2/4 SLIDES © Jim Wilson/The New York Times
3/4 SLIDES © Jim Wilson/The New York Times
4/4 SLIDES © Jim Wilson/The New York Times
WEED, Calif. — The water that gurgles from a spring on the edge of this Northern California logging town is so pristine that for more than a century it has been piped directly to the wooden homes spread across hills and gullies.
To the residents of Weed, which sits in the foothills of Mount Shasta, a snow-capped dormant volcano, the spring water is a blessing during a time of severe and prolonged drought .
To the lumber company that owns the land where the spring is, the water is a business opportunity.
Sign Up For NYT Now's Morning Briefing Newsletter
Roseburg Forest Products, an Oregon-based company that owns the pine forest where the spring surfaces, is demanding that the city of Weed get its water elsewhere.
“The city needs to actively look for another source of water,” said Ellen Porter, the director of environmental affairs for Roseburg who led the company’s negotiations with the city. “Roseburg is not in a position to guarantee the availability of that water for a long period of time.”
For the past 50 years, the company charged the city $1 a year for use of water from the Beaughan Spring. As of July, it began charging $97,500 annually. A contract signed this year directs the city to look for alternative sources.
Roseburg has not made public what it plans to do with the water it wants to take back from the city. But it already sells water to Crystal Geyser Alpine Spring, which bottles it in Weed and ships it as far away as Japan. Crystal Geyser is looking to increase its overall supply.
Residents of Weed, including the current mayor and three former mayors, say the water was always intended for municipal and domestic use and should not be sold to the highest bidder.
“The corporate mentality is that they can make more money selling this water to Japan,” said Bob Hall, a former mayor of Weed and currently a member of the City Council. “We were hooked at the hip with this company for years,” he said of the timber company, the largest private employer in the area. “Now, they are taking advantage of people who can’t defend themselves.”
Bottled-water plants have met with resistance and in some cases protests in a number of places across California, including a Nestlé plant last year in Sacramento. In the water-rich towns in the shadow of Mount Shasta, residents have raised concerns over proposed bottling plants that they say could severely diminish local water supplies.
A measure on the ballot in the November election in Siskiyou County, where the towns are, would for the first time require that companies obtain permits to export water.
The disputes echo California’s broader water wars. Five years of drought have escalated competition among farmers, factories and residents over water use and have pitted the arid south against the more water-rich north.
“Water is money,” said David Webb, a resident of the city of Mount Shasta who follows the water disputes in the area. “If you can get it, you can make money from it.”
The mayor of Weed, Ken Palfini, says the value of the city’s water was emphasized during a visit several weeks ago by Pierre Papillaud, the founder of the company that owns Crystal Geyser Alpine Spring. In what the mayor and another participant described as a tirade of abuse, Mr. Papillaud demanded that the city give up its spring water so that his company could have more.
“He said if he didn’t get his way, he was going to blow up the bottling plant,” Mr. Palfini said of Mr. Papillaud’s visit. “He said that twice.”
Mr. Papillaud’s son Ronan Papillaud came to Weed in mid-September to apologize for the brusque treatment and to rescind his father’s demands. But Mr. Palfini said it was a lesson on how small municipalities in the area need to protect themselves from water-hungry companies.
“They are just corporations,” Mr. Palfini said. “They are not your friend.”
Residents of Weed, which is still rebuilding after a major wildfire two years ago, say they believe that their dispute with Roseburg will end in the courts and that they have a document showing that the previous owner of Roseburg’s timber business here, International Paper, handed over water rights to the city in 1982.
But they describe a David and Goliath battle between Roseburg, a wealthy corporation capable of paying for high-powered lawyers, and a relatively poor city with just 2,700 people.
Residents in Weed followed the legal battles of Missoula, Mont., where the State Supreme Court ruled in August that the city could seize water from a private company by eminent domain to secure the municipal water supply.
The alternative to legal proceedings for now is to drill a new well at a cost of around $2 million, according to Ron Stock, the Weed city administrator.
Roseburg has suggested a site on its property, but city officials say it is potentially dangerous: The well would be located a few hundred yards from a former wood treatment facility that is contaminated with highly toxic chemicals including arsenic. The facility, which is managed by Roseburg, was fenced off in 1986 and has been declared a Superfund site.
Because of the complex hydrology of the area, including lava tubes that carry water in various directions under the mountains, the city would not know whether the water was safe until it drilled a test well, Mr. Stock said.
“The city has to be very careful,” he said. “We don’t want a Flint, Mich., situation.”
Ms. Porter, the Roseburg representative, said the proposed well site was “well outside any area of contamination.”
In an interview at the company’s timber plant outside Weed, where logs are spun and shaved into thin sheets used for plywood, Ms. Porter blamed Mr. Hall, the city councilor, and others in the city for casting Roseburg in a bad light.
“We are becoming the corporate bad guy, and that’s really unfortunate,” she said. The city already has wells that serve around half the population, she said.
Ronan Papillaud, the president of CG Roxane, which owns Crystal Geyser Alpine Spring together with a Japanese pharmaceutical company, Otsuka, was also defensive when asked about his company’s plans.
“We do not belong in this story,” Mr. Papillaud said. “We are not depriving anyone of anything.” CG Roxane has bought water from Roseburg since the late 1990s and dedicates one of its production lines in its Weed plant to bottling water bound for Japan.
Mr. Papillaud described his deal with Roseburg as a simple relationship between a buyer and seller.
“Is this blood water? Are they involved in child labor?” he asked rhetorically. “We are clients, end of story.”
Watching the water dispute warily are members of the Winnemem Wintu, a small Native American tribe that considers the slopes of Mount Shasta sacred.
According to tribal beliefs, one of the springs on the mountain is the place where animals and mankind emerged into the world. Six years ago, for the first time in the oral history of the tribe, that spring dried up, according to Luisa Navejas, a tribe member.
The water around Mount Shasta is not limitless, she said.
“This mountain is calling us now, and we need to listen,” Ms. Navejas said of the inactive volcano.
“This mountain will talk,” she said. “The time will come.”

Weed is located in really beautiful country.
Sadly they are learning that ''water is life''....The corporations do as they please, wonderful for capitalism, piss poor for the public.
BTW, it's in the mythical kingdom of Jefferson.
Good luck fighting for your water.
Another meanspirited jab at another member. You should be embarrassed.
Ah, XX waterboy shows up. Thank you for your comment, Cerenkov.
BTW, I own property in Siskiyou county, that's the county that Weed is located in. Here is the difference, I have my own well and water rights. And I'm not one that voted for being in a mythical state.
So I'm not embarrassed at all.
I'm not surprised. Your offtopic incivility renders your seed about wayer rights and mythical sacred mountains moot.
I'm glad that blu has your "back" though. Have fun.
''I'm not surprised. Your offtopic incivility renders your seed about wayer rights and mythical sacred mountains moot.''
Only in the simplest of minds, Cerenkov.
I'll defer to your expertise with a limited intellect. Keep trying!
Since you seem to be incapable of addressing the article, I would say that limited intellect belongs to you, Cerenkov.
Now, do you want to at least try to address the article and the problem that the city of Weed is having.
BTW, you have been off topic on each of your comments, so get on topic or leave the article.
Everything was on topic. You made it so. But I'll address the seed.
Mountains aren't sacred and property ownership is a basic human right.
Of course mountains are sacred. And property rights are not a basic human right.
How about what the corporation is doing to the town, any thoughts on that?
Sorry. Mountains ate upthrust plates made of rock. They are not connected to any "gods" and are not sacred. That's just mythology.
And yes, property ownership is a human right.
"“Everyone has the right to own property alone as well as in association with others. No one shall be arbitrarily deprived of his property.” So declares article 17 of the 1948 Universal Declaration of Human Rights."
It's not necessary to attach religion to the meaning of the word "sacred". Whether or not anyone does, matters little, because IMO all of nature is sacred. In fact, among the definitions of the word "sacred" is this: "regarded with reverence:"
"reverence" is defined as well: "a feeling or attitude of deep respect tinged with awe; veneration."
Unfortunately for the world and the population thereof, nature is neither revered nor considered sacred by too many, and if it's necessary or convenient to attach religious belief to the word in order for the population to respect nature, so be it. The Indians did so for millenia, and before the white man came to America, the land was pristine - it no longer is.
"The Indians did so for millenia, and before the white man came to America, the land was pristine - it no longer is."
That's not really true, except in the sense that preindustrial societies have less impact on their environment. The land was "pristine" during the European stone age as well.
"The land was "pristine" during the European stone age as well."
Don't believe this land was part of the European stone age - ya think?
Native Americans kept their lands/Mother clean, neat and productive for thousands of years and way before Euros had even learned how to march and hold Crusades. When the Euros came to North America, many of the writers were totally amazed and the "Park like" atmosphere of the forests and woods - everything was so well-maintained with hunting paths, agricultural plots, wildland fire control ANNUALLY. The Euro's fear was that they would desecrate the lands and its pristine beauty - which they did.
The same can be said for stone age Europe. It's related solely to the environmental impact of a society.
Uhhh - sorry Cev - the city is well within their rights based on numerous law cases, SCOTUS decisions and the fact that International Paper GAVE the city the water rights.
If fact, if the city wanted to, they could and should begin charging the paper company for use of the city's water as they have the water rights.
"...and the fact that International Paper GAVE the city the water rights."
That's disputed.
Show me your link.
"the Weed Water Company obtained a grant deed to 2.0 cfs of the Beaughan Waters, which was subsequently leased to the Weed Water and Sewer Company to provide domestic water to the city."
Case closed - the city owns those water rights unless they have released the deed - which I doubt.
Besides, the article is from August 2014 - needs to be updated.
1st, this problem with Weed is happening in different ways through out that area of California. Lake Shastina, the Klamath River, Modoc county.
I don't believe this case has been completely settled yet. But it's only one of many battles taking place in the area.
May, 2016
WEED, Calif.-- The city of Weed officially has water for the next ten years.
Roseburg Forest Products signed the lease with the city. The former mayor said within two years, the city will have to look for alternative water sources.
Former Mayor Bob Hall said he will go to court to get an official decision on who owns the water.
The new contract will raise rates for residents.
"Somebody has to make a decision on this," former Mayor Bob Hall said. "It's too important of a thing, just to give up the rights just because somebody told us to do it? We have to--we have to carry this out."
The current contract ends on June 29th. The new contract will begin July 1st.
Water is the new oil.
Yes it is Pat, and soon more and more towns/cities will be learning some hard facts.
Yes, Pat. It is something I made a comment about about several years ago, and even said that the day was coming when states would be guarding their water sources with armed national guard.
Looks like we might be getting there.
And I said a while ago that Canada, with about 20% of the world's fresh water supply, may have to defend itself from an invasion from the USA to steal the water.
You know, Buzz, I seem to remember you and I having that discussion..
No surprise that I don't remember. I can remember events from when I was 3 and 4 years old but I can't remember where I put my pen down 5 minutes ago.
It's going to be interesting to see how the Northern Cali Supreme Court rules when it get there. They don't often see the law as do the vast majority of state Supreme Courts. 9th District Court of Appeals ring a bell??????
Interesting that Native Americans had their land confiscated by force, those confiscating it writing subsequent laws to make the confiscation "legal," then allowed deep pocket companies to buy the confiscated land … and now and again, ironically, confiscate or exploit it yet again.
The market place is God.
I think it is interesting that having confiscated and stolen Native American land, the very people who did it are now shaking in their boots at the prospect that what they considered "theirs" is being taken out from under them by fellow looters.
Not only here, but the ranchers in Standing Rock, as well. One of them has sold a "parcel" of land to the oil company at a secret, undisclosed price and is furious at the Native Americans, because his deal may not go through if the pipeline is stopped in front of the Indian's front door, or rerouted. It's possible other ranchers adjacent to the reservation are expecting extravagant offers as well.
"1948 Universal Declaration of Human Rights." - Not applicable, not a law, not enforceable.
You want to reduce human rights?
Where does this say I want to reduce human rights????? - "Not applicable, not a law, not enforceable."
My statement is quite clear. Your Humans Rights revelation is a 1948 "Dream" that never came to fruition. Neither has the newest "Dream" - United Nations Declaration on Rights of Indigenous Peoples". Sure, a lot of nations have signed the Charter, but it is not a law, is not a regulation, thus it is not enforceable.
You wanna try again? How 'bout getting back on topic?
You are free to believe property ownership is not a basic human right, and I am free to condemn your view.
Real Property ownership is not a basic human right. Show me where you got that information.
I already did.
"United Nations Declaration on Rights of Indigenous Peoples". Sure, a lot of nations have signed the Charter, but it is not a law, is not a regulation, thus it is not enforceable."
Did not Canada take it seriously?
They signed the Charter and are actually following up on a number of the stipulations.
The U. S. also signed the Charter and have basically said - next - and, as usual, have done nothing.
Gee, it would have been nice if the US government would apply that to Native Americans. They keep chopping away at everything Indians own, and keep dismissing the treaties signed with them.. well, they have never honored a single one of them, but the government DID sign them, and the existing government is bound by them... but that is assuming the existing government or any government administration for that matter has any honor to bind them.
Property rights are not absolute. Governments from city to state to federal are in the habit of taking them under imminent domain for the public good and paying what they think you ought to have.
Of course mountains are sacred.
That is the same type of "reasoning" that makes the middle east the disaster it is today . All of those Holy sites to be defended to the death . Alluhah Akbar !
petey are you comparing Indian religions to radical Islam?
are you comparing Indian religions to radical Islam?
No . But the similarity of concepts about "reverence" for some land does give me pause ...
Would it not be the same as ''holy sites'' throughout the world, petey?
It seems to me, Petey, that the only ones who are intent to demolish "holy sites" are the ones who cry out "Aluhah Akbar", whether those sites are Buddhist, Hebrew, or whatever.
the only ones who are intent to demolish "holy sites"
That is one consideration . What I found interesting is that there are nations willing to go to war over land in their domains that is considered sacred . Saudi Arabia has some but there are others ...
Would it not be the same as ''holy sites'' throughout the world, petey?
Possibly ... and they are all potential hotspots for conflict .
Not to mention in the 1200's, this little thing called Crusades where the white guys were gonna tell the ME guys that they didn't know shit from shinola 'bout religion - that the one?
Natural resources are FINITE! As such, the natural resources of America whereas water, especially, is concerned at this stage, should not be sold as a commodity when American citizens are in such dire need of it that they are being rationed, that 5,000 Californians are drinking water that is five times over the accepted level for arsenic, that over six million Americans are drinking water that is six time over the accepted pollution level due to sewage plants overflowing and contaminating drinking water supplies of fresh water rivers and lakes, as well as ground wells due to their lack of capacity for the amount of people they are trying to serve.
One fourth of the United States is in serious drought condition; livestock and wildlife are dying. Commerce is being affected in that commercial farms are being downsized and livestock farmers are reducing herds. As a matter of public and national concern, there should be intervention on shutting off a town's water supply; for one thing, the company will increase its massive profits and the few taxpayers still working will see the effect because federal relief will be needed to provide these towns with tankers and semi trucks of bottled water.
And one damn thing is sure, we need to stop all immigration because we do not have the basic resources right now to take care of our own, let alone tens of thousands or hundreds of thousands of more people. Water is the most basic necessity of all and as it is this town's only source, bottling it to sell to outside the US should be forbidden. We did it with rubber and steel during the war, didn't we? This is a war for survival.
I thought this was a good place to put a quotation by one of my heroes:
There are those among us who will never understang the meaning … THEY ARE THOSE WHO KNOW THE COST OF EVERYTHING AND THE VALUE OF NOTHING.
I have posted this same proverb so many times I have lost count over the last two years, Buzz. It never loses relevance.
Still off topic Cev. This is 'bout water rights, courts and azzhole corporations - try those areas, OK?
Your article brought the superstitions of sacred springs into play. Try for more rational sources nextctime.
The people vs the corporations. Is it time for a revolution?
It is time, Buzz.
I always thought that a public drinking water supply had precedence over any corporation-- at least that's how it is here. Years ago, Corning Glass dewatered a huge area in northern Indiana, and they, (and the surrounding states), enacted laws protecting the water supplies of cities, towns, and private home owners... Maybe California's laws are different. Corning Glass had to spend millions of dollars replacing water supplies for the surrounding cities and farms. The aquifer still hasn't fully recovered.
Quite true Dowser - SCOTUS has ruled in favor of municipalities on numerous occasions for water rights.
The city has the upper hand.
I think the city will win pretty easily in this case. The company was stupid and greedy to overplay their hand.
Dowser,
I, too, thought that having used that water supply for so long it was a sort of de facto right for them to continue using it It's not a golf course, for Pete's sake, it's water, the one thing no living creature can do without and survive. To suddenly say, "We're taking it, go find your own supply now," when they aren't going to be using it for drinking themselves, and plan to sell it to others who HAVE drinking water... especially foreign concerns... is downright un-American.
In Tennessee, if a person on an adjacent property has been given access to using a spring or creek or well on a property, and the property is sold, the new owner cannot take away the rights of the adjacent property owner to continue using the water even if no actual contract was signed with the previous property owner, as a precedent was set for the water use. The adjacent property owner cannot add to the water draw, such as increased dwellings or extreme livestock usage, or digging a pond, but the normal usage is allowed until the last family member is deceased, and if the home and property is handed down to family, the water rights are also.
Exactly what SCOTUS said in one of their water rights cases.
That's what I thought, too.
I hope that the city sues this company, because I think they will win! Note: If the EPA was doing its job, this wouldn't even be an issue.
Dowser,
I am wondering why the Mayor hasn't already had an attorney look into this. Of course we are talking about California here, and a lot of the stuff that happens there is beyond my comprehension at times. I don't know a lot about their property rights situation, but from what I'm reading, it looks like this company may have its own Indian Wars over water and the sacred mountain.
It's kind of awesome that Indians are rising up all over the country...
It's about time... It's time for the Indians to make a stand against all the horrible treatment they have received! This is just yet another incident in a long long long string of incidents...
Completely agree, Dowser.
Since is the ''religion'' of those particular people, and you find that mythical than you must feel the same way about other religions and their so called ''gods''.
Your a supporter of the UN.....Or just when it's fits your argument.
I am an atheist, yes. I also admire the early UN, before it became corrupt.
Do you have a point?
I do have a point, but you must have missed it.
I think you forgot to make it.
One more time, please stick to the topic of the article. That is the water battle between the City of Weed CA. and the Roseburg Forest Products.
Any further off topic comments a moderator will be called in to delete them.
It seems like half of this article is off topic bickering.