reasonable. 

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6  replied to  PJ   10 years ago

Oh come on now PJ.  Her doctor releases a statement because people are asking about her health then she damn near collapses.  I think we should all take into consideration Hillary's past and the fact that the doctor note will say whatever the hell Hillary wants it to, don't you?  (So will Trump's for that matter.)

The fact of the matter is she  always lies, and tries to keep too many secrets in the first place,  and then when the truth comes out, she waits too long after something like this happens to let people know what is going on.   She constantly makes her own bed with this crap and never learns.

  Do you really think she had PNEUMONIA and no one knew about it PJ?    Think about it.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser  replied to  96WS6   10 years ago

JFK had Addison's disease and no one knew about it.  My father died of it.  His heart just quit, because he adrenal gland stopped functioning.  The leader of the free world, JFK, was inches from death, every moment of every day, just because he had an adrenal gland problem.

Why is everyone so in an uproar over Ms. Clinton's health?  Shouldn't they be asking about Trump's health, too?  He's 2 years older than Hilary, and has been spray tanned to look orange.  What is that spray tan covering up?  Does he have a liver ailment, or a bad spray tan?

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6  replied to  Dowser   10 years ago

Why is everyone so in an uproar over Ms. Clinton's health?  Shouldn't they be asking about Trump's health, too?  "

 

Well Trump is not the one falling on his buttocks. ;)    lol

256

 
 
 
PJ
Masters Silent
link   PJ  replied to  96WS6   10 years ago

96 - I don't know what was wrong with her.  I'm not a doctor......but I do work with some of the brightest in the world.  Still, I don't think association gives me the credentials I would need to give an opinion on her health.  I will say, as I did earlier, that it was clear to me from watching the video that she was unable to make it into the vehicle without assistance and that it appeared to me that she was on the verge of collapsing.  

I'm not going to go back and forth on the issue of lying.  We've all skirted some truths in our lives for a variety of issues and I think it's safe to suggest that most all politicians lie.   Sadly I don't expect the truth.  I'm just looking at this point for the candidate that will do the least amount of harm and I'm convinced Donald Trump will destroy America......plus I'm a woman and I can't vote for someone who would take away women's rights and who thinks women are in general whores and sluts.  

 

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6  replied to  PJ   10 years ago

Two words for you PJ....GARY JOHNSON

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy  replied to  96WS6   10 years ago

"The fact of the matter is she  always lies, and tries to keep too many secrets in the first place,  and then when the truth comes out, she waits too long after something like this happens to let people know what is going on. "

Perfectly put.  She's an instinctual liar.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy  replied to  PJ   10 years ago

Well the information in the public record is that she fainted and suffered a severe head injury that restricted her inability to work as SOS for months. The brain injury was so severe that she told the FBI she has no memory of parts of her tenure as Secretary of State. Yesterday, whatever the cause, was pretty bad.

She obviously has issues  with her health and the capacity to handle the stress of leading the free world 24/7 is a legitimate question. As her husband said, the health of the President is a legitimate issue. 

Maybe it's just a case of pneumonia. Maybe it's something more dire. We do know she's a Clinton, which means the only thing we really know is that she is going to lie. Just like her camp did yesterday. If the video had no surfaced, is there a chance in hell she would have told the Press she had pneumonia as her excuse for leaving the ceremony early? Of course not. 

Until she undergoes an independent examination by an independent physician, it's impossible to know that she can handle the job. She has no credibility on this subject, as the laughable excuses her camp issued yesterday demonstrates. She just lies. 

 

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    10 years ago

This captures the media's culpability:

B. What fact-based source was motivating journalists for the past several months to not only  ignore  the questions regarding Clinton’s health, but, to aggressively and publicly  shame and humiliate  any reporter writing about their observations that, perhaps, Clinton was not the picture of health?  The good word of the Clinton campaign and the candidate, herself.

That’s right, the candidate with the lowest trustworthy ranking of any modern presidential candidate. The person known to skirt the truth if not lie outright on any issue that might make her or her husband look bad gave her own personal assurance to reporters that her health was fine.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov  replied to  Sean Treacy   10 years ago

Gullible or complicit? Either way, the media is failing their mission.

 
 
 
jennilee
Freshman Silent
link   jennilee    10 years ago

My doctor, because of my age, brings up the flu and pneumonia shot whenever i go in for a check up.  Wonder why her doctor didn't give her one as she is constantly exposed to stranger's  germs on the campaign trail. 

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy  replied to  jennilee   10 years ago

I wonder why her doctor gave her anti-biotics since their is supposedly a breakout of viral pneumonia amongst her staff. Odd, since anti-biotics are worthless against viruses. 

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  sixpick  replied to  Sean Treacy   10 years ago

I wonder why her doctor gave her anti-biotics since their is supposedly a breakout of viral pneumonia amongst her staff. Odd, since anti-biotics are worthless against viruses.

I read in one of those credible sources John likes that she was chasing some children around in her daughter apartment.  And then she did the photo opt with the little girl outside.  You can't make this stuff up.  It's disgusting how dumb they think we are.

Then her doctor put her on antibiotics which could make her situation much worse if it is a viral infection?  Where has common sense gone???

 
 

Who is online



JohnRussell


105 visitors