KEY PRELIMINARY FINDINGS OF THE HIGH LEVEL INTERNATIONAL MILITARY GROUP ON THE GAZA CONFLICT
KEY PRELIMINARY FINDINGS OF THE HIGH LEVEL INTERNATIONAL MILITARY GROUP ON THE GAZA CONFLICT
Published on June 12, 2015 in Human Rights Council (UNHRC) by unwatch .
Key preliminary findings on the 2014 Gaza Conflict by a high level international military group assubmitted to the UN Human Rights CouncilsCommission of Inquiry, which isexpectedto issue its report nextweek.
______
HIGH LEVEL INTERNATIONAL MILITARY GROUP
THE GAZA CONFLICT IN 2014
From 18 th 22 nd May 2015, the High Level International Military Group, made up of 11 former chiefs of staff, generals, senior officers, political leaders and officials from the United States, Germany, the United Kingdom, Holland, Spain, Italy, Australia and Colombia visited Israel for a fact-finding mission on the 2014 Gaza conflict. We were led by General Klaus Naumann, former Chief of Staff of the Bundeswehr and Chairman of the NATO Military Committee, the most senior officer in the Alliance, and Giulio Terzi, former Foreign Minister of Italy. Also in the group were Ambassador Pierre-Richard Prosper, formerly US State Department Ambassador at Large for war crimes issues; and Mr Rafael Bardaji, former National Security Adviser to the Government of Spain.
This was part of a longer term project by our group, whose principal concern is how civilian lives can be protected and military forces can fight effectively when operations must be conducted in a densely packed civilian area. We will be producing a full report this autumn.
Our mission to Israel was unprecedented. We were the first such multi-national group of senior officers to visit the country. We were granted a level of access to the Israeli government and Defence Force that has not been afforded to any other group, from the Prime Minister, Benjamin Netanyahu, and the Minister of Defence, Moshe Yaalon, right down to the field commanders responsible for fighting the battle on the ground.
We were well aware of the allegations made by some governments, the United Nations, human rights groups and the media, that Israel acted outside the laws of armed conflict in Gaza. Some have suggested that the IDF lacked restraint or even deliberately targeted innocent civilians.
Our findings lead us to the opposite conclusion. We examined the circumstances that led to the tragic conflict last summer and are in no doubt that this was not a war that Israel wanted. In reality Israel sought to avoid the conflict and exercised great restraint over a period of months before the war when its citizens were targeted by sporadic rocket attacks from Gaza. Once the war had begun, Israel made repeated efforts to terminate the fighting. The war that Israel was eventually compelled to fight against Hamas and other Gaza extremists was a legitimate war, necessary to defend its citizens and its territory against sustained attack from beyond its borders.
In the main Hamass rocket attacks deliberately and indiscriminately targeted Israeli civilian population centres in the south of the country. We visited one, the kibbutz Nahal Oz, at which more than 150 Hamas rockets had been directed last summer, causing loss of life and large-scale destruction. Many attacks were also launched against major cities further north including Jerusalem and Tel Aviv. Hamas deliberately fired missiles at Ben Gurion International Airport, disrupting and threatening international civil air traffic. There is no doubt that all of these attacks constitute war crimes.
Hamas also constructed an array of tunnels, using materials diverted from humanitarian supplies, which penetrated the border between Gaza and Israel, in many cases emerging close to civilian communities. We entered one such tunnel, which extended over two kilometres, terminating only a few hundred yards from a kibbutz and likely intended to eventually bore into the kibbutz itself. We can only conclude that these tunnels were designed, at least in part, to attack, kill and abduct Israeli civilians. This again constitutes a war crime.
Hamas launched attacks against Israel from the heart of its own civilian communities in Gaza and positioned its munitions and military forces there also, including in schools, hospitals and mosques. As well as carefully documented IDF evidence of this, we have viewed international media footage confirming several cases and are aware of senior Hamas officials own claims to have used human shields. A recent report by the UN Secretary General confirmed that in some cases Hamas even used UN facilities for storing munitions and launching attacks.
Again, these actions clearly amount to war crimes. The laws of armed conflict not only forbid the use of human shields but also demand that combatant forces ensure their civilians are physically evacuated from combat areas. Hamas made no effort to evacuate civilians; on the contrary, there are documented cases of them compelling civilians to remain in or return to places where they expected Israeli attacks to come.
Click this link to read the rest of this article:
http://blog.unwatch.org/index.php/2015/06/12/key-findings-of-the-high-level-international-military-group-on-the-gaza-conflict/
Tags
Who is online
76 visitors

For those members of NT who will inevitably attack the source of information that is contrary to their opinion, the source in this case is this list of Military personel, and not UN Watch.It was signed by the following persons:
Signed by the members of the High Level International Military Group that visited Israel 18th 22ndMay 2015,
Giulio Terzi former Foreign Minister of Italy.
General Klaus Naumann former Chief of Staff of the Bundeswehr and Chairman of the NATO Military Committee.
General Vincenzo Camporini former Chief of the Defence Staff of Italy.
Admiral Jose Maria Teran former Chief of the Joint Staff of Spain.
Ambassador Pierre-Richard Prosper former US State Department Ambassador at Large for war crimes issues.
Mr Rafael Bardaji former National Security Adviser for the Spanish government.
Lieutenant General David A Deptula former Standing Joint Force Air Component Commander, United States Pacific Command.
Major General Jim Molan former Chief of Operations, Headquarters Multi National Force, Iraq and Commander of the Australian Defence College.
Colonel Eduardo Ramirez Member of Colombian Congress and former Chief of Security, Colombia.
Colonel Vincent Alcazar former senior United States Air Force officer in Iraq and Afghanistan.
Colonel Richard Kemp former Commander of British Forces in Afghanistan.
31 May 2015
Nice try, flame, but no cigar. Your response was expected. You can parrot the Hamas line all you want but there was a international universality on the list. None of them are bound to the Shariah-imposed adherence to Takiyyah.
I agree that I erred in making that "personal" comment, and deleted it. However, notwithstanding your dissent as to the contents of the report, I personally stand by it, notwithstanding any attempt of yours to refute it. I know that there are a limited number of Israel-bashers on NT who might support your argument, but I will rely on the fact that there are many more who will realize that there is a side to the story that is not being told by Hamas propaganda and the media's Palestinian-pandering bias.
It seems to me that the "one side of the story" that is the most prevalent is the one that attempts to demonize and deligitimatize Israel. This article is the one "those people" need to see.
Wth does Israel think it's doing protecting itself anyways?! No other country would get away with that! /s/
Just think, if this was happening tothe US, we woulda already bombed the hell outta the place, annexed it, took it over, and put a fifty-first star on the flag.
Unmitigated Bullshit. As someone whois part Indian, and has many relatives and friends who are Indian, we do not appreciate one bit the attempted hijacking of the Native American plight, by swindlers and spinners of Palestinian propaganda.
Truly Flame, it's not about teaching, it's about learning; and, I can't do that for you.
The difference? The white man was never in the USA before the Indians were, but the Jews were in Israel thousands of years ago, and have always been there. There is lots of archeology and antiquities to prove it. Besides, you know very well that "Palestinians" is a recently made-up name.
Since you're a very fair individual who believes in "balance", isn't it good to see that finally Israel's side of the story is being told? After all, I'm sure your links are to "findings" that have already been public.
So please explain to me how what happened to Indians is different than what is happening to Palestinians.
Being a whore trying to perfume your stink doesn't work, flame. What a disgusting piece of work you are when you try this shit. There is nothing remotely similar between the two; you don't like the report so you're attempting to taint the thread... but the only thing that stinks here is you.
I don't post "red rules" screminmimi, but I would appreciate it if we didn't get too personal. Address the issues, please.
Apologies, Buzz.
He has a habit of pulling this same hat trick out every time.
The remark that Israel "went overboard" in protecting itself is ludicrous. Custer's policy was to refer to Indians as lice on the backs of the white settlers, and he justified slaughtering Indian women and babies by calling them nits, saying that nits grew into lice.. and only by killing the young and the child bearing women could whites be guaranteed that more nits could not be bred to grow up to avenge their dead.
Israel, if they are going to be compared to the whites in early America, should completely wipe out the Palestinians to assure there will be no more attacks on their citizens... they have not, and will not, do that.
This report has enough independent and neutral observers to give a fair assessment of what happened.
Ok then, lets start with this then...
~LINK~
That's why they feel justified in firing Iranian made missiles at Israel !
The Iranian made devices are missiles . The crude homemade devices are rockets . But feel free to live in your own fantasy world ...
Not exactly ... BTW Iran regularly & publicly declares itself devoted to the destruction of Israel . Does the reverse happen ?
I enjoy the way you use the language, flame. The difference is that the US sends weapons to Israel is for Israel to defend its citizens whereas Gaza uses the Iranian weapons to invade Israel. Israel's responses into Gaza were to stop the rockets and missiles that were being fired into Israeli civilian areas.
Unfortunately for the Palestinians Einstein's definition of insanity isn't written in the Q'oran.
And you are so biased against Israel's survival that you refuse to consider even an international consensus from experts in warfare and counterterrorism as having credibility. So we can share that box of cigars.
Another tangential remark on your part to divert attention from the topic.We are not speaking of the Muslim world, we are speaking of Hamas, of the Palestinians.
Go back far enough you'll end up with the Neanderthal man. Who build the Dome of the Rock ON TOP OF David's Temple?
Had the Indians been offered 95 or 97% of their demands as the Palestinians were offered, I am sure it would have been acceptable, but that wasn't good enough for the Palestinians.
Even Abbas admitted that not accepting Partition was a disasterous mistake.
You're good at asking questions, so I'll ask one.
Why did Israel have to "invade" Gaza?
There is no such thing as absolutely no bias - and nobody knows that better than you. However, not all the countries where these signatories come from are so friendly with Israel, and on what factual evidence do you base your opinion that they are biased other than they actually take a different view than that promoted by Hamas.
They had a choice - 97% or nothing, and they chose nothing. I think that kind of puts them in the same league as the person who shot himself in the foot to see what it felt like.
Peace also means normalizing relationships between people, and I think you are aware of what happens to Palestinians who try to normalize their relations with Israelis.
Do you have evidence that a tunnel from Gaza approaching an Israeli village was meant for friendly purposes? Has Hamas not already announced that they will attempt to kidnap Israelis and use them to trade for prisoners (as they have already done)? If someone breaks into your house you must think their purpose is to leave you Christmas presents (Isn't that what Santa does?). I used to believe in the tooth fairy too.
Thank you, flame. There is no reason why these discussions cannot be carried on in a mature and reasonable fashion, from which all sides can learn.
97% of their demands - it was what Olmert had offered. Arafat walked away from an offer of 95% of his demands previously.
Before Hamas took control, Gazans were working in Israel, there was no blockade, there were relationships between Israelis and Gazans, life for Palestinians there was much better, and rockets were not fired at Israeli civilian areas.
Sounds a lot like Hamas' official position about Zionists (or is it really the about Jews? ):
Sometimes, flame, it's necessary to come to logical conclusions. What purpose do you think a tunnel starting within Gaza crossing the border and approaching closely to an Israeli civilian village, that probably uses tons of (badly needed for housing) concrete and steel and huge (even dangerous) personal effort would be for? Can you please give me a reasonable answer to that?
Sorry, I only read the article and only a couple of the comments, but they had an emergency session at the UN on Gaza where Iran, Syria, PLO try to shut down UN Watch, not unlike they do here in the USA in trying to shut down anyone who disagrees with them. So, here is a YouTube Video that has that emergency session with these countries not even wanting to allow UN Watch to have a word in all of this. I've provided the video and an audio of this session or at least what was on the 6.5 minute video. Only in the end do you hear from those who support Israel.
The first voice you will hear is the lady speaking of the accusations and in order... Palestinian Foreign Minister, Iran, Algeria, Venezuela, Syria, Sudan (if you can believe it), Hillel Neuer of UN Watch, lady who is directing this session, Hillel Neuer, interruption by Egypt, man and therefore you shall allow the NGO to continue to speak, Iran (tries to silence him), Canada defends him, Israel defends him, Venezuela tries to silence him, Palestine tries to silence him, Cuba (our new buddy) tries to silence him, Hillel Neuer, interruption by Syria, Hillel Neuer end of video. The voices are in order you will hear them above on audio. Here is the video and the audio will be attached. It may be too loud in the beginning but will be much better once they start talking.
UN emergency session on Gaza: Iran, Syria, PLO try to shut down Hillel Neuer
Dictatorships try to shut down UN Watch's Hillel Neuer at the 23 July 2014 UN emergency session on Gaza. Iran, Syria, Egypt, the "State of Palestine," Cuba & Venezuela interrupted. The U.S. & Canada defended Neuer's right to speak.
* Learn more:
* Transcript: ...
What do you mean by "recognize"? Do you mean "accept the existence of"? Do you expect Israel to accept the existence of a nation that swears to destroy it and annihilate its population? Have you not read the Hamas charter? You cannot deny that Israel would be happy to "accept the existence of" Gaza, and in fact leave it in peace, if Hamas and Gazans were to end hostilities against Israel, but you know the chance of that happening at this time.
Racist slurs scrawled in Arab Jerusalem area
Please do not use this article as an excuse to go entirely off topic in a derail attempt. The article is about the conflict between Israel and Gaza. If you are interested in discussing the problems in Jerusalem then please post an article about it.
It is absolutely laughable that Syria, Iran, Egypt, the "State of Palestine", Cuba and Venezuela, those stalwart defenders of human rights, try to muzzle someone from speaking in defence of Israel. As Pamela Geller has aptly indicated, free speech is on the wane, and in those countries it is totally absent.
My biggest disappointment is that although my country Canada joined the US in defending the right for UN Watch to be heard, Canada abstained and did not join the US in voting against the resolution. Canada had held itself out as being Israel's strongest supporter - so it has reduced my respect by a notch due to that failure.
Right now its really quite simple-- Hamas is terrified! No-- not terrified of Israel. While they don't say it publicly, they know Israel won't attack them unless they resume firing volleys of rockets & missiles at Israeli civilian centers. Rather, they are scared sh*tless that some more radical group will appeal more to the Gazans, and Hamas will lose its iron grip it has on the Strip.
(Previously one of the biggest threats to Hamas was a group called "Islamic Jihad". But now, however, there is the possibility of ISIS infiltrating. Also, pro-Iranian groups. (remember, Iran is Shia, Hamas is Sunni).
Hamas is terrified of losing the power and control. (ironically, there's another group that is also afraid of Hamas loosing power-- Israel! Despite the recent war, and despite Hamas' goal of destroying the Jews-- at this point Israel wants them in power. Why? Simply because if they lose control, what would replace them would be worse.
(That's also why Israel has been allowing so many supplies into Gaza to-- to keep down Gazans slowly rising discontent with Hamas!)
That's an interesting theory. If a more viciously violent group takes over it will not hesitate to provoke Israel into REALLY "mowing the grass". Personally, I am really beginning to feel that Israel has nothing to lose by doing so since when they do their damndest to limit civilian casualties when forced to defend itself (as established in the article of this seed) yet still earn the hatred of the rest of the world, what do they have to lose?
Makes me think of a saying that a folksinger whose name I forget said:
(Was it Richard Farina?)
Krishna used the story as an allegory in reference to Hamas attitude towards Jews - he tied it together. Your story is not a valid response to that, but a whole other incident which is not allegorical towards the Israel/Gaza conflict nor did you make it so.
By the way, it's 9 p.m. here, but you DID amuse me by referring to me as "Your Honour".
Dear Friend Buzz: Thanks for posting this.
One major difference between thenewstalkers and what the newsvine has devolved into is that here articles such as yours are fact based.
All too often on what the newsvine has become, not wholly but far too much, truth becomes a casualty of cottage industry hate mongering and prejudice inflaming.
I still keep open my newsvine room, Chaplains Corner. I still write and occasionally co-author articles on the Vine. I cannot turn my back on anyone who wants Pastor care form me on their terms and needs through the privacy of email. A person best serves G-d by helping any of His children of any sort when and how they need and want it.
That said, mostly, I come to thenewstalkers precisely because here the truth will out.
Thanks for this and all your outstanding contributions to this site.
We are grateful.
Peace and Abundant Blessings to You and Yours, Always.
Enoch.
If I wasn't pissed at having to back up 2 pages to reply to comments I would have said that it's okay, flame, because you know that flattering me with calling me "Your Honour" will get you anywhere with me. Next time if you do something REALLY off topic, try calling me "Your Lordship" (which is for a higher level justice).