Poll of Gazans shows 63 percent said they support launching rockets at Israel (but not Egypt!) while an Egyptian blockade is in place. Why?
Category: News & Politics
Via: the-irascible-harry-krishner • 11 years ago • 22 comments╌>
Category: News & Politics
Via: the-irascible-harry-krishner • 11 years ago • 22 comments
At the very least it can be said that Hamas are slow learners!
Well, no matter how often you repeat a lie-- its still a lie.
Its the terror group Hamas who has taken their land. (True, Gaza had been previously occupied, first by Egypt and then by Israel-- but the last Israelis pulled out completely in 2005 (see "Exodus from Gaza" ). There's no longer a single Jew in the place! And any land the Jews had in Gaza is now in Arab hands).
Israel and Israelis do not own a single cubic decimeter of land in Gaza-- and that's a fact!
Rofl!
Another of your attempts at derailng. LOL!
Haha.
This seed is about Gaza-- a poll of Gazans. Yes-- discussing Palestinians in the West bank, Jordan, Syria, Lebanon, Iraq, Detroit, Sweden, etc is of interest-- and important. But rather than derailling this discussin (of Gaza)-- why not seed your own article re: Palestinians in other areas?
All Palestinians are not alike-- and neither is their situation. So attempting to derail this seed about Gaza not only complicates things, but takes away from the discussion about Palestinians in Gaza. (Who, BTW, have differing circumstances-- and even opinions, of those in, say, Jordan (where they form the majority of the population)-- or those in Syria. Or even the assassination of RFK.
(9 times out of 10 when someone feels the facts aren't on their side, they try to bring up a derail-- an often effective attempt at getting the conversation off track. ..)
Of course the implication is that its Israel that's blocking Gaza- but is that really the problem?
If they want to fire rockets at Israel til the blockade ends-- does that really make sense?
Perhaps they are firing at the wrong target?
Israel is letting truckloads of supplies into Gaza daily-- while Egypt blockades Gaza. Yet in the poll Gazans only mention firing rockets at Israel. Why not Egypt?
'Tis a mystery indeed!
Nice try! But surely you know that you can't prove a negative-- yeyt another one of your manipulative tactics! (I also can't prove there's no Israeli owned land in Mongolia...)
So, a$$hole-- can you prove there is Israeli owned lnd in gaza? If there is you should have no trouble finding an article about that...
There's no longer a single Jew in the place! And any land the Jews had in Gaza is now in Arab hands).
When will that happen on the West Bank. Oh that's right. Bibi doesn't believe in a two state solution so he's just going to absorb the occupied territories by building a lot of settlements on them and the just start calling it Israel too since there are so many Jewish people already living there. It's no different then land grabs we've see in other parts of the world in the 20th century.
Dear Friend Krish: Kind of like watching Wile E. Coyote keep chasing the Road Runner, and thinking, "This time things will end to my advantage".
Meep meep.
E.
Yes-- they are building settlements in Judea and Samarria. (AKA "The West Bank").
But did you know-- they also built lots of settlements in Gaza!!!
People kept saying how those settlements in occupied Gaza were a "permanent obstacle to peace". Do you know what happened with those "permanent obstacles to peace" (settlements) in Gaza?
Exactly.
They keep doing it-- and the world keeps rebuilding for them!
The Gazans never learn (or maybe they have learned...that they can take any violent actions they want, and not have to suffer the consequences of their actions). Maybe its their European enablers -- and the U.N.-- who never learn!
The West Bank is considerably larger with a lot more settlements and the settlers tend to be much more orthodox the the average Israeli citizen. No matter what they are ordered to do, they will not leave their settlements without a possibly bloody fight. The Israeli army would have to drag them out and they will fight with weapons against the IDF and I doubt Tel Aviv will allow that to happen. It will be annexed instead.
You missed my point-- the settlers in Gaza did build lots of settlements. The hate-israel crowd (or maybe they were just uninformed?) kept saying that the Gaza settlements were a "permanent obstacle to peace". I asked the question-- what happened to those settlements that were allegedly a permanent obstacle to peace? Most Americans have no idea.
The answer is-- they actually were't "permanent". Israel ended the occupation of Gaza in 2005-- and the settlements in Gaza no longer exist!
Most westerners are unaware of it-- but that's exactly what people said when the government said that they were going to withdraw from Gaza! (Which they actually did do in 2005). So what happened then?
Back in 2005 people said that :
1.They wouldn't leave Gaza settlements voluntarily.
2.That the IDF would have to drag them out and they will fight with weapons against the IDF and I doubt Tel Aviv will allow that to happen.
3. That it would be bloody.
(Just what you said about the current situation re: the West Bank in 2015!).
People really dreaded it-- imagine, Israeli kids (soldiers) firing on fellow Israelis....
(cont'd in next comment)
(Cont'd from previous comment):
So-- what actually happened in 2005? Well, just as you said about 2015, in 2005 many settlers in Gaza didn't leave voluntarily. And yes-- the army literally had to drag many out! And yes-- Tel Aviv allowed the confrontation to happen.
BUT: there was no serious violence. (Despite the propaganda in the pc media, most Israelis don't like violence. And my personal experience is that most israelis would want a Palestinian state if it guaranteed peace-- the masses in Tel Aviv could care less abut keeping settlements in the Judean desert in the West Bank).
And of course in 2005 they didn't annex it (Gaza) instead. Rather, the settlements there no longer exist. The occupation is totally over-- there's not a single Jew in the entire place-- its totally ruled by Arabs (Hamas)!
People here frequently don't look at links, but if you really want to see what happened (text + actual photos) I highly recommend this article-- amazing coverage!
--->LINK
(After you perouse the photos, I can tell you a lot of other interesting & relatively unknown facts about Gaza-- and how it relates to ending Israeli control of Judea & Sammaria, AKA the "West Bank").
Readers of this column: Do Not Feed the Trolls!
So-- what actually happened in 2005? Well, just as you said about 2015, in 2005 many settlers in Gaza didn't leave voluntarily. And yes-- the army literally had to drag many out
Like I said, Bibi will not allow that to happen. Likud will not allow that to happen. They are in power and the was the last vote went they may be for some time. It is not just a case of Israel allowing it to happen. It's case of will Likud and Bibi allow it and the answer is no. They will annex the West Bank while they are in power and no one will stop them. And once it's done, it'll almost impossible to separate them. They will be one country.
Looks like you didn't look at the unusually informative link I just posted. Oh well-- you're in good company-- most people don't want to "get smarter here."
True. I totally agree. Hamas would never allow it. And neither would Bibi.
However, like the U.S. and other democracies. the Israeli government changes. We've had Bush as president-- and then Obama! Things that Bush "would never allow" have been happening under Obama!
Actually, historically Israel has had governments far to the left of anything the U.S. has had. (When the vote on statehood came up in the UN, Communist Russia voted for it.. Why? Because Israeli rulers were so leftist that the USSR thought Israel will join the Soviet bloc in voting in the UN! And Britain did not vote "yes"-- partially for the same reason. After all, many of Israel's founders were Atheistic Communists-- and Socialists. (Socialists yes-- but, unlike Obama, they were neither Socialists nor secret Muslims-- secret Muslims like Obama, who prayed in Christian churches & not mosques!)
And-- here's another fact that's not widely known. When Israel unilaterally & voluntarily ended the Occupation of Gaza (without bargaining with the Arabs to get anything in return), it was not under a Labour gov't. In fact, it was under Sharon. And it was his idea (he was no liberal...and considered a real hawk).
......
I agree.
I disagree about that. I don't think they will annex the West Bank. Most Israelis wouldn't want the problems. Sure-- the extreme right (Likud, etc) wants more territory. But most Israelis don't want the headache-- and it would be a headache.
Sort of like how the Ukraine was once one country-- and attempts to separate & annex Crimea by Putin failed--- it was impossible to separate it, Crimea and the rest of the Ukraine was one country! /sarcasm
And of course once Israel occupied Gaza, it become one country with Israel-- it was impossible to separate the two. /more sarcasm
Here's something for you to think about. How come Israel totally left Gaza-- settlements and all? And the person who pushed the idea was Ariel Sharon-- a hawk and a right winger?
I disagree about that. I don't think they will annex the West Bank. Most Israelis wouldn't want the problems. Sure-- the extreme right (Likud, etc) wants more territory. But most Israelis don't want the headache-- and it would be a headache.
That's the part I will never believe until I see it.
He's right. Gaza is more open air prison then a place to live.
It really makes no sense at all, considering the facts. perhaps some of the Jew-haters Israel-haters have some sort of bias? Maybe, maybe not-- ya never know.
To cite but one example:
Again. The West Bank is considerably larger with a lot more settlements and the settlers tend to be much more orthodox the the average Israeli citizen. No matter what they are ordered to do, they will not leave their settlements without a possibly bloody fight. The Israeli army would have to drag them out and they will fight with weapons against the IDF and I doubt Tel Aviv will allow that to happen. It will be annexed instead.
The land will be annexed. It would be a form of civil war briefly, until the IDF wins and even then there will be a militant Resistance movement there for years and years and years. Even if it succeeds then it will still be very, very bloody, with Jews killing Jews. It'll make the forced evacuation in Gaza look like a peace picnic. As compared to the 1968 wars outside of the convention in Chicago. Moving the settlers out without a LARGE amount of blood being spilled will be impossible.
The residents of Gaza are the low information voters of the mid-east. Probably waiting for their Obamaphones.