Obama vetoes bill allowing families to sue foreign governments linked to terror attacks
“Obama Vetoes Terrorism Bill as Override Votes Loom,” by John T. Bennett, Roll Call , September 23, 2016:
President Barack Obama on Friday vetoed a bill that would allow families of the victims of terrorist attacks in the United States to sue foreign governments believed to be linked to the strikes, setting up a difficult election-year decision for congressional Democrats.
Obama expressed “deep sympathy” for those who lost loved ones on Sept. 11, 2001, writing in a statement accompanying the veto that he has “deep appreciation of these families’ desire to pursue justice and [is] strongly committed to assisting them in their efforts.”
GOP presidential nominee Donald Trump called the veto “shameful,” and said he would have signed it into law. Earlier in the day, Democratic nominee Hillary Clinton broke with Obama and said she would have signed it.
Obama cited concerns that the legislation, which passed both the House and Senate with overwhelming bipartisan support, could prompt other nations to pass look-alike laws, leading to more lawsuits and inconsistent standards for what constitutes state support for terrorist attacks. Proponents, however, call it “narrowly” crafted to guard against such things.
He wrote that he could not sign the measure into law because it “would neither protect Americans from terrorist attacks nor improve the effectiveness of our response to such attacks.” Instead, Obama concluded, as crafted it would allow cases to be brought to U.S. courts against other countries based solely on allegations, not longstanding methods of determining state sponsors of terror.
What’s more, the president argued the bill could open the door for other governments to allow cases in their court systems against “U.S. officials — including our men and women in uniform — for allegedly causing injuries overseas via U.S. support to third parties.” Obama also said if it became law, the measure “threatens to create complications in our relationships with even our closest partners.”…
Tags
Who is online
81 visitors

Can't offend his friends.
Or cut off the DNC funding...
Can't offend his friends.
OK maybe you don't get the legal reasons why. This bill would open the door to the US being sued by individuals of other countries and we are one the #1 nation present in other countries.
While I would like the Saudis involved to pay for those who died on 9/11, I also understand why this can't be.
And you're right Perrie.
You are correct Perrie, again.
I agree with Obama. This law would be incredibly stupid and counterproductive. Basically, it would lead to the weaponization of litigation. We have the deepest pockets on the planet and, therefore, we'd be at the most risk. No country would sit back and let our citizens raid their treasuries through lawsuits. They'll retaliate by, among other things, allowing their citizens to sue us (for the people we kill and all the property we damage) or even allow citizens of other countries to sue us in their courts. There would be no limit to the kinds of ridiculous causes of action to which we would be subject. Can the Palestinians sue us for giving weapons to Israel that we allow to be dropped on civilians? Are we liable to everybody in Iraq for an illegal war? This kind of friction will undermine our efforts in dealing with international terrorism as our partners become opposing litigants in the courtroom bitterly fighting over financial assets. Fighting over money can easily destroy a marital relationship and it will destroy or damage our international relationships as well.
Terrorism is illegal. The war in Iraq was legal. That's the difference.
Terrorism is illegal. The war in Iraq was legal. That's the difference.
That clear distinction is in your mind, not in international law. The UN Security Council did not authorize the war nor did we act in self-defense. Therefore, it was arguably an unprovoked war of aggression no different (legally) than Hitler's invasion of Poland or Japan's attack on Pearl Harbor. My point here is that, without a clear legal justification, another country can call our invasion illegal and make us liable for our actions. And that's just for starters.
Iraq violated sanctions. The war was legal.
Iraq violated sanctions. The war was legal.
At the time, many countries were in violation of UN resolutions and, in at least one case (Israel), the US blocked enforcement. Enforcement is up to the Security Council, not individual nations acting as vigilantes. We do not have a clear legal leg to stand on and will be opening ourselves up to litigation in foreign courts. Let's see how many of those courts agree with your view of international law.